Slashdot Mirror


User: Wycliffe

Wycliffe's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
2,529
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 2,529

  1. Re:Fire them. on Once Again, Baltimore Police Arrest a Person For Recording Them · · Score: 2

    they can determine quickly and unilaterally which specific cases are firable offenses?

    yes the cops are ignoring a law and a directive but they are doing so specifically because your stupid suggestion isn't possible and they know it.

    The police chief and/or the mayor and/or the police department has the ability to decide what is a fireable offense and what is not.
    Many places falling asleep on the job even once is a fireable offense and some even showing up to work late once is fireable.
    If the fireable offense are listed and well documented then even most unions will leave them alone.
    There are plenty of fireable offense for a police officer. The only reason this is being ignored is because it is not considered serious.
    Putting out a memo that says "harassing a bystander with a camera or deleting something from a bystander's camera" is grounds
    for immediate termination is all that it would take. Obviously asking them to leave or stand back where safety is concerned is
    reasonable but taking their phone from them and accessing it should be on the same level as tasering them or punching them in
    the face or making them remove their clothes. There is absolutely no reason a cop should take a phone from a bystander and
    start deleting stuff. Taking a phone for evidence or for safety, maybe, but even for evidence, the street cop shouldn't be accessing
    it, it should be accessed by a forensic team who is recording and documenting what they are doing.

  2. Re:gotta be Bennett on An Algorithm To Prevent Twitter Hashtag Degeneration · · Score: 1

    They've already got the "block by posting editor" feature. All they have to do is make Bennett an editor.

    Yeah, it's very bizarre. He's obviously associated with slashdot somehow. It would make sense to have him post
    his own articles under his own name. His articles are also 10 times longer than other submissions. It would also make
    sense to have them on their own page instead of cramming 10 paragraphs into what is suppose to be a summary.

  3. Re:gotta be Bennett on An Algorithm To Prevent Twitter Hashtag Degeneration · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Is there a chrome extension that blocks slashdot stories with "Bennett Haselton" yet?

    They let us moderate, metamoderate, and even flag everyone else's comments. They should at
    least give us the "flag this post as spam" option for posted articles. It might help them realize
    which articles suck and which don't. I wonder if they don't just count the total number of comments
    and as Bennett gets a bunch of comments (most of which are saying how much everyone hates
    his articles), they think his articles are popular because they aren't reading the actual comments.

  4. Re:Reduced revenues != lost profit on Utilities Face Billions In Losses From Distributed Renewables · · Score: 1

    It's still going to be cheaper for a utility company to set up hundreds
    of solar panels and sell the electricity to consumers than it will be for everyone to buy/maintain their own system.

    Only if energy companies are willing to accept zero profit.

    A utility company could easily still make a profit using the same technology as the consumer.
    If they save only 10% via economy of scale and then tack on another 10% for the customer
    convenience of not having to maintain their own system, that is 20% right there. My guess is
    that economy of scale is closer to 50% as the utility company can use technologies that are
    not practical at the home level, cut corners that are not safe at the home level, optimize in
    ways that are not practical at the home level as well as buy in bulk and create custom specs.

    A power plant near my house did a $20 million dollar upgrade which was suppose to increase
    yield by 5%. They said that if it worked then they would break even after 3 months.
    Those type of optimizations are just not practical on the individual level.

  5. Re:Reduced revenues != lost profit on Utilities Face Billions In Losses From Distributed Renewables · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Well, they're kind of in a losing position - raise rates to pay for losses, and people just move to renewables sooner.

    It seems pretty clear that generating electricity from free sunlight is going to be cheaper than mining and transporting fossil fuels to a complex facility to burn them.

    Even IF green energy becomes cheaper, this doesn't mean distributed power is going away anytime soon,
    it just means that large power companies will have to move to green energy sooner.
    Economy of scale still applies to solar energy. It's still going to be cheaper for a utility company to set up hundreds
    of solar panels and sell the electricity to consumers than it will be for everyone to buy/maintain their own system.
    There is a potential saving by being able to eliminate distribution costs so it's possible that local generation could
    bet out economy of scale if distribution costs are a significant part. So the question really becomes
    what percentage of your electricity price is generation and what percentage is distribution?
    The other way that local generation wins is if people start installing solar for reasons other that cost of generation.

  6. Re: I'm sorry on Microsoft's New Windows Monetization Methods Could Mean 'Subscriptions' · · Score: 1

    at $10/month you start overpaying for office in only 2 years. If you're upgrading your computer every 2 years
    or suspend it for long lengths of time so you never reach 25 months before you upgrade then this might make
    sense but for most people who upgrade their computer every 3-5 years or longer then renting is definitely more
    expensive. We ran office 97 for probably about 10 years before switching everyone to openoffice. Our copy of
    office97 actually outlasted multiple PCs. We would just transfer it over to the new PC.

  7. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 1

    The rest of your post is filled with bold speculation, and causual observation, and "what ifs".

    I'm not saying you're not entitled to your views, I'm just saying its not science.

    That's kindof the point of this article. So James Watson states an opinion based on
    his casual observation and bold speculations and gets railroaded for it.
    Here is an interesting article about it: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/...
    Skip down to the "known facts section":
    1) No one has a firm handle...
    2) No one has a firm idea...
    3) No one has proof...
    4) As for "race", it's a sticky muck...
    5) Like "intelligence", the term "race" is ill-defined...

    Note that this is an article that comes out AGAINST James Watson but clearly admits
    that noone knows. So a man was crucified for stating an opinion in a largely gray area.
    Here is another quote from James Watson:
    If someone's liver doesn't work, we blame it on the genes; if someone's brain doesn't work properly, we blame the school. It's actually more humane to think of the condition as genetic. For instance, you don't want to say that someone is born unpleasant, but sometimes that might be true.
    and another:
    We're not all equal, it's simply not true. That isn't science.
    and another:
    Our goal should be to understand our differences.
    and another:
    Ultimately, we'll help the people we discriminate against if we try to understand more about them; genetics will lead to a world where there is a sympathy for the underdog.

    James Watson firmly believes that there is a strong genetic component to intelligence and personality.
    This doesn't instantly make him a racist. It makes him fall on one side of the nature/nurture debate
    that is still very much up in the air. This isn't just some random part of him, if he didn't strongly believe
    in the nature side then it's very probable that he would have never discovered the DNA that gave him
    his nobel prize.

  8. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 1

    Say it again, there is no scientific proof that diffrences between races are greater than diffrences between inviduals. In fact there is proof in the opposite.

    Difference between individuals is greater than differences between races
    is not the same as saying there are no differences between races.
    There will always be outliers but there is no denying there are difference
    between races. There are even diseases that attack certain races more
    than others and medicine specifically targetted at those diseases.
    Heck, there are traits that are specific to a particular religion like
    Amish are more likely to be born with 12 fingers. Any isolated group
    will start to have divergent traits. Average skin color isn't the only
    difference between africans and caucasians. It would be shocking if
    average intelligence, average height, etc... was exactly the same.
    Whether the difference is significant is up for debate but there are
    definitely going to be differences in any group isolated and allowed to
    drift. I would argue that there are probably also significant differences
    between the different regions of africa and definitely differences
    between blacks living in africa and the ones that have lived in the
    USA for several hundred years. The conditions in africa and the conditions in
    the USA over the past several hundred years have been considerably
    different so it only makes sense that certain traits that were advantageous
    in one place and not that other were probably passed on more.
    The same could probably be said of the differences between europeans
    and americans. There were several selection biases that probably started
    it out skewed like religious persecution. It very well could even explain
    why americans on average are more religious that their european counterparts.
    Sure, there's cultural influences but I wouldn't be surprised if there was
    a slight genetic component too.

  9. Re:What a minute here!! on Displaced IT Workers Being Silenced · · Score: 1

    Except that they basically would deem that American "unqualified", thus not a real contender.

    If you had to pay the h1b1 applicant 4 times the american, what would be the incentive to deem the american unqualified?

  10. Re:H1-B debate? on Displaced IT Workers Being Silenced · · Score: 1

    Both are true, from a certain point of view. Any time you would say, "there are not enough qualified applicants", there's a good chance that you could still find enough if you were willing to pay enough. But perhaps the "enough" that you'd have to pay is simply unreasonable. So in my opinion, that's really the question that we need to answer: Is the 'enough' that you'd have to pay in order to attract qualified applicants unreasonably high?

    There is also the difference between the individual company and the economy as a whole.
    As an individual company (i.e. google), I could easily get enough employees if I paid double what
    facebook paid but if there are truly not enough employees then this will cause an upward spiral of
    scalping from each other until someone can't afford it anymore. This may or may not be a bad
    outcome.

  11. Re:H1-B debate? on Displaced IT Workers Being Silenced · · Score: 1

    The problem is defining the prevailing wage.

    And why would you make it a tax? If you can identify the rate that other, similarly qualified people are making, then you can just require that H1Bs get paid 10% more than that.

    You answered your own question. It's next to impossible to define the prevailing wage. It's much simpler
    to say that we don't care what you pay them but you must pay 50% over whatever they are willing to work for.
    A combination of you must pay the "prevailing wage" and half again as much to the government might be a
    good solution. The point is to make it so that H1B1s are considerably more expensive than hiring locally.
    If you have an important position that you REALLY need someone and can't find someone local then you'll
    be willing to pay the premium. It doesn't make sense to give that extra to the H1B1 holder. Why should the
    H1B1 holder get paid more than local talent? It does make sense though to make H1B1 holders more
    expensive than local talent. The other advantage of having a 50% tax on H1B1 wages is that then instead
    of driving local wages down they drive local wages up as it's much cheaper to give a local a 25% pay increase
    than it is to pay the H1B1 tax.
    The "no quality candidates" problem can be more easily seen in the trucking industry. The complaint there
    is that there are not enough truck drivers. The truth is that they just don't pay enough. Almost anyone can
    drive a truck with only minimal training. If you doubled the salary of truck drivers then you could easily find
    plenty of candidates. You actually see this from time to time. As truck driver salaries start to increase then
    factory workers start quiting their jobs and becoming truck drivers.

  12. Re:Wouldn't it be easier to just circumvent Adbloc on French Publishers Prepare Lawsuit Against Adblock Plus · · Score: 1

    Most (all?) ABP users use blocklists that are updated frequently, the plugin itself doesn't change that often. And you can naturally add your own (regex-based) rules. Sure, it might work, for a little while. But it is ultimately futile.

    I don't think it's futile. A website knows if you view their ads. There are already websites that block your access if you
    turn off their ads. You're viewing their ads because you're viewing their content. Worst case scenerio is that the website
    makes ads indistinguishable from content then there is no way to block the ads. This can be accomplished by embedding
    the ad as an image in the website, writing the website in flash, product placement, etc... It's the same thing that will
    happen with blockbuster movies. If the studios can't make money by selling the movies then they will make money with
    tie-ins, product placement, etc... It will degrade the movie, sure, but they have to pay for it somehow.
    The same will happen with the web. If ads ultimately fail then websites will start doing product placement, charging for
    access, etc... New scientist went the pay route. Their free content is basically gone. I could see slashdot easily going
    the product placement route where every 5th article is an article that was paid to be put there.

  13. Wouldn't it be easier to just circumvent Adblock? on French Publishers Prepare Lawsuit Against Adblock Plus · · Score: 1

    I would think it would be trivial to circumvent adblock plus. It's a free download so as soon as they
    release a new version you could load your site and check to see if it is working and if not then
    adjust accordingly. It's an arm race that adblock can't possibly win. Spamassasin is much harder
    to fight because it is based on text and is based on the individual's personal heuristics but I would
    think circumventing adblock plus would be trivial.

  14. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 1

    IQ is just a measure of intelligence, and I agree not a perfect one.
    That's not the point. The point of the "lead crime hypothesis" is that
    if there is a shift downward in intelligence or a shift upward in violence, etc...
    then this shift although minor might have significant effects by pushing
    people below some threshold. Africa also has the problem of "brain drain"
    where alot of highly intelligent people escape and move elsewhere causing
    further stagnation. Just like "generational poverty" here in the USA there
    are multiple factors playing together but I don't think it's safe to completely
    ignore the population's intelligence when trying to figure out how to solve the
    problems in africa.

  15. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 1

    As far as IQ diffrences between races, there is no scientific proof. There are a few books such as IQ and the Wealth of Nations, but they are not scientific, as their methodology is horrible.

    Of course there is no scientific proof. There is no scientific proof against it either because no
    one is allowed to study it so the only books that get written are by fringe people who are racist
    and trying to prove an agenda. Whether it's worth studying is obviously debatable but it should
    be allowed to be spoken about and studied without being criticized.

  16. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 1

    He basically said he thought Africa was unlikely to improve its condition because black people are stupider.

    Although this is definitely on the extreme side of things and I don't necessarily agree with it there
    is some evidence for it. Google the "lead crime hypothesis". If say the average IQ of africans
    is 10 points lower than the average IQ of north americans, this might be enough to destabilize the
    region. 10 points doesn't sound like much but it means there are alot more really dumb people and
    alot less really smart people which might be enough to halt progress.
    Again, Watson shouldn't be shooting stuff like this out of his mouth without evidence but that doesn't
    mean his hypothesis is completely bogus.

  17. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 2

    2. There are no good scientific studies on race and IQ that factor out things like education and poverty, and conclusively prove discrepencies.
    you don't have to a horse in this race just to see bad methodology.

    One reason there are not any good studies is because it's a taboo topic.
    No professional would risk their career testing something like this. It would be suicide.
    What's left is a bunch of fringe people on both sides that have bad methodologies.
    If you want good, rigourous studies then you need to allow the studies to take place.
    It's very hard to have a study take place when just vocalizing an opinion gets you
    crucified before the study even begins.

  18. Re:A felon with misdemeanor convictions on Ask Slashdot: Can a Felon Work In IT? · · Score: 1

    Drug use could motivate theft though...just sayin'

    Yes, this is the same logic that causes companies to pull your credit report before offering you a job.
    Someone who has financial problems is probably more likely to steal but I still don't like it.
    It's the same problem that a felon has. You run into financial problems and now you can't find a job
    because you've had financial problems which causes the financial problems to be worse.

  19. Re:Fear the Asian carp on How One Man Changed the Ecology of the Great Lakes With Salmon · · Score: 1

    The answer to invasive species like Asian carp is to introduce seals into the Great Lakes. Of course, you will need some polar bears to keep the seals in check.

    This might not be a completely bad solution if the seals preferred asian carp to salmon.
    You don't need polar bears to keep seals in check. I'm sure humans can do a decent job there.

  20. Re:the evils of Political Correctness on James Watson's Nobel Medal Sells For $4.1 Million · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Except your missing the fact that the opinions of a scientist are not equal to science.

    Your treating science as a religeon, something men in lab coats say and you unquestioningly believe.

    Science is a method. Its not believing unquestioningly what scientists say. Science has standards for ascertaining truths based on observation. Watson's claims are not backed by science, but by his own personal prejudices and political views. That alone is good reason to kick someone out of the scientific community.

    For science to work you must be able to state an unpopular opinion and not get slaughtered for it.
    I'm not for sure how substantial his claims were but there is no denying that there are differences between races.
    How many white people do you see in professional sports? And there is a reason we split men and women
    sports apart. An average male athlete would have no problem competing at the olympic level in many sports
    if they were allowed to compete on the female side. I've heard somewhere that an average 50 percentile male is
    stronger than 90%+ females. Even pointing this out though can get you persecuted and heaven forbid someone
    mentions that there are IQ difference between races.
    We're talking about a very smart guy that helped discover DNA. If he says that there is a DNA element to
    intelligence (and everyone knows there is) and that it varies by race (again, this is a no brainer) then what is
    the big deal, he's speaking the truth. Now how much is based on race/genetics is a nature/nurture debate
    that we're a long way from solving but the fact that there is a genetic basis to intelligence is undeniable however
    much people stick their heads in the sand and try to deny it.

  21. Re:Freelance/Consulting on Ask Slashdot: Can a Felon Work In IT? · · Score: 2

    This is absolutely not true. Any respectable broker will thoroughly vet their contractors.

    This might be true but most of the people I know who freelance/consult don't use a broker.
    If you're good, it's pretty easy to pick up jobs on craigslist, vworker, walking around town, etc..
    and the more jobs you pick up, the more your name gets around.

  22. Re:A felon with misdemeanor convictions on Ask Slashdot: Can a Felon Work In IT? · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Being a felon means he committed a serious crime.

    really???

    i got convicted of felony because i got caught with some personal MDMA pillis in 2001 at an electronic music concert.

    that's a "serious crime"??

    As someone who hires programmers, a felony like this I would completely ignore if everything else was in line.
    Honesty and theft are the big ones in IT not drug use or even assault. Other careers would be different but
    as a programmer you are entrusted with alot of stuff (like credit cards) so a felony that is theft related is
    probably going to be much harder to be overlooked. Drug use, I don't really care that much about. I've hired
    plenty of alcoholics and probably a few pot smokers but as long as it doesn't interfere with their job, why
    should I care?

  23. Re:40 watt PC battery vs. 3 watt LED on Using Discarded Laptop Batteries To Power Lights · · Score: 1

    I'm doubting these are a single LED but a bunch of LEDs stuck together.
    Even if it is a single LED, that's not what we're talking about. We're
    talking about low watt LEDs that can run for days on a small battery.

  24. Re:Salaried positions only make sense in a few cas on Should IT Professionals Be Exempt From Overtime Regulations? · · Score: 1

    Yeah, I agree. It would definitely have to be based on the number of weeks worked or some
    other calculation. It would be easy enough to come up with some rules and then maybe
    tweak them a bit to prevent abuse. One possible problem would be construction workers
    that only work 9 months out of the year so they could be worked half to death for those 9
    but they get overtime and still work that way anyways.
    I think the main point is that they should allow employer/employee flexibility with compliance
    but crack down on obvious abuse. There *might* be a few occupations where it's difficult to
    track hours and you might have to use estimates or other ways to calculate it but for the most
    part just like other employee protection laws we should make an effort that they are effective
    and aren't circumvented. Currently overtime laws are constantly being abused or subverted
    to the point where overtime protection is almost non-existent for whole groups of people.

  25. Re:Abuse of overtime is resulting in unemployment on Should IT Professionals Be Exempt From Overtime Regulations? · · Score: 1

    Yeah, those are also household incomes where a household on average has 1.7 wage earners.
    Overtime pay has always been individual and probably never will be based on household.