Filmmaker Installed Security Software On a Decoy Phone To Spy On Smartphone Thieves (theverge.com)
An anonymous reader writes from a report via The Verge: Dutch film student Anthony van der Meer had the unfortunate pleasure of having his phone stolen while having lunch in Amsterdam. Unsatisfied with the response from the Amsterdam police, who register an average of 300 stolen phones per week, Meer decided to find out what kind of person steals a phone. He downloaded DIY security software on a decoy Android phone, intentionally got the phone stolen, and was able to spy on his thief for weeks. He recorded the ups and downs of his covert investigation and turned it into a 22-minute documentary called Find My Phone. Meer preloaded the decoy device with an anti-theft application called Cerberus, which allows the owner of the device to access any file on the phone remotely, as well as discretely activate the phone's camera and microphone. Meer and his friends were able to navigate the technicalities of surveilling the thief with relative ease. They even snapped a close-up of the guy's face. The hard part, it turns out, was getting the preloaded phone stolen in the first place. It took Meer four days to get his device pilfered in a city with high rates of theft because concerned citizens kept coming to his rescue.
Not to sound too paranoid, but a guy who switches out phones to use a new stolen phone every two weeks or so, sets the phone to Arabic, and makes a few calls back to Egypt every few days... does the film make find nothing even a tiny bit odd in all that?
The rest of it wouldn't matter but the "use a phone for two weeks than toss it" approach to phone use seems mighty suspicious, along with apparently just sitting idle... waiting to be activated as it were...
Also, no description of his preferred porn? Not a very hard-hitting documentary!
"There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
The "story" such that it is doesn't go much deeper than the Slashdot summary. It would be nice if there was a more tasty tease to watch the film, such as the perp used the phone to run some sort of huge prostitution business or a huge drug ring or maybe some sort of Islamic terrorism.
Given that there is no such tease, we can assume the perp used it to call his grandma now and then in some faraway place.
If you want news from today, you have to come back tomorrow.
...I'll have to vent my frustration here. You don't take last names by just taking the last separate word of someone's name. The guy doesn't have two middle names "van" and "der" his last name is "van der Meer"
"van der Meer had the unfortunate pleasure of having his phone stolen while having launch in Amsterdam."
You really got to watch out for that... Having Launch. That's what sent Bob Denver into space.
I had to laugh when the thief consulted an imam who told him that Allah would give him what he wanted if he prayed every hour for 24 hours. But the thief didn't notice Allah had already given him a smartphone without praying! Those mysterious ways are really universal. Take another person's possessions and thy will receive. Fool another person, and you will receive tithes.
Bert
Unfortunately, also probably a good way to get yourself thrown in jail or murdered.
Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
Well, it was not a fan favourite iPhone but a mediocre HTC. I do not believe the aftermarket for HTC spare parts is too lucrative, even if the police told so.
Because a modern phone isn't really a phone any more.
It is what used to be called a Personal Digital Assistant, a handheld computer that might just occasionally be used for making voice phone calls.
It is a web browser, diary, ebook reader and everything else. Most people use them on wifi and avoid the phone companies whenever they can.
The word you're looking for is entrapment. However that requires a policeman to actively encourage the criminal to commit the act.
Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
I think thief should file a lawsuit against filmmaker for making his private live public without consent. Probalbly he would be able even to defend himself from charge of theft, because it evidently was a provocation.
Wow. America, fuck yeah right?
Yeah stay away.
We have far too many of you fucking retards visiting the place. (Over 17million every year on a population of less than a million, it's starting to look like Venice here)
I think thief should file a lawsuit against filmmaker for making his private live public without consent.
What would be the point in the thief exposing himself?
The filmmaker pixelated his face, censored his name, and didn't get the police involved (This second time around, the filmmaker was more interested in making his film, not recovering the second phone). Hopefully, the filmmaker provided the address to the police of the phone shop where the phone finally got wiped. The police should try to sell stolen phones to that particular phone shop, to see what happens.
I think thief should file a lawsuit against filmmaker for making his private live public without consent. Probalbly he would be able even to defend himself from charge of theft, because it evidently was a provocation.
Maybe he should have had the thief agree to a 4,207-page EULA first. After all, that's how corporations have made invasion of privacy legal for years.
Government doesn't even bother anymore. They just fucking do it and dare you to do something about actions that once were illegal and (in America) used to be constitutionally protected.
TL; DR - Control is an Illusion. Privacy is a Delusion.
That's US thinking, with your fantasies about "due process" and "admissible evidence". Europe is more like "You steal my stuff, your ass is mine!"
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
I really wonder how many laws the filmmaker broke.....
Unless all of this was known to everybody and just as show.
Only in your country do you consider thiefs "victims."
At least you guys are better at keeping the water out than the Italians are, so it won't look too much like Venice.
Yeah they should lock away that 'filmmaker' scumbag for good and give that thief a medal for exposing a conspiracy of illegal privacy violation.
sudo rm -r -f --no-preserve-root /
No the EU has due process and admissible evidence too.
What this is is some twisted view that someone who steals something has a right to expect it to be as he bought it, and that there's an expectation that people take care of the scumbags who thieve from them (like the guy in the USA who tried to rob a house, fell through the skylight, cut his leg on a choppingboard, sued the home owner and ... won.
We have zero tolerance for that bullshit in most European countries, and when the Brexit happens I think it will be all European countries.
I think thief should file a lawsuit against filmmaker for making his private live public without consent...
Privacy is a delusion.
Humans are caught on camera and audio dozens of times a day by doing nothing more than walking around this planet, so let's drop the dramatic bullshit regarding "consent".
As far as exposing a criminal, fuck 'em. I'd rather this concept go viral to help destroy the stolen cellphone market that obviously thrives rather well.
I'm not sure leaving something behind is enough to count as inducement in the US.
Person wasn't convinced to steal, person clearly has the capacity to take a phone left behind, and people leave phones behind often enough that I'd think the typical opportunity was there too.
Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
Obviously, from your comment, you are a drastically unimaginative person who can only see their own viewpoint. Now - this is going to blow your mind - most people don't have phones as cheap as $25. Lots have phones that go $400-$600 or more.
So unfortunately, it can matter if it's stolen. And yes, of course, anyone who doesn't see the world exactly like you is a complete idiot - this is slashdot, after all.
I do not want your cheap brainburning drugs. They are useless for work. And I am a working man today.
Yeah. "I stole a phone, and I was subsequently provoked into stealing it."
I do not want your cheap brainburning drugs. They are useless for work. And I am a working man today.
You not liking it is seriously tempting me into visiting.
I do not want your cheap brainburning drugs. They are useless for work. And I am a working man today.
I'm not sure how phone theft is still happening. At least iPhones, not sure about Android. But if you put a password on your phone then report it stolen, I thought it was useless at that point? Could never be reactivated by another person. Is that not the case?
I think thief should file a lawsuit against filmmaker for making his private live public without consent. Probalbly he would be able even to defend himself from charge of theft, because it evidently was a provocation.
Yes, this would be a totally European thing to do. But act fast because the political climate there is changing fast.
Honestly, I find using the location mightily irritating.
I want my language to always be English. Always. Which is what my OS is set to.
Then some shitty noob programmer comes along and checks my location, overrides my preferences and sets the language to whatever country I'm in. No thanks.
Jesus Christ man, location =/= locale. Truly, so much for techies.
I don't think it would be all that interesting to hear such a case - I doubt anyone believes you have a reasonable expectation of privacy using someone else's phone, particularly without permission.
Stupid sexy Flanders.
Yes, it's still stolen.
If you leave your car, running, doors wide open, and someone takes it, it's still stealing.
If I leave the door to my home wide open and someone comes in and takes things, it's still stealing.
Taking something that does not belong to you is stealing no matter how easy it was.
Stupid sexy Flanders.
In the end, the police response was the most efficient and correct. After all the effort and expense, not a thing was done to further the cause of "justice."
Report the crime, recover data and wipe the phone if you can and move on.
The filmmaker was a wimp. This presentation at DEFCON by a guy who got his Mac stolen was EPIC:
https://youtu.be/Jwpg-AwJ0Jc
Spoiler: he showed the guy's adult selfies, online dating profiles, Google searches, and more. The moral: if you want to keep your data safe, use robust encryption and access security. If you'd rather get your computer back (or at least, hours of entertainment at the thief's expense), configure it with auto-login (so the thief won't even BOTHER to reinstall the OS) and remote control software w/DDNS client. :-D
Comment removed based on user account deletion
Those people are called "thieves", and should be treated accordingly.
Comment removed based on user account deletion
He's doing an AMA on Reddit: www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/5jg18f/iama_anthony_van_der_meer_director_of_the
42 hidden comments
Phones are often like cars, the value of the parts meets or exceeds that of the whole. Even if they can't use the phone itself, they now have a working LCD/digitizer (often $150-$300 value for newer phones), battery, buttons, speaker, etc etc.