Slashdot Mirror


Top Ten Shameful Games

Ant writes "Not necessarily the worst, but the most wrong -- here are 10 of the most seriously flawed titles of all time according to GameSpy."

33 of 455 comments (clear)

  1. This has been done before by dlc915 · · Score: 5, Informative

    This has already been done here.
    The two lists seem to be very similar...

    --
    I still haven't found the "any" key.
  2. That's it? by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 4, Interesting

    They didn't mention the "Lunar Lander" game on a HP-65 pocket calculator??? There was a lame game if there ever was one...

    1. Re:That's it? by dokutake · · Score: 5, Funny

      The next generation model, the SR-71 "Blackbird", left its calculator roots behind, focusing more on high speed and flying really really high in the air.

      --
      - Peter
  3. Too bad GameSpy isn't a game... by Dark+Lord+Seth · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ... otherwise they'd be the number one most shameful game. Taking bets at which community they will buy out and kill next.

  4. You can tell... by RobertTaylor · · Score: 5, Funny

    You can tell its the xmas / new year break as 'news' becomes 'reporters top ten ...'

    There must be *something* going on somewhere?

  5. Obviously, this tester never played... by vasqzr · · Score: 5, Informative


    50% of the games which have been created for PC

    Something Awful has:

    Game reviews

    and

    The ROM Pit

    Don't say I didn't warn you.

  6. I owned one of 'em, and liked it! by analog_line · · Score: 4, Interesting

    It was Donkey Kong for the Intellivision. Yeah, I'm sure it was worse than the other versions, but hey, I didn't know any better. I played the hell out of that thing. Play control was fine enough for me.

    As for Action 52, as the story hints at, there is a pretty funny and interesting story that goes along with the game. Here's a link to the Something Awful Rompit Review of Action 52, and go here
    for the Gamefaqs.com reviews page for Action 52. I've rarely laughed as hard as I did reading this stuff.

    On a side-note, if you are at all into video games, browsing Gamefaqs for the reviews of really bad games can be a laugh riot sometimes. There are a few people who seem to make it their mission to completely eviscerate the worst offenders of the old cartridge console games. Some of the crappy PSX games get some hilarious reviews, too. For when you've got some surfing time, at least.

  7. What gives? by jkabbe · · Score: 5, Funny

    They should have called this article "Top Ten Shameful Games on Consoles No One Under 20 Has Ever Heard Of".

    Any shameful game list just HAS to include the disaster called Outpost that was released for the PC in the early 90's. It had a great guide (sold separately) that made the game look great. Too bad most of those features didn't actually make it into the game. What a stinker.

    1. Re:What gives? by DeadMoose · · Score: 5, Funny

      They should have called this article "Top Ten Shameful Games on Consoles No One Under 20 Has Ever Heard Of".

      Hey! I keep my old 2600 & ET cartridge around just so I can scare young children.

      "HAHA! You fell into the pit again!"

      Trust me, there are people under 20 who've heard of that one...and it haunts their nightmares.

  8. Old old old by tinrobot · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Atari 2600? NES? Coleco? Seems like most of these games are ancient by industry standards. I think that it's kind of beating a dead horse. The industry was in it's infancy, people really were still defining what a video game was - of course there would be some spectacular duds. Goes with the territory.

    What about recent titles that were 'shameful'? Would someone from Jerry Falwell's congregation like to chime in?

    1. Re:Old old old by Alan+Holman · · Score: 5, Funny

      You're absolutely right! Rating these first games IS beating a dead horse; however, it's a horse I'd like to beat BECAUSE I've got lots of fond memories of playing the original videogames. Lots of us do. Lots of us remember watching our older brother, and his jerk friend Lance, play new games for their Atari, and their NES, waiting eagerly for our turn which never came. I was the little brother who was sent to my older brother's friend's house against my will because it was convenient for both sets of parental units. (Okay, now I'm venting.) My first fascination about video games came from waiting, and waiting, to play Atari or NES. Asking through burning tears, "When's my turn?" My brother's friend Lance replies, "Never. Why are you here anyway?" And then I cry, "I DIDN'T WANNA COME HERE!!!" And then the closest I get to playing a video game is getting hit in the nose by a football... Hmm... Maybe this has something to do with why I hoard classic video games now, and maybe this has something to do with why I love beating the dead horse of those old games by reading articles about them. And maybe those old games aren't so old to people like me who enjoy reading those lists of the worst ones. They're not so old to me because I didn't get to play them when they originally were released because my brother's friend kept me away from them! So now I ramble on and on about how I hoard these games, and cherish info about them now, because I didn't get to play them back then! Okay, sorry for the venting rant, but maybe someone'll sympathise and give me a score of 5 in the mod, eh?

    2. Re:Old old old by Sentry21 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Would someone from Jerry Falwell's congregation like to chime in?

      This reminds me of some customers I had at work. They were trying to find a game for their son, and somehow had stumbled across Diablo. The two were obviously religious from their reaction to a game featuring demons, the undead, and of course, Diablo himself. After looking at the box for a while, asking my coworker some questions, and saying 'oh my' or what have you, they asked their final question, which it seems no religious advocates seem to consider.

      'So... you're supposed to kill Diablo?'
      'Yep, that's the whole point of the game.'
      'That doesn't sound too bad then. We'll take it.'

      These parents seem to realize what most religious groups don't: namely, that games like Diablo, that feature unholy evil, are not necessarily bad. Why? Because you're KILLING THE EVIL. You can be a Paladin, a holy warrior of God. How is this bad?

      --Dan

  9. LOL by robbyjo · · Score: 5, Funny

    This list is simply hillarious. For the worst of the worst games (i.e. Custer's Revenge) I was thinking that the screenshot shows a cowboy shooting to the left an Indian to the right. But... the explanation is about pr0n. LOL....

    Go straight to this game's explanation.

    --

    --
    Error 500: Internal sig error
    1. Re:LOL by Snaller · · Score: 5, Informative

      . For the worst of the worst games (i.e. Custer's Revenge) I was thinking that the screenshot shows a cowboy shooting to the left an Indian to the right. But... the explanation is about pr0n. LOL....


      Wanna try it?

      --
      If Google really cared they would fix Android Chrome to reflow text, instead of discriminating
  10. Ghostbusters for NES by mediocratese · · Score: 5, Funny

    Does anyone remember this digital trainwreck? Your character is 2 pixels worth of ghostbusting hero and the climax of the game involves you repeatedly pressing a "climb" button to go up 30+ floors to the top of a building to fight StayPuff Marshellow Man. I actually beat the game once, and the win screen was a simple typed message thanking you for playing "this truly awesome game!!!"
    After playing this piece of shit I no longer wanted my eyes.

  11. Who cares? by sevensharpnine · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Does anyone really care what Gamespy thinks? I can't help but laugh when I see these articles. Their website has become nothing more than a playground for hive-minded children looking to find this weeks new "cool" words and get fed advertisement driven "content" on the game industry. Their webmasters have a collective gaming experience on par with what you could find at and local Wal-Mart's nintendo kiosks. Check the insightful gameplay guides/tips of any planet site. PlanetQuake and PlanetWarcraft are prime examples; they're both full of laughable advice.

    Furthermore, their bullying and underhanded tactics towards the entire industry is damaging everyone (try to use a game finding tool other than Gamespy -- the alternatives don't support as many games, thanks to "exclusive content"). Their entire site, as defined by virtually every hardcore gamer I know, is a complete joke. There are many interesting websites out there dealing with games. Please quit linking to the worst one.

    --
    "God is a comedian playing to an audience too afraid to laugh." -Voltaire
    1. Re:Who cares? by Gutboy_Barrelhouse · · Score: 5, Funny
      Their website has become nothing more than a playground for hive-minded children...

      And you're ranting about this on Slashdot?

    2. Re:Who cares? by sevensharpnine · · Score: 4, Informative

      If you're looking for general interest sites, a few to check out would be: Shacknews -- www.shacknews.com and Blue's News -- www.bluesnews.com and maybe even the Adrenaline Vault -- www.avault.com and Thresh's FiringSquad -- www.firingsquad.com. While these sites aren't perfect, they aren't nearly as bad as Gamespy and Gamespot.

      Better yet are actual fan sites for games you're interested in. A good way to find some is to check the game's official page for a list of fan sites or simply talk to other players. To show you what happens when real gamers put together web sites...

      Warcraft III: (Excellent replays)
      www.theinclan.com

      Counter-Strike: (Replays and configs)
      www.sogamed.com

      Quake: (News)
      www.quake3stuff.com

      --
      "God is a comedian playing to an audience too afraid to laugh." -Voltaire
  12. 2600 Pac Man by wideBlueSkies · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Every kid I knew in the 7th and 8th grade was excited about the prospect of playing Pac Man at home. No more trips to the arcade. No more standing in line. No more scrounging for quarters. Everything was going to be right with the world.

    On the day of the game's release, there were lines at the electronics stores, lines at Sears, lines at K-Mart, lines everywhere that sold 2600 stuff. Some places had given out lottery bracelets (like they do at ticketmasters). But there were lines anyway. All these people were waiting to bring the magic of Pac Man home with them.

    Then the game came home. What a horrible, horrible dissapointment it was. Ugh. I think that was the beginning of the end for Atari. They pissed off a lot of kids (and parents) with that piece of crap.

    This was also about the time that the TRaSh 80 was out, along with the Commodore and Vic machines (I think). Anyway, some of us started getting interested in computer based games after the Pac man debacle. Shortly after that, a number of us left our 2600's behind for the promise of real computers.

    Personally, I haven't had a new game console since the 2600. Not because of the Pac Man mess though. I don't see the point of having a dedicated, fixed hardware game platform. A PC does so much more, and the games are generally better than those available on a console.

    --
    Huh?
    1. Re:2600 Pac Man by ClosedSource · · Score: 5, Interesting

      There were technical reasons why the graphics were so bad. If you want to have a game like Pac Man look good on the 2600, you have to insure that only one ghost appears in the same horizontal scan lines as the Pac Man. That's because there are only 2 "high resolution" players (objects) available in a single scan line.

      In order to preserve the Pac Man gameplay, Atari didn't follow that rule and had to multiplex the players. Thus the anoying blinking.

      One of the reasons that games from Activision had much better graphics, was because their games were designed around the limitations of the 2600.

  13. I saw something similar to this by staticdaze · · Score: 5, Informative

    Seanbaby.com - EGM's Crapstravaganza: The 20 Worst Games of All Time He has a few of the same titles (ET, Superman 64, and Custer's revenge), and, in my opinion, has much funnier reviews. I really enjoyed it, this is just for if anybody else cares for a second list like this.

  14. A pretty arbitrary list by tc · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Does seem to be a somewhat arbitrary list, with a puzzling bias for games on very old systems. Sure, Custer's Revenge is clearly a shameful heap of junk, but some of the other choices seem arbitrary. Impossible Mission on the 2600 is not the only game to have shipped that was inadvertently impossible to beat, and as the article notes, it was otherwise a decent product.

    Plus, how can anyone leave Trespasser off the list of worst gaming travesties? Not only was the game monumentally awful, but it was also accompanied by such stomach churningly over-the-top hype from Seamus "Media Whore" Blackley, that the resulting derision meant that he later felt compelled to 'redeem' himself by attempting to take credit for the Xbox.

  15. Slot machine games by angle_slam · · Score: 4, Funny

    I can't believe they didn't include any slot machine "simulators." In a real casino, the only joy you get from slot machines is the chance to actually win money. Yet the computerized version gets rid of that, so you are stuck hitting the "spin reels" button over and over again, while occassionally "winning" credits. What a pointless waste of time!

  16. Donkey Kong Engrish by rigmort · · Score: 4, Interesting
    In The First Quarter, a history of video games, Steven L. Kent claims that the Japanese version translated to "Stubborn Gorilla"; for lack of a better word for stubborn, the word Donkey was used.

    Thes rest, as they say, is history...

    1. Re:Donkey Kong Engrish by rigmort · · Score: 5, Informative
      I just dug out my copy of The First Quarter. As Steven Kent puts it:

      "Because of his desire to penetrate the American market, [Shigeru] Yamauchi wanted the game to have an English name. Since Miyamoto spoke only a little English, he used a Japanese-English dictionary to find the correct words for the title. He wanted to name the game after the ape -- "Stubborn Gorilla." Looking throught the dictionary, Miyamoto selected the word Donkey as a synonym for stubborn and the word Kong for gorilla."

      Another interesting tidbit from the book:

      "Before Namco showed Pac-Man to Midway, one change was made to the game. Pac-Man was originally named Puck-Man, a reference to the puck-like shape of the main character. [Masaya] Nakamura worried about American vandals changing the "P" to an "F." To prevent any such occurence, he changed the name of the game."

      "So when you're there in class, learning `his story' Learn a little of your story, the real story" -- Boogie Down Productions, "Part Time Sucker"

  17. They left out the arcade one by TerryAtWork · · Score: 4, Funny

    I think called Jungle Lad where he gets captured by 8 bit block jungle natives who are, to give no offence to anyone, GREEN.

    I remember thinking 'He's been captured by the Booger Tribe..."

    --
    It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
  18. What they don't tell you... by Nindalf · · Score: 5, Informative

    It's not just offensive, it's unplayably bad.

    The entire gameplay is on that one screen, moving toward the woman while dodging arrows. The arrows fall in a random, unpredictable, unlearnable pattern. They often appear in volleys that cover too much area for it to be possible to avoid them.

    All in all, the perfect choice for the worst game ever.

  19. F-15 Strike Eagle? by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Anybody remember F-15 Strike Eagle for the Atari 800 series? Not only did it have an embarrasingly slow frame-rate, but you could land your plane upside-down!

  20. 2600 Pacman & Space Invaders could've been bet by dmaxwell · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Some 2600 Roms have been hacked by people who I suppose wanted to expunge some bad memories. Ms. Pacman for the 2600 wasn't at all bad and somebody hacked it into a fairly arcade-faithful Pacman. Since Ms. Pacman was decent to start with, the hacker limited it to one maze that is a good approximation of arcade Pacman's maze. The prizes were fixed in place below the ghosthouse and edited to match arcade Pacman's prizes. Go to Atari Age and check it out.

    Several credible jobs were done on reforming space invaders. There is no reason why 2600 Space Invaders couldn't have been more accurate as this proves.

    Oh well, anyone who played games in the early eighties knew that crap was rushed out the door. Most of us bought it anyway. Me too. Suckers....

  21. What about games released for Timex/Sinclair 1000? by alchemist68 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    They didn't mention Frogger and Flight Simulator for the Timex/Sinclair 1000 / Sinclair ZX81! Unngh! Man oh man did I hate loading in those games from cassette, hoping the input level wasn't too low or too high, otherwise I wasted 15 minutes attempting to load the programs. Then there was that aweful monocolor BLACK and WHITE ONLY graphics, the membrane keyboard that was SMALLER than my hand, the 4 Megehurts Zilog Z80A. And you couldn't pound on the keyboard too hard during game play, you'd dislodge the 16K RAM Pack from the back expansion port, killing your game, and wasting another 15 minutes loading it back in from cassette. Ah...the good'ol glory days of computing I will tell to my grandchildren.

  22. Hunt the Wumpus for the TI-99/4 and TI-99/4A by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 5, Funny

    But why all the "worst games" lists?

    The usual hype. But I was surprised by the lack of one hugely important game:

    Hunt the Wumpus.

    Hunt the Wumpus was apparently an old Unix text-based RPG, which Texas Instruments brought to life on their under-rated but massively overbuilt TI-99/4A home computer in 1980 or so.

    The TI-99/4A (and its rare older brother, the TI-99/4) had a 16 bit TMS9900 processor chip (in 1979 and 1981, boys and girls!), a kick-butt video chip (the TMS9918) which had 32 sprites and a video overlay feature. But Texas Instruments, a company which is/was making more chips than Frito-Lay, hobbled the machine by using the video chip's RAM as the console's main memory, bottlenecking the expanded memory down to 8 bits, and creating the single slowest BASIC interpreter ever designed by having it interpreted TWICE (from BASIC to GPL - "Graphics Programming Language" - then to machine language).

    With this nasty kludge, they released a graphical version of Hunt The Wumpus. Horrible sound effects, and game play which made you feel like you were drunk and on LSD. Oh, and attempting to add graphics to an old text-only game is doomed to fail, don't even attempt it.

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
    1. Re:Hunt the Wumpus for the TI-99/4 and TI-99/4A by dandelion_wine · · Score: 5, Funny

      Omg. OMG. Hunt the Wumpus.

      My mind is actually reeling. HOW THE FUCK COULD YOU DO THIS TO ME??! You know how long it's taken me to forget that? And -- uhhh -- the sound it makes when you incorrectly guess the direction of the fat little fucker? I think I'm going to be sick.

      It's ok. It's ok. (rocking back and forth) Think pleasant thoughts. The new agey music and colours underwater in DK Country. Ok, your sanity is slipping just a little, like that marble in Marble Madness. You're having trouble grasping the controls, like that little fuck Q*bert. But it's ok. I'm almost back to my Prague sanctuary in Vampire, Masquerade Redemption. See how I keep my faith objects though they're useless to me? Think weird, alternate universe, in Super Mario II. Happy little running mushrooms. I'm selling Tandelovian Happy Juice to the Teeelveee in Starflight 2, Trade Routes of the Cloud Nebula (system 125, 95). And I'm getting a REALLY GOOD price. Nice Teeelveee. See, everything is JUST FINE. :D :D :D :D :D

  23. A bit unfair with Atari 2600 Pacman by FyRE666 · · Score: 5, Informative

    Ok, so it looked far worse than the original, but personally I was amazed they managed it at all, given the miserable hardware the 2600 had! The machine was designed to display 2 player sprites, 2 missile sprites, a ball and a playfield which was basically a vertical line, unless the video chip was preloaded each X scanlines. Remember, the machine had 128 BYTES of work RAM and NO graphics RAM, so the entire background and sprites had to be redrawn by the program every frame.

    It's no wonder the ghosts flickered, it must have been impossible for the little 8 bit CPU to manage to keep everything on screen all the time at 25pfs...

    There's an old article about programming the 2600 here which may open a few eyes!