Slashdot Mirror


OSDL Releases Q&A on SCO Legal Actions

craigoda writes "OSDL released a Q&A today written by Lawrence Rosen, noted expert on technology and intellectual property law. The Q&A points to serious flaws in SCO's claims that end-users have to pay for Linux licenses." The press release is a little more diplomatic, saying that the document only helps one determine whether or not one should buy a license from SCO.

34 of 285 comments (clear)

  1. Document summary by mhesseltine · · Score: 5, Funny

    Q: Should I buy a license from SCO?

    A: No

    --
    Overrated / Underrated : Moderation :: Anonymous Coward : Posting
    1. Re:Document summary by ePhil_One · · Score: 2, Funny
      Q: Should I buy a license from SCO?

      A: No

      But what if I were trying to protect my monopoly on x86 operating systems?

      --
      You are in a maze of twisted little posts, all alike.
    2. Re:Document summary by mhesseltine · · Score: 4, Funny
      But what if I were trying to protect my monopoly on x86 operating systems?

      Well then, Mr. Gates, go ahead and purchase as many licenses as you see fit.

      --
      Overrated / Underrated : Moderation :: Anonymous Coward : Posting
    3. Re:Document summary by interiot · · Score: 2, Funny
      • what does this have to do with SCO declaring the GPL invalid? What the HELL does it have to do with their lawsuit against IBM. I do not understand.
      But ladies and gentlemen this is Chewbacca. Now think about that for one minute. That does not make sense. Why am I talking about Chewbacca when a man's life is on the line? Why? I'll tell you why. I don't know. It doesn't make sense. If Chewbacca does not make sense you must acquit.
    4. Re:Document summary by TheFrood · · Score: 4, Funny
      Q: Should I buy a license from SCO?

      A: No.

      Q: But what if...

      A: No.

      Q: Okay, but suppose...

      A: Even then, no.

      TheFrood
      --
      If you say "I'll probably get modded down for this..." then I will mod you down.
  2. SCO by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    SCO, wow, I haven't heard about them for a long time! I was starting to wonder what happened to them.

    Good Job Slashdot!

  3. They didn't answer the real questions by rf0 · · Score: 3, Funny

    How far up is SCO's head up their own ass?

    - Normal service is now resumed -

    Rus

    1. Re:They didn't answer the real questions by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      How far up is SCO's head up their own ass?

      Far enough to recieve legal advice from yesterday's dinner.

  4. Ugly site by Robawesome · · Score: 2, Funny

    Did anyone else notice that the Q&A site was poorly formatted and ugly-colored?



    "SCO purports to be a respecter of intellectual property- but in fact at this time is violating no less than four IBM patents" -IBM counterclaim

    --

    I did NOT learn everything I need to know in kindergarten.

  5. So... by grasshoppa · · Score: 5, Funny

    ..they are saying what we already knew: "SCO is full of shit".

    Wouldn't that be great if a big time lawer for IBM called a huge press conference to say just that?

    "Thank you all for coming today. We would like to say, in response to SCO's most recent *finger quotes* allegations, that SCO is full of shit. Thank you all for coming."

    --
    Mod me down with all of your hatred and your journey towards the dark side will be complete!
    1. Re:So... by Shivetya · · Score: 3, Funny

      I still prefered the summarized version of the 46 page counter suit.... (someone posted on that thread)

      ARMONK, NY - Aug. 8, 2003 -- "Dodge this."

      --
      * Winners compare their achievements to their goals, losers compare theirs to that of others.
  6. Paranoia by Faust7 · · Score: 4, Funny

    a Q&A paper written by noted technology law and intellectual property expert Lawrence Rosen

    Boy, that gave me a nasty start.

    1. Re:Paranoia by be-fan · · Score: 3, Funny

      Who is Lawrence Rosen? The love-child of Lawrence Lessig and Hillary Rosen.

      That sound you just heard was the heads of every single slashdotter simultaniously exploding...

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
  7. PDF v.s. HTML by thenextpresident · · Score: 5, Funny

    Let's see, they offer a PDF version and an HTML version. Hrm? I know! This is Slashdot, and we have to try and bring them down. Rather than link to the HTML version, let's link to the PDF version. I mean seriously, HTML is so not the prefered format for reading things on web sites.

    --
    Jason Lotito
  8. SCO? by Biomechanoid · · Score: 5, Funny

    SCO? Whats a SCO? Is that Danish? I noticed a couple of other people talk about a SCO also on slashdot.

    1. Re:SCO? by molarmass192 · · Score: 2, Funny

      I think it's an abbreviation for SCOW which is a Dutch (not Danish) word for the common trash barge. In slang I think it would be referred to as "a floating pile of sh*t".

      --

      Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws-Plato
    2. Re:SCO? by Xeth · · Score: 2, Funny

      I know! I feel so betrayed, the slashdot editors have failed badly in their attempts to bring news of this "SCO" pastry to their loyal readerships. Perhaps if they had posted stories now and again...

      --
      If your theory is different from practice, then your theory is wrong.
  9. Call to linux developers by ciroknight · · Score: 3, Funny

    I know this is a difficult request.. but could someone PLEASE start a project to replace what ever code SCO claims to have copyright over? And start NOW instead of after SCO wins or loses? This way half way through the case, SCO will lose plainly because they couldn't even claim they had hold in the kernel at all....

    This is made difficult by the fact that SCO refuses to tell anyone what code actually is "theirs" in the kernel, other than it has to deal with computers with more than one processor.. I'm just getting sick and tired of hearing SCO's lawyers and execs and everyone else flaming because they can't figure out who really owns the code.... It's disgusting really. Please help :-)

    --
    "Victory means exit strategy, and it's important for the President to explain to us what the exit strategy is." G.W.Bush
    1. Re:Call to linux developers by plierhead · · Score: 5, Funny
      could someone PLEASE start a project to replace what ever code SCO claims to have copyright over ?

      Actually I claim ownership over the whole of linux myself - I wrote most of it in my spare time using notepad on the computer here in my cube at Walmart's admin offices. Oh yeah, and some of it I wrote on my palm pilot on the bus on the way to work..

      Why are you panicking? Life is full of people who act like bullies. Usually they get whats coming to them. The key here is to draw SCO so far into this that they overstretch themselves, go belly up and take their shareholders down with them.

      --

      [x] auto-moderate all posts by this user as insightful

  10. Too bad he's stuck creating document in windows by adamshelley · · Score: 1, Funny

    PDF Producer: Acrobat PDFWriter 5.0 for Windows NT. :(

  11. Outstanding achievement by Timesprout · · Score: 5, Funny

    He points out that SCO has a long long shaft up its ass

    Finally legalese I can understand

    --
    Do not try to read the dupe, thats impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth
    What truth?
    There is no dupe
  12. The Current SCO Situation...via the medium of song by Gourou · · Score: 5, Funny

    The Current SCO Situation...via the medium of song

    Please mirror and spread if you agree with the sentiment (if not the singing :-)

    The Asshat Song [2.73MB MP3]

    To the tune of You're So Vain by Carly Simon ;-)

  13. Anagrams of "Santa Cruz Operation" (SCO) by Alien+Being · · Score: 2, Funny

    sue a corp, anoint tzar
    ran crap zoo, sue titan
    i can root azure pants
    rapacious, not zen art
    can't earn it, zap our os
    ip rat unto an os craze

    - a post one czar in a rut

  14. An Allegory: The SCO Poker Game by Gourou · · Score: 5, Funny

    It's a saloon in the wild west.
    There's a poker game on. Texas Hold 'Em.
    There's five cards on the table.
    The first player is from Utah.

    He says "I got Ace High. I win the hand."
    The second player. They call him the Finn.
    He's got lots of friends, says "Show me your cards then."
    Utah says "No, just hand over your cash. You don't need to see my cards."

    Then the third player, Bluebeard pipes up: "Well I got a flush. So I beat ya anyway."
    Utah says "Show me *your* cards then."
    Bluebeard replies "Nope. I'm gonna wait to see your lame ass ace."
    Utah smiles nervously "Did I say ace high? I meant four aces. Yeah. Four aces."

    Now the silent fourth player, Berkeley pipes up
    "Well I got a Royal Flush and I've had it since the flop."
    But Utah has turned to Joe at the bar and says
    "Well, you owe me $32 for this game."
    Joe looks puzzled "But I ain't even playing the game."

    Utah gets a mean look now and starts sweating.
    He pulls his guns and shouts "Look, just give me your money now. No questions. I MEAN IT!"
    Suddenly Utah is surround by a whole boatload of guns.

    There's Joe Public, he has no guns, but good fists,
    Linus the Finn and his friends have guns, but they rarely use them,
    they're rumoured to be really quick on the draw.
    Berkeley is calmest of all, he's won a gunfight just like this one already.

    Finally Utah turns to Bluebeard. He has a shotgun.
    Bluebeard smiles, and pulls the trigger.
    And that's the legend of how old SCO died.

  15. SCO's bulletproof action plan: by rice_burners_suck · · Score: 5, Funny
    For immediate release:

    Scam Con & Overcharge (NAZDAC: SCO) today announced a barrage of new lawsuits against users of pornography processing software called Linux. A proprietary IBM product, Linux allegedly violates SCO intellectual property. This new development comes on the heels of another SCO lawsuit against God for denying immortality to SCO CEO Darl McBurglary.

    "Women and young children are viewing cartoon images of NAKED penguins!" shouted McBurglary, throwing his coffee mug across the room during an interview. "It's disgusting! And besides, it contains OUR intellectual property! It's a conspiracy! And everybody's in on it!!!"

    When asked which SCO intellectual property was found in Linux, McBurglary commented, "IBM invented, developed, trademarked, copyrighted and patented certain technologies. Therefore, they are infringing on OUR intellectual property rights!"

    SCO spokespersons refused to specify what constitutes the allegedly infringing properties. McBurglary had to be escorted back to his home at the looney bin by two big black guys in pinstriped suits. "Die, fucker, die!!" he yelled at some child walking down the street with a stuffed penguin doll. (I know we're only joking, but with SCO, it could happen!)

  16. Boycott my ass by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
    And then why don't we all gather as well in our mohair jackets, smile lovingly at each other and reaffirm our own reasons for being here, and then chant gently up to the moon, so that the SCO execs feel our dissaproving vibes wafting in on the night breeze through their windows ?

    Get real Dick. What counts is the courts, not your lefty petition. Don't get yourself worked up, SCO would laugh in your face even if you got a million supporters. They are in it for the money.

  17. OSDL Attorney Declares SCO Invalid by cnb · · Score: 5, Funny

    ... would have made a nice headline coming
    right after "SCO attorney declares GPL invalid"

  18. I hereby nominate by pair-a-noyd · · Score: 4, Funny

    the goatse "person" to replace the /. SCO logo. Tubgirl is first runnerup.

  19. Re:Same old Same old by Thumb-One · · Score: 5, Funny

    Of course, were I a SCO insider that also read Slashdot, when the inevitable investigations came, I would have a response ready:

    "It wasn't insider trading! I sold because it was common knowledge that we were fscked; hell, I read it on Slashdot fuhchrissakes."

    --
    This is only a test Sig. If this were a real Sig, it would be witty, pithy, or rude, just like all the other Sigs.
  20. Anyone notice this?? by pair-a-noyd · · Score: 2, Funny

    On the bottom of the CBS market watch page a few
    interesting links?? (see below)

    Coincidence??? Or prophecy?????

    Sponsored Matches
    (What are Sponsor Matches?)

    Avoid Bankruptcy - Learn to Manage Your Money! Free Credit Counseling Services & More

    Bankruptcy Alternative - Savings to 70% on Credit Card Debt on $20,000 up: Call 866-7xx-xxxx

    "I Filed Bankruptcy" - Read my story and see what it is really like before you file

  21. Finished the DRDOS lawsuit, need something to do? by Peter+Greenwood · · Score: 2, Funny

    Caldera (back when SCO were called that) bought Digital Research, apparently just to get the right to sue MS over DRDOS.

    3 months ago this was wound up. I suppose SCO's lawyers need to keep looking busy. Or maybe there's something more sinister going on, since this is Slashdot?

    --
    freedom, n. Allowing people you don't like to do things you disapprove of.
  22. Re:What if I do not use SCO code? by plugger · · Score: 3, Funny

    I just went to their piracy reporting form. I thought they would be interested to hear about a company which is distributing GPL code combined with code which said company claim to be proprietry, in violation of the GPL. I hope they take this as seriously as any other 'piracy' that is brought to their attention.

  23. SCO-Linux EZ registration kit! by pair-a-noyd · · Score: 4, Funny

    Due to all the confusion about licensing and registration of your Linux package,
    we good folks at Blackbag Opz have completed work on an all new registration kit for the confused.

    Just run *this* easy to use SCO Registration Kit,
    fill in the blanks, check "Number of Cycles, Infinite" and press the SEND button.

    Sit back and wait while your SCO-Linux EZ registration kit does the hard work for you!

    And sleep well tonight knowing that SCO got your message!

  24. One things for sure by maroberts · · Score: 2, Funny

    ..anyone claiming long Linux uptimes in the Eastern US is almost certainly a liar or a survivalist!! :-)

    --

    Donte Alistair Anderson Roberts - hi son!
    Karma: Chameleon