Slashdot Mirror


User: Overly+Critical+Guy

Overly+Critical+Guy's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
4,952
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 4,952

  1. Re:Price Fixing? on AMD Admits To Slowing Sales · · Score: 1

    This may come as a shock to you, but all businesses are out to drive their competition out of business.

  2. Re:MS not now how to engineer software? on WinFS' Demise Not a Bang Or a Whimper · · Score: 1

    With four OS releases under its belt since 2001 and going on number five, Apple seems to have gotten a reasonable clue on how to manage it.

  3. Re:a shame on WinFS' Demise Not a Bang Or a Whimper · · Score: 1

    It's incredible that one of the cited reasons for WinFS' death is that Microsoft couldn't figure out how to expose the technology to the user. Call me crazy, but planning how the user was supposed to interact with the technology should have been one of the first design steps. In fact, it kind of illustrates a difference between Microsoft and Apple in that area. You'd know Apple would design the user interaction first and then build the technology to support that. Not the other way around where you hope for an interface idea to come along after you've worked on an API for the last five years. Silly, silly, silly.

  4. Re:Not only that... on Microsoft To Release 'iPod Killer' at Christmas? · · Score: 1

    That's the funny part of Microsoft offering to re-purchase your music. It's not like people made the iPod the #1 player because of the iTunes Music Store. It's the cool thin design with the clickwheel and the slick interface. Most iPod users have ripped their CD tracks into MP3s or M4As in iTunes.

    Nobody really thinks a Microsoft portable media player will go anywhere, do they? Did you already forget about "Ultra-Mobile PCs?" Yeah, me too.

  5. Re:Apple and RIAA are laughing softly on Microsoft To Release 'iPod Killer' at Christmas? · · Score: 1

    It's Urge, not "Surge," and it's already out...and it sucks.

    Microsoft has 96% of desktops but those desktops use iTunes almost entirely.

  6. Re:uhh on Microsoft To Release 'iPod Killer' at Christmas? · · Score: 1
    At least Microsoft licenses WMA to third parties so that purchased music will play in my in-dash car stereo, my dvd player, and multiple portable music players from multiple companies.


    Funny, I manage to do all that with the MP3s already on my iPod. But thank goodness for Microsoft saving me with their Windows-only WMA format!
  7. Re:Not only that... on Microsoft To Release 'iPod Killer' at Christmas? · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Meaning it will allow for easy replacement of the rechargeable battery


    Which will increase the size.

    not require proprietary vendor lock-in formats (ACC)


    AAC isn't a proprietary vendor lock-in format, it's the successor to MP3, as in MP4. It's amazing how many people think AAC is an Apple thing. They've obviously never even looked into the format. AAC is the standard audio format for next-gen movies (HD-DVD and Blu-Ray).

    and use generic cables/interfaces/devices to extend the use of the product? SIGN ME UP!


    Right, people have found no uses for the port at the bottom of the iPod.

    This is another money-sinking venture into locking you into WMA and getting you reliant on Windows tech. The device will be bulky (bigger screen? What, you think Apple won't be introducing new iPods this Christmas either? Probably those huge widescreen touchscreen iPods we've been hearing about for a year) and will only work with Windows and Window Media Player. Yuck.

    As for free downloads of iTunes purchases, does Microsoft think people use iPods because of the iTunes Music Store?
  8. Re:Consider that they have to sell machines on Apple to Unveil New Leopard OS in August · · Score: 1

    What is "OS/X"? Where do people get their magic slashes and dashes from? It's OS X, as in OS Ten.

  9. Re:Is it really fair? on EU Fines for Microsoft Approved, Off the Record · · Score: 1

    It's not a billion dollar fine; it's a fine for each day since the deadline that they broke the law for not complying with the documentation request. If you were fined for parking in front of a hydrant and kept doing it for over a year, you'd be paying a lot of money too. All they had to do was comply with the law.

  10. Re:Well great on EU Fines for Microsoft Approved, Off the Record · · Score: 1

    Man, it's weird how much pro-Microsoft shilling appears on Slashdot whenever there's a EU discussion. All Microsoft had to do was document their APIs as requested by the commission. Why do MS fanbois hate that idea so much?

  11. Re:Is it really fair? on EU Fines for Microsoft Approved, Off the Record · · Score: 1

    Microsoft was told the consequences of not complying with the API documentation requests. Of course they deserve the ruling. The fine goes back to the date they were told to comply and is meant to punish them for each day of noncompliance. If they had complied, they wouldn't be fined. You're essentially asking if it's unfair to enforce the law.

  12. Re:so? on EU Fines for Microsoft Approved, Off the Record · · Score: 1

    That's just not true. Microsoft is being fined for not complying with the API disclosure the EU demanded. It doesn't matter if Microsoft has enough money to pay the fines, shareholders will not be happy with the company paying a multi-million dollar fine every day. As a result, Microsoft will be forced to change its behavior and provide the adequate documentation, which accomplishes what the EU wanted.

    The point of this isn't to destroy Microsoft or anything.

  13. Re:Mac nerds? on Nerds Switching from Apple to Ubuntu? · · Score: -1, Troll

    15% worldwide install base and counting. Where is Linux on the desktop again? Just askin'.

  14. Re:Mac nerds? on Nerds Switching from Apple to Ubuntu? · · Score: -1, Troll

    Oh no! Apple should be worried about two guys! Two guys have switched. What ever will Apple do about two guys? Someone at the New York Times better crack the scoop on the two guys. I suspect Apple's strategy to deal with two guys involves drying their tears on the cash from the higher-than-expected sales of the MacBook.

  15. Re:not the funniest joke on Student Suspended Over IM Icon · · Score: 1, Troll

    You pretty much nailed it. A large number of people today misunderstand what Freedom of Speech actually means. It's the freedom to speak and not have the government censor you. The right does not extend to situations where someone else's rights may be endangered or limited in some way, like harassment or libel. In this case, the teacher's safety was under threat.

  16. Re:what did he expect? on Student Suspended Over IM Icon · · Score: 1
    an IM icon isn't a threat, it's an icon.


    I'm not sure I understand how it being an icon negates it being a threat. An icon is "a person or thing regarded as a representative symbol of something."
  17. Re:Still feature limited on Intel Pushes Back with Xeon 5100 · · Score: 1
    They put the memory controller on chip, which again improves multicore performance.


    Recent reviews of the Core 2 Duo have mentioned that Intel avoided this because it would limit their future chip designs, and they instead relied on Moore's Law to catch up. Word is that AMD is now limited to a certain design strategy that isn't as efficient as Intel's because of that memory controller (which doesn't provide improved performance over Intel anymore...Intel's new chips stomp the AMDs).
  18. Re:No. on Intel Pushes Back with Xeon 5100 · · Score: 1

    Jobs and other Apple representatives have stated repeatedly that the switch to Intel was based on Intel's future roadmap.

  19. Re:A disturbance in The Force? How stupid is this? on WGA Turning Off PCs in the Fall? · · Score: 4, Informative

    Why do people capitalize "MAC?" It's Mac, short for Macintosh. MAC means something else.

    It's like those people who call it OS/X or OS-X. Where are they getting these magic hyphens and slashes from?

  20. Re:In other Words... on Microsoft Ponders Windows Successor · · Score: 1

    Of course, XAML has been pretty gutted in the past 12 months. Vista's APIs could easily have been made available for download on XP. In fact, I wonder if Microsoft is still planning to do that as they originally promised.

  21. Re:What is worse that a first post? on The 10 Tech People Who Don't Matter · · Score: 1

    Everyone by default can get mod points, but your chances go up the higher your karma. Many trolls karma whore and get mod points to abuse the system in this way. Meta-moderation was instituted to try to combat this, but it's barely done much, if anything.

  22. Re:What is worse that a first post? on The 10 Tech People Who Don't Matter · · Score: 1

    Mod points are randomly assigned to a pool.

  23. Re:Slashdot moderation on The 10 Tech People Who Don't Matter · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's just frustrating, Jamie. We've been hearing about a "future moderation system" for a few years now. I call today's version absolutely, totally broken because it doesn't scale well. It only takes one moderation from one person to knock a post up or down an entire grade. A +5 Interesting just means 3 or 4 people who had mod points found it interesting, not everyone else. Also, it's far too easy to modbomb and ruin an account.

    I'll stay tuned...

  24. Re:What is worse that a first post? on The 10 Tech People Who Don't Matter · · Score: 1, Funny
    any idiot with an agenda moderates


    In that regard, then, it is Slashdot's peer.
  25. Re:What is worse that a first post? on The 10 Tech People Who Don't Matter · · Score: 0

    That's what's great about web feeds. The Digg front page RSS feed is my prime source of information throughout the day. If you want to slow things down, raise the Dugg threshold, or just follow certain sections (Digg 3.0 unrolled today). It's a very customizable experience. Digg is a fast-paced, user-driven link site, which is how I used to view Slashdot until about five years ago.

    It should be noted that Digg surpassed Slashdot's traffic a while ago. There isn't enough time to "savor an article" because the point of Digg is to quickly give you the link to the article, and not have--as Linus Torvalds famously put it--a bunch of wankers who don't know what they're talking about posting comments for karma points. Things are kept short and to the point--the focus is the link, not the babble surrounding the link.

    Not that commentary isn't good, but Slashdot's comment system would improve dramatically if the moderation system were more like Digg's. The way it is now, sifting through the good and the bad is a real pain in the ass. Idiotic comments get modded up too quickly, and really great comments that go against the status quo get marked down. It only takes one person to knock a post down an entire grade. Screw CSS, I wanted a revamp of Slashdot's completely, totally, absolutely broken moderation system.