Slashdot Mirror


Star Wars Fan Films, now Star Wars Audio Drama

darth fluffy writes "Star Wars Fanfilms have become as popular as anime music videos in the geek world over the past year (if not more), but here's a new spin: a full length Star Wars Fan Audio Drama. Recorded with over 40 actors from 5 different countries. Hurray for the power of home PC's!"

32 of 102 comments (clear)

  1. This would be sooo cool... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    If I was 22 and living in my parents basement.

    1. Re:This would be sooo cool... by glwtta · · Score: 2

      good thing I am not... err... for another two weeks.

      --
      sic transit gloria mundi
  2. New Stuff Folks? by ewanrg · · Score: 2, Redundant

    I think it's interesting to see this many people put this much effort into something they love. But I think it would be even more interesting to see folks put this much effort into something new. Something that would create it's own effect on the world - something new and fresh and...

    OK, so when can I expect to see some Cowboy BeBop fan animes?

    1. Re:New Stuff Folks? by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

      "I think it's interesting to see this many people put this much effort into something they love. But I think it would be even more interesting to see folks put this much effort into something new. Something that would create it's own effect on the world - something new and fresh and...
      OK, so when can I expect to see some Cowboy BeBop fan animes?"


      I'm a little surprised somebody gave this guy a 'Redundant' rating. He makes a good point. Part of the problem of the vast majority of Fanfics (for any franchise, not just SW) is that the writers of these feel that they need to make the story as familiar as possible. "I better reference everything I know about Star Wars so that these people realize they're reading about it!" So what happens? Too much familiarity, too little creativity, too little risk-taking.

      What's really needed is inspiration. Any story can be good, even if it's a fanfic, as long as it's inspired. But here's the problem with Star Wars (or Star Trek.. etc...) too many rules have been defined. You should see the dorks come out of the woodwork whenever somebody does a Star Trek vs. Star Wars crossover fanfic. "Starfleet shields can withstand any laser weapons, Captain Picard was very clear about that. The Empire is powerless against the UFP!" "Bullshit! Just because they call them 'turbolasers', doesn't mean they really are lasers! The Empire could easily..." I'm not making this shit up. People get so uptight about the rules that it's hard to produce any work of fanfiction in these overly defined universes to satisfy lots of people.

      At least, with something new (like the parent poster suggested), the rules aren't defined yet. They have control over what they're doing and they can make something truely interesting and inspired.

  3. Uh Oh... by da3dAlus · · Score: 5, Funny

    "I think George Lucas' gonna sue somebody!"

    --

    Sometimes I doubt your commitment to Sparkle Motion.
    1. Re:Uh Oh... by Joey7F · · Score: 2

      He doesn't care as long as you aren't using Star Wars itself. Ie Troops is A-Ok but the phantom edit (TPE) not so okay.

      --Joey

  4. Lucas Strikes Back? by webword · · Score: 2

    So how long until George kills this?

    1. Re:Lucas Strikes Back? by Mitchell+Mebane · · Score: 2

      No need. It's already dead...

      Can somebody who got it put it up on KaZaA and post a sig2dat here?

      --

      The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet.
      --Aristotle
  5. Good thing they ignore physics... by FearUncertaintyDoubt · · Score: 5, Funny
    ...because explosions in space would sound exactly like non-explosions, and therefore, make for very dull audio.

    begin the great space battle
    "Roger, Red leader, I'm going in"
    twelve minutes of silence
    "This is Red niner. We got 'em. Let's go home"
    end the great space battle

    1. Re:Good thing they ignore physics... by TerryAtWork · · Score: 5, Funny

      In Movie Physics sounds are LOUDER in space because they haven't got all that air in the way.

      --
      It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
    2. Re:Good thing they ignore physics... by Rosonowski · · Score: 2

      Well, then you'd have to worry about being sued. Silence, as you know, is copywritten. Of course, which part of the silence is copywritten will end up in dispute

      --
      01101001 01100001 01101101 01101110 01101111 01110100 01100001 01101100 01100001 01110111 01111001 01100101 01110010
    3. Re:Good thing they ignore physics... by sckeener · · Score: 2

      In Movie Physics sounds are LOUDER in space because they haven't got all that air in the way.

      Same goes for Anime and is in fact law #3. To see the rest of the Anime laws, go here.

      --
      "Only one thing, is impossible for god: to find any sense in any copyright law on the planet." Mark Twain
    4. Re:Good thing they ignore physics... by TerryAtWork · · Score: 2

      Excellent, thanks!

      Some of those rules are what I call the 'God Bless Japan' rules, for example, the first time saw certain genres of anime I thought 'God bless Japan!'

      --
      It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
  6. I just hope Lucas by TerryAtWork · · Score: 4, Insightful

    has the brains to not kill this.

    IF HE'S SMART he'll encourage it. But you never know when he'll stop being smart.

    Like Henry Ford said about Model T jokes 'Every joke is another Model T sold' so every SW fan effort is another pile of tickets sold.

    --
    It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
    1. Re:I just hope Lucas by irc.goatse.cx+troll · · Score: 2

      If he encourages this, he essentially gives up any ability to defend his copyright. At best he can just look the other way, but that would hurt their ability to defend also.

      --
      Pain lasts, kid. Its how you know you're alive. Sometimes I think this growing up thing is just pain management-TheMaxx
    2. Re:I just hope Lucas by TerryAtWork · · Score: 3, Informative

      No its a TRADEMARK he has to defend.

      And that brings up another of my pet peves. This 'defend your trademark or lose it' thing is a scam by the lawyers.

      In Japan where they do not have this law the IP grafix/comix business is a lot bigger than in the west. Not a coincidence.

      By putting 'SW and all characters TM George Lucas 2002' they can cover their asses on this.

      --
      It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
    3. Re:I just hope Lucas by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

      God, I hate replying to acknowledged trolls, but this idea is repeated too damn often as it is.

      What you said only applies to trademarks. You can only claim ownership of a trademark if the word or phrase isn't already in common usage to describe the thing you're trying to sell. You couldn't trademark "mouse pad," for example, because everybody already calls them mouse pads. Once you have a trademark, if you let people use it without authorization, it gradually becomes diluted to the point where you can't reasonably claim exclusivity any more. But this takes a lot of time. Johnson & Johnson still owns the trademark on "Band-Aid," Kimberly-Clark still owns the trademark on "Kleenex," and Xerox still owns the trademark on "Xerox."

      The fact that you don't defend your copyrights against infringement doesn't dilute the strength of your claim to those copyrights. Copyrights are non-conditional.

      --

      I write in my journal
    4. Re:I just hope Lucas by TerryAtWork · · Score: 3, Informative

      No they aren't.

      If I cut a scene of Luke Skywalker from a SW movie and put it in my own I'd be violating CR and TM.

      If I dress up as Luke Skywalker and wave a cardboard light sabre around shouting "I, Luke Skywalker, Jedi Knight, will save you Princess!' on camera, I'd be violating TM and the Laws of Good Taste :-)

      You can't copyright a character, only a particular representation of it. TRADEMARK is for the character and it's name and likeness.

      --
      It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
  7. Not my thing, but... by BFaucet · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Well I'm not a big starwars fan, nor am I a big fan of fan fiction (how many times can the "fan" be placed in a sentence?) However, I feel the fact that this can be done is quite cool! I say, "More power to 'em!"

    After all, bringing people together and sharing ideas and such is the best thing about the net, right?.. Well other than porn, of course.

    --
    -Derick
    1. Re:Not my thing, but... by AlfaGiik · · Score: 2, Informative

      They're not sharing ideas, they're rehashing someone else's. Amazing what passes for creativity these days...

  8. I think its good by mugnyte · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Fan fiction is no more than collective imagination. When you envision the "just past the ending" scenes of your favorite move, you don't discuss it? Sounds like boring date, you.

    Fan fiction can be as bad as anything built through a collective, but this departure from a bunch of Harvard screenwriters' 6-month chop-n-splice is a refreshing. How many movies are you skipping because it seems formulaic, formulaic with a single twist or anti-formulaic in an almost reactionary sense?

    With fan fiction, its a bit of a random roll of the dice. Now, I will admit that having fans create their own story is a bit like asking for more of the same. But a movie sticks to a genre/premise at some level anyway, so either accept that or eat your popcorn and go home.

    The negative on fan fiction seem a bit ironic given the pro open-source stance seen on the /. It's not much different, IMO.

    mug

  9. Bah by Aggrazel · · Score: 2, Funny

    I'm still waiting for Space Balls The Sequel: The Search for More Money !

  10. actually you would hear the explosion by SHEENmaster · · Score: 2

    the atmosphere of the ship would carry the sound with it. By the law of conservation of energy, and wave reflection, the sound would make it to the destroying ship.

    Whether or not it could be heard through another ship's hull is an entirely different matter.

    --
    You can't judge a book by the way it wears its hair.
  11. Star Trek: Starship Exeter by kevcol · · Score: 2

    Sort of related, this Star Trek TOS based film has been making the rounds the past few days:

    http://homepage.mac.com/starshipexeter/

    Apparently it was in production for 7 years and they have just released it.

  12. Written Examples by mugnyte · · Score: 3, Informative


    In the SW storyline, this may give you an idea of the creativity being cultured online for fan fiction.

  13. Dear God. by RatBastard · · Score: 2

    I hope that post is a joke.

    --
    Boobies never hurt anyone. - Sherry Glaser.
  14. Shouldn't reply to a troll but... by RatBastard · · Score: 2

    I know that you are biung a troll, but I'll bite. It's the duty of the parents to instil in their children what they consider "proper morals". It's not my job, nor anyone esles to teach your children values. It's not our job to make up for your mack of parenting skills.

    --
    Boobies never hurt anyone. - Sherry Glaser.
  15. The spirit is still alive by OleMoudi · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Is good to know the classic fantasy spirit that made Star Wars films so moving for an entire generation is still alive. These fan activities prove, the latest films like Episode one and two have not killed that spirit as many critics state

    --
    ---------
    Thinking never hurt anybody --MacGyver
  16. Howabout Starship Exeter by ch-chuck · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Described by one writer as:

    "an interesting site that will be a delight for anyone with broadband and an interest in obsessive sci-fi fandom. Ask yourself: if you and your friends decided to shoot an entire episode of TOS Star Trek, and you wrote a script set on the recommissioned Exeter, and you rented a warehouse, built a replica of a Constitution-class starship, designed all the sets and lighting to look like 1967 TV, and spent SEVEN YEARS on the project, meticulously recreating the look and sound of a TOS episode, what would the result look like?"

    I haven't checked it out yet but looks rather interesting.

    --
    try { do() || do_not(); } catch (JediException err) { yoda(err); }
  17. Yikes. by bluephone · · Score: 2, Funny
    And when we Trekkies do this kind of stuff, we're called losers. :)

    And I don't care what ANYONE says, nothing in Trek is as goofy as those midicondrians from Ep1. :P

    --
    jX [ Make everything as simple as possible, but no simpler. - Einstein ]
  18. Let's See What We Can Do Here... by NPB-2S · · Score: 3, Informative

    Nice to see Slashdot taking an interest in the project. Of coure, now we're on a frantic hunt for more mirrors so 2S doesn't kill the entire StarWarz/JediNet server, but that's okay.

    To answer some of the comments (particularly the ones that show that the poster has no clue what they're talking about):

    Don't expect GL or LFL to kill the site. For those who haven't been keeping up, fan productions such as fan films have been around for years, and are an ever-expanding community. Lucasfilm takes a fan-friendly approach to the genre, only curtailiing those that somehow tarnish the SW name through extensive sexual content (Tripping the Rift, StarBallz, etc.) or use film footage direct from their films (the original version of The Dark Redemption, for example). While fan productions cannot receive official approval from Lucasfilm, many projects (including Second Strike) have received positive comments from people who work with or work for Lucasfilm or LucasBooks. (Daniel Wallace, for instance, has a regular segment on Second Strike's sister project, ChronoRadio, while Kevin Rubio, Ann Crispin, and others, have interviews scheduled for CR as well). In other words, there's no need to worry about LFL "shutting us down." They're about the most benevolent company in terms of fan productions that there is.

    FearUncertaintyDoubt: That's why you'll never hear a space explosion in Second Strike, only ones in the mid-atmosphere, at the highest.

    Fan Fiction Naysayers: There's a difference between fan fiction that directly comes out of a film and an original story set in the context of a fictional universe. Second Strike does the latter. It has very few tie-ins directly to previously released materials. It simply uses the backdrop of the time frame created by one comic book series and one novel series as its setup. After that, it could be an audio presentation of any other story or an entirely separate story. The Star Wars tie-in, though, represents the community we wanted to present it for, as a thanks for the support given to the projects that many of our 40+ cast have worked on in the past. In many of our cases, this is the last hurrah before leaving the fan production community.

    StewyGriffin: Perhaps it didn't make the page, so you didn't know. The entire production has cost *maybe* $40, mostly for food and such that our Mixer has been using as fuel for late-night mixing. Pretty much everything has been done with programs that we all had to begin with, and, after that, all that was required was time. A fan *film* on the other hand, require a decent sized budget. Part of why Second Strike is audio is to cut down costs to almost nothing.

    a1englishman: Listen to the opening of 2S. That's what we're paying homage to. You can tell the most in the model used for the opening narrator.

    I'll try to check back again tonight or once I get back to Atlanta this weekend. Just have to remember to ignore the trolls and keep an eye out for people who *have* bothered to check it out who can therefore make *informed* comments.
    --NPB
    http://www.starwarz.com/timeline /2s/

  19. A *whole* month to write the script. . ? Gee! by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 2
    This does not bode well.

    But you know what? I'm downloading the first act right now. I'll reserve judgement. . , well indefinitely. Even if it sucks bananas, I love collaborative projects like this. I'm sure everybody involved has learned a mountain of cool new skills, and are richer people because of it.

    Simply trying to coordinate a project of this scale represents a spectacular effort!

    Kudos, Kudos, Kudos!

    Now, (fingers crossed), if the script is any good, the project itself and not just what it represents might just be something special. Perhaps a new force in the galaxy to contend with. . ?

    Fingers crossed. . .


    -Fantastic Lad