Slashdot Mirror


User: 91degrees

91degrees's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
12,024
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 12,024

  1. Disconnecting from the ISP on U2's Manager Calls For Mandatory Disconnects For Music Downloaders · · Score: 1

    Plus side - as a response, this is proportionate. No multi-million dollar lawsuits for sharing a handful of songs.

    Minus side - You need a right of appeal, it involves an invasion of privacy, it passes the expense onto the ISP.

  2. Re:Don't be to distracted by the retroactive immun on Telco Immunity Goes To Full Debate · · Score: 1

    Uhm...

    I said "retroactive". But I'm not sure what the difference is. Both seem to mean applying to events in the past.

  3. Don't be to distracted by the retroactive immunity on Telco Immunity Goes To Full Debate · · Score: 4, Informative

    Unless you think that warrantless wiretaps are a good idea, the rest of this bill is pretty damn bad as well.

  4. Re:I like the concept on Canadian Songwriters Propose Collective Licensing · · Score: 1

    If I thought it represented $5000 worth of quality, of course I'd be happy to pay that much for it. The chances are, I wouldn't. And neither would most people. Perhaps there are 10000 people who would. It's up to them to set the price such that per-unit-profit times total units sold is maximised.

  5. I like the concept on Canadian Songwriters Propose Collective Licensing · · Score: 1

    I'm not so sure a flat rate is the right way to go about things. Is it really right to treat all musical works as equal? If a few people consider a work to be of great value, isn't it worth as much as if a larger number of people consider a work to be of reasonable value?

  6. Re:NO on Canadian Songwriters Propose Collective Licensing · · Score: 1

    Distributing files without compensating the rights holder is seen as intrinsically wrong. Applying compensation makes it right.

  7. Re:Space Gun on World's Most Powerful Rail Gun Delivered to US Navy · · Score: 1

    Kinetic energy is 1/2mv^2. Double the speed, you need 4 times the energy.

  8. Re:Real Money Mules on The Anatomy of Money-Mule Scams · · Score: 1

    Apparently the 419 scam was pretty common after the French revolution. No doubt it goes back even further than that.

  9. Re:EBay is not a court of law on The Anatomy of Money-Mule Scams · · Score: 1

    It is slightly different. There's a legal basis for Paypal insisting that it's legally binding. You agreed to their contract. It's possible that this would be considered an unfair contract term, but by no means guaranteed.

  10. Re:Paypal is not a court of law on The Anatomy of Money-Mule Scams · · Score: 1

    But that doesn't answer anything. It just redirects the question.

    Since when does Paypal get to decide who is responsible for fraud?

  11. Re:Lego people on LEGO Brick 50th Anniversary · · Score: 2, Funny

    Having proportions where you're roughly twice as high as you are wide and hands that rotate 360 degrees is also a little freaky.

  12. Re:But remember kids - piracy actually *helps* peo on The Pirate Bay Tops 10 Million Users · · Score: 1

    Screw that. I pirate stuff so I don't have to pay for it. No idea if I'd have paid for it if I didn't but I reckon I spend plenty on legitimate movies and TV shows. I've bought a good couple of hundred DVDs so I really don't think they can claim I cost the industry money. If they do I'd like to see the alleged loss on a balance sheet

  13. Re:IANAL, but... on Author of ATSC Capture and Edit Tool Tries to Revoke GPL · · Score: 1

    I'm not sure it is a contract. Although at this point I'm not sure that the difference is that clear.

    The GPL doesn't require that you do anything. However it grants you a limited right to distribute (as long as you include a copy of the licence, distribute code etc.) which is not fundamentally different from a driving licence or a fishing licence (as long as it's not a class that the licence doesn't cover/As long as you only fish at certain times). The GPL requirements seem more like limitations than obligations.

  14. Even if he can.. on Author of ATSC Capture and Edit Tool Tries to Revoke GPL · · Score: 1

    Which I seriously doubt, I'm pretty certain that posting on a blog isn't going to be seen as a valid way to revoke a licence.

    What he needs to do is deliver a legal notice to every distributor of this software telling them that the licence has been revoked.

  15. Re:*shrug* on HD DVD Player Sales Grind To a Halt · · Score: 1

    I mildly regret not waiting a few weeks after my decision to buy. The player I bought is 40% less now than when I bought it. But yeah. I share your *shrug*.

  16. Re:Poor Bastards on HD DVD Player Sales Grind To a Halt · · Score: 1

    Why will it suddenly stop working? I have a lot of much less reliable tech that's a lot more than 5 years old that I still use regularly.

  17. Re:Poor Bastards on HD DVD Player Sales Grind To a Halt · · Score: 1

    Okay. Enjoy yourselves.

    I'm quite happy with my HD player. I'll buy a Blu-ray player as well when they're region free and their price falls to a similar amount. For now, I can enjoy some HD movies. I will continue to enjoy them for the lifetime of my player.

    Do you think discs stop working when a format is no longer supported?

  18. Re:Please read the U.S. Constitution on Internet Group Declares War on Scientology · · Score: 1

    But The First Amendment does not define freedom of speech. It merely codifies the entitlement of the government to regulate speech.

    Freedom of speech is more fundamental than that. It was one of the basic principles that resulted in that particular piece of law making it into the constitution, and Article 19 of the UN declaration of human rights.

  19. Re:And the bad news..... on Teen Takes On Donor's Immune System · · Score: 1

    Lots of people seem to change food preferences after an operation. I don't think the donor angle is relevant. The examples they give are interesting but not exactly a double blind study...

  20. Re:Please read the U.S. Constitution on Internet Group Declares War on Scientology · · Score: 1

    Of course they can violate freedom of speech. If you threaten of harrass someone because they criticise you, you have violated their rights.

  21. Re:how moronic on Internet Group Declares War on Scientology · · Score: 1

    I'm sure they have every interest in encouraging Scientologists to shout their scriptures from the rooftops.

  22. Re:It's not a church on Internet Group Declares War on Scientology · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Human psychology. The hard sell works using various techniques such as making it seem like a logical contradiction if you say "no", or making it seem like you're being mean to a nice person. People become incredibly uncomfortable with these situations and paying money is an easy way to escape.

  23. Re:Seriously on IBM Responds to Overtime Lawsuits With 15% Salary Cut · · Score: 1

    Ask to leave early, and you get yelled at.

    Who the hell would work in a place like this. There is no need to ask to leave if you've done your hours. You just leave. If they want you to work overtime then they have to convince you.

  24. Re:regulated in contract or law? on IBM Responds to Overtime Lawsuits With 15% Salary Cut · · Score: 2, Insightful

    or treat it like the beginning of a negotiation, which will in most cases get you labeled as a difficult employee.

    There are ways to do this politically. Explain why you think you deserve a higher salary in terms of absolute values. Don't be smug or arrogant. Just make a business case for a higher salary.

  25. They're not giving up control on DRM-Free Music Spells Trouble? · · Score: 1

    They didn't have control with DRM. They lost control as soon as Napster started. Removing DRM is just giving us another means of getting what we already had, where the selling point is that it's actually legal.