Slashdot Mirror


The Ten Most Overpaid Jobs In The U.S.

misbach writes "Here is what the 'compensation experts' have to say are the ten most overpaid jobs [original article at CBS MarketWatch]. 'Almost no one in America would admit to being overpaid, but many of us take home bloated paychecks far beyond what's deserved. 'Fair compensation' is a relative term, yet human-resource consultants and executive headhunters agree some jobs command excessive compensation that can't be explained by labor supply-and-demand imbalances.'"

37 of 1,130 comments (clear)

  1. I don;t know about 9 by grub · · Score: 3, Insightful


    I have to think about 9) Pilots for major airlines. If the plane hits inclement weather or other serious issues arise do you really care if the people behind the cockpit doors are making ~250K a year?

    Oh and 2) Washed-up pro athletes in long-term contracts? Crap. All major sports athletes are overpaid primadonnas. Paying them millions because they can throw a ball only fuels consumerism. "Did you watch the game on Sunday? Wow!" mindless sheep..

    --
    Trolling is a art,
    1. Re:I don;t know about 9 by geekoid · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Athletes is about supply and demand. There are very few people who can supply an acurate, repeatable 50 yeard pass(or whatever) while 3 or 4 300 pound guys moving as fast as an elk bear down on them.
      The company that owns the team makes money from that, and the athlete gets a percentage.

      pretty simple actually.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    2. Re:I don;t know about 9 by Thud457 · · Score: 3, Insightful
      "2) Washed-up pro athletes in long-term contracts? Crap. All major sports athletes are overpaid primadonnas. Paying them millions because they can throw a ball only fuels consumerism. "Did you watch the game on Sunday? Wow!" mindless sheep.."

      Actually, this is driven by advertising.
      Sports bring in viewers. Star athletes sell stuff people. Advertising corrupts anything it touches. (Just look at professional baseball or pop music for prime examples.)

      --

      the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff

    3. Re:I don;t know about 9 by antis0c · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I agree. A major airline pilot holds the lives of a lot of people in their hands. I wouldn't mind if they got paid twice that as long as they were well trained and happy.

      Last thing I want is a depressed pilot worrying about bills when the left engine fails. Last thing I want to enter his mind is "fuck it" when that happens.

      --

      ..There's a-dooin's a-transpirin'
    4. Re:I don;t know about 9 by transient · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Another thing to consider with airline pilots is the huge investment they have to make for initial training. And if you look at salaries for any pilot who isn't working for a major airline, you will begin to understand the sacrifices that have to be made to make it to the majors.

      --

      irb(main):001:0>
    5. Re:I don;t know about 9 by gaijin99 · · Score: 5, Insightful
      I'm inclined to agree with you. Airline pilots are highly skilled, and do work where a single screw up can kill people... $250,000/year puts them into the upper 1% of Americans (according to the US census). I'd argue that they're some of the few people in that income bracket who actually do work worthy of that much money.

      What staggered me about the list was that CEO's as a body weren't included. Yes, the CEO's of underperforming companies are horribly overpaid, but you can't tell me that Michael Eisner actually did work equal in value to $700 *million*. Honestly, I rather doubt that its possible for anyone to do work worth 700 million... Eisner is on the high side, but all corporate executives tend to earn well beyond what they are worth.

      You want to know why were in a recession? Its simple, really. The people earning that money don't spend it. Not because they're malicious, but because you *can't* spend $700M, not unless you're buying solid gold toilets every day, or something equally silly. Since the money doesn't get spent, it simply vanishes from the economy. The truth is that trickle down would work, if the upper 1% spent all (or even most) of their money. Since they can't, trickle down is doomed to fail, as is the economy unless money starts flowing *out* of Eisner et al, and into the general economy...

      --
      "Mission Accomplished" -- George W. Bush May 1, 2003
    6. Re:I don;t know about 9 by 0x20 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Oh, I don't know, charge $3 for tickets and $1 for cokes, and let the idiots on the field make as much as schoolteachers or cops? Sounds fair to me.

    7. Re:I don;t know about 9 by PPGMD · · Score: 5, Insightful
      9) Pilots for major airlines. If the plane hits inclement weather or other serious issues arise do you really care if the people behind the cockpit doors are making ~250K a year?

      Too bad the 250K a year is a myth, only the most senior pilots at the major airlines make that much money. The average co-pilot for the majors makes about $30k, while an average line pilot makes $45-55K.

      The commuters such as ASA, and Comair start their co-pilots at $18.5K, and their average pilost make about $30-40K, with the most senior making close the 6 figure.

      Note that this is after a pilot invests nearly $50K geting a Bachlors degree, and another $50-60K in flight training. Also the pilots generally spend 2-3 years making just better than McJob wages, doing flight training themselves or other jobs.

      Corporate pilots don't get as high pay wise, but they can move up more quickily to their highest pay scale if they are good.

      /karma whoring consultant that was once a broke pilot.

    8. Re:I don;t know about 9 by grasshoppa · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Where do you expect the money to go? I really enjoy watching football.

      That's fine, but how much is it worth to you? What would you say the average ticket costs?

      he feats of athleticism and dedication required to play at the level of NFL players is just amazing.

      You'd get more enjoyment out of going outside and doing it yourself, trust me on this one.

      So, I'm willing to pay money to watch their games. I'm willing to sit through commercials, and the advertising are more than willing to pay to for my attention. So, who should get all that money? I mean, it's pouring in. Lot of people are paying it. Where does it go?

      This is a truely fucked up country where people can honestly and with a straight face ask this question.

      Try: Homeless. Education. Security. And these are just off the top of my head.

      I, for one, would MUCH rather have it go to the players, the guys out there on the field, who've spent their lives training for this, and who risk serious injury every Sunday for my entertainment, than have it line the already cushy pockets of the team owner.

      I would like to see them paided enough to live on and have BITCHING medical. That's fair I think, for playing A CHILDS GAME FOR A LIVING. And they should consider themselves lucky they get that much.

      Supply and demand at its finest.

      And morality at it's worse.

      --
      Mod me down with all of your hatred and your journey towards the dark side will be complete!
    9. Re:I don;t know about 9 by GeekZilla · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Huge investment? Next time you see a commercial airline pilot, ask him where he/she got their training and you will find that a majority of them will say either the Air Force or the Navy. Cost to former military pilot for training: Almost $0.00.
      Yes, there is additional training required to go from flying an F-14 to a 747, but some of these pilots have been flying modified 737's (Air Force) all their careers anyway. And it's not like becoming a doctor-which IS a much bigger investment in time and money than training to become a commercial airline pilot after being trained in the military.

      --
      Veritas patesco per quaestio questio. Truth is revealed through questions.
    10. Re:I don;t know about 9 by anubi · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Airline pilots are the sole ones on the given list that I think justifiably earn the compensation given.

      There is a helluva lot of training and responsibility to running the aircraft, to be there, and do whatever has to be done in the event of ANY malfunction, no matter what. Sure, I can see its all automated. I'll betcha they could take a whole planeload of passengers from one airport to another by remote control without a pilot at all in the plane.

      Now, try it if the plane has major malfunctions midflight.. say part of the fuselage gets caught up in the slipstream, the hydraulics jam, some kook gets onboard and causes sabotage. Now, without a knowledgeable individual onboard who knows how to handle any emergency, what's the chance of getting back to earth alive?

      On top of that, I consider these guys face a major health problem, by the nature of their job which requires MUCH sitting. Sitting through training. Sitting in the cockpit. All this sitting... guess what happens to the old cardiovascular system? The blood will start pooling in the legs. The heart is not a suction pump. It won't pull the blood up. You HAVE to walk around in order to get the blood back up, by way of contractions of the calf and thigh muscles, to squeeze the blood back up. The eventual end to this is a condition like phlebitis, where blood pools in the legs, forms clots, which eventually break loose, shooting up the leg venuous system, up to the heart, over to the lung, where they become trapped forming a pulmonary embolism. Not a fun thing.

      I am not an airline pilot, nor are any of my family or friends... but I did consider it as a possible career option and when I realized I would have to spend a large portion of my live confined to a cubbyhole that would make a restroom stall large by comparison, I reconsidered. I feel these guys earn their pay, not only for their skills, but as compensation for the wear and tear it puts on them.

      --
      "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good." [KJV: I Thessalonians 5:21]

    11. Re:I don;t know about 9 by dboyles · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "Did you watch the game on Sunday? Wow!" mindless sheep.."

      I was under the impression that I enjoyed watching sports purely as a form of entertainment (and that entertainment includes discussing sports with friends). Now, through the insight of your post, I realize that I have simply been following the herd. I shall hereby resign my fan status, and retire to Slashdot, where I will post only things that will be accepted as mainstream geek.

      Whew, I almost fell in with those sports fan sheep who always say things because they think that's what others want to hear. Good thing I'm away from that and safe here on Slashdot.

      --
      -- "Complacency is a far more dangerous attitude than outrage." -Naomi Littlebear
    12. Re:I don;t know about 9 by Golias · · Score: 5, Insightful
      because like the case of Shawn Kemp, there are plenty of guys who could score 6 points and 3 rebounds a game.

      That's the big myth behind the "overpaid washed up athletes" claim. There are not plenty of guys who could score 6 points and three rebounds against NBA players. The European leagues are full of very good former college stars who couldn't do it.

      Out of almost 300 Million Americans, only a couple hundred are good enough to be benchwarmers in the NBA. Fewer than ever these days, because there are so many good players from the rest of the world now entering the league. You could easilly take the worst team in the NBA (the Clippers at the moment, I suspect) and mop up the floor with any college team in the US, or have a winning record against the pros in the Italian League. They may seem to suck in contrast to the Tim Duncans and Kevin Garnetts, but don't let that fool you into thinking they are anything less than elite athletes.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    13. Re:I don;t know about 9 by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 3, Insightful
      Cause it is the pilot who has the training and experience to land that aircraft on only 1 gear down. With half the engines off. With part of the control surfaces stuck. It isn't always bad maintenance that causes failures. Sometimes things just break. Then the pilot go to land it. No matter how much you pay the mechanics they can not fix the aircraft inflight.

      Plus of course there are a hell of a lot more mechanics for each plane then pilots. So it would be like pay several million more on maintenance or just a million more on pilots. Simple choice really.

      --

      MMO Quests are like orgasms:

      You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

    14. Re:I don;t know about 9 by Obfiscator · · Score: 3, Insightful
      Any reason why you left other professional entertainers (actors, actresses, writers, etc.) off your list?


      People seem to forget that professional athletes are entertainers, and they'll be paid as long as people pay to see them.

      --
      "Nothing shocks me. I'm a scientist." -Indiana Jones
    15. Re:I don;t know about 9 by Lucidwray · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Everytime I hear the argument that Pro_Athletes are over paid it drives me crazy. What no one seems to realise is that pro athletes are nothing but advertsing draws for their owners. They are paid 10Million a year because the owner is hoping that that one player will contribute more than 10 million in advertising dollars. The better/bigger the players the more people go to the games. The more people at the games the more ad signs cost in the stadium, the more ticket sales, more tv viewers, more tv money, more radio money, more merchandising.

      It has NOTHING to do with an athletes ability to throw a ball, it has EVERYTHING to do with how good the fans think he is, therefore how much money they will spend on the team.

      Its nothing but business. You can complain all day long how fat and old XXX basketplayer is, But if he fills seats and turns on TV's, then thats all that matters.

      --
      My sig can beat up your sig.
    16. Re:I don;t know about 9 by bnenning · · Score: 3, Insightful
      Care to tell us just what someone who can reliably throw an object 50 some odd yards is actually contributing to society at large?


      Because many members of society place a positive value watching him throw objects, as indicated by their willingness to pay to do so. Perhaps you don't agree with their preferences, but that doesn't mean they're not valid.

      --
      How to solve most of our problems: 1.Lots of nuclear plants. 2.Cure aging.
  2. I think at least part of the problem by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    is that the pilots for the non-major airlines are making so, so much less.

    Is this because the pilots for the major airlines are better? Is it because the lives they protect are worth more? No. It's because they have a better union.

  3. Re:Where is Gates on this list? by geekoid · · Score: 5, Insightful

    But Microsoft is not an underperforming company. Security issues do not matter, the bottom lines does.
    A CEO that manages to put 50 billion dollars away for emergences is a damn good CEO.

    Now their product may suck, but the product is not the issue here.

    --
    The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
  4. Public Program Managment. by Brigadier · · Score: 5, Insightful



    I work for an architecture firm that handles airport noise mitigation projects. and I'ved worked with several municipalities with regards to differnt programs accross the country. The majority of these programs are federally funded. I recently saw a job opening for a program director assistant type position paying over 80k a year. For someone not knowing the real requirments of the Job it may sound intence but the job is so easy and so useless. It blows my mind to see how over paid public servants are in the US it is crazy. Not only that but how many uneccessary jobs are created in adminitrative positions. Another area is State education systems and the amount of money paid to administrative professionals when teachers are in short supply and classrooms are under equipped.

  5. PO'ed photographers speak out. by TheMysteriousFuture · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Got this from a photography forum

    Quote


    There was some recent NEGATIVE PRESS about us as Professional Photographers being over paid.

    IF you would like to FLOOD this guys email box expressing your feelings, please go here:

    http://cbs.marketwatch.com/news/mai...3BF2A%7D

    Here is an a small amount of what he said about us professional photographers:
    --------------
    What follows is a list of the 10 most overpaid jobs in the U.S., in reverse order, drafted with input from compensation experts:

    10) Wedding photographers

    Photographers typically charge $2,000 to $5,000 to shoot a wedding, for what amounts to a one-day assignment plus processing time. Some get $15,000 or more. Yet many mope through the job, bumping guests in their way without apology, with the attitude: "I'm just doing this for the money until Time or National Geographic calls."

    They must cover equipment and film-development costs. Still, many in major metropolitan areas who shoot two weddings each weekend in the May-to-October marrying season pull in $100,000 for six months' work.

    Yet let's face it; much of their work is mediocre. Have you ever really been wowed flipping the pages of a wedding album handed you by recent newlyweds? Annie Leibovitz and Richard Avedon they're not, but some charge fees as if they're in the same league.

    --------------
    Come on gang...this guy can't get by saying this about us....let's send him a message!!!!!!

    End quote

    Interesting that he doesn't even consider that SOME (not all) photographers just MIGHT actually be over paid.
    --
    .sig
  6. pay reflects risk analysis by Speare · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The bit about the wedding photographer sounds like he had some grudge against his (or his daughter's) photographer. Whine whine whine.

    If you hire a bargain-basement photographer's assistant, you might get stunning Annie-Liebowicz-level artwork. But the chances are that you'll get fifty images that are ill-timed, ill-posed, ill-conceived, ill-focused or ill-processed. You pay the money to someone who will get the best possible angle on the critical moments that the wedding couple will want to remember for the rest of their lives. Sometimes that requires a nudge to move Aunt Marge out of the way. It's not an occasion you're going to want to repeat if the photographer got it all wrong.

    The same goes for an airline pilot... think about all the training you're depending on. Sure, it's "routine" to fly from coast to coast, but emergencies happen and it's the pilot's experience and training that you're paying for. It's a little late to complain that you didn't get your money's worth, once you've landed safe and sound after a boring flight.

    --
    [ .sig file not found ]
  7. Jeez... by American+AC+in+Paris · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Skycaps?

    OK, I get harshing on most of the others, but c'mon, skycaps? Let's smack down a bunch of guys who make $30k a year standing in the exhaust-drenched air at airport dropoff points, dealing with irate travellers, lugging overpacked suitcases around to the cries of 'Be careful with that!'...so they make tips, too--you think the surly, don't-give-a-damn ones are the ones raking in $300/day in tips? Right.

    Saying it takes less brains than stuffing fast food in a bag is rather insulting to skycaps, too--does this guy honestly think that a skycap can just kinda traipse around with a cart full of luggage, darned if he cares what happens to it? (This even without taking the crazy new security measures into account--I'm sure that makes their jobs oh-so-easy these days...)

    Pro atheletes? Sure. High-end real estate agents? Yep. Skycaps? That's...kinda reaching for a top ten list...

    --

    Obliteracy: Words with explosions

  8. Malarkey by jdavidb · · Score: 5, Insightful

    "Overpaid" is an opinion. This article acts as if "overpaid" can be objectively defined. You may not think sports stars are worth it (hey, I sure don't), but apparently everyone else does and is voting with their dollars. If you want these people's salaries to be "corrected," you're going to have to sway public opinion.

    Honestly, I'm so tired of reading articles by people who never understood the intersection of a supply curve and a demand curve.

    Great reading on the subject from Walter Williams.

    I don't think the sports stars should make that much money. Sometimes I even resent them. But for me to decree that they're "overpaid" means I think I have the right to prohibit thousands of people from purchasing sports tickets. I don't have the right to that kind of control over people's lives any more than I have the right to choose their religion.

    1. Re:Malarkey by Noren · · Score: 4, Insightful
      Not quite, if you read the article it argues in come cases that the market isn't reaching equilibrium because of collusion or fraud.

      "9) Pilots for major airlines" and "8) West Coast longshoremen" are both claimed to be overpaid because of powerful unions controlling all the labor supply and acting as a monopolist.

      "4) Orthodontists" argues that the supply of orthodontists is kept artificially low by "U.S. Dental Schools". I don't necessarily agree with the whole of the argument here, but it's not based on misunderstanding of the funamentals of supply and demand.

      "1) Mutual Fund managers" is claiming the whole profession is guilty of fraud, may be an overreaction because of current events, but fraud is certainly a way to be paid more than your fair market value.

      Some of the examples cited are bad, but in situations of monopoly, artificial scarcity of supply, or fraud it does happen that people are paid more than their fair market value. (I do agree that most professional athletes are not overpaid... but the article doesn't cite the general case, rather "2) Washed-up pro athletes in long-term contracts", which is more arguable.)

  9. they are wrong about wedding photographers by Savatte · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Have you ever really been wowed flipping the pages of a wedding album handed you by recent newlyweds?

    It takes more than just snapping photos to be a wedding photographer. It's like being a drummer: Do your job well and no one will notice, but mess up and you'll catch hell. I guarantee you can tell the difference between a professional wedding photographer's photographs and some doofus with a disposable. Wedding Photographers are also not only working against the clock, but they only get one day.

    Articles like these with the lack of repsect for profession's intricacies as are borderline offensive. Just because the author doesn't see what the big deal is is no reason to bash it.

  10. Re:law of supply and demand. by FuzzyDaddy · · Score: 4, Insightful
    If someone is willing to pay it and some body's willing to supply it. It's a fair price.

    Unless the guy making the decision and the guy parting with the money are not the same guy. If the board of directors of a company is deciding how to pay the CEO more (because the CEO is on THEIR board of directors) this isn't supply and demand - it's called "milking the system".

    --
    It's not wasting time, I'm educating myself.
  11. Re:Where is Gates on this list? by filth+grinder · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Of course everyone should sacrifice... yeah right.

    The Red Cross needs good management and a good CEO. Take a look at the amount of money the company handles, and the stuff they do around the world. They are equal to a multinational corporation. Now, they need people with the ability to lead a company that size. In order to attract these people, they have to offer a salary. Now in order to get the people needed into these positions, they need to pay a competitive salary. Some guy off the street being the CEO of the Red Cross for 50K a year might look good, but unless he's independently wealthy and doing it as a humanitarian effort, he's not going to do the job well.

    CEOs actually do alot for companies, it may look like a cushy job, but there is alot of work going on there.

    I mean, compare it with software development. If you have a project going on, you want a good software dev team to work on it. Sure, you are going to "piss away cash" to pay their salaries, but you could always just farm out the job overseas. Anyone here will tell you, the farmed out code is going to be subpar. If you farm out the CEO of the Red Cross, the result is going to be subpar.

    It is the samething with teachers. Everyone will complain that teachers are underpaid. Yet, I don't see anyone ponying up more tax dollars to pay for them.

  12. Many are overpaid, even more then become underpaid by 2TecTom · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The gap between top and bottom salaries is at a historic all time high. The powerful simply bent the rules so they gain more than their fair share at the expense of all of the rest of us. This cripples our economy as it's a clear disincentive to labor. At the current rate of mismanagement, it surely won't be too long before the whole rotten house of cards collapses again. Excessive affluence is a sure sign of a corrupt society and I, for one, wish there was even some justice in America. Really, the real enemy isn't overseas, they inhabit the top floors of our institutions.

    --
    Words to men, as air to birds.
  13. Airline pilots? by pcraven · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I don't think top airline pilots are overpaid.

    Consider the fact that their 'off' hours are usually away from home. There is a LOT of work that they do outside of flying. This doesn't count in their per-hour charge.

    They spend a lot of time gaining hours in small aircraft and as co-pilots of large aircraft. And they get dirt-pay for that.

    They can't drink 12 hours before going on the job.

    They work odd hours.

    They are controlling a big gas tank with an aluminum shell and 300 people inside, all while moving 600+ mph in weather conditions that prevent you from seeing out side.

    Yea, I want a good incentive for the pilot up front in my aircraft. I want to get to my destination!

  14. Re:The article (Thanks /.!) by Animaether · · Score: 3, Insightful

    40-60k ? That's somewhere down from celebrity weddings, I'm sure.

    You could get a very nice downpayment on a house for that money :)
    ( or one really, really giant diamond on that ring, if the spouse-to-be is so inclined %) )

    That said, even the $2k photographers often have an insiduous clause in their contract - I swear it was up on /. , but I can't spot it in the search results now.

    The clause is that the photos they made belong to them.
    - You want re-prints ? you have to pay, because You're not getting the negatives.
    - You photocopy the prints you got ? be careful the photographer doesn't find out, or they may sue you.
    - Want digital versions ? Expect crappy web-sized 640x480's or so, because a good resolution means you could print them out. That is -if- the photographer even offers digital versions.

    And if he wants to use your pictures in his portfolio, he's free to do so.

    You generally have to pay a good amount of money to nullify these clauses.

    Very nasty stuff, very much something to look out for when picking a photographer.

  15. Wow by NDPTAL85 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Do you ever get dizzy from up there on your high horse?

    The road to hell is paved with good intentions. I know you "mean well" and all with your utopian plans of providing for the homeless and eduction but unfortunately due to the fact that we're HUMANS that means we need to arrainge our economies in a capitalist fashion.

    We could try socialism but obvious examples have already demonstrated the sheer humanitarian horror that that produced.

    And where do you get off telling someone that going outside and pretending to be as good at sports as a pro is would be enjoyable? Why put your body at risk of injury when you can watch others play a game better than you'd ever be able to? Don't you think thats a bit condescending?

    --
    Mac OS X and Windows XP working side by side to fight back the night.
  16. Get Real! by INetUser · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Are you guys kiddig me? Look, the truth of the matter is that nearly all CEO's who are getting more than $1/2 Mil each year are grossly overpaid! And that's just about all of them! Next are all the wonderful Demicrooks and RepubliCONS in CONgress. They are all basically in the deep pockets of the cheating and lying CEO's! and don't give a rip who they cheat or steal from nor who they are lying to as long as they have their campagin warchests filled up to stay in office. If the middle class collapses in this country, and there are signs that they are based on economic control and whose got it and wealth distribution, something gonna blow up really big! (IMHO).

  17. Re:#10 by Dalroth · · Score: 4, Insightful

    No kidding. My friend got married last spring and in his wedding the Photographer was a really horrid woman (late 30's early 40's). She did EVERYTHING that was mentioned in this article. She shoved people out of the way, she was rude, she hogged all the good pictures to herself. All while spending the entire evening bitching to anybody she possibly could about how digital cameras were ruining her business.

    You know what though, SHE was the one ruining her business, not the digital camers. You have to adapt with the times, and you have to adapt to the situation, and being a horrid cold bitch is not the way to sell yourself to potential future customers. You can't be complacent, no matter who you are or what job you do, times change.

    You want to take good wedding pictures? Hire a local college student who is going to school for Photography. You'll get a great price, great pictures, and the student will get some extra money for beer and some pictures for their art classes. I can tell you my college friends who were photography majors sure would've appreciated the work!!

    Bryan

  18. Re:And lay off the damn longshoremen by mveloso · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Yeah, get off it. Longshoremen are basically cargo monkeys, no different than the UPS delivery guys, except for one thing - longshoremen have more equipment, so they don't actually have to lift anything.

    It's great that their union is so powerful that it can disrupt commerce worldwide. That just means that, like the Mob, they've become experts in extortion.

    Don't try and point the finger somewhere else - those guys are way overpaid, and it's no good to say "hey, they're overpaid because the other guys is a monopoly too."

  19. Re:#10 by mlilback · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The cheapest price they could find for a wedding photographer was $1200 in the Houston area.

    My dad was named the 2003 Houston-area professional photographer of the year, so I know a little bit about this subject.

    For a good photographer, 1200 is way too low. When my dad shot a wedding, he'd bring an assistant. Some wedding photographers I know bring 2-3 assistants.

    They are at the wedding beforehand to shoot pictures because there will be no time during the wedding for posed family shots. They stay throughout most of the reception. That is easily 6 hours of work. Normally on a weekend. I don't think $100/hour for a freelancing professional on the weekend is that outrageous.

    Now add in the massive costs for a professional. For my dad, that meant bringing a professional lighting setup and multiple hasselblad cameras and lenses (easily over $10,000) so there is no chance at missing a shot. Then throw in processing costs, proofs (4x5 proofs of all shots are made), basic administrative/advertising overhead, travel, planning sessions, profit, etc.

    And don't understimate the fact that it normally is weekend work. My parents would work all week long and then not be around on the weekend because they were shooting weddings. That's one of the main reasons they closed their studio -- it was too taxing on their personal lives.

    You are paying for an expert to capture one of the most important days of your life, and you get what you pay for.
    Sure you can trust your wedding to a college student with a single 35mm camera. But is a few thousand more really not worth it to get a trained professional who uses redundent, top-of-the-line equipment?

    But then again, look at how much of the world uses Windoze because it is "good enough".

  20. Re:What about HR people? - What about them? by meta-monkey · · Score: 3, Insightful

    You make some good points about HR people that most laymen would never realize.

    I think that's the problem with just about all the jobs listed in this article, and all the bitching in these comments on /. : ignorance. People just don't know what these jobs entail. They see one part of it, think it must be easy, and therefore not worth any money.

    I'm a wedding photographer (#10 on the list), and a lot of people on /. seem to think I only work the 8 hours at the wedding on Saturday, charge $4,000, and leave. They don't seem to consider the several hours of prep work before the wedding, or the 40 or 50 hours of work retouching and editing the photos afterward, or the cost of all my business overhead, including equipment, insurance, rent, phone, internet, etc etc etc. Oh, and I gotta eat and provide my own benefits, too.

    Seems to me people should walk a mile in your shoes before they judge. Might as well ask some programmer, "Well, what does it really cost you to work for your company? I mean, gas mileage to and fro, right? So how can you possibly defend the fact that you charge your employer $50,000 a year for your services?!? It's not like it costs you anything! You're just stealing from your poor employer!"

    Oh yeah, there's that whole "sucking away my life" thing.

    --
    We don't have a state-run media we have a media-run state.