Slashdot Mirror


User: geoffspear

geoffspear's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
2,534
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 2,534

  1. damn you, MPAA! on Old Film to DVD Transfers Examined · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How dare you keep those negatives locked in a temperature-controlled room? Movies want to be FREE!

  2. Re:I'm going to switch on Intel Flaunts Mac mini Knock-off · · Score: 3, Insightful
    If you expect a different OS to work exactly like the one you're most familiar with to the point that you actually believe you need to use the keyboard instead of the mouse for anything on a Mac, you're an idiot.

    Preferring one UI over the other has nothing to do with it. Assuming the different UI doesn't work because it's not identical to Windows shows that you're either unwilling or unable to learn anything new.

    Someone who's able to switch between Windows, Linux, and a Mac and use them all is not an idiot, even if he or she strongly prefers one over the others.

  3. Re:Two ways to look at this ruling on Virginia Court Overturns Spammer Convictions · · Score: 1
    The court, in the bit you quoted above, held that walking with your mail to the garbage can is reasonable. This does not mean that having to filter thousands of emails a day is also reasonable.

    You'd probably argue that since the Court held that a reasonable person wouldn't allow the police to search their car during a routine traffic stop, that it's perfectly legal to engage in a high speed chase rather than pulling over at all. After all, you might be able to draw some ridiculously tenuous analogy between the two, so why not assert that there the same thing?

  4. Re:I'm going to switch on Intel Flaunts Mac mini Knock-off · · Score: 3, Funny
    Translation:

    I'm too stupid to figure out how to use a Mac, therefore I don't think anyone else should switch.

  5. Re:I'm not confident on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1

    There already is such a federal law. It's called the 8th Amendment.

  6. Re:NRA on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1

    Outlaw marriage, and only outlaws will have inlaws.

  7. Re:Is it legal to record off the radio? on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1
    It is, in fact, neither legal nor "time-shifting" to tape broadcast programs on your Betamax machine to keep them as a collection. Time shifting refers specifically to taping a show at one time to watch it at a more convenient time. The fact that this particular use was held to not infringe copyright, and that a substantial number of Betamax owners were found to be using their machine in precisely this way, meant that it was not illegal for Sony to manufacture and sell the devices.

    At no point was a right established to record without limit anything that's broadcast.

  8. Re:I hate professors on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1
    The phrase "electoral college" doesn't appear anywhere in the US Constitution, either. Therefore, the US Constitution doesn't establish the electoral college.

    Also, Article I, Section 8, does not use the terms "copyright" or "patent", so obviously the Constitution doesn't grant Congress the right to create things with those names.

  9. Re:No, it has to do with lack of expertise on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 3, Funny
    On the other hand, David Boies seems to be pretty good at failing miserably in big cases (US v. Microsoft, Bush v. Gore, and now SCO v. everyone), so I'm not sure he's the best person to be taking legal advice from.

    If you want advice on how to get paid lots of money without showing results, though, he's your guy.

  10. Re:I'm not confident on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1
    Congress cannot pass laws that override the Constitution. Laws that violate the Constitution are null and void. The court isn't making law, it's ruling on existing laws that never should have been made.

    Yes, the state legislatures should change their laws so that they're no longer unconstitutional. But if they refuse to (see Alabama's constitution), the laws are just as invalid as they'd be if they were repealed.

  11. Re:I'm not confident on MGM v. Grokster: Here's Why P2P is Valuable · · Score: 1
    It's a crime to provide alcohol to a minor, even if you're the minor's guardian.

    This is like arguing that whether a minor is murdered in his sleep on any given night is decided by his or her guardians on a case by case basis. Sure it is, but that doesn't make it either legal or morally correct for a parent to sneak into their child's room to kill them. Your comment is a complete non sequitur.

  12. Re:This would halt the entire software industry on Software Patents Could Stop EU Linux Development · · Score: 1
    That's ridiculous. There are software patents in the US. Guess where the vast majority of the world's software comes from.

    Guess the entire industry wasn't halted by patents. Nice panicked hyperbole, though.

  13. Re:Firefox isn't made by Microsoft. on Mozilla 1.8b1 Released, Firefox Growth Slowing · · Score: 1
    There are thousands of perfectly readable fonts that are not included in a standard Windows install.

    Granted, you might think that the ones that are installed with Windows are good enough for any purpose.

    On the other hand, if we accept your argument, we can also argue that it makes no sense to not build web pages that will only display properly in browsers made by Microsoft. If Microsoft's font selection isn't open to debate, why should their belief that IE is the best browser and good enough for anyone be up to debate?

  14. Re:I can see it now on Craigslist to Beam Ads into Space (for Free) · · Score: 1

    Right, because they're going to be communicating with Earth while travelling faster than light. With normal radio waves.

  15. Re:TACO IS AN IDIOT on Microsoft AntiSpyware thinks Firefox is Spyware · · Score: 1

    If you're looking for K5, you know where to find it.

  16. Re:Well.... on Bill Gates to Receive Honorary UK Knighthood · · Score: 2, Informative
    Dale Carnegie was not a tycoon of any type.

    You're thinking of Andrew Carnegie.

    In any case, Melinda Gates probably deserves the award a lot more. Without her, Bill most likely would have continued to hoard his money.

  17. Re:How much does it take? on Bill Gates to Receive Honorary UK Knighthood · · Score: 1

    Nothing. Per capita wealth might change, but the GDP has nothing to do with how much wealth a nation's inhabitants have.

  18. Re:How much does it take? on Bill Gates to Receive Honorary UK Knighthood · · Score: 2, Insightful
    It is sad that it requires more work to become a citizen of America than just living here

    No, it's sad that we don't strip citizenship from and deport the vast majority of our citizens who couldn't become citizens if they weren't born here. The requirements to become a citizen are an affirmation of the principle that democracy doesn't work when the people know nothing about their government and couldn't care less how it's run. Now if only our education system was still based on the same principle, our elections might become something more than a popularity contest.

  19. Re:Freedom of Speech on First Arrest Made in U.S. For Spimming · · Score: 1
    Bullshit.

    If I know you cheated on your wife, it's legal for me to tell her you cheated on her. It's not legal to blackmail you.

    Extortion is a crime. Period.

  20. Re:Monopoly by artist? on MP3 Download Prices to Rise? · · Score: 1
    So what?

    I have a monopoly over my own writings. Are you suggesting I should be prosecuted for unfair business practices if I offer to sell the rights to everything I've ever written to you for one million dollars?

  21. Re:Well they have to raise prices on MP3 Download Prices to Rise? · · Score: 1
    If you measured it in any way you want, it will be much, much lower than your made up figure.

    Using statistics to lie is one thing. Making up statistics to help your point just makes you look stupid.

  22. Re:Well they have to raise prices on MP3 Download Prices to Rise? · · Score: 1
    That's nice. He doesn't get a penny if you BUY the recording either.

    As long as you don't do any public performances or support artists who cover beatles songs, you're fine.

    Now stop stealing from Paul and Ringo!

  23. Re:Cleary a response on AOL Opening Up AIM Community to Third Parties · · Score: 4, Informative
    They didn't.

    They did, however, drop "AOL" from their name and changed their stock ticker symbol from "AOL" to "TWX" when they realized that a major media corporation being bought up by an internet provider that spent more money sending CDs to every person on the planet than it will ever make selling internet services was really, really, stupid.

  24. How horrible! on RFID + Dart gun = DartMail! · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Just think of the privacy implications!

    Anyway, this would be a lot more "useful" (and I use that term loosely)if they weren't just sending pointers to files that are on a shared server. This implies they've already got a network link between them, making a physical transport even more pointless than it would be anyway.

  25. Re:Stop, thief !!! on MP3 Download Prices to Rise? · · Score: 1
    Sure, but so are you. You're stealing karma from everyone by posting Funny messages, which draw moderations without even giving you any karma. This greatly reduces the total positive karma available to the community as a whole. This is not just theft, it's extreme anti-social behavior.

    We should all pray that some prosecutor doesn't stumble upon this thread and decide that he could probably imprison every single person in his jurisdiction for committing theft under this definition.

    And you, Mr. Prosecutor who's reading this: if you don't prosecute us all, then you are stealing from the prison industry!