Slashdot Mirror


User: CSMoran

CSMoran's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
481
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 481

  1. Re:Good answer on Ellison Doesn't Know If Java Is Free · · Score: 1

    You can also not answer the question "Did you stop beating your wife?" with Yes/No.

    Nonsense, Yes and No are the only valid answers to that question. It may not be an appropriate question but that is orthogonal to what answers are valid.

    I disagree. "Mu" ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mu_(negative) ) is a well-known valid answer to this loaded question.

  2. Re:Panspermia on Scientists Study Trajectories of Life-Bearing Earth Meteorites · · Score: 1

    It was not improved to dubnium, for fsck's sake, just like seven is not an improved five, after you add two to it, it's a different number. Addition of protons means getting a different element, that's the essence of the definition of chemical element. The original statement concerned "all elements". And it was wrong -- dubnium is an example of an element that was never created in a star, even though the constituent protons may have a history of having been in a star. Were we just adding neutrons, it would have been a different story (and the same element).

  3. Re:Panspermia on Scientists Study Trajectories of Life-Bearing Earth Meteorites · · Score: 1

    The americium-243 was almost certainly formed inside of a star, so... yes

    I do not care much about the americum-243 in here, it's an isotope of a different element. I'm using the example of dubnium as an element whose atoms were never created in a star, but rather on Earth, by fusion from americum-243 and neon-22 -- a counterexample to the proposition "all of the elements on Earth heavier than iron were once inside a star" which I disagreed with. The origin of the element americum is not relevant here.

  4. please not on the quantum internet... on The First Universal Quantum Network · · Score: 1

    trapped inside a reflective optical cavity. These atoms communicate with each other by emitting a single photon over an optical fiber. Each atom is a quantum bit — a qubit — and the polarization of the photon

    Sounds to me like they're reinventing Flash.

  5. Re:Panspermia on Scientists Study Trajectories of Life-Bearing Earth Meteorites · · Score: 1

    Sorry, but I'm not following your reasoning.

    When the boffins created several atoms of dubnium in a lab in Dubna fifty years ago, were these atoms ever inside star?

  6. Re:Panspermia on Scientists Study Trajectories of Life-Bearing Earth Meteorites · · Score: 1

    where are these life-seeding bolides coming from?

    Did you know that all of the elements on Earth heavier than iron were once inside a star? It's true - and not our star, either.

    Except for the ones we created by nuclear fusion.

  7. Re:Panspermia on Scientists Study Trajectories of Life-Bearing Earth Meteorites · · Score: 1

    When you throw a dice, your first throw may be a six. Why are you trying to do statistics with a single event?

    Bert

    Not statistics. Educated guesses. With just one throw available to reason from, the educated guess for the next throw is another six.

  8. Re:Well... Look on the bright side. on End of Windows XP Support Era Signals Beginning of Security Nightmare · · Score: 1

    This 'nightmare' assumes [...] we will still have a level of technology that needs computers. [...] I have serious doubts if that assumption is correct.

    I suggest you try placing a wager on it then. I'm sure there'll be plenty of people willing to bet, say, $100 on "we will still need computers in two years". If your doubts are THAT serious, why not capitalize on them?

  9. hmmm on Using Non-Newtonian Fluids To Fill Potholes · · Score: 1

    I think the auxetics people are ahead on the whole thing.

  10. Re:The easy way on Ask Slashdot: How To Make My Own Hardware Multimedia Player? · · Score: 1

    What's with the fast drives and the SSD? Even maximum bitrate Blu-Ray is only 54Mbps. Any hard drive you can buy will be able to keep up with that.

    Provided it's the only thing the HDD is doing, and not seeking to death scanning all .exe and .dll files in the background or building an index.

  11. Re:Content creation on Polish Government To Deliver Free Textbooks For All Kids Grades 4-6 · · Score: 1

    Maybe someone from Poland or more familiar with the topic could expand a little

    I'm Polish and can give you this expansion -- the road from "announce" to "happen" in this country is a long road which very often leads nowhere.

  12. Re:correlation != causation on Confidentiality Expires For 1940 Census Records · · Score: 1

    Yes, and the Ribbentrop-Molotov pact never existed, right?

  13. Re:Why? on Ask Slashdot: How Do You Test Storage Media? · · Score: 1

    Even if your storage passes the test, it could fail the next day.

    Similarly with medical checkups. Why bother, when you can get cancer the next day.

    Sarcasm aside, screening is not meant to guarantee lack of failure, but rather allow you to sort out clearly defective hardware.

  14. Re:Oh really? on Ask Slashdot: Store Umbilical Cord Blood — and If So, Where? · · Score: 1

    I was thinking about making a comment that just because you live in your parents' basement doesn't mean other people can't have a normal life, but that would just be playing to the same stupid meme...

    Good you didn't make that comment.

  15. Re:Not Surprised on Munich Has Saved €4M So Far After Switch To Linux · · Score: 2

    one thing - win7's drag-explorer-to-the-edge-and-it-fills-exactly-half-the-screen really saves the time i spend in a fit of OCD dragging edges around so i can move shit from two folders fast.

    I recommend FAR manager.

  16. Re:Something married men should stay away from. on Google 'Account Activity' Jumps Into Personal Analytics · · Score: 2

    I have 2 kids, both of which goto:

    Isn't that considered harmful?

  17. Re:Richard Feynman on Particle-Wave Duality Demonstrated With Largest Molecules Yet · · Score: 1

    This is the scientific method, if contradictory results are observed no conclusion can be made and neither is correct.

    Why exactly can't one of them be correct?

  18. Re:Astronomers are so funny on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 1

    Time has an age, it is approx 13 billion years old.

    Time and space were created at the moment of the Big Bang. Time didnt exist before that, so therefore it has an age.

    Is your assertion still valid in the cyclical universe case, when there was a big crunch preceding the big bang?

  19. Re:maybe they dont exist on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 0

    not anymore, all they are seeing is the light that was emitted by them billions of years ago

    375 years ago, more like.

  20. Re:dude tottaly on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 1

    Here at Slashdot, we take our comments seriously. At the very least, you are expected to keep a couple of dozen brain cells functioning if you intend to post. Proper spelling and grammar are optional, but highly recommended.

    You act like you're new here.

  21. Re:Iron poor -- yet still able to build starships. on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 2

    not going to make a starship out of water

    Why not? I'd welcome them ice-spaceship-travelling overlords. Extra points if it's ice-9.

  22. Re:Astronomers are so funny on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 1

    Didn't get one thing: the article says the star is 13 billions yo, but it's 375 ly from our solar system.

    I always have thought that distance meant age. Which other technique there is to tell a star's age?

    Distance does mean age. However, the Earth has not been the reference point since the 16th century or so.

  23. Re:Astronomers are so funny on 13-Billion-Year-Old Alien Worlds Discovered · · Score: 1

    Nothing is "ageless".

    How old is time itself?

  24. Re:Gahh on Maybe the FAA Gadget Ban On Liftoff and Landing Isn't So Bad · · Score: 2

    "should offer Xanax to passengers" != "should force passengers to take Xanax".

  25. Re:Of course it is on Early Exposure To Germs Has Lasting Benefits · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Typically these numbers include an extremely high infant mortality rate, without which the difference is significantly smaller.

    Of course. But that doesn't mean that 0 year olds dying back then magically stopped being a problem. It merely points to a deficiency of describing a distribution with just its first moment, the mean.