Slashdot Mirror


Ethernet Via Electric Conduits

windows bios world writes "From a CNet article NYC businesses will be able to get internet access via ethernet routed through electrical conduits from a subsidiary of Con Edison. CEC is targeting business customers and telecommunications carriers with its PowerLan Ethernet services as part of a larger strategy to become the premier provider of high-bandwidth transport services for New York." Interesting that a non-telecommunications firm can parley a single asset (right-of-way in existing conduits in the crowded tunnels under Manhattan) into a business.

14 of 97 comments (clear)

  1. Remember Sprint? by cperciva · · Score: 4, Informative

    Interesting that a non-telecommunications firm can parley a single asset (right-of-way in existing conduits in the crowded tunnels under Manhattan) into a business.

    Sprint was created when the Southern Pacific Railway realized that they could take advantage of their railway rights-of-way to lay fiber-optic cable.

    1. Re:Remember Sprint? by alexburke · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Sprint was created when the Southern Pacific Railway realized that they could take advantage of their railway rights-of-way to lay fiber-optic cable.

      Then, several years after the fiber had been installed at a cost of God-only-knows-how-many hundreds of millions of dollars, someone discovered their rights-of-way were for the surface and the fiber was buried... where Southern Pacific's rights-of-way didn't extend. I mean, after all, they were intended to allow them to lay track, period.

      Oops.

      (Whatever happened to that whole brouhaha anyway? I haven't heard anything about it in forever...)

    2. Re:Remember Sprint? by elfkicker · · Score: 3, Informative

      According to Qwest's FAQ, they were started in the same way.

      How long has Qwest been in business?
      In 1988, Southern Pacific Telecom was established as a subsidiary of Southern Pacific Railroad to lay telecom cable. This subsidiary was purchased by The Anschutz Company. The company began offering limited long distance services in 1991, changed its name to Qwest Communications in 1995, and incorporated in 1996 when it began construction of the Qwest Macro Capacity Fiber Network. Joe Nacchio was appointed CEO in January 1997 and Qwest made its Initial Public Offering in June 1997.


      Is this some kind of sham that the railroad execs pull everytime they gets a subsidy to build out new lines? Can anyone shed more light on the history of this? Or is this just misinformation. Sprint's history page make no mention of Southern Pacific, and dates itself back to a 1899 as a telephone and utilities upstart.

    3. Re:Remember Sprint? by jrp2 · · Score: 3, Informative

      Sprint was used for internal communications until 1968, when the FCC (Carter Phone Decision) allowed alternative to the Bell system. After that they parlayed it into a business.

      Actually, the CarterPhone decision related to connecting 3rd party (not leased from the telco) telephones and equipment to your phone line. It was instrumental in allowing things like modems. More info on CarterPhone (and a real cool telco history page) here.

      It did not relate to Long Distance at all, that was more related to Judge Green's decision to break up AT&T. Sprint did not enter the LD market until the 80s, with details here. You are correct about the internal communications part though (I know IBM used them for inter-office comms in the 70s).

      --
      The only athletic sport I ever mastered was backgammon - Douglas William Jerrold
    4. Re:Remember Sprint? by bboyers · · Score: 3, Interesting

      From the way it was explained to me, Sprint (then called United Telecom) in the early 80's was only a local telco (small one at that), and there was a partnership between United Telcom (local telco operations), GTE (long distance), and Southern Pacific Railroad (they had the right of way for the fiber drops).

      They started building this network before the breakup of ATT. Once the breakup of ATT. The network that was being built was a long distance network, and GTE wanted out since it could provide long distance now since ATT was required to lease out part of its network to competitors. Souther Pacific wanted out since, it is a railroad company, not a telecom company.

      The partners were slowly bought out by United Telecom, and this is where the name Sprint was picked up, because Sprint was the old name of GTE's Long Distance.

      A similar thing happened with Sprint PCS, it was originally a partnership between Comcast, TCI, and Sprint. Sprint sold off their old Analog Cellular network (I think to Alltel). The cable partners joined because they feared the Baby Bells power, and want in on an alternative solution. As time went on, the cable companies were bought out by Sprint. I guess the cable partners started to realize that with the possibility of cable modems, they already owned an alternative to the baby bells.

      This is how it was explained to me, let me know if there are any mistake in it.

  2. sewer lines too by studarus · · Score: 3, Informative

    Reminds me of another project where they installed fiber optic cable through sewer lines so they didn't have to tear up the streets. They are at City Net. I wonder what is next? Power through my cable tv line?

    1. Re:sewer lines too by spongman · · Score: 3, Funny
      man... and i was just going to post a joke about getting my toilet connected to the internet, too.

      We need more crap on the internet.

      Oh, wait...

    2. Re:sewer lines too by jrp2 · · Score: 3, Funny

      man... and i was just going to post a joke about getting my toilet connected to the internet, too.

      Hehe. Back when I was working at U.S.Robotics we had an April Fools press release describing our new "sewer modem" that used sewers as a transmission medium. It even went down to detail as to how we detected and overcame "noise" such as a toilet flushing. It was too funny, too bad I don't still have a copy to share.

      --
      The only athletic sport I ever mastered was backgammon - Douglas William Jerrold
  3. Also available in Turku, Finland by Johku · · Score: 3, Informative

    Turku Energia (a local energy company in Finland) also announced (link in Finnish) a similar product couple of days ago.

    They are offering a 1.125 Mbps Internet access and they are planning for a product including a telephone line (VoIP), electricity and broadband Internet access all from a single electricity outlet. The service would also make it possible to introduce LANs into old buildings without installing any cables.

    In the testing phase they had some problems with interference but they report those problems being solved now.

  4. back in the mid-80s... by Syre · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Back in the mid-80s I was doing networking down on Wall St. and we needed to connect ethernet LANs in two buildings that were about 100 yards apart.

    We looked into running cable, but the rights-of-way were not available. We looked into getting dark fiber, but NY Telephone said they were not tarrifed to let us have it (although there was in fact dark fiber already in the buildings).

    Then we talked to a company that would run the cable using their right-of-way. That company was (if I recall correctly) called "Metropolitan City Subway" and had nothing whatsoever to do with the subways. Their sole reason for existence, so far as I could tell, was to rent people parts of their right-of-way, which they had obtained I have no idea how.

    They proposed letting us run a cable between the buildings but not directly. We would have to go down to the tip of Manhattan and back again. Instead of 100 yards it was about 4 miles. They also wanted to charge us $20K per month, and had few safety provisions in place to guarantee that our cable wouldn't suddenly be cut by their or other workers.

    Based on the long cable run, the costs, and the uncertainty, we passed, and I ended up installing the first microwave ethernet link in Manhattan instead (24GHz microwave between two ethernet bridges). Which worked fine and required no right-of-way...

    1. Re:back in the mid-80s... by jdcook · · Score: 3, Informative

      It's Empire City Subway, a subsidiary of what is now Verizon.

      --
      Q:How many libertarians does it take to stop a Panzer division? A:None. Obviously market forces will take care of it.
  5. This is not ethernet over power lines by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    This is simply using the conduit (the containers of electrical wires) to house network cables.

    Their advantage is that they have existing right of way all over the city and they have spare room to lay in new cables (new fiber or copper).

  6. Re:They don't use the actual power lines, do they? by jrp2 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    So, tell me this isn't a real-world application of the technique to send data over power lines, is it? They're using their control cables or stuff instead?

    Yeah, the article sure was unclear on that. I think it is safe to assume this is NOT running over power lines, but something like fiber. It just takes advantage of the conduit/right of way they own.

    --
    The only athletic sport I ever mastered was backgammon - Douglas William Jerrold
  7. Also Williams by TheSync · · Score: 3, Informative

    Williams Communications was a gas and petroleum pipeline company with 100,000 miles of right-of-way. In 1985, they started putting fiber in decommissioned pipelines.

    They now have the "largest fully-lit, U.S. next-generation network with local-to-global connectivity, linking 125 cities and reaching five continents."