Slashdot Mirror


Scientists Crack Silk's Secret

AEton writes "Researchers at Tufts University have reportedly discovered the mechanism by which spidersilk is produced. Besides the obvious use as a Kevlar substitute in bulletproof vests, silk has applications in microprocessor production, nanoscale optical fiber, a and any other application requiring strength and flexbility. Scientists have long grappled with the issue of creating silk; artificial silk is inferior to the real stuff, and the spiders can't be farmed (when you put them too close together, they eat each other). The method these Tufts researchers have found makes "strong silk" production feasible; if they can make it economical, the impact on safety equipment alone makes this material a worthwhile investment."

31 of 408 comments (clear)

  1. A changing world... by mgcsinc · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Scientists develop $5 artificial diamonds and scientists develop economically produced artificial silk; I'd say its been a pretty good time for those who had kept their hopes up for alchemy after the 18th century turned out unfruitful... How long until workers in industries "ruined" by scientific development (though only ever valued for the rareness of their product) develop a cult-like anti-scientific religion and take over the world?

    1. Re:A changing world... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      I can't wait til they "ruin" the automobile market with artifically manufactored BMW 745 LIs for $20 bucks. I'm gonna be pimpin.

    2. Re:A changing world... by NotAnotherReboot · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Perhaps the part about changing materials that are next to worthless into something valuable is what you mean by alchemy, but none of this is anything like alchemy. Atoms are not being transformed into the "diamond atom" from the carbon atom, it is still carbon, just in a different form.

      Obviously, the diamond industry has reason to worry if the fakes are indistinguishable, but I'm not sure what you're talking about a "cult-like anti-scientific religion," that is just silly.

      There is nothing wrong with economical silk- after all, how big is the industry, and are the people in it that well off right now? Silk is something with actual applications (diamonds do as well, but not as many). Science marches on and puts people out of work, but at the end of the day, they find another line of work and everyone is better off. The standard of living in the developed world has steadily increased- and most of it is because of science.

      Spare me of the doomsday theories.

    3. Re:A changing world... by kd5ujz · · Score: 4, Informative

      There is a company, I believe its called gemisis, that is creating diamonds using a laser induced plasma cloud. The diamonds were taken to am inspection lab, and the only way the techs could discern them from natural diamonds was that the artificial ones were too perfect. Diamonds generated by heat and pressure in a lab have more flaws then natural, but the plasma diamonds had too little flaws. I suppose you could dope the chamber with a few minerals and come out with a diamond that was very damn hard to detect. You can read all about it in the latest Wired magazine.

      --
      -William
      God is everything science has yet to explain.
  2. Aaww by Rosco+P.+Coltrane · · Score: 4, Funny

    the spiders can't be farmed (when you put them too close together, they eat each other)

    Why can't everybody be nice to each other ?? :-(

    --
    "A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
  3. Eh? by rde · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Well, I've read the article. I've read Scientific American's version. I've read a few other ones google referenced. And I still haven't a fucking clue why silk is so strong.

    Am I getting dumber, or are these science article getting more opaque?

    "becuase of proteins with various properties" me arse.

    1. Re:Eh? by pajamacore · · Score: 5, Informative

      Searching ScAm's Ask the Expert section, I found the following:

      "Dragline silk [a kind of silk all spiders make] is a composite material comprised of two different proteins, each containing three types of regions with distinct properties. One of these forms an amorphous (noncrystalline) matrix that is stretchable, giving the silk elasticity. When an insect strikes the web, the stretching of the matrix enables the web to absorb the kinetic energy of the insects flight. Embedded in the amorphous portions of both proteins are two kinds of crystalline regions that toughen the silk. Although both kinds of crystalline regions are tightly pleated and resist stretching, one of them is rigid. It is thought that the pleats of the less rigid crystalline regions not only fit into the pleats in the rigid crystals but that they also interact with the amorphous areas in the proteins, thus anchoring the rigid crystals to the matrix. The resulting composite is strong, tough, and yet elastic."

    2. Re:Eh? by i+am+fishhead · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Well, strong but flexable silk gives the spiders that spin it a pretty good reproductive advantage over those that don't. Over time, natural selection will favor those spiders with strong but thin (and, as such, difficult to see) webs. It's not too suprising that scientists are no match for millions of years of evolution.

    3. Re:Eh? by danila · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I am really disturbed by the tendency of people to proclaim "scientists are no match for millions of years of evolution" after scientists understand (somewhat) another mystery. Look, this achievement is the first step after a long preparatory work. Now for the first time scientists really understand what is going on. Yes, they still don't know some aspects of the process, but they are just getting started. The area of bionics is booming. Just recently we could read in the news that engineers are building submarines that swim without propellers - by moving the "tail" instead. Yes, their crude attempts are no match for a dolphin, but give them time. We have supersonic aicrafts, we have spaceships, we can dig more than 10km deep into the Earth, we can move from the ocean surface into the Mariana trench in the same craft, we can build moving objects weighting million tons! Can the nature do that? Did the evolution do that? The answer is a resounding no!

      So wait a few years (at most a decade) and artificial spider silk will be stronger than natural. After a decade more we will have not only stronger, but ligher, more flexible, cheaper and overall better threads than any spider will ever have. Evolution is too slow and we gave it a huge start - billions of years. And we are gaining on it now.

      --
      Future Wiki -- If you don't think about the future, you cannot have one.
    4. Re:Eh? by mrgeometry · · Score: 4, Interesting

      but the elasticity comes from the sticky quality right? is it possible to retain the elastic quality without it being sticky?

      Good question, but as there are lots of elastic yet non-sticky things out there, I would think that it should be possible to make non-sticky clothing out of this stuff.

      Maybe the spiders can decide whether or not to add an extra "stickiness" protein to the silk as they extrude it, so they can make non-sticky support strands for their webs. That way they could walk around without getting themselves stuck---or maybe they have some weird foot-based non-stick thing.

      Also, is silk from silkworms sticky?

      OK, I don't know any of the answers, so those are just a few thoughts on the topic.

      Just imagine, if every super-bouncy ball were also super-sticky... :-)

  4. Weapon against crime? by hahn · · Score: 4, Funny

    So does this mean we're going to start arming the cops with spidersilk so they can assist Spiderman in his pursuit of justice? Cool!

    --
    "The only normal people are the ones you don't know very well."
  5. DMCA by kamakot · · Score: 4, Funny

    Let's just hope the spiders don't use the DMCA against the scientists.

  6. Spider farming by cybermace5 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Do you honestly think anyone EVER seriously considered farming spiders for their silk? The idea of unimaginable numbers of spiders all together is chilling even to the bravest of us. And of course they'd discover that black widows or brown recluses or giant bird spiders produced the strongest silk, and then they would escape....
    *shudder*

    --
    ...
    1. Re:Spider Farming by slackingme · · Score: 4, Funny
      I can see it now...
      "Cage #10000000, check."
      "Cage #10000001, check."
      "Cage #10000002, check."
      "Cage #10000003..."
      "Oh, shit! The spider in cage #10000003 is missing! Lock down the system! Call the national guard! Help! Help!"

      Lots of spiders, lots of little cages, very little practicality :) Even the egg industry packs multiple chickens to a cage (despite adverse consequences) and they're a lot bigger than these guys.

    2. Re:Spider farming by Daniel+Dvorkin · · Score: 4, Interesting

      AFAIK, there have been several attempts to farm spiders, actually. Sure, spiders are creepy and potentially dangerous, but that's not why the attempts failed. (Having once been caught in the middle of an honest-to-God cattle stampede, I can tell you that a bunch of cows are scarier than a bunch of spiders any day of the week -- which, obviously, doesn't keep us from raising the critters.) The problem is that spiders are just stubborn; they spin webs pretty much only when they feel like it. Silkworms, OTOH, will turn out silk all day if you keep them fed.

      Again, this is all AFAIK, based on stuff I heard a long time ago.

      --
      The correlation between ignorance of statistics and using "correlation is not causation" as an argument is close to 1.
    3. Re:Spider farming by Tsu+Dho+Nimh · · Score: 5, Informative
      Welcome to your nightmare, come true. Spiders WERE farmed by Zeiss, Bausch & Lomb and others, and black widows had the best silk
      http://us.expasy.org/spotlight/articles/sptlt024 .html
      "Spider silk is 40 times finer than human hair and right up to World War II, it was used for crosshairs in optical devices such as microscopes, guns and bomb-guiding systems. In fact, though crosshairs are now etched or made with metal filaments, some military facilities still keep a domesticated black widow spider as a silk provision for old instruments. To this day, Australian aborigines use the silk of a giant spider for fishing lines."

      Knowing how to collect Black Widow silk is essential if you are repairing and restoring old microscopes and other optical equipment. They are not aggressive, and live a long time, and are content in a very small container.

    4. Re:Spider farming by Tsu+Dho+Nimh · · Score: 4, Interesting
      uh ... very carefully, of course :)

      They aren't really "domesticated", just captured in the wild and kept in a container, such as a terrarium. A couple of crickets a week keeps them fed. There is one spider farm locally, collecting venom for research and anti-venin production. They use plastic refrigerator containers, and have well-sealed buildings. They have a small group of collectors - instead of raising the spiders, they buy mature females as needed.

      I have an old microscope repair manual that explained how one gets the silk from the spider ... if I recall you put the spider in a rather large container, with a tiny shelter at the top. They will run a long strand from the shelter down to the bottom of the container and make their messy trap web there, of sticky strands. You harvest the long strand on a loop of wire and then lay the strand onto the glass reticule, usin gan alignment jig. It's sticky enough to cling to the glass.

  7. Different silks? by hahn · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This brings up an interesting question. Does anyone know what the difference is in properties between the silkworm's silk and the spider's silk?

    --
    "The only normal people are the ones you don't know very well."
  8. One unfortuate side effect... by One+Louder · · Score: 4, Funny

    However, you can't have too many silk researchers working on the project - when you put them too close together, they eat each other.

  9. Finally! by slackingme · · Score: 5, Funny

    Yes, finally! We can start producing super-strong silk boxers to protect all us sexy geeks from the swarms of girls outside our rooms. Personally, I'm all for reducing user latency in the kernel and reading the latest rant by RMS, but *indestructable silk boxers* get me really excited. I'm blowing through several pairs a week when I leave the dark, secluded safety of my room to get more gin and tonic at the store. I certainly can't make the swarm go away, but this takes care of a symptom!

  10. Spider Farming by SuperBanana · · Score: 4, Funny
    Scientists have long grappled with the issue of creating silk; artificial silk is inferior to the real stuff, and the spiders can't be farmed (when you put them too close together, they eat each other)

    I don't suppose it occured to any of these rocket scientists to put the spiders in seperate cages.

    ...or better yet, genetically modify the spiders to be nice! Perfect plot for a B-grade movie with LL Cool J; the spiders are only PRETENDING to be nice! Mwuahahahaha...

  11. Sacrifice a spider-silk goat by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny
    How long until workers in industries "ruined" by scientific development ... develop a cult-like anti-scientific religion and take over the world?

    I imagine a bizarre cult of disgruntled former Kevlar workers sacrificing one of the spider-silk goats.

    What ever happened with the spider-silk goat and cow experiments anyway? Or is that how they got enough material for the current breakthrough?

    Hey! HEY! Stop that! No goatse links!

  12. Another Application by tunabomber · · Score: 5, Interesting

    You don't suppose this stuff could be strong enough to make a space elevator, could it?

    --

    pi = 3.141592653589793helpimtrappedinauniversefactory71 ...
  13. Farming Spiders by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    "the spiders can't be farmed (when you put them too close together, they eat each other)."

    hey, not so fast. :)

    check out this cbc article and click through to the photo gallery to get really creeped out.

    that's one whole lotta silk. i'd still like to know who/what they ate to do that. and i'd really, really like to know what biochem outfit owns land nearby.

  14. spider silk is _not_ the same as SiLK by sarpedon77 · · Score: 5, Informative

    SiLK which is used for microprocessor applications is not connected in any way to spider silk. The former is an acronymn for a resin
    (aromatic hydrocarbon) made by Dow Chemicals and used by IBM and other chip companies as an insulator between the multiple layers of wires on a chip. Silicon Low-K = SiLK

  15. Excerpts from SCO press release on the subject by Trailer+Trash · · Score: 4, Funny

    "It's obvious that they couldn't have discovered the secret to making silk that quickly without access to SCO's intellectual property," said Darl McBride, SCO's president. He continued, "In 1999, they were making some silk, but it was low quality. Then, suddenly, over the course of a year or so, their silk became enterprise quality. Stuff that took other people 30 years took them months."

    In a move considered to be brilliant in the business world, SCO bought the patents on silk production from God in 2000 for an undisclosed sum. "We've been looking to leverage those patents ever since" said McBride.

    Right now, SCO isn't planning on suing individual spiders, although they won't rule out the possibility. "We've considering going after some of the nuisance species, such as brown recluses and black widows, first," said Chris Sontag. "We've been warned by our attorneys that doing such would expose us to the possibilities of bites and nasty wounds, so it's really something we don't want to do right now."

    Eric Raymond, president of the Open Silk Initiative, says that God lost protection on His silk production techniques by creating so many different species that use the intellectual property and not entering into any official licensing agreement with them. "It's a little late to be worrying about that now", said Raymond. A 1993 lawsuit regarding silk production methods also cast doubt on the validity of the patents.

    Meanwhile, some spiders have openly questioned Raymonds repeated assertions that he represents them or their opinions in these matters.

  16. Forget the bullet-proof vests! by Tsu+Dho+Nimh · · Score: 4, Funny

    I want run-proof stockings and sexy lingerie out of this stuff.

  17. What about the goat milk spider silk? by cyberwench · · Score: 4, Interesting
    A Quebec company, Nexia, has genetically engineered goats to produce spider silk within their milk. (Apparently, the way mammary glands work and the way a spider's silk glands work are remarkably similar.) I know that they've been able to pass the genes on to offspring, and they are getting silk from the milk now. I think it is supposed to be as strong as dragline silk, which is the strongest type of spider silk.


    I understand from the article that they've figured out how strong silk is actually produced, which should give them a heads-up on making a mechanical/chemical process to do all this artificially. It should be pointed out, though, that there are already means for production of non-artificial spider silk currently, which the article seems to have missed.

    --
    ~ Leilah
  18. It's not the same thing, though. by cyberwench · · Score: 4, Insightful

    There isn't currently a spider-silk industry. There's a silk industry, but from what I understand the whole point of spider silk as opposed to silkworm silk (which is at least relatively easily harvested), is that spiders have stronger silk with many more applications. So realistically, what we have here is not one industry "ruining" another, it's an entirely new industry that's being added. It's not like the spiders are going to get upset about us taking over their industry.

    On the topic of displaced workers though - there's always going to be a demand for "the real thing". While artificially produced diamonds may be exactly the same as naturally formed ones, for many people they are two entirely different things. It's all a question of perception. As long as people view the two things differently, there will always be a market for the rarer and consequently more expensive natural diamonds.

    --
    ~ Leilah
    1. Re:It's not the same thing, though. by TTK+Ciar · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I have to agree.

      There is already a material being produced which is superior to spiders' silk in every way -- stronger, lighter, higher elongation-to-break, and easier to mass produce. It is called ultra-high molecular weight high-density polyethylene. Spectra is one form of the stuff; Dyneema is a superior form.

      UM-HDPE is basically the same stuff that garbage bags are made of ("ordinary" HDPE), but the polyethylene chains in it are several tens of thousands of times longer. This was made possible by the discovery of a new process by which to build the PE chains, using a new catalyst (and lots and lots of MAO, which always cracks me up).

      UM-HDPE production has been ramping up slowly over the past several years. In time, we should expect it to be fairly commonplace and inexpensive (Dyneema is currently extremely pricey stuff, due to limited production). So cracking the silk "code" is nothing to get riled up about, at least not from a material engineer's perspective. It's a johnny-come-latey. I seriously doubt its production could be ramped up any faster than Dyneema's, and Dyneema has a huge head start.

      -- TTK

  19. Re:Bulletproof vest? by panurge · · Score: 5, Insightful
    You don't. It's the ceramic plates that stop the bullets. The Kevlar is there to hold the thing together.

    And, given the time that life has had to develop, it is far from amazing that "natural" materials can be strong. Life is a bit like an arms race that has been going on for over a billion years. The development of advanced materials by human beings using brainpower and technology is just an extension of the normal mechanisms of evolution.

    Wood (for instance) is chemically and structurally similar to many advanced composite plastics, and the strongest woods are as strong as structural plastics. It just shows that there is a clever way of making strong, resilient materials and that you can do this by natural selection of biochemistry or you can do it by technology. It's interesting, but not amazing.

    --
    Panurge has posted for the last time. Thanks for the positive moderations.