Slashdot Mirror


User: rogersc

rogersc's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
30
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 30

  1. Singh also said "happily" on In Britain, Better Not Call It Bogus Science · · Score: 1

    Singh said that the BCA "happily promotes bogus treatments". If he just said that the treatments were bogus, he would probably be okay. But he implied that the chiropractors knowing give phony treatments.

  2. Here is the actual old definition on Kansas Adopts New Science Standards · · Score: 1
    No, you have been misled that the word 'natural' had been previously stricken from the definition. The previous definition was:

    Science is a systematic method of continuing investigation that uses observations, hypothesis testing, measurement, experimentation, logical argument and theory building to lead to more adequate explanations of natural phenomena. Science does so while maintaining strict empirical standards and healthy skepticism.
    The old definition was actually quite sensible.
  3. Not a good argument for H-1B visas on The Impact of Immigrant Innovators · · Score: 2, Insightful

    These studies are used by the WSJ and others to promote increases in the quotas for H-1B visas. But the foreigners with the H-1B visas are not the ones starting companies. The H-1B visas are mainly used by big companies to cut their labor costs, and get employees who will not leave to join start-up companies.

  4. 3rd party cookie problem on GMail Vulnerable To Contact List Hijacking · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    It looks to me as if the real culprit is 3rd party cookies. These have almost no legitimate use, and are mainly used by advertisers like doubleclick.net to track users. Third party cookies are turned on by default in the browsers, but you can turn them off. This is another reason to turn them off.

  5. Re:Does anyone actually doubt that Yau is a thief? on Mathematician Claims New Yorker Defamed Him · · Score: 1

    Yau is not a thief. If he were, he would have had his name on the Cao-Zhu paper as a co-author, and the paper would have claimed to give the first proof of the Poincare Conjecture. He did not. The New Yorker article if offensive to many Chinese mathematicians, not just Yau. See this comment for details.

  6. Maybe it is just a lousy film on Imax Theaters Demur On Controversial Science Films · · Score: 1

    The article said that the Volcanoes film did not score well on other
    criteria, such as narration and music. It sounds like this is just a
    mediocre film that failed a test market, and Christians are being blamed.

    I really don't see why a science film about underwater volcanoes needs
    to offend people. Some people apparently thought it had a blasphemous
    presentation of human existence. And then the producer stubbornly
    refuses to make any changes. Why? If the film stuck to scientific
    facts about underwater life, I doubt that anyone would be offended.
    If it launched into wild speculation, then a scientific film should
    recognize that there are alternate views that are widely held.

    No, I am not a creationist, but I do get annoyed when scientists
    unnecessarily pick fights with Christians, and then pretend that they
    have some sort of right to present offensive speculations. Yes, they
    have a right to make the film, but no one has to buy it.

  7. Legal to deceive on Where Do Dummy Email Addresses Go? · · Score: 1

    No, you are wrong. There is no law against just "intent to deceive". There are laws against fraud, but to commit fraud you have to deceive someone as well as cheat him out of some money. If you are just lying for the purpose of avoiding spam, then it is entirely legal.

  8. Yes, BBC is a govt agency on More On The BBC's Codec 'Dirac' · · Score: 1
    The BBC is a govt monopoly that is funded by taxes. The British have different terminology, but in the USA we'd call it a govt agency.

    The USA has some agencies, like the Postal Service, that are formally private corporations in some respects, but people consider them govt agencies.

  9. NDA ok with IBM on The Cult of the NDA · · Score: 1

    IBM lawyers are known to be very about NDAs, and IBM personel are only allowed to sign them if they meet certain conditions. Is there a sample NDA posted anywhere that meets with IBM approval? That would be useful whenever a plain vanilla NDA is needed.

  10. Oppenheimer was a commie on Edward Teller Passes Away At 95 · · Score: 1
    Teller did not say that Oppie was a commie. Oppie lost his security clearance because of repeated lies about his contacts with Communist agents. You can find the official documents here.

    That said, Oppie really was a commie. Letters were released last year that prove that he was a member of the Communist Party.

  11. McCarthy did his best on Edward Teller Passes Away At 95 · · Score: 1

    McCarthy didn't know about the Venona Project, and did well with what he had. He did a great job exposing govt tolerance for disloyal commies.

  12. Oppie was a Commie on Edward Teller Passes Away At 95 · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Oppenheimer really was a Communist, according to a recent book. See also this NY Times article.

    A lot of left-wing scientists hated Teller for his ambiguous testimony about Oppenheimer, but Oppenheimer really was a security risk.

  13. Vonage doesn't allow dirty jokes on Vonage Fights Minnesota's Attempts To Regulate VoIP · · Score: 2
    Vonage customers have to agree not to say or listen to anything offensive! No dirty jokes, racist comments, etc. The contract says:
    You agree to use the Service and Device only for lawful purposes. This means that you agree not to use them for transmitting or receiving any illegal, harmful, threatening, abusive, harassing, defamatory, obscene, sexually explicit, profane, racially or ethnically disparaging remarks or otherwise objectionable material of any kind, including but not limited to any material that encourages conduct that would constitute a criminal offense, give rise to a civil liability, or otherwise violate any applicable local, state, national or international law.
  14. Story misrepresents poll question on Pew Study: File Traders Don't Care About Copyright · · Score: 1
    The story says that two out of every three adult file traders don't care if they are violating copyright laws or not.

    But the poll question actually was:

    Do you care whether or not the music you download onto your computer is copyrighted, or isn't that something you care much about?
    That is entirely different question. If I were polled, I would certainly say that I don't care whether the downloaded music is copyrighted. That is because all recorded music is copyrighted. Even the music that is authorized for free distribution is still copyrighted. I once downloaded some patriotic songs from the US Air Force marching band thinking that it would be in the public domain, but it even had a copyright notice.

    But if you ask me whether I care about violating copyright laws, I would say that I certainly do. I care enough that I have taken measures to avoid detection, to stay within legal safe harbors, to prepare arguments for the legality of my activities, and to lobby for changes in the copyright laws.

  15. Result is better privacy on Librarians Join the Fight Against The Patriot Act · · Score: 3, Insightful
    This law only lets one govt agency (the FBI) access records from another govt agency (the Santa Cruz library system) in the case of a foreign terrorist investigation. The libraries should not have been keeping long-term records on what books I check out in the first place. When I check out a book, it only needs to keep a record of that until I return the book. Then the record should be deleted from the library database. There is no law requiring the library to keep the records. The law just says that if they keep the records and they are subpoenaed, then the library has to turn them over.

    I live in Santa Cruz, and I am glad that this controversy has resulted in the libraries destroying old records. I am more concerned about Santa Cruz misusing the old data than about the FBI misusing its subpoenas. The best solution to privacy invading databases is to purge the unnecessary info from the database, and not to rely on controls on who can access the database. If the data is there, then it can be had by low-level workers who can be persuaded, bribed, or coerced.

  16. Reward or punish a benign hacker on Ask Prof. Felten About DMCA's Effects · · Score: 1

    Last year Princeton demoted an admissions dean after he accessed a Yale web site without authorization, and then reported the security weaknesses to the Yale admissions dept. It seems to me that a benign hacker who finds a security weakness and voluntarily reports it should be rewarded, not punished. What is your opinion on this? Did you give it to the Princeton president?

  17. name 'windows' is generic on Lindows Media Computer: Power to Strike Microsoft? · · Score: 1

    The name Lindows sounds like Linux-windows, but so what? When I hear that, I figure that it is running X-windows, not Microsoft windows. The term 'windows' has been used in a generic sense before Microsoft started using the term.

  18. The 'export' keyword is a failure on C++ Templates: The Complete Guide · · Score: 1

    When the experts cannot figure out how to use the export, that tells you something. What is does is very subtle and complicated, and hardly anyone understands it. It appears to be a major C++ design mistake.

  19. NSA was right -- Skipjack is secure on Ask Security/Cryptography Expert Paul Kocher · · Score: 1

    You implied that NSA was wrong when it said that Skipjack was a secure cipher. Actually, it was a true statement because no weakness in Skipjack has ever been found. The attack on a 31-round variant of Skipjack is of only academic interest and not the slightest bit embarrassing to the NSA. It shows Skipjack to be very well engineered. You seem to be suffering from some fundamental misconception about cryptology.

  20. Skipjack is not broken on Ask Security/Cryptography Expert Paul Kocher · · Score: 1

    NSA did not lie to Congress when it said that Skipjack was secure. Skipjack is secure, and there are no known attacks on it that are faster than brute force search of the key space. Biham's attack is only on a crippled version of Skipjack, and might well have been known to the NSA all along.

  21. Re:P2P Terrorists? on E.U. Commission Suggests Permissive Copyright Rule · · Score: 1

    Bowling For Columbine is an even sillier piece of propaganda than those movies.

  22. Education is highly valued in America on AFL-CIO Proposed Reforms for the H1B Program · · Score: 1
    > The truth is, education is not important in America

    No country values education more than America. Here in California, we have high taxes and about 60% of state taxes goto education. Foreigners come to the USA for education because their home countries do not value education as highly as the USA.

    All of which is beside the point that there are plenty of extremely talented American programmers that are available. The H1-B program is just designed to bring in cheap labor.

  23. Talent comes at a price on AFL-CIO Proposed Reforms for the H1B Program · · Score: 1
    There are plenty of extremely talented American programmers that are available. You just have to pay the price. If advertise a low salary, then you will get lower-skilled workers. Supply and demand. It is as simple as that.

    The H1-B programmers are no better than American programmers, in my experience. They are hired because they can be hired more cheaply, and they are less likely to jump to another company for better pay.

  24. The whole H1-B premise is wrong. on AFL-CIO Proposed Reforms for the H1B Program · · Score: 1

    The whole H1-B premise is wrong. The H1-B supporter claim that there is a shortage of skilled works in areas like programming. It is nonsense. There are lots of unemployed or underemployed American programmers. Whenever the local newspaper advertises a job that pays a little more than the going rate, the company gets swamped with excellent resumes.

  25. What good does this federal law do? on Russian Student Arrested For Revealing DirecTV Secrets · · Score: 2, Interesting

    A couple of things bother me about this. Why is a federal prosecution needed, when California already has strong laws against trade secret theft? Why did federal prosecutors need high-level approval in DC to apply this law, unless the DoJ knows that the law is overbroad and easily abused? Why did a law firm even have these documents, unless there was already some dispute about them? How are the feds going to prove economic espionage when that entails proving economic benefit, when the Russian did not economically benefit and it is not clear how anyone else might have economically benefitted either?