Internet Censorship in Utah Schools & Libraries

One of my old partners in crime, Michael Sims, contacted me with the latest report from Censorware.org. By analyzing their web logs, Censorware found that they were blocking access to such offensive materials as The Bible, and The Declaration of Independence, and the US Constitution, using the unaptly named SmartFilter software. Check out the Salt Lake Tribune for more information.

Comments

Censorship is _never_ GOOD...

[ethereal]

First things first: I agree with you wholeheartedly that community resources like computing time in the library or in school shouldn't be wasted on browsing porn, etc. Of course, they shouldn't be wasted browsing the news, ESPN, or Slashdot either, unless that's an assignment or research project. It's a non-argument that schools and libraries exist to provide information, not entertainment, and when resources are limited, those with legitimate information needs should get preference over mere web browsers.

...but what is inarguable is that children should simply not be allowed to view certain things...

However, I will certainly argue with that. Who decides these "certain things"? I certainly wouldn't be comfortable with your choices for what my kids should see, because I have no idea what your beliefs are - your religious convictions, your morals, even your taste in art. Can't have you deciding things for my kids.

I'll go a step further and say that I may not even be a good person to decide which "certain things" we censor. Why, you ask? For all you know, I might be a militant flat-earther, a Luddite, or some other persuasion of thought that society generally sees as reactionary. Do you want me to decide that your kids shouldn't read about space travel, evolution, or medical information about the human body?

Granted, none of my examples address the examples that you mentioned. Personally, I happen to agree with you that I wouldn't be crazy about my kids learning how to treat women from pornography, or learning about the rest of the world from a Nazi viewpoint. However, I don't see censorship at school as a solution. Why?

• Because reading about Nazis or pornography on the Internet doesn't automatically make you a racist or a wife-beater. If my kids are that impressionable, then I've already been making mistakes as a parent for a long time. There's a big difference between finding out that something exists, and wholeheartedly espousing it as a way of life. Most of the porn I've run into on the Internet was more laughable than anything, and certainly hasn't altered the way I treat my wife, for example.
• Because by the time someone is 13, like it or not they are going to have to deal with adult issues. If your kid gets to age 13 before he hears an off-color joke that puts down women or another race, then please let me know what school system you're in! Kids are blasted with the same flood of information and impressions as any of us, and you can't really shelter them once they head off for that first day of school. The only thing you can do as a parent is try to explain to them not just how to act but why to act that way, so that they can make their own decisions about porn, etc. Children have to be taught to have an open mind but at the same time be skeptical about what they hear.
• Because I as a parent could be wrong in my views. For example, my grandparents held rather, um, conservative views on race and so on. However, their daughter turned out to be the most open-minded person I know, regardless of the way she was raised. If she hadn't been able to learn that there were other viewpoints, she might be a very different person today. Give people enough information and let them draw their own conclusions - the worst thing you can do to a person is to deny them access ideas that let them make their own decisions.
• Because, believe it or not, we the community could all be wrong in what we think is right. There are plenty of crazy people out in the world, and 99% of their ideas are worthless. But there are also the brilliant people who can make the mental leap to the next level, and we don't want to ignore them just because they don't fit our conventions. People that can really change things if we cultivate an open mind: Jesus Christ, Galileo Galilei, Mahatma Gandhi, and so forth. All of these people offended the views of the majority at the time, and all of them went on to really shake things up. Now, I personally don't think that skinheads have the right perspective on the world, but I'm not willing to censor 99% of the crazy people and risk not hearing about the next revolutionary idea.

An idea

[Mr T]

What if you had to log in at a school? Colleges require this. Then each month or something, the list of URLs visited by the student get's mailed to their parents, it could even be assembled into an easy access webpage type list on a disc. No censorship or anything of that sort, just tracking.

Naturally, when your 16 year old daughter is visiting lot's of sites about birth control you're going to want to have a sit-down with her. The thing is, you should have that talk with her anyways.