Slashdot Mirror


How a PhD Student Unlocked 1 Bitcoin Hidden In DNA (vice.com)

dmoberhaus writes: A 26-year-old Belgian PhD student named Sander Wuytz recently solved a 3-year-old puzzle that had locked the private key to 1 Bitcoin in a strand of synthetic DNA. Motherboard spoke with the student about how they managed to crack the puzzle, just days before it was set to expire. From the report: "As detailed by Nick Goldman, a researcher at the European Bioinformatics Institute, in his pioneering Nature paper on DNA storage, to encode information into DNA you take a text or binary file and rewrite it in base-3 (so rather than just ones and zeroes, there are zeroes, ones, and twos). This is then used to encode the data in the building blocks of life, the four nucleobases cytosine, thymine, adenine and guanine. As Wuyts explained to me, coding the data as nucleobases depended upon which nucleobase came before. So, for instance, if the previous base was adenine and the next pieces of data is a 0, it is coded as cytosine. If the next piece of data is a 1, it's coded as guanine, and so on. After the data is encoded as synthetic DNA fragments, these fragments are used to identify and read the actual files stored in the DNA. In the case of the Bitcoin challenge, there were a total of nine files contained in the DNA fragments. The files were encrypted with a keystream, which is a random series of characters that is included with the actual plain text message to obfuscate its meaning. The keystream code had been provided by Goldman in a document explaining the competition.

After running the code, Wuyts was able to combine the DNA fragments in the correct order to form one long piece of DNA. After working out some technical kinks, Wuyts was able to convert the DNA sequence into plain text, revealing the private key and unlocking the bitcoin (as well as some artefacts, including a drawing of James Joyce and the logo for the European Bioinformatics Institute). He had cracked the puzzle just five days before it was set to expire."

58 comments

  1. Ok by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So what?
    It's not like people are hiding stuff in DNA often.

    1. Re:Ok by Mr0bvious · · Score: 1

      Seems we live in different circles.

      --
      Never happened. True story.
  2. "One Bitcoin" by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 1, Troll

    He hid a private key. A string of text. That's it. The story has nothing to do with cryptocurrency.

    These guys stored a video clip in DNA.

    1. Re:"One Bitcoin" by Frosty+Piss · · Score: 2

      He hid a private key. A string of text. That's it. The story has nothing to do with cryptocurrency.

      Who said it did?

      --
      If you want news from today, you have to come back tomorrow.
    2. Re: "One Bitcoin" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      A bitcoin wallet consists of a private key and a public key. With the private key you can prove the wallet belongs to you and hence are able to start transactions.

      The private key hidden in the DNA belongs to a wallet in which 1 bitcoin was deposited, as a reward for solving the puzzle. So with recovering the private key, this student can access the bitcoin.

    3. Re:"One Bitcoin" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      The headline, ya dingus.

    4. Re: "One Bitcoin" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If true... this is astounding.

    5. Re:"One Bitcoin" by Frosty+Piss · · Score: 1

      The headline, ya dingus.

      BZZZZT! Wrong, Anon Coward, as usual.

      --
      If you want news from today, you have to come back tomorrow.
  3. Re:Ok, but Hillary is going to JAIL for TREASON by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Circles, like prokaryotic DNA?

  4. fuckin buttcoins by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Can this autism kroner bullshit finally crash? Does nobody understand the price is artificially inflated by the the tether money printer?

    The funniest thing is that bitcoin true believers were all about shitting on fractional reserves, but now that tether is printing fake money, they are all about fractional reserve scamming

    1. Re: fuckin buttcoins by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am more concerned with these fucks pushing up GPU prices.

    2. Re:fuckin buttcoins by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why does this bother you so? The lady doth protest too much, methinks.

    3. Re: fuckin buttcoins by DivineKnight · · Score: 1

      You know, AMD / Nvidia could always ramp up production...

    4. Re: fuckin buttcoins by supremebob · · Score: 1

      That's a risky move. By the time the extra stock is available, they crypto bubble might have burst and miners will be unloading their GPU's on eBay for half of what they paid for them.

      It would be good for consumers, I guess ($250 GeForce 1080's for everyone!), but it would probably kill AMD's and Nvidia's profits for a few quarters.

    5. Re: fuckin buttcoins by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You know, AMD / Nvidia could always ramp up production...

      No, they don't own their own foundries and can't just ramp up on a moments notice.

  5. BTC news stories by originalGMC · · Score: 1

    after all the hubbub of the BTC markets these days (even though comcast, 1 evil company still has a nearly equivalent market cap) I find this story to be both entertaining and relevant to the technology. Other BTC news stories are just not as fun or insightful, mostly about money grubbers and corporate cronies gaining/losing whatever, just don't care anymore! I wanna see a DNA blockchain now, can we put wifi chips in pigs and code their dna with the blockchain info? Or how about a DNA interface with a raspberry pi? Can anyone tell me / link me about DNA interoperability?

  6. the crash.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    if he would have worked faster, his 'prize' would have been $17k instead of 10k.. no.. 8k.. oh, wait.. 11k......

    1. Re:the crash.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      If anyone else had known about this treasure hunt, it would have been claimed long ago. Just sayin'

    2. Re:the crash.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      if he would have worked faster, his 'prize' would have been $17 instead of 10k..

      FTFY.

  7. But... by dohzer · · Score: 2

    But was it stored as big data in the DNA-cloud as a service?

    1. Re: But... by datavirtue · · Score: 1

      Holy shit...that is awesome

      --
      I object to power without constructive purpose. --Spock
  8. I remember that episode by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Picard received one section of the private key after the mysterious death of his old mentor - but he didn't know what it was at first, since they don't use money anymore in the 24th century. However they eventually figured out where more parts of the private key were, even though a Klingon captain and Tara King tried to interfere. Finally they got to the last planet, where the shapeshifter lady from DS9 gave a little holographic presentation.

    --
    #DeleteChrome
    1. Re:I remember that episode by Kremmy · · Score: 1

      Don't mind the anonymous coward. He thinks you're joking.

  9. Sad to see by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    This type of story is about as Geeky / Nerdy / Technology based as it gets, and the modern day Slashdotter does nothing but talk it down.

    Before this thread is done, we'll have Trump, Russians, guns, Hillary, luddites, a GD hosts file that can fix anything, things that go Moo, all sorts of slurs and a few homophobic topics to wade through.

    I don't think it's Slashdot that has lost its way, but rather the clientele that frequent these parts nowadays.

    You would think Slashdot was a subreddit by the way folks act around here anymore.

    1. Re:Sad to see by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In the interest of adding something about the actual article to the discussion, I came here to find out why they used base 3 and encoded the data in the change from one base to another, rather than just storing 2 bits per base directly.

      The original paper says

      The bytes comprising each file were represented as single DNA sequences with no homopolymers (runs of >= 2 identical bases, which are associated with higher error rates in existing high-throughput sequencing technologies and led to errors in Church et al.’s experiment)

      So, the same techniques used for reducing errors in magnetic information storage can also be used with DNA information storage!

    2. Re: Sad to see by datavirtue · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So, nothing has changed in 20 years. You are simply new here.

      --
      I object to power without constructive purpose. --Spock
    3. Re:Sad to see by mrbester · · Score: 1

      You forgot a Beowulf cluster of hot grits, you insensitive clod!

      --
      "Wait. Something's happening. It's opening up! My God, it's full of apricots!"
    4. Re: Sad to see by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      (Not the same poster you replied to here)

      No, there are very obviously changes that happened over that time.

      15 years ago political articles and technical articles both ended up with a very similar number of comments posted to them. Those numbers were also much larger as well.

      That is not even close to the comments posted today.

      One may initially think this is due to a smaller readership, and that no doubt has some effect of course.
      However the fact that political articles still get a high number of comments posted, the smaller readership can't be more than a tiny factor in things.

      Today political articles still get the same multiple hundreds of comments posted as in the past.
      Perhaps only 300-500 instead of 600-1000 comments, but still a very large number.

      Troll/flame articles used to be pretty equal to political comment counts, but today tend to be in the 100 range or even lower depending how beaten into the ground the topic is.

      Technical articles however? The days of 500-1000 comments are over. Today they only hit double-digits, and there are even occasional technical articles that don't get a single comment modded up over the default value of 3, aka a zero counter. (Not to say they deserve it, but still)

      Just a quick look at the front page right now shows this to be the case:

      13 - glucose tracking contact lenses - scientific
      114 - trump on nasa - political
      43 - this article - technical
      62 - fitbit ending pebble support - technical
      27 - Google X - technical
      56 - Apple and medical records - flamebait article
      161 - kim dotcom lawsuit - political
      97 - new york net neutrality - political
      51 - memes have rights - (ok no idea what this one would be)
      53 - monkey cloning - scientific
      107 - at&t net neutrality - political
      125 - microsoft and win10 - technical, and finally the first counter example to my point
      74 - fcc net neutrality - political
      197 - face swap porn - you'd think technical but the entire top 4/5ths of the comment section is political
      140 - tax cuts for intellectual property - political
      114 - apple - flamebait article
      222 - nsa thing - political
      39 - youtube and musicians - technical-ish?

      Nearly all political articles have hit triple digits.
      Only two technical articles have, one of which devolved into political very quickly.
      The other devolved into a privacy based argument, but I'll give you that one, that sort of thing has pretty much always been the case.

      I can't help but agree with the GP poster, this isn't specifically slashdot causing it, it is the readership.
      Most of todays readers don't even seem to know its even possible to submit articles, let alone the fact the site is driven by user submitted articles.

      The moderation system had evolved with the site up to a point, an by that point it was based on a larger readership and thus more mod points to go around. I'm not really sure it's evolved much since, and certainly not in a way that works with less users.

    5. Re: Sad to see by dave420 · · Score: 1

      A lot has changed in 20 years - go back and read some of the threads. A lot less negativity, more acceptance.

  10. How do I find the bitcoin in my DNA? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Help! I want to unlock the hidden value in my own DNA. Will this method work for me, too?

    1. Re:How do I find the bitcoin in my DNA? by Fly+Swatter · · Score: 1

      Is your DNA synthetic? Then I have bad news for you...

      Now if they had done this in the DNA of a living and functioning organism, then it would be news to me.

  11. Bet it was really an ancient Porn Video by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  12. Re: Ok, but Hillary is going to JAIL for TREASON by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No that would be Trump for obstruction of justice.

  13. GATTACA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Last I Iooked there were four bases, not three....

    1. Re:GATTACA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Three or four.... It doesn't matter because, either way, all your base are belong to us.

  14. Base-3 ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Shouldn't DNA need base-4 encoding ? It's GCAT... Using base-3 as described, how is a sequence of GGAA encoded, for instance ?

  15. This virtual money is virtually insane. by xxxLCxxx · · Score: 1

    This is insane and NOT funny:

    https://www.enbridge.com/energ...

    "Bitcoin is consuming enough energy to power Denmark for a year
    Mining the cryptocurrency ‘consumes a ridiculous amount of energy’ estimates suggest"

    For those of you who live in the US: Denmark is a small country up the north of Europe with less than 6 million inhabitants. In terms of civilization, it is more advanced than the US. This means that they consume energy in abundance.

    1. Re: This virtual money is virtually insane. by c6gunner · · Score: 1

      So basically it uses less power than New York city?

      It sounds so much more impressive when you compare it to a "country".

    2. Re: This virtual money is virtually insane. by xxxLCxxx · · Score: 1

      That doesn't make it any better.

  16. Not only beers by sad_ · · Score: 1

    You see, we Belgians are not only good in making beer, waffles, fries, ....

    --
    On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero.
    1. Re: Not only beers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well done!

  17. my grandfather hid his watch by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    in DNA during the war

  18. Wrong by dereference · · Score: 1

    At no point in the challenge was anything actually stored in actual DNA

    Finally we get an interesting article here, and the moron patrol is out in full force.

    FTFA: "During this presentation, Goldman distributed tubes of DNA in which he had encoded the key to a digital wallet containing one bitcoin." Near the end of the contest, there was a reminder tweet, and this student "requested a DNA sample from Goldman" and "also had access to sophisticated tools for genome sequencing."

  19. See Figure 1 by dereference · · Score: 4, Informative

    I wondered that as well, but the choice seems deliberate. The PDF says a single "trit" is encoded as the difference between each nucleotide and the next in the sequence, explicitly to avoid sequences with repeated nucleotides. For any given nucleotide, there are only three possible non-repeating values. The PDF goes on to mention that every other segment is reverse-complemented, and that this choice of non-repeating was important in order to readily determine whether any particular segment had been reversed or not.

    1. Re:See Figure 1 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      +1 Informative. You didn't expect me to actually RTFA did you?

  20. Nice! by DaMattster · · Score: 1

    He deserves that bitcoin!

  21. That's what I wanted to know too! by sabbede · · Score: 1

    Except I was wondering why base 3 instead of base 4, which would seem to make more sense considering that there are 4 amino acids involved. But is it really base 3, or is it something like base 3(rot1)?

  22. grad student learns how to apply 3-year old method by Rutulian · · Score: 1

    He had cracked the puzzle just five days before it was set to expire.

    Cracked the puzzle?!! I'm sorry, but this is just stupid. There was no puzzle. The supplementary document provided by Goldman provides a precise specification for how the files are encoded. The only thing an interested person had to do is just apply that specification to a decoding task. Happy for the grad student, though, who has probably doubled his income this year.

  23. Huffman by dereference · · Score: 2

    It's really base 3. One "trit" is encoded as the transition from each nucleotide to the next. With no repeats, there are only three possible choices for the next nucleotide in the sequence. The PDF goes on to mention that every other segment is reverse-complemented, and that this choice of non-repeating was also important in order to readily determine whether any particular segment had been reversed or not.

    1. Re:Huffman by sabbede · · Score: 1

      Thanks!

  24. DIY Cryptocurrency Mining... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you want to get in on the cryptocurrency mining scene, you need a good motherboard that allows for multiple GPUs: ASRock H110 Pro BTC+, ASUS B250, Biostar TB350-BTC, and GIGABYTE GA-H110-D3A.

  25. science by Maksim1997 · · Score: 1

    If you are interested in similar scientific stories I can advise you should have a glance at the link Here you will find rules of writing an intro for essays. And also you can read interesting essays.