Slashdot Mirror


Should DNA be Patentable?

nexex writes: "This story seems brings the patent debate home; specifically, should a company or person be able to 'own' your DNA? Obviously researchers want to profit from their discoveries, thus funding new research. But critics counter they are profitting at the expense of our health, citing restrive screening licenses for things such as breast cancer and Alzheimer's. Citing a figure from a UK activist group, 500,000 gene or gene sequence patents have been applied for worldwide. Another excellent article on this issue from Salon.com was from a couple years ago."

6 of 257 comments (clear)

  1. jhfjhfg by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    OHH YAH!

  2. Patent this by Greg's+Trolling+Acct · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    aaaggctccatgccgcctcgactaggaaggccacctactatcatattcgt
    ggccggttaggagattatgcgcggcaagtaacctacgaaaggggttct gg
    tggaatcaagtcgcacttttgttaaacttaggtacatcgggtgtatct gg
    cgagttgcgtgggtgtcaccgatagctcagtgtcttgacagccaacgg ga
    gacagatagacgggtatagcgtaaactctcttcggttttaaatgacgc at
    atgggccagagggctagtttgcagctgggatacacagatcagttgcta cc
    ccaccgtccagtttagtgacgtcggctgtcaggcacagcggtgtacga gc
    gtggagctactctcaacatctgctggagattctactccggccgtggta tt
    atcgtggcccttttgtccaatgtcccggacattgagagatatccccgc cg
    atgattggaggcgggcgaagcaataagcgacggtgccaagacctagtg ag
    ccaaattgttgaactgtgaaagccagatttccgactcgtaccatactc tg
    cttaggaaggtgacaacgcaaatcttcctttcggaaccgcactgagta at
    acagtgccggaatacgtgcggagaatgtcgagcgctgtggatgtgcac ca
    tcgaacaacgaaagggcaagtgtattgtaagggattctgacctgccgg gt
    aaatagtgcgagggttgataaattttgagccagtgtacgtctaaaact gc
    agcgctactcccaagtaacgtatgggctaaatagcggggtaagaacct cc
    aggtctaataacgtgatgttgcagggtggcgtagaggtagacgagttt tc
    ttacaccataggaggtctgaaatgtccgtctgggcaatctcatcgagt aa
    acttttactgcgtcttcccctaacgtcttagacaccgcagttgggatg tc
    tcagcccggccacagcactcaccccgaatggccgcacgcgtcacccct ct
    tccgagtttaacttaggcgcgccagaaatcttgggctcttcttagctt aa
    tcggtcggcgatcgagtattggatgcacgtaaagatcgctgtacggat ac
    ctccaattcacttgtgctactccttatagctgatgttcagggcgaggt tt
    cggcagcgtcacagcggtcctcaccgactcgattcctactggctcatt cg
    ttctcgtgccggccgatcgtgagaaattttctacggccgtatgcagat tg

    // This is the clever part to create five fingers

    tctagctagcgcctaacgctaaagcctagcagtatagtaaaccttacg cc
    agagacggcgttttacggatagtcgacgggagccgtttctgaggtggc tc
    aacgctcgtgatctgcgcgcattaccaggctaatccatgtacgtaacg ga
    aaataccctgagcccctctcacgctggatgatttctcccgagtgtgga gc
    gaactatatggcacgccgcatcgctccgtgagctatctggttgtccat aa
    atatacacgataaccaggattcgcatctgtggagcatggatcggcacg gc
    tatgctgggcacggcagatcgattatcccccgcggccagtattgagaa gt
    ggcggcggtaacgagttcgggtcagggcacttgttgcacttacctaac aa
    gccactccgcgaaggaaatacggcagtataatagagagacggtcgagg cg
    tgctcttataattatttttgaaggacgtcttatcgtacgtaacctcct tt
    ttaggatgtaacgtcggcgcttcttttgaaccaacggaccagtatggc ct
    gccaggtaatatgggcaacggccccaagattctgtagaggccagtagg aa
    atgaacataccaactagaggggcgtaacgtgcaacacgttatttggac ac

    // Unknown glucose-generation sequence

    agaatcgattcgcgtttggactaatgcccgggcctggtatcaccactg cc
    tgtttcactcactaatgcaccaattaataacgtccaggtactccgcat tc
    acggggccagtgtagtacgcctgttcctgaaccaacacgtctcttggt ac

    // This is clearly redundant

    aaggaccacagtagtttccgttgggtgacttgccccagcatcgacatg ga
    cacgccccgtgcagtctgttacttgacatggcaaccgtgttgcatgaa tc
    attccgcgcctagtcttaaaaagcagatggtgtccgctcatatgaatt ga
    agtgccggaacgggagggttgcacacaaggcatctcgtaacgagggat ta
    tatcgtgtttctctgtgatcgttctaatccttccgatcgtccaacttc ct
    aatcctgcgctctggaccctcatgaaaggggaagggccatgcagggca ga
    tactctcggaaaaacggactttgtctgatgacggtgcgtcgagtacac aa
    agtcaggctccaaggtggccactaataggccaatgctaggacgctgcc tc

    // CTGGGA would have been a better endcap terminator here

    attcgagtagtcgtcccgataaagggacgagatgtcccatagctacgt ag
    tcgccctggccaggggacgttggcgctgcgtcgcgagcgctttgcact ta
    ttcggaggcactccttaactgaaggccccatgcattacctatgcccct at
    cggcagtcggtgatggccgcgtgcccgtgggttcggttcctgttggag tg
    ccaggtaccaaagggcacatttcttgaagcgaatggagcgttgctatt ta
    attgcacaattgcgtgagctcggtttcttataagtcgtgcgcagcaaa cc
    ccacatacttgaatattcgtagaactttacaatttcctactttcgatt ct
    agagacgtagtacgtcaatttgggcaccaaaatcagcttgagaaaaca cg
    gtgtgttgaccatgtcgtgtacaaccagccggtatatgacaaactgcg gg
    ccgctactttcttggtacattcctcacagatcatccagtactaggaga at
    gaaaccctgcccataagaacggcttagacagcctggtaggcggtcccc tc

    // Compare to monkey DNA, clearly this is similar

    catatccactcgcatcatgcgcagcacattgcccagcaactggaagag ac
    aggtgtgggtcttcgtactacgagaactactgaaagcaggaaggcctg gg

    // Patent #41847593 here

    taggtattctccacctaaactcatacaaccttggcacgagttcggttc ca
    tcggggagtcgcgacgtgaacgagcgttggtagatcgtcaatcagagt tt
    tgtcatttccttataatgtagctcactaggtctacggcgagaggggcc tc
    cattagtctccatgtaaggcggcagtgctaatcgtcacttgacaacct ac
    ccccgaacggaaaggaaacgccaaagaaatacagcttagacgcgacac at
    taggagggttggttatattctgaacaccttctatcgctgggcggaaga cg
    cccagccatggccttatcgtccctgtgcccctcaccgtgtggtcacca aa
    agacctaggatgggttttacggtcacaaaccccggttacctccgacat ac
    gatcaatcaccaagtaagcgctgagagtccgggaacatagggttgggg ca
    gacttgtctacaggagacacgttaacatgaactggtgcagcaagatac ta
    tttgaaaacagaacgatcgtgaacccggattccaccctcctacaatga cg
    ttatgacagaggggcgatagcgtcacccgacaggtttctatagatgtt cg
    agcttatatcttggtgcttcttcatatccaagcactccggcagtttgc aa
    aattccacttcagcttgctacacttttactgggcgtccatgaagtcat tt
    ccttgtgtggtccagatcacgctccagaaatcactgctgttcgatttt ac
    tcatacgtaattatggacaatcctcgtgccgacgggtgtacgcgatgc cc
    cggtgatcccgatcatatttagtggcatggtccccgaccgatacctct tc
    aaaaaagatgagcggcaacaacacgcacattgccacgctcgataccta tt
    ccgaaaactgagactgagagtacagtcttgaaggccgactgcctcgag ct
    taagatcggcaaagctatattattctgctacctctgggaaccttctcg ac
    gtacggtgacacgagtccggacttagggatagctaccacggacggggc tt
    attaccgttagcgggctactctagttctattgggagatgccccccagc ct

    // Inefficient but clever

    ctcgaaacacgtggtccaattgctacacggtcttcgtctgacccaggg tg
    cgggcaattggttaaggtgaatcaaacgggtttccgttaaaggctgaa ct
    agcttccgtcgcgatgctccggcgttggatatcccataccctatgcac tc
    cggtcgggtgtccttctctcacaatgagtagcaagatgggggcgtatt cc
    tgtttggctaaacaataaactgagacgctcctgaacaacggaggcgta cg

    // Heh!

    gagtacacgtgtctgcaaacctggtacacacttcgtcggcatccatgc ca
    gattcctttgtcgtattccctagagaaaccaacgagtgtttgtgcgca ac
    atcacggggccattgtttacgtaatcaatgctcactcaccctgatgat tt
    tccatataacgaattatccgcaactgttacagagtcgtaacagagtga gg
    taacggctcagtaggtcgtgttctagccgagttgaagtccccggcttg ta
    atgaaagcaggtgaataaaattgattttgtcccaaaaatttgctagag tc
    agtttcatttcctagaaattgtagcaatagcttatattgccctatacg ac
    ggccctatgtgttttcatctaaatggaaccgtaaggcgatcgttgtcc cg
    ccgccttctcagcgggtactaagggagtggcttcattccatgactagg ct
    tcaacccgtgtttggagacttctgcgttctctcgctcgacctcgctta ta
    tggtctttgcgcggacattgaatctgtgccaaaaggcttttatgtctc cg

    // DNA sequence is questionable here

    acgtgttgaagtgtatataagttgcggaaagtgaaactattgatcaga ta
    ggttcactagacaattcttttataaaatctaacacccgggagctggtg at
    aaggagctattggagtttcagtgctgtatgtctaagccgtatcgttta ct
    acggagctatatggtatgacccctcccgggggaggtaaatccctaata gg
    aacactcgttggttcgccgcgatcaacccttctttgttctggacggat ct
    atcaccgacaagcacatcaacctcccacccgaaccagagaactcccac ca
    ctataaccagtctggtggcaatgtgtcgaaatcgctattcctcctatc cc
    acgtctagttggtacccgtaatactaaaagaggatcgtggtagggaac ta

    // A rather elegant protein generation chain

    tgttttttattggacaagcgcgggtgccactagaaatagtccgtatct ga
    aactactacacgcagtaaccctgccaacgtacgatactgcccattatg ta
    agacctacaggctgataaccacctcggttgcaaagtccgctttgatcg gg
    ggggtatcagtacgactagttgcaaacatcacctgggataacatacgt ca
    taaaactgaaatcatcgcccctgtcctttgcacctgcttttcgcttga cc
    cgattgtgacgaaatctgctaaactgatggctaccgttgtcgcatgag cc
    tggcgaagagtcagcctatgcgttaacataacttcttacgctagcgag gg
    caagagcaatggcgtgtgtcgcttagggtcaaaacaattggagctgtg ta
    attgtacatattcgatgtttgcaagaaaggtctgccctttgtagttga ta
    gcaacgtcccccctgagttcagcgccgaccggggcggttcccgtaatg gt

    // Not known

    ggtgccatcggacggcgggctatattgcaggcagtacgacctccgaga gg

    // Patent #49491845 here

    ggtcgatggatctgcgtacaatttcacgccccgtaaagcagccatcgt cg
    aggtcatttgcgctgcctcttagtgttatatttgggtcacctcagggg cg

    // Not a bad choice

    ggctcttacctgtccatcccgccgtacggcgtgacgtcttcccctcgc ct
    agttttcctaaattacggggttagtaaactgttggccgcataggactc ta
    tgcgatcaataccacgatgctacgtggatttacataccctttagataa aa
    gtgtgcacggcatagcaaatacttcaactgtaagcggcatagttctgg tt

  3. This has already been tested in Japanese courts... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    You can read about it here. Hopefully, the outcome would be much different if it were to be tried under the American court system.

  4. Hey guys... by jasamaman · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I'm going to patent light. And while I'm at it the entire electromagnetic spectrum! ::Evil laugh::

    --
    Someone ever tries to kill you, you try to kill them right back!
  5. Re:analogy? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Just how in the hell is this offtopic? Time to METAMODERATE!

  6. Re:This has already been tested in Japanese courts by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    OFFTOPIC??!!@#$ What kind of crack have you moderators been smoking?

    Jesus...