Slashdot Mirror


User: Cheakamus

Cheakamus's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
5
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 5

  1. About JRRT (was Re:These movies ought to be banned on Lord of the Trailers · · Score: 5
    The Silmarillion represents the real life's work of Tolkien. He started his writings in 1916 (during WW1, while in the trenches), where he wrote the stories of Fall of Gondolin and Turin Turambar. I'm a bit rusty on the sequence of his life, but after the war he was a professor of Old English at the University of Leeds and also served on the staff of the Oxford English Dictionary. Through the 1920s he continued to develop several mythical languages (based upon Welsh and Finnish) that provided the basis for the cultures of his mythologies. During this time he was appointed to a professorship at Oxford.

    When JRRT wrote The Hobbit (published in 1937) he initially did not place it in Middle Earth. Actually the original story was quite different in one crucial respect - Gollum shows Bilbo out after he lost the Riddles game and they part on friendly terms. If you ever find a first edition of The Hobbit you can read the original version of the story - (good luck! B&N had a copy for sale for $12,500!). The Hobbit was so successful that the publishers immediately demanded a sequel. It was at this point that he rewrote chapter 5 (Riddles in the Dark) to set up the story that became The Lord of the Rings.

    The LOTR started in much the same style as The Hobbit, and he struggled for many years with it. He really wanted to publish his epic mythologies, and not to work on a sequel. Towards the later part of the 1940's he got into the swing of it and cranked out LOTR, published in three volumes in 1954 and 1955 (it is NOT a trilogy - it's three volumes of the same tale). It was during the composition of the LOTR that he tied The Hobbit to the mythologies. It also provided a framework for the eventuality of his epic works, later laid down in The Silmarillion. The Silmarillion is actually several books in one:

    • Ainulindalë, the tale of the Music of the Ainur and the creation of Arda (Earth).
    • Valaquenta, the tale of the Valar, in which the nature of each of the Powers is described.
    • Quenta Silmarillion, the longest tale, which gives an account of the history of Arda from its beginnings until the end of the First Age.
    • Akallabêth, the tale of the Second Age, which concentrates on the history of Númenor until its Downfall, and
    • Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age, which spans the late Second Age and the Third, telling of the forging of the Rings of Power and their history up to the War of the Ring.

    Tolkien died before he felt thatThe Silmarillion was completed. His son, Christopher, took it upon himself to select from his father's writings all of the material that would constitute a complete story and published it posthumously to his father.

    Reading The Silmarillion for the first time is a fairly brutal endeavor. It's so packed full of information that it took me several readings to really start to grok it. Karen Wynn Fonstat's Atlas of Middle Earth is essential, as is J.E.A. Tyler's reference (the name escapes me, but the second editions includes The Silmarillion content).

    Unfinished Tales contains more detailed information from the stories in The Silmarillion, but they were never deemed to be complete enough to be included in The Silmarillion. Christopher Tolkien's 12 volume series The History of Middle Earth breaks down all of JRRT's writings into chronological order and discusses in great detail the evolution of the stories (well worth the read if you like scholarly studies of fascinating characters).

    Also read The Letters of JRR Tolkien and his biography, both by Humphrey Carpenter, if you want real insight into Tolkien's life and beliefs. He was a truly remarkable man.

    ---

  2. Where the artists *really* make their money on SDMI: The Music Industry Strikes Back · · Score: 1
    Most artists don't make money from the sale of recorded music. Period. Most money is made in ticket sales and merchandise. One of the most commercially successful bands in history, the Grateful Dead, pioneered the concept of allowing mass free distribution of their music (not the studio records - only live performances) that allowed for a huge community to grow around the band, thus leading to 25 years of sold out shows and massive merchandise revenue. While allowing "tape trading" their management was brutal about trademarks and merchandise.

    I have numerous friends in the music industry - both at management level and performers - all of whom are hip to the idea of free online distribution of some of their recordings. If that brings more people out to their shows to buy tickets and t-shirts then they're thrilled.

    There's an article about mp3 over at Rolling Stone entitled World War MP3 - a worthy read to get industry perspectives on this subject.

    Cheakamus

  3. Smoking Crack. on Dell start selling PC's with Linux · · Score: 1

    I don't know what's up at the Dell site but I set up two identical systems in adjacent windows and the Linux box was $200 cheaper. Why are others getting it more expensive? Is ASP incapable of math?

  4. Wood cases on Cool Computer Cases Continue · · Score: 1

    As I understand it, it is important to have a case to block the EMF from the system (please correct me if I'm wrong). What is the shielding capability of wood? Would it have to be lined with some sort of metal, as most plastic cases I've seen are? I think a nicely finished wood case would be awesome.

    Thanks!

    Cheakamus

  5. R. Crumb? on The Road To Linux -- The Summit, but not the Peak · · Score: 1
    > In the words of one of my favorite bands:
    > Keep on truckin'

    Huh? I thought R. Crumb was a cartoonist!

    Oh... you meant the Grateful Dead!

    8^)

    Cheakamus