Slashdot Mirror


Snowden Doc Shows NSA Blamed Russia For Hack of Murdered Journalist (thehill.com)

The National Security Agency (NSA) knew that the Russian government hacked the email account of a prominent journalist the year before she was killed in Moscow, documents published by The Intercept show. The 2006 murder of longtime Kremlin critic Anna Politkovskaya -- who was gunned down in the elevator of her apartment complex -- is widely believed to have been a contract killing. Politkovskaya was a noted critic of Russian President Vladimir Putin, and it has long been suspected that the murder was carried out on his orders. From a report: The NSA compiled an internal file on Politkovskaya, which was exposed as part of the Edward Snowden leaks. Much of the document is unclassified and public, except for one top-secret segment: "Russian Federal Intelligence Services (probably FSB) are known to have targeted the webmail account of the murdered Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya," the passage reads. "On 5 December 2005, RFIS initiated an attack against the account annapolitkovskaia@US Provider1, deploying malicious software which is not available in the public domain. It is not known whether this attack is in any way associated with the death of the journalist."

52 of 110 comments (clear)

  1. Re:So basically... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I hope you're happy. You gullible morons have fucked us all.

    It took 8 years to undo the damage caused by Bush. It might have taken another 8 years to undo the damage caused by Obama, if a sane conservative could have been found hiding under a rock somewhere and convinced to run for President. But now it will take 100 years to undo the damage caused by Trump... and that's without taking the half-lives of various fission products into account.

    Good jorb.

  2. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler

    Calling a Russian "Hitler" is probably a pretty good way to get your ass kicked.

    --
    Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
  3. Obama pull your fucking head in. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    seems Obama wants to stir as much anti Russian sentiment as he can before he joins the trash heap and make it as difficult as possible for Trump. I am very much anti trump but what Obama and Co are doing at the moment is fucking appalling.

    1. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by GrumpySteen · · Score: 3, Informative

      Seems you've confused Edward Snowden with Obama. This is not information that Obama released.

    2. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by benjfowler · · Score: 1

      The motherfucking RUSSIANS are stirring up anti-Russian sentiment.

      Don't want people to hate you? Stop stealing land, stop murdering people, and stop fucking lying about it.

    3. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      you could replace Russians with Americans and be just as accurate.

    4. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by benjfowler · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Stupid vatnik. Done with the hair rinse yet?

      What about all the land you're stealing off Georgia, as you move your borders in South Ossetia and Abkhazia? Or how you sent soldiers to steal Crimia off another nation-state? Or how you're stealing Donbass? Or your countless 'frozen' conflicts (colour-revolutions by another name)?

      When was the last time the US actually annexed land? It's been centuries.

      Seriously, fuck off with your apologist bullshit, troll.

    5. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by Sassinak · · Score: 2

      Umm.. so lets see a sitting president wants to slap a foreign government's hands for obviously attempting to meddle/influence the election and by extension its own government.. a fact that to be fair, we've had for months/years (increasing evidence and cases) and this is "stirring up anti-russian" sentiment?

      Your argument is akin to someone being abused for months in school and NOW that they are finally taking action towards the end of the semester (when a new teacher is coming in), you side with the blamed party, without regard to the months of abuse that they inflicted? Yeah.. that makes sense.

      Given how volatile the situation is, the US is not going to make a bold proclamation like this without evidence. (this is not Iran that is a small country and COULD be wiped this is Russia, the #2 Super Power and one that is not particularly shy about using its military or other weapons at its disposal).. so you don't toss theory and supposition about.. you work on facts.. because when the shit hits the fan (and it will).. you need data to back it up.

      --
      God made the Idiot for practice, and then He made the School Board -- Mark Twain Look for http://Thebar.steelbeachca
    6. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by FilatovEV · · Score: 1

      The motherfucking RUSSIANS are stirring up anti-Russian sentiment.

      Don't want people to hate you? Stop stealing land, stop murdering people, and stop fucking lying about it.

      To his credit, Putin stopped murders of journalists that started well before him at much greater rate than anything that happened during his terms in power.

    7. Re:Obama pull your fucking head in. by michael_wojcik · · Score: 1

      When was the last time the US actually annexed land? It's been centuries.

      1898 (Puerto Rico, Hawaii, Guam, etc.) was barely more than one century ago. And then there's the Philippines: annexed 1902, sovereignty restored in 1946. And while the US never formally annexed Okinawa, we held complete control over the archipelago from 1945 until 1972.

      And we've had plenty of nasty proxy wars, not to mention those we've been directly involved in.

      Of course the sins of the US have little bearing on those of Russia (or the USSR before it, or Czarist Russia before that). But trying to claim the moral high ground only weakens your argument.

  4. Re: So basically... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Snopes is a hardcore liberal site. If you think they're neutral I've got a bridge to sell you.

  5. No the NSA did not blame Russia for death by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    https://theintercept.com/2016/12/29/top-secret-snowden-document-reveals-what-the-nsa-knew-about-previous-russian-hacking/
    https://prod01-cdn07.cdn.firstlook.org/wp-uploads/sites/1/2016/12/Polit1.png

    (TS//SI//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL) Russian Federal Intelligence Services (probably FSB) are known to have targeted the webmail account of the murdered Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya. On 5 December 2005, RFIS initiated an attack against the account annapolitkovskaia@US Provider1, by deploying malicious software which is not available in the public domain. It is not known whether this attack is in any way associated with the death of the journalist. [1]

    What the NSA appears to know is that the Russians targeted the journalist's email account using malware that it believed was not in the public domain.

    But teh internal wiki itself is a little problematic:

    Unfortunately, in the case of this wiki there’s no indication of exactly what sort of SIGINT was collected with regard to Politkovskaya, or how it incriminated Russian intelligence — all we have is the allusion to the evidence, not the evidence. The NSA declined to comment.

    TheHill article is terrible because it draws from alleged and unproven information produced by private security firms like Crowdstrike, assumes that information is factual, and then merges that with a sliver of NSA information coming from a internal wiki (!) that was released with the Snowden docs. You wanna see fake news? This is it.

    1. Re:No the NSA did not blame Russia for death by tinkerton · · Score: 1

      People should indeed follow the link to the original intercept article because the article in Thehill is just bad.

    2. Re:No the NSA did not blame Russia for death by AHuxley · · Score: 1

      Once people read theintercept and get away from all the US suggestive comments and news, what remains?
      More code not seen in the wild and the NSA telling other 5 eye nations that it knows the code has not been seen in the wild.. with the word probably.

      --
      Domestic spying is now "Benign Information Gathering"
  6. wow! by gravewax · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Seriously Obama you are starting to make Trump look sane. The last thing the world needs is a new cold war, never thought I would say it but Trump can't come soon enough before you do any more damage, I can only assume you or your party has big financial interests that are not supported by friendly relations with Russia.

    1. Re:wow! by Carewolf · · Score: 4, Informative

      Seriously Obama you are starting to make Trump look sane. The last thing the world needs is a new cold war, never thought I would say it but Trump can't come soon enough before you do any more damage, I can only assume you or your party has big financial interests that are not supported by friendly relations with Russia.

      Where did you shills see Obama's name in any of this?

      Please get your own head of your own ass before you shill on.

    2. Re:wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Come to thing about it, I've never seen Snowden and Obama in a room together...

    3. Re:wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      trump is a fucking retard, just because you call out Obama for being a cocksucker doesn't mean you support the other cocksucker.

    4. Re:wow! by rahvin112 · · Score: 2

      So a release by Snowden that was made more than 2 years ago and publicized as part of the ongoing review of those documents about a murder that occurred during the Bush administration is somehow Obama's fault?

      Get over it, Trump will be president in less than a month. You have an unnatural obsession with blaming Obama for everything.

    5. Re:wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      No the timing of the finding and publishing of it is almost certainly Obama work though. unless you believe in amazing coincidences then it is near impossible to believe this wasn't published without some backdoor support from the whitehouse. comes immediately after Obama expels diplomats and states he is going to embarrass Russia in the press. If it was coincidence then Obama truly is blessed with incredible fortune and luck having the press respond to swifty in his favour a few hours after making his statements.

    6. Re:wow! by rahvin112 · · Score: 5, Informative

      So now you're claiming the evil Obama mastermind is in control of what stories from the Snowden leaks are published even though Obama's government has gone to great length to prevent the publication of ANYTHING Snowden provided to the journalists?

      Yea, Obama is such an evil mastermind. :roll eyes:

      Just like my inlaws that blamed Obama for the $10K cash transaction limits that were put in place 30 years ago during the Regan administration. Everything is his fault and everything will be better under Trump. You're lying to yourself and you probably don't even realize it.

    7. Re:wow! by mmell · · Score: 1

      Seriously Obama you are starting to make Trump look sane.

      Not all the acid in Berkeley could make Trump look sane. Just sayin'.

    8. Re:wow! by painandgreed · · Score: 1

      Seriously Obama you are starting to make Trump look sane. The last thing the world needs is a new cold war, never thought I would say it but Trump can't come soon enough before you do any more damage, I can only assume you or your party has big financial interests that are not supported by friendly relations with Russia.

      Unfortunately, cold war seems to be exactly what Russia wants. They've always had a chip on their shoulder as far as Europe goes and can be seen as the Abusive drunk uncle of Eastern Europe. Once the Union was broken up, they found themselves now surrounded by their former union mates who immediately tried to shield themselves from Russia. Their post break treaties with the Ukraine were broken once Russia had their nukes back. Rather than try to join the EU themselves, they are instead trying to create a new sphere of influence with themselves at the head involving their neighbors and anybody who will side with them against the US and EU. They've lost a great deal of status and the only way they seem to think they can get it back is to renew their position as cold war opponent of the US. They're not really trying for war but they do want their status as a superpower back and are willing to break a few eggs to get there.

  7. Re:So basically... by guises · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It took 8 years to undo the damage caused by Bush.

    This just isn't accurate. We still have the TSA, we still have prisoners held without trial at Guantanamo Bay, we still have a Patriot Act (even though it isn't called the Patriot Act any more) and carte blanche spying on US citizens, we still have massive massive debt... The damage is most certainly not undone. This is Obama's greatest failure as president - he was elected pretty much with the sole purpose of undoing what Bush had done.

    He managed to reduce it in some areas - there are fewer prisoners in Guantanamo Bay, the Patriot Act is marginally less bad than it was, the Bush tax cuts are mostly not bankrupting us anymore - but one cannot simply undo eight years of terrible legislation. You're right that we will be feeling the Trump administration 100 years from now, but we will still be feeling the Obama administration, the Bush administration, etc. Every legislator makes their mark, for good or ill, and when we vote we have to do so with the recognition that the decision we make is not a reversible one.

  8. This is the foreign government ... by quax · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ... that now owns the White House.

    We are truly living in interesting times.

    1. Re:This is the foreign government ... by benjfowler · · Score: 1, Informative

      As much as it pains me to say, it's Obama's weakness which caused this. Obama should've come down on Putin and his entourage like a ton of bricks at the first sign of misbehaviour.

      PNG'ing 35 Russian spies today is too little, too late. He should've done that the second it was clear that the traitor Snowden was defecting to Moscow.

      If anything, Obama's forfeited his Peace Prize, by emboldening the vile dictator of Russia. Putin is a savage, and savages respect strength, but viscerally despise weakness.

    2. Re:This is the foreign government ... by dunkelfalke · · Score: 1

      I don't think that a citizen of a country that was ruled by Dubya and his goons has a moral right to call any other head of state a savage.

      --
      "It's such a fine line between stupid and clever" -- David St. Hubbins, Spinal Tap
    3. Re:This is the foreign government ... by benjfowler · · Score: 1

      We most certainly do.

      Get some perspective. Putin murders and steals far more indiscriminately than any Western leader in living memory.

    4. Re:This is the foreign government ... by dunkelfalke · · Score: 1

      ORLY? So, what is the bodycount of Putin? More or less than the bodycount of Dubya? Because the Iraq war killed about half a million Iraqis and I don't count Afghanistan yet. If you add up the second Chechen war (about 25k), the war in Georgia (a few hundred people), the current conflict in the Ukraine (10k) and Russian bombing in Syria (8000 in worst case), Putin won't even come into proximity. Nixon is responsible for even more deaths.
      So if Dubya isn't in your living memory then you are just a bloody kid - and that pretty much explains your black and white view of the world.

      --
      "It's such a fine line between stupid and clever" -- David St. Hubbins, Spinal Tap
    5. Re:This is the foreign government ... by acrimonious+howard · · Score: 1

      Get some perspective. Putin murders and steals far more indiscriminately than any Western leader in living memory.

      ORLY? So, what is the bodycount of Putin? More or less than the bodycount of Dubya?

      Kudos, lol. I agreed then immediately agreed with the counter-argument.

      But this shows the real problem is party not country here. In the last several decades, Reps have caused so much death and waste, I've been turned into a one-party person. Philosophically I'd be against that, but cmon I have no choice.

  9. Offtopic by codepigeon · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Well, after being a daily user of this website for almost 15 years I have to give it up. I took a break during the heat of the election season because the comment sections had gotten over heated and partisan. ... came back today to give it another chance and see the first comment in this thread...Oh well.

    Thanks for the memories slashdot. Truely.

    The intelligent discussions seem to have disappeared. Best wishes.

    1. Re:Offtopic by bug1 · · Score: 1

      The intelligent discussions seem to have disappeared

      If you only look in convenient places you will never find it.

      (grow some skin)

    2. Re:Offtopic by JThundley · · Score: 2

      This story is new and the comments are fresh. You need to wait a day before more comments pour in and they get moderated so you don't see all the bullshit and smart comments make it out. I do feel your pain though, Slashdot comments have gone down in quality overall. If you find a website with tech news and smart people commenting, come back and let us all know! And consider staying and contributing to the intelligent conversation!

    3. Re:Offtopic by krakelohm · · Score: 1

      Can you honestly expect to not see extreme comments on a political article?

      --
      You are all a bunch of idots.
  10. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by zlives · · Score: 3, Informative

    or roman like behavior... just being human is probably more like it.
    i just read history and say meh, we have done worse.

  11. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by dunkelfalke · · Score: 1

    Judging from American history I'd rather call it manifest destiny. I mean, the whole nation was built on stolen land and bones of natives.

    --
    "It's such a fine line between stupid and clever" -- David St. Hubbins, Spinal Tap
  12. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by zlives · · Score: 1

    meh we have done worse, i hope to say the same at the end of Trumplethinskin's end of term

  13. Re:So basically... by unixisc · · Score: 1

    ...Hillary is pretty similar to Putin then.

    Gad we dodged THAT bullet!

    Then Anna Politkovskaya is to Seth Rich what Vladimir Putin is to Hilary Clinton

  14. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by unixisc · · Score: 1

    Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler

    Calling a Russian "Hitler" is probably a pretty good way to get your ass kicked.

    Actually, the closest Russia got to a Hitler was Stalin, if you include Communists, and Ivan the Terrible, if you wanna look at the Tsarists

  15. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 2

    First, why not Stalin instead of Hitler? He arguably murdered more people over the course of his life - and even engaged in his own brand of ethnic slaughter.

    Second, I'm just thinking that constant hyperbole means I don't have a clue what someone means when they compare a person to Hitler these days. Trump is regularly called "Hitler" or a "Nazi" too. So is Putin a real Hitler, intent on purging million of people and taking over the world, or a George Bush / Donald Trump type Hitler where you disagree with his policies or behavior, or somewhere in-between? Calling someone Hitler these days means absolutely nothing, because it's now a term used to describe anyone the left disagrees with.

    For the record, I didn't see any justification for Putin to invade Ukraine. It's hard to make a judgment on Crimea, which seemed to have populations vying both ways in a power play, while stabilizing Syria does seem to at least coincide with their actual economic interests (and they're a hell of a lot closer to that region than we are). He could very well be a very dangerous man to his enemies, though obviously we only have suspicions of killings. This makes it hard to differentiate from a conspiracy theory, especially from such a distance away. Remember, a lot of people believe there are a string of suspicious deaths tied to the Clintons as well. He's going to be very difficult for the next US administration to deal with, but it seems we could hardly do worse than what's happened over the past few years short of getting caught up into another a shooting war.

    --
    Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
  16. Why is this story even on Slashdot? by guacamole · · Score: 1

    I gotta say that the level of anti-Russian xenophobia is continuing hitting ever higher levels of stupid. NSA alleges that somebody hacked into some journalists account.... 11 years ago. Shocking stuff.

    1. Re:Why is this story even on Slashdot? by FilatovEV · · Score: 1

      If you follow the data by the Committee to Protect Journalists, Putin should be clearly credited with improving the situation with journalist murders in Russia (i.e. less journalists were killed during his terms in power on the annual basis.) The most typical Western mistake -- ignore or feign ignorance about Russia's 1990s. I don't blame you on that, because you are just a victim of the Russophobic MSM interpretations of the data.

  17. Re: So basically... by Zero__Kelvin · · Score: 1

    Uhhhm .... You know the president isn't a legislator, right?

    --
    Guns don't kill people; Physics kills people! - John Lithgow as Dick Solomon on Third Rock From The Sun
  18. No link to her death by manu0601 · · Score: 1

    No real news here: as in many countries, domestic intelligence monitors opponents, and there is nothing more, as the classified stuff says:

    It is not known whether this attack is in any way associated with the death of the journalist.

  19. Re: So basically... by guises · · Score: 1

    This is a vague response. There are a lot of points that you could be trying to make here, none invalidate what I said above.

  20. Did Putin murder Seth too? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    No, Anna Politkovskaya said things that upset Putin, and Putin hacked her emails and had her killed.
    And Seth Rich was robbed and shot on his way home, and you pretend it was a big Hillary Clinton conspiracy and pretend he secretly revealed the DNC emails.

    But we know how the DNC emails were obtains. The NSA details how the hack was done, it was not Seth as you wish it was, you are simply smearing a dead man for political talking point:
    https://www.us-cert.gov/sites/default/files/publications/JAR_16-20296A_GRIZZLY%20STEPPE-2016-1229.pdf

    The hacked DNC emails were used as basis for propaganda, and the hacked RNC emails have been kept back for use later. And you want to defend Putin the murderer/hacker, because you view him as being Trump's boss, and you support Trump and so support Putin killing dissidents.

    On this we agree, Putin is Trump's boss. Trump even quotes Putin like you'd quote your boss:

    "Donald J. Trump @realDonaldTrump Dec 23: Vladimir Putin said today about Hillary and Dems: "In my opinion, it is humiliating. One must be able to lose with dignity." So true!"

    When you defend "Trump' and attack 'Hillary' on every Putin story you are simply confirming what the opposition already knows, that Trump is a Putin puppet. And we're waiting to see how Trump tries to defend Putin's hack of the US election, I guess he has to wait for his talking points in co-ordination with the Russian propaganda planners.

  21. Why would that bother me? That was the point. by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    You'll note *I* fairly presented all sides of the argument rather than posting a biased link - whereas YOU want us to believe one particular thing.

    I merely lead people to research and decide what they think is correct.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  22. Re: Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 1

    It's about ports. Crimea goes back to WWII and the naughty document signed by Churchill.

    Ah, that makes sense. Doesn't make it necessarily right, but does make sense.

    --
    Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
  23. Re:So basically... by nehumanuscrede · · Score: 1

    The man hasn't been President for eight years now. . . . . . and folks are still blaming everything on him.

    Fact of the matter is this: If Obama had really wanted to clean up the mess, he could have eradicated most of it with a stroke of his pen. The fact that he didn't bother speaks volumes.

    It's hilarious how when Team Democrat has the ball and doesn't get anything done, it's all Team Republicans fault.
    Yet, when Team Republican is in play and fails to deliver, it's still Team Republicans fault.

    I wonder if anyone will ever realize that, while slightly different flavors, they're both the same incompetent team. :|

  24. Statements that always raise flags for me... by PortHaven · · Score: 1

    "deploying malicious software which is not available in the public domain"

    What the heck does that mean? Does this mean the hacking tools don't have a GPL or similar license that grants free use? Or not commonly used by hackers? If these tools have been deployed to machines, I am sure someone has picked them up and modified them. It's like the "I Love You" worm. It was quickly modified by many.

    But how many individuals has our government hacked, listened in on, and killed?

  25. Re: So basically... by guises · · Score: 1

    Oh, you weren't trying to make a point at all. Sure, okay. I thought you were going somewhere with that.

    Yes, the president is not part of the legislative branch - I said that because I wanted to be inclusive of not just the president, but I should have said something like "elected official."

  26. Re:Vladimir Putin is a clone of Hitler by shutdown+-p+now · · Score: 1

    It depends a lot on the Russian in question. E.g. this guy is Russian, and was a prominent militia commander for Donbass separatists for a while. Note the flag he's holding on the first photo.