Slashdot Mirror


KeepVid Site No Longer Allows Users To 'Keep' Videos (torrentfreak.com)

An anonymous reader quotes a report from TorrentFreak: For many years, KeepVid has been a prime destination for people who wanted to download videos from YouTube, Dailymotion, Facebook, Vimeo, and dozens of other sites. The web application was free and worked without any hassle. This was still the case earlier this month when the site advertised itself as follows: "KeepVid Video Downloader is a free web application that allows you to download videos from sites like YouTube, Facebook, Twitch.Tv, Vimeo, Dailymotion and many more." However, a few days ago the site radically changed its course. While the motivation is unknown at the time, KeepVid took its popular video download service offline without prior notice. Today, people can no longer use the KeepVid site to download videos. On the contrary, the site warns that using video download and conversion tools might get people in trouble. "Video downloading from the Internet will become more and more difficult, and KeepVid encourages people to download videos via the correct and legal ways," the new KeepVid reads. The site now lists several alternative options to enjoy videos and music, including Netflix, Hulu, Spotify, and Pandora.

73 comments

  1. Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I just use softwares like Jdownloader, which let you download videos among other things, quickly and easily, if I need to download anything.
    Otherwise I can just as easily Inspect Element on video streams and get the direct URL of it to download.

    1. Re:Meh by sexconker · · Score: 3, Informative

      Otherwise I can just as easily Inspect Element on video streams and get the direct URL of it to download.

      No you can't. Most major platforms have layers and layers of obfuscating javascript, and the actual resource URL isn't exposed in the DOM, and neither is the key you need to get a working response from the server.

      And many platforms have obnoxious DRM on top of that.

    2. Re:Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      +1 for jdownloader. Works with a shitload of sites other than youtube, intuitive GUI and clipboard monitoring, and can be used as a generic download manager as well. Devs seem to do a good job updating it promptly when sites break it, too.

      Only complaint is that it's a touch on the heavy side for what it does. Java's fault, I assume.

    3. Re: Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is where monitoring your network traffic comes in handy.

    4. Re: Meh by ArchieBunker · · Score: 1

      Why isn't there some driver that just grabs the video stream from the tcp connection? Something like ngrep but specialized for video.

      --
      Only the State obtains its revenue by coercion. - Murray Rothbard
    5. Re: Meh by mysidia · · Score: 1

      These days it's usually sending the video over a HTTPS connection, so just snagging the TCP stream isn't quite enough.

    6. Re: Meh by Sigma+7 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      This would be a specialized proxy server, an extremely "niche" use where I haven't seen obvious instructions on how to setup. The steps involved are also the scary "OMG, you're becoming vulnerable to MitM attacks" despite the process actually being safe. Plenty of obstacles as well. 1. No easy toggle for switching to and from a proxy server. There's extensions/utilities for this, but you have to find them. 2. HTTPS requires you to create and install both a root and intermediate certificate. (Which basically shows that HTTPS simply just prevents casual interception - any skilled malware author could trivially intercept anything.) 3. Current video sites download the stuff in piecemeal (either DRM style, or as a means to save bandwidth). You need special software to patch them together again. 4. (If running a caching proxy) The HTTP standard document (some random RFC) is no longer the comprehensive standard. Any trivial mistake (including something not obvious in the origianl document) confuses the browser. None of this stops pirates or experienced programmers, only casual users.

    7. Re:Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      youtube-dl works well for youtube and many other sites.

    8. Re: Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      HTTPS is trivial when you control the browser that decodes it. Use an open-source browser like firefox, add a hook for saving the decrypted video stream. Browser likely uses a video library, so put it there. The hardware driver is another option.

    9. Re:Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I hate to burst your bubble, but it is amazingly simple to do it on your own. I've been doing it for years. There is a standard format for all streaming video, I'll give you a hint... #EXT it comes in a master file and I won't give the name of that file, well maybe accidently one day. You do need to piece together the individual streams but that is simple to write.. What about the encryption you say??? There are loads of open source programs that do the decryption and the master file that I won't give the name of tells you where to get the decryption key from.

      The bad news is there is layer upon layer to get to the point that the server will hand you this master file. But, most of the time what you need to get though the layers is in the cookies. Also most websites depend on adobe as the key keeper, yes adobe. If you can find out how a major network, just pick one, interacts with adobe and learn the way the auth_pass is laid out, adobe hands you the keys to almost all kingdoms. I figured it over a weekend and I'm no genius.

  2. bye bye by supernova87a · · Score: 4, Informative

    The site's content is straight out of Google Translate engine and smacks of someone in a foreign country being hit with a lawsuit and putting up this content to satisfy the terms of the settlement. Goodbye, keepvid.com, as you get forgotten in the search rankings.

    1. Re:bye bye by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's OK, as AI progresses, good luck at trying to keep people's actual eyeballs on your site. In the future, AI will be used as both further ad filter, content finder, and content creator.

    2. Re: bye bye by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You only see one side of the arms race, as if AI was going to evolve in end user tools but companies would stick with web 2.0 websites. That's not how life works.

  3. Well... by Known+Nutter · · Score: 2

    Well fuck.

    --
    Beware of the Leopard.
    1. Re:Well... by AmiMoJo · · Score: 2

      Try 4k Video Downloader. Works great for me.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    2. Re:Well... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      me too!! 4K mp3 downloader too!

  4. Who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Just use youtube-dl or a browser extension.

    1. Re:Who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      that method is starting to break thanks to changes in youtube's site and how (at present, some) videos are delivered to the browser. i fully expect youtube to complete the process and use drm on all videos, even ones of totally original content, by year's end.

    2. Re:Who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If so, it would hopefully hasten Youtube's death.

    3. Re:Who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      In my experience, sites break youtube-dl frequently. It often fails the first time I use it in a day. But it's almost always already been fixed; all I need to do is check for an update and it's working again.

    4. Re:Who cares? by Catbeller · · Score: 1

      Can't wait for the Ctr / Print Scrn key combo to be disabled.

      I'll keep my old boxen around as long as I can. The internet is a cable TV system now.

    5. Re:Who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ty, excellent advice, and concise

  5. was bound to happen eventually by v1 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    it really sounds like they got hit with a big threat from someone (like youtube) and were given the no-choice-choice of 100% compliance with their demands or facing a bankrupting lawsuit. The typical demand is:

    1. take down your service immediately
    2. never come back
    3. don't tell anyone who we are

    "in exchange, we won't sue you into oblivion"

    --
    I work for the Department of Redundancy Department.
    1. Re:was bound to happen eventually by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I just hit the record button. Oh, wait, you don't have one of those, too bad. Us old timers with our actual buttons and switches that can't be software locked aren't phased by this.

    2. Re:was bound to happen eventually by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      what happens when your gramophone breaks gramps?

    3. Re:was bound to happen eventually by technosaurus · · Score: 1

      What is the most popular site not mentioned in the recommended alternatives??? That is the aggresor. They werent allowed to publicize them, so they just made it easy to deduce.

    4. Re: was bound to happen eventually by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      He can fix it, unlike your iphone.

    5. Re:was bound to happen eventually by Chrisq · · Score: 1

      what happens when your gramophone breaks gramps?

      Gramophone? - What's wrong with the good old wax cylinders?

    6. Re:was bound to happen eventually by infolation · · Score: 3, Funny

      Because Edison only invented wax cylinders in 1885. Before that, way back in 1877, he was using tin foil cylinders and, as every Slashdot reader knows, tin foil is the answer to every problem.

  6. Thought control continues... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Because downloading the videos keeps facts alive that YouTube et al would rather make disappear and be forgotten.

    1. Re:Thought control continues... by michelcolman · · Score: 1

      No, not at all. You are still allowed to download them, they just "encourage people to download videos via the correct and legal ways".

      Now all we need to figure out is how to actually do that.

  7. Use youtube-dl by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    It can download from most major sites and even a few of the smaller ones. It let's you pick what format the video is (or only the audio from YouTube videos if you prefer to listen to them as podcasts).

    1. Re:Use youtube-dl by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Exactly

    2. Re:Use youtube-dl by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Youtube-dl will grab an entire playlist - it'll even snag a whole series off crunchyroll along with the subtitles. Occasionally it breaks... but then they fix it. 10/10.

  8. Motivation by manu0601 · · Score: 1

    While the motivation is unknown at the time, KeepVid took its popular video download service offline without prior notice.

    Probable motivation: they got a letter from a some company's attorney

    1. Re:Motivation by mikael · · Score: 1

      Youtube were announcing that they were banning gun related videos. Presumably, they want to stop anyone from keeping and archiving these videos. Same with anything political sensitive.

      --
      Vintage computer adverts: http://www.vintageadbrowser.com/computers-and-software-ads
  9. What's a good web-based alternative? by GameboyRMH · · Score: 1

    I know all about the various client programs. but sometimes you're on someone else's computer and you don't have those, so what's a good web-based alternative to KeepVid?

    --
    "When information is power, privacy is freedom" - Jah-Wren Ryel
    1. Re:What's a good web-based alternative? by sonicmerlin · · Score: 1

      clipconverter.cc

    2. Re:What's a good web-based alternative? by AC-x · · Score: 1

      If they have Windows 10 you can always Win-G and use the built-in screen recorder. Not as convenient as downloading the clip directly but it gets the job done.

  10. I bet anything it was... by denis.goddard · · Score: 1

    Google trying to get more $$$ from the flailing YouTube Red

    1. Re:I bet anything it was... by wardrich86 · · Score: 1

      Google trying to get more $$$ from the flailing YouTube Red

      Maybe they should consider releasing it in more countries... then I wouldn't have to constantly be using hacked apk's to get adblocking on YouTube.

    2. Re:I bet anything it was... by Lord+Kano · · Score: 1

      CBS All Access, YouTube Red, Disney's Whatever Service and what next? They need to accept that Netflix and Amazon are in charge with Hulu as the straggling little brother.

      I'm actually interested in watching the Cobra Kai series but I'm NOT subscribing to YouTube Red. That shit is just not going to happen.

      LK

      --
      "Hi. This is my friend, Jack Shit, and you don't know him." - Lord Kano
    3. Re:I bet anything it was... by war4peace · · Score: 1

      This. I want it but it's unavailable in my country.

      --
      ...gis sdrawkcab (usually not responding to ACs; don't bother posting as AC)
  11. Pity by carriegy · · Score: 1

    It's really a pity when I know the news. But my friends send an alternative: https://www.vidpaw.com/ It's free and safe, I've used it to download several videos.

  12. Just use youtube-dl or quvi by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    It is a bad idea to rely on web sites such as keepvid that are full of ads and incomprehensible scripts that do god-knows-what.

    It is a much better idea to instead use a free and open-source video-downloader such as youtube-dl or quvi.

    And if the maintainers/developers of youtube-dl or quvi decide to discontinue the project and "encourage people to download videos via the correct and legal ways", then you can always fork the code. That's the beauty of free/libre software.

    This situation is a perfect example of why Richard Stallman warned about "Service as a Software Substitute (SASS)". i.e. websites that offer a "service", that should instead be done by a software program running locally on your computer, fully under your control.

    1. Re:Just use youtube-dl or quvi by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And if the maintainers/developers of youtube-dl or quvi decide to discontinue the project and "encourage people to download videos via the correct and legal ways", then you can always fork the code.

      Yeah, and deal with the semi-monthly changes the web site makes, to keep your fork functional.

      I swear, some commercial web sites change every few weeks to deter screen scrapers. That, or their designers have nothing better to do.

  13. ClipGrab or Youtube-dl by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Been using both of them for a while now. Highly recommended.
    Download audio of talks and audiobooks on Youtube, and put it on the phone to listen in my car during my commute.

  14. I know how this war ends by istartedi · · Score: 2

    I don't know how WW3 will be fought, but video war X will be fought with a vintage analog video recorder aimed at a monitor.

    --
    For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    1. Re:I know how this war ends by k6mfw · · Score: 1

      I don't know how WW3 will be fought, but video war X will be fought with a vintage analog video recorder aimed at a monitor.

      Yeow, I just did that the other day. I wanted to make a small video clip (90 seconds) of an episode of Kolchak The Night Stalker where he talks with an exterminator about rats.

      Instead of camera aimed at monitor, I fed HDMI output to a HDMI to composite converter. Composite routed to a Firestore DVR.

      Clip is for a safety manager to highlight PPE not used in 1974. Also to show where exterminator eating a sandwich while spraying bushes. Kolchak commented concern of poison on the sandwich but exterminator replied, "It's already loaded with chemicals and preservatives, what difference does it make."

      I didn't go to keepvid because I don't want entire episode (YT has them all), only just that portion.

      OK, download videos with proper and legal means... however, there are many unique videos online that finding the proper source to purchase is more difficult than finding Jimmy Hoffa.

      --
      mfwright@batnet.com
    2. Re:I know how this war ends by AnalogDiehard · · Score: 1

      I don't know how WW3 will be fought, but video war X will be fought with a vintage analog video recorder aimed at a monitor

      Good luck, because HDMI has replaced VGA ports on every computer and any VGA converter reduces the display resolution. That's by design to prevent piracy - recording a low resolution VGA display with a video recorder results in grainy video.

      --
      Eternity: will that be smoking, or non-smoking? I Corinthians 6:9-10
    3. Re:I know how this war ends by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      that site has blatant misinformation.

      "VGA, even in its highest resolution from SVGA, is only capable of an 800 x 600-pixel resolution" - in the context of VGA cables, this is some good crack they are smoking. XGA is a subset of SVGA and includes eg. 1600x1200 which was a popular graphical designer choice.

      Per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... "SVGA effectively supported resolutions like 1280x800 and higher"

      And higher! Words mean things.

      Now I know, citing wikipedia, but a lot of folks here used larger resolutions too.

    4. Re:I know how this war ends by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You've also got an educational fair-use claim here. The clips you selected are short and the use is illustrative, not used in their original narrative form at all.

      ymmv by country, ianal, etc.

  15. The least they can do by wolfheart111 · · Score: 1

    Is post their source on Github... dambit. Its probably just a simple solution... but damb, G has some great developers.

    --
    [($)]
    1. Re:The least they can do by Meneth · · Score: 2

      https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl

      It's not KeepVid, but it's pretty darn good if you like command line interfaces.

  16. Plenty of alternatives by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Using websites is so unnecessary. You can easily use programs like youtube-dl or even VLC to download, not to mention the plethora of firefox addons.

  17. Codes Of Conduct defeat you. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Codes of Conduct will prevent such forks from being hosted.

    Codes of Conduct the kryptonite against the mMMAALLLLEEEE free software developers

  18. Give up Vid by stooo · · Score: 2

    "Keepvid" becomes "Give up Vid"

    --
    aaaaaaa
    1. Re:Give up Vid by Impy+the+Impiuos+Imp · · Score: 1

      "KeepVid" becomes "Gives Up Ass"

      --
      (-1: Post disagrees with my already-settled worldview) is not a valid mod option.
  19. KeepVid Alternative by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The site is not working since Mar 18th... Well, if you're looking for KeepVid substitute, try amoyshare free video finder. It's a free online service.

  20. They also broke their desktop downloader by Static · · Score: 1

    You know, the one they wanted you to buy. It still does conversion, but downloading has been downloaded and it won't download from youtube at all anymore.

  21. It's still up. Literally fake news. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I don't understand anything at all here. THE KEEPVID SITE IS STILL ONLINE AND WORKING. Just to be sure, I used it to download two different videos from youtube. Both worked perfectly. For some reason the site only offered 720p download, not 1080, though, but other than that it works perfectly fine.

    Oh wait. You guys aren't using keepvid.com, right? You are using the actual keepvid site? Right?

    1. Re:It's still up. Literally fake news. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I just looked at keepvid.com and it was nothing but a long tablet-friendly info-graphic page.

      Download YouTube Tips
      KeepVid Tips for Video Download Solutions
      Which Websites Do People Download Videos from?

      KeepVid finds an online survey about video download, and this survey shows the statistics about video sharing sites that people mainly download videos from. The following chart shows you more details:

      Which Site Has Most Video Download Requests?

      YouTube owns the largest video download requests. More than 92% video fans download videos from YouTube.
      Lynda.com is also a popular website which people would like to download videos from, and it owns more than 5% of the total download requests.
      Facebook, the largest social network in the world, occupies 1% of the total downloads.
      Other sites like Dailymotion, Vimeo and so on, share the extra 2% of total video download requests.
      Disclaimer: KeepVid gets the statistics from the Internet, and KeepVid doesn’t ensure the absolute .accuracy of the number of all video download requests.
      What Video Categories Does YouTube.com Have?

      KeepVid learns that YouTube provides certain copyright-free videos for users to download without any problem, but most of the videos are copy-right protected by the video owners. KeepVid divides all YouTube videos into several categories according to YouTube copyright restrictions:
      Copyright-protected videosCopyright-free videosCopyright-protected musicCopyright-free musicVideos uploaded by ourselves
      What Are the Problems and Issues for Video Download?

      People may go against the YouTube rules when they download videos online. KeepVid will show you the regulations about downloading videos on YouTube as below:
      You shall not download any Content unless you see a “download” or similar link displayed by YouTube on the Service for that Content.
      —— Quoted from YouTube by KeepVid.com Learn More >
      According to the ToS of YouTube, KeepVid unveils that users aren’t allowed to download videos from YouTube, unless the videos are for fair use or permitted to be downloaded in the service.
      KeepVid Tips about How to Watch and Download Videos in the Market

      There are many video sharing sites in the market. KeepVid learns from their website descriptions that these websites allow you to download videos and watch them offline. In this part, KeepVid will introduce you the top sites to watch and download videos.
      Note: Using these downloaders to download copyright-protected videos or the videos without permissions may put you into risks. KeepVId suggest you download videos legally in accordance with the related terms and conditions.
      KeepVid Ideas about Top 3 Sites to Watch and Download Videos

      1. YouTube
      YouTube.com is a video sharing website that can help you to watch and download videos. KeepVid thinks that this website is undoubtedly the first choice when you want to watch and download videos.

      2. Vimeo
      According to the description from this site, KeepVid thinks this online video sharing site is also helpful. With this site, KeepVid believes that you can watch and download videos with easy process.

      3. Lynda.com
      Lynda.com is a video sharing site, and it provides video download features as well. But KeepVid knows that you’ll have to pay for subscription before you can save the videos for offline enjoyment.
      KeepVid Ideas about Top 3 Sites to Watch and Download Movies

      1. Hulu.com
      KeepVid thinks that hulu.com is the most popular video site among all the video fans. This website enables you to watch videos online and download videos for offline enjoyment after you subscribe to it.

      2. Netflix.com
      KeepVid finds out that website is also a very popular place to watch and download videos to your computer. The website enables you to watch videos if you’ve paid for the subscription, and it also allows you to download videos to your computer or device for offline enjoyme

    2. Re:It's still up. Literally fake news. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      (same AC) Ahhhhh, okay I see. Very clever.

      Regardless, I've been using other sites like clipconvertor since KV doesn't do 1080p+ for free anymore and I prefer to get the largest size available. I keep meaning to try youtube-dl but it always slips my mind.

  22. Alternative by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I've found this https://hooktube.com/, which not only has a better interface than youtube but also allows bypassing restrictions.

  23. Sharing Mine by AaronLee · · Score: 1

    Sad to know about the KeepVid shuts down, but I am lucky to found out that https://www.vidpaw.com/ will work.

  24. just fucking stop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    you fucking idiots, stop clogging my intertubez with your lame video shit. go watch paint dry.

  25. program name is new. "long live the program.. by MichaelRudner · · Score: 1

    and its programmers"

  26. google "keepvid alternative" by MichaelRudner · · Score: 1

    and move on user EOF

  27. And that's all, folks. by Catbeller · · Score: 1

    Dad da da da da daaaaaa da.

    RIP Internet.

  28. Can I have my 1990s Internet back by sheph · · Score: 1

    I liked it better when corporations were afraid of the Internet and didn't want anything to do with it.

    --
    I don't believe in karma, I just call it like I see it.
  29. If you can stream you can copy. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The LAST hope of the streamers is 'protected path'- hardware in the CPU and GPU that decodes the video at the last possible moment in an attempt to prevent data intercept on your computer.

    But in truth, especially now AMD gives us cheap powerful mutli-core solutions, even that fails by 'camming', pointing a good camera at the monitor and allowing software to capture, correct, and create video data. Few want to 'cam' at home today, but if push comes to shove, it will be trivial enough for anyone to do.

    The Beatles spent millions on always hopeless attempts to protect their music on record and tape. Sane media experts know the answer is to provide the public with services they want to pay for- clean and convenient- and that a war on potential customers is simply self-defeating.

    Those that want to 'pirate' see it as a hobby, and will thusly put much effort in. When the industry fights such people, it is utterly futile. Ensuring that most people never invest in the 'pirate' hobby is the right way to go- and that means giving them commercial services that are 'easier'.

    Ordinary punters want to PAY ONCE, and then be able to access whatever they want. It is for the industry to ensure single outlets contain the majority of content people want. Punters should not be forced to be aware of 'studio wars'.

    PS the US government, back in the day, had to take cinemas out of the hands of the studios to ensure the principle I've explained above. Before, studios played a 'content' game where their cinema wouldn't play the content from another studio. Amazon, Netfix et al should be allowed to carry ALL film, TV and music content- a single point of access, with royalties then distributed to the creators of consumed content.

  30. Re:I like this guy by wolfheart111 · · Score: 1

    Here is a good author. :) Interesting reads indeed. https://github.com/jeckman/

    --
    [($)]