Slashdot Mirror


Japan Subsidizes Linux Development, Considers Switch

TheAB writes "Japan is betting 50 million yen ($450k US) that the next-generation of high-tech products and computer networks will rely on open-source software. The money is to develop an 'operating system for consumer electronics goods'."

28 of 248 comments (clear)

  1. Defined "betting" by Rocko+Bonaparte · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Japan plans to spend about 1 billion yen (US$8.3 million) funding Asian software developers working on the open-source Linux

    This makes it sound like a certain win, but what is this about "betting?"

    Tokyo has already budgeted 50 million yen (US$416,000) for next fiscal year to study the possibility of switching government computers to an open-source operating system.

    So are they putting that upfront to see if it's worth it, with the $8.3 million conditional? It sounds exciting, but I don't want to hold my breath without clarification.

    --
    No I'm not trolling.
  2. Actually... by Archie+Steel · · Score: 5, Informative

    According to the article that's 50 million yen for Tokyo alone...for the whole of Japan it's closer a billion yen (8.3 million$).

    In either case it's not that big of a sum, but any amount helps!

    --

    Reminder: find a new sig
  3. Why? by loknor · · Score: 5, Funny

    " Japan plans to spend about 1 billion yen (US$8.3 million) funding Asian software developers working on the open-source Linux "

    Why do that when you can just pull a Castle and steal it.... :-)

    --

    me karma am bad
  4. The Japanese government, not Japan by palfreman · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It is the Japaese government that is spending the money, not "Japan". This may seem off-topic, but a country is different from its government. The amount Japan spends on Linux would be all the money all Japanese people and companies spend on Linux and Linux related things, not what the government did there. Governments are just another organisation and for most countries the main source of their problems.

    1. Re:The Japanese government, not Japan by Henry+V+.009 · · Score: 5, Interesting

      You've come square up against what I like to call "the one big person" theory of foreign states. Anything that is both very complex and very unfamiliar is treated as one big person: France is a big crybaby. Canada is a wimp. Israel is just one big Holocaust survivor. America is arrogant. On and on. Sure the sterotypes might sometimes contribute some pithy insight, but once they begin to suck up all debate nothing constructive ever gets said again. It is fundamentally impossible to sum up a complex system in this manner. It leads to all sorts of problems. Not that this mode of thinking will ever go away, mind you.

      Actually, I think the whole 'complex entity = person" idea is something very human, and applies to all sorts of things beyond foreign countries. Businesses, cultural groups, one's own government, all of them treated like this. Its the human mind's way of dealing I suppose. And to a degree, maybe it even makes sense. The individual human is one of the most complex systems on this planet. Therefore we try to model other complex systems with that model.

    2. Re:The Japanese government, not Japan by palfreman · · Score: 4, Insightful
      It takes its money from people who live there by force. So what if the government where you live is elected - I didn't vote for them, I hate almost everything they do (they in my case being the "British" government and the warmongering fool who runs it), and if I don't pay up they really would arrest me and send me to jail.

      Just as I wouldn't want to be lumped in with a bunch of techno-illiterate nutcases in London, I'm sure there are plenty of people in Japan who wouldn't like to be associated with what their government does.

    3. Re:The Japanese government, not Japan by firewrought · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Its the human mind's way of dealing I suppose...

      And people do the same thing with the concept of "God"... even though the details vary drastically, most cultures have a mythology that posits a source of universal intention: something or someone that controls natural events (weather, harvest, childbirth, astronomical bodies, etc.) and interacts with individual human lives (by providing comfort, discipline, special powers, spirtual growth, second chances, forgiveness, condemation, tests and trials, equalizing opportunities, purpose and meaning, spouse and family, absolute morality, eternal security, etc.). The fact that these things are (or will be) explainable through the lenses of natural and cognitive science hasn't done much to convince people that there's no God mediating their reality. It's as if we have to attribute agency (in the AI sense of the term) to events that are personally significant. All these uncontrolled externals are wrapped up into "God".

      But, to reply to the parent post, there are more practical reasons for making the "complex entity"==>"person" simplification. When we say "France opposses war with Iraq", it's pretty accurate, because we get the impression that (1) the official government posture and (2) the general sentiment of the French population do not want to see a war. We have no way of characterizing it in a finer manner than that... we don't have a list of x million French who oppose war and the y million French who endorse it, so we use the label "France" to tag the relevant input (in this case, the relevant input is "political pressure", but if we were watching a news broadcast about organized protest against the rapid expansion of metropolitan Paris, than we might categorize the input as "environmentalist").

      I'm sure there are a thousand interesting AI and cogsci theories for explaining or expressing this... the human brain is truly incredible, but it make broad, obvious machine-like mistakes too.

      --
      -1, Too Many Layers Of Abstraction
  5. Re:I don't know about this by awa · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Err... putting Japan and China in the same bag is akin to saying the U.S., Mexico and surrounding areas are all alike.

    Besides, if you read the story, the entities mentioned are Ministries and two _very_ big corporations (Sony and Matsushita) - highly unlikely to be pirating software.

    --
    --Moo
  6. Interesting choice of dates.. by Edball · · Score: 5, Funny
    "Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry official Shuichi Tashiro said the subsidies will be doled out next fiscal year, which begins April 1."

    Hmmmm....

  7. Oh boy! $450k! by occamboy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    At the risk of being obvious...

    Linux is a stupendous 'operating system for consumer electronics goods' -- as an engineer who's developed embedded systems, I think that Linux is great for this purpose. For example, Tivo, which is Linux-based, is the greatest consumer electronic item of all time.

    But $450k? Gee, what a commitment! That's like 2-3 full time people if you include overhead.

  8. developers, developers, developers... by pubjames · · Score: 5, Interesting


    This kind of thing must be extremely worrying to Microsoft. All up all the developers working for governments around the world, and I bet there are about ten times as many as work for Microsoft. It's probably even more than that if you think about it.

  9. refrigerator root by scrotch · · Score: 5, Funny

    Personally, I would love to be able to ssh into my refrigerator and poke around without having to get up and go all the way to the kitchen...

    And imagine how cool you'll be with sendmail running on your air conditioner.

  10. WOOHOO! GUNDAM! by macshune · · Score: 5, Funny

    When they *finally* get around to getting that Gundam operational, it will run Linux!!!!!

  11. Here's the REAL question by deanj · · Score: 4, Funny
    The real question is, will THESE folks violate the GPL in products?

    Previous story here is on a company that did that. If Japan's encouraging the use of open source (and presumably GPL), what do they ship if they, for example, do an embedded linux port for a microwave? Do they ship a CD with the code with the microwave?

    Geeze, if they did that, half the country would use the thing as the coaster, 49 percent would try and mu-wave the thing, and 1 percent (well, less...go with the idea here) would be left figuring how to do cool hacks on it.

    1. Re:Here's the REAL question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

      if they, for example, do an embedded linux port for a microwave? Do they ship a CD with the code with the microwave?

      Lots of companies are already shipping products with embedded linux in it. You dont have to ship the code with the microwave. You can to make it available on a website.

  12. Re:whoa there pilgrim by Lockjaw · · Score: 5, Funny

    According to the Bill Gates Net Worth Page they could hire him for over two hours with that kind of money...

  13. Makes perfect sense. by amberspry · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Many of the small devices that have any type of computing power run on Linux or proprietary software. Seeing as how open source software is already out there and developed to the point of using without as much modification, it is much cheaper that development from scratch. Since they do have such a high piracy rate they don't have to worry as much about licensing and other legal complications.

    As far as the government computers all they have to worry about is the software that runs on top of the OS, in fact most of the applications they would need access to are already available in one form or another. They can also get around any trouble from Microsoft. Even though they are probably not loosing any sleep over it now.

  14. This should be good news, but... by Sheetrock · · Score: 5, Interesting
    I'm not particularly happy living under our current operating system monopoly, but this article only bolsters my concern that we're on the brink of creating a new one.

    Could the adoption of Linux go too quickly and be too widespread?

    I know it seems a bit funny now, as it's still not very useful as a desktop environment and is going head-to-head with arguably better server software, but I think there's a menace lurking beneath the surface: companies may soon get to the point where they -expect- software to be produced for free. It's a bit ironic, I think, that the products of our success at programmers are in the position to undermine our ability to survive in our careers.

    Already, programming jobs are being exported to places where they can be done almost for free. I'm starting to wonder if Linux and other open source projects are choking off what remains of our software economy. Is it too farfetched to think that some restrictions need to be put into place to protect workers?

    --

    Try not. Do or do not, there is no try.
    -- Dr. Spock, stardate 2822-3.




  15. Press Release by $$$$$exyGal · · Score: 4, Funny
    Business - AP World Business

    Microsoft Buys Japan
    Wed Feb 5, 03:53 PM PT

    Microsoft plans to spend about 1 billion dollars (120 billion Yen) funding Japan in its entirety, says Bill Gates, Wednesday.

    Gates' plans on purchasing the country at the end of fiscal 2004, but he's not sure what to do with it. Industry pundits predict that Japan will go the way of WebTV and many other companies/countries purchased by Microsoft.

    "I like Japan", says Gates, "they really are good at science". Later, Gates was seen snickering.

    --naked

    --
    Very popular slashdot journal for adul
    1. Re:Press Release by Tingler · · Score: 4, Funny

      Joke (n)

      Pronunciation: 'jOk
      Function: noun
      Etymology: Latin jocus; perhaps akin to Old High German gehan to say, Sanskrit yAcati he asks
      Date: 1670
      1 a : something said or done to provoke laughter; especially : a brief oral narrative with a climactic humorous twist b (1) : the humorous or ridiculous element in something (2) : an instance of jesting : KIDDING c : PRACTICAL JOKE d : LAUGHINGSTOCK
      2 : something not to be taken seriously : a trifling matter -- often used in negative construction

  16. Re:Math by Rinikusu · · Score: 5, Informative

    That doesn't mean "linux". Open Source Operating System != Linux, folks. IT could be one of the various BSD's or even something like Plan 9.

    Of course, I'm putting my money on "linux", too, but you can never just assume things...

    --
    If you were me, you'd be good lookin'. - six string samurai
  17. Next-Gen? by theCat · · Score: 5, Interesting

    OK, let's think about this a moment. The current generation of networks and servers already hinges largely on Unix and Unix-like things (GNU/Linux). Linux is free, and many point out that Linux is mostly replacing Unix boxen at the moment.

    Ipso facto, GNU/Linux will probably be a big part of the "next-generation" platform, whatever the foosh that actually refers to in practice.

    But I guess what is interesting here is that they are broadcasting this "truth" and not, oh for example, signing up on some zany M$ initiative-of-the-week.

    Someone actually pointed out in an earlier post (since modded into oblivion I can assume) that Asia pirates all their software so la-de-da. Which misses the point that Asia pirating software was always a good thing for the proprietary products. India is so awash in black market copies of Windows that they are practically addicts now, and still M$ gives them buckets of cash "donations" as soon as someone over there mumbles "Linux rulez" in his sleep.

    --
    =^..^= all your rodent are belong to us
  18. I ain't falling for this again ... by RavinDave · · Score: 5, Funny
    "Japan is betting 50 million yen ($450k US) that the next-generation of high-tech products and computer networks will rely on open-source software. ... "

    Last time I read a headline about Japan trying to predict the future computer trends, I tossed out my "C" books and wasted 6 months learning PROLOG.

  19. Next Generation? by PetWolverine · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Japan is betting...that the next-generation of high-tech products and computer networks will rely on open-source software.

    The next generation?

    As far as networks: The Internet is the most important network that I can think of, and what does it run on? Apache is the main Web server; I run a mail server with Qpopper and sendmail, of which the former is open source and the latter is at least free (is it open source? I don't even know); for the FTP part of serving, you can choose from Pure-FTPd, Pro-FTPd, wu-ftpd, or whatever else. "High-tech computer networks" of this generation already run on OSS.

    As for products: There's a little more room for improvement here, but my PowerMac G4 is pretty damned high-tech, and while the GUI is closed, the core OS, Darwin, is open-source. And unlike Linux nerds who will say they have such-and-such a high tech system that's running OSS, mine came like this--right out of the box--and is a product targeted at, and sold mainly to, non-nerd consumers.

    It used to be that I used very little software I paid for because I pirated everything; now I use very little software I paid for because it's free anyway, and for a substantial part of that software the source is available if I want it. Open source isn't a bet pertaining to the next generation, it's here already.

    --
    I found the meaning of life the other day, but I had write-only access.
  20. Japanese Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny
    Microsoft, concerned about Japan's move towards Linux, visits government executives with the hopes of swaying their decision.

    Microsoft Exec: We're a bit worried that you guys are moving away from Windows.

    Japanese president: There is nothing to worry about! We in Japan are all in awe of your large penis!

    Microsoft Exec: What?!

    Japanese president: You see, Japanese penis is so small!

    Japanese vice-president: So small!

    Japanese president: You Americans have such humungous-bungus penis!

    Microsoft Execs: Well... that's true!

    Japanese vice-president: Oh, such, a nice, big penis, American!

    Japanese president: What can we possibly do with such small penis? We cannot take over your operating system with programmers of such masterdonic penis!

    Microsoft Execs: Well, you've got a point there! That settles that! We're sorry for taking your time, gentlemen!

    Japanese president: Oh, no! Thank you! Another chance to be in same room with big American penis!

    Microsoft Execs (leaving): Nice guys!

    ... later ...

    TV announcer: And now, for a special announcement from the President of the United States.

    George Bush: My fellow Americans, I wish to address the concerns many of us have over the growing number of Japanese Linux distributions in America's IT sector. The new Japanese Emperor Linus Hirohito has made our own children into programmers who will soon launch a DDOS attack against American military networks at Pearl Harbour. However, I spoke with Mr. Hirohito this morning and he assured me that I have a very large penis! He said it was dinosauric, and absolutely dwarfed his penis which he assured me was nearly microscopic in size. My penis, he said, was most likely one of the biggest on the planet. I applaud Mr. Hirohito in his honest. Thank you.

  21. Re:Oh boy! $450k! by nsandver-work · · Score: 5, Informative

    It says right in the article (did you read it?) that "Japan plans to spend about 1 billion yen (US$8.3 million) funding Asian software developers working on the open-source Linux operating system for consumer electronics goods, an official said Wednesday." That is a sizable commitment.

    The $450k figure in the article comes from this: " Tokyo has already budgeted 50 million yen (US$416,000) for next fiscal year to study the possibility of switching government computers to an open-source operating system." Note, that's the city of Tokyo, not the Japanese government.

    Read the article.

  22. Re:I don't know about this by kryonD · · Score: 5, Informative

    Do a Google on Akihabara. Or if you're too lazy to do that, just imagine an entire city of computer stores. I was just there three weeks ago and there is MORE THAN ENOUGH sources for legitimate software, both Japanese, or English versions.

    As far as illegal software, there is a great deal of street vendors who pawn that stuff off, but I've seen the same thing in New York. It may be a little bit worse in Japan due to the vast availablilty of high-speed broadband. And no, my use of high-speed and broadband is not redundant. I have a 12MBit ADSL line which usually averages 2.5 MBit, but on sites that can handle it, I've gone as high as 7.5MBit sustained. There are also regions that run 100MBit ethernet straight to your home. I only pay 2800yen (~$25) per month for my ADSL, which makes piracy quite cheap for me if I decided to go down that road to make an illegal yen or two.

    Now, I have also been to Hong Kong, where after 5 days I had still not located a store that was actually selling legitimate copies of software. But there were more places than I could count pawning off the illegal copies.

    --
    I've dirtied my hands writing poetry, for the sake of seduction; that is, for the sake of a useful cause. --Dostoevsky
  23. Just like the days of E-TRON. by torpor · · Score: 4, Informative


    Actually, its not really news that the Japanese government is doing this. They've been doing this for years - trying to get a globally accepted embedded device-control operating system widely adopted among the industry.

    There used to be a project, headed up by one of Japans most respected computer scientists, called TRON.

    This was pre-Hollywood "TRON" movie, which actually had some basis in its script and 'ideology' on the Japanese ideals put forth by the TRON project; which were, simply, to create a global networked computer 'system', accessible throughout the world, out of the embedded OS in consumer devices. In other words, put chips *everywhere* and have them all function as part of a global computer system.

    I guess the end result would be so that the phrase "imagine a Beowulf of that!" could be applied to *anything*, in actual fact there would be nothing *but* Beowulf clusters of everything, and its name would be "TRON".

    TRON was a project to try and define this OS and how these devices would communicate with each other - in 1978!!

    (It may also be referred to as the "E-TRON" project, I seem to remember there being some move to change the name at one point...)

    Anyway, just wanted to point out that the move of the Japanese government to promote OSS is probably based on an even older ethos among the Japanese techno/industrial zaibatsu's...

    --
    ; -- the corruption of government starts with its secrets. a truly free people keep no secrets. --