Slashdot Mirror


MythBusters - Who Ya Gonna Call?

An anonymous reader writes "The currently-airing Discovery Channel show MythBusters has been profiled in a Newsweek article. Basically, the show takes two former Hollywood effects designers as they set out to prove or disprove various folklore myths that have come about over the years, such as the actual effect of a poppy-seed bagel on a drug test, or what effect a penny dropped from the Empire State Building observation deck will have on a human at ground level."

21 of 92 comments (clear)

  1. Busted? by Godeke · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I wonder if there is any way of "busting" urban myths. Even after I send people to various urban legend sites to combat the more annoying email variety, it seems some people are just credulous or just want a good story to tell. I suspect that the reality of it is irrelevant, and busted or not, the same stories with be with us for a very long time.

    --
    Sig under construction since 1998.
    1. Re:Busted? by BrynM · · Score: 2, Insightful
      I suspect that the reality of it is irrelevant, and busted or not, the same stories with be with us for a very long time.
      Ah, but now there's the additional story to tell: How a pair of wackos proved or disproved the old story. I don't think that they're killing the stories off as much as they are enhancing them. Maybe even assuring that some will be with us even longer, now that they are proven fact (bagel anyone?).
      --
      US Democracy:The best person for the job (among These pre-selected choices...)
  2. And on the next episode... by weeboo0104 · · Score: 5, Funny

    They will explore whether or not a webserver can melt as a result of something called "The Slashdot effect".

    --
    It is easier to build strong children than to repair broken men. -Frederick Douglass
  3. Maybe... by Asprin · · Score: 3, Interesting


    Maybe when they get done debunkning all of the ULs you can find on Snopes, they can turn their crosshairs on huckster quackery such as cell-phone radiation shield stickers, magnet therapy bracelets and all the other crap that shows up on late-night infomercials.

    THAT'S what I'd do to improve humanity.

    --
    "Lawyers are for sucks."
    - Doug McKenzie
    1. Re:Maybe... by You're+All+Wrong · · Score: 2, Informative

      Penn and Teller did "Bullshit" to bust open some of those kinds of things. I'd send you a URL, but sho.com refuses to serve pages to those of us outside the US for some reason.

      YAW.

      --
      Your head of state is a corrupt weasel, I hope you're happy.
    2. Re:Maybe... by stefanlasiewski · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The Amazing Randi, along with Penn and Teller and a host of other illusionists, have actually has done a couple of shows debunking certain quackeries and paranormal happenings.

      They mostly focus on psychic tricks and illusions-- showing tricks on how it is to get information on your dead relatives, by using selective questions and special wording, watching for you to react to certain words, etc.

      Their philosophy is that it's OK when everyone involved knows that the trick is for entertainment. The line is crossed when people start taking it seriously, and start paying large sums of money for quackery.

      Randi has even appeared on some popular kids science shows such as Bill Nye the Science guy where he'll take a horoscope, seperate each sign and the associated "fortune", mix them up, and then paste one sign to an unrelated fortune, so that the sign Aries actually has the fotune for "Taurus", etc.

      He then has audience members read the fotunes, and guages their reaction. "Gosh, that fortune sounds just like my brother, who is an Aries", when in fact it's just a fortune from another randomly selected sign. The fortunes are all so generic that they work for just about everyone, at about any point in your life.

      This stuff is mostly focused at kids, but it's a great science lesson.

      --
      "Can of worms? The can is open... the worms are everywhere."
    3. Re:Maybe... by Prior+Restraint · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Not to defend that sort of behavior, but he's gotten enough of that sort of stuff hurled at him from con artists that over the decades he probably sees it as "sauce for the goose".

    4. Re:Maybe... by elmegil · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I suppose. It doesn't seem to me that one does much good for a reputation as a skeptic by being dogmatic though. The point of skepticism is "prove it" not "that's impossible".

      --
      7 November 2006: The day Americans realized corruption and incompetence weren't addressing 11 September 2001
    5. Re:Maybe... by Noren · · Score: 3, Funny
      No, he'd just demand that pesky 'evidence' that snake oil peddlers worldwide have so much trouble coming up with. The nerve of him, to actually expect people making wild claims to substantiate them! It's ever so much easier to lie to people if you're never asked for, you know, evidence.

      I'm quite in favor of debunking the likes of John "the biggest douchebag in the universe" Edward.

  4. Re:topics topics topics by Zack · · Score: 3, Informative

    They did do the Cola and bloodstains and rust... turns out it was marginally better than water at cleaning blood, but it cleaned the chrome on a car better than the chrome cleaner product that they had! Very cool show.

  5. My favorite show by develop · · Score: 5, Informative

    It's one of my favorite shows. Three thumbs up on the TiVo. For those interested here is a list of some of the topics they covered.

    1. coke's ability to remove blood stains/rust/etc
    2. do piercing's make you more susceptible to lightening
    3. ice bullets (CIA myth)
    4. the JADO rocket on the car in the desert
    5. the weather balloon lawn chair story
    6. running in the rain keeps you drier then walking
    7. eel skin wallets erase credit cards
    8. smoking on the toliet can kill ya
    9. poppy seeds can make you test positive on a drug test
    10. peeing on the third rail will kill ya
    11. tree canon
    12. ways to beat a breathalyzer
    13. dropping a hammer in the water before you fall in will break your fall
    14. penny off the empire state building
    15. exploding cdrom drivers
    16. breast implants explode in airplanes

    anyway - good show... no answers listed - watch the show to find out.

  6. Vint Cerf told me that Al Gore was in fact... by Futurepower(R) · · Score: 2, Offtopic


    Vint Cerf told me that Al Gore was in fact the strongest early supporter of making the old ArpaNet into the public utility we call the Internet. Without Gore's technical understanding and power in the U.S. Congress, it would have taken much longer.

    For those who can remember back that far, there were many ArpaNet users who did now want the system open to the public. There was intense opposition to making the system open to commercial interests, too. Al Gore was a true visionary, in this case.

  7. Exploding cd rom drivers by AtariAmarok · · Score: 2, Funny

    "15. exploding cdrom drivers"

    That is why I use a special version of WinZip that includes a reinformed titanium shell for my file downloads. You never known when one of these might detonate inside the modem or at the wall phone-plug outlet.

    I'm sure glad the RIAA has not discovered exploding files. It could escalate their war against p2p to a new level.

    --
    Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
  8. Exploding CD rom drives by BeatdownGeek · · Score: 3, Interesting
    I didn't see the episode so I'm not sure exactly what this was explaining... If it was talking about CDs exploding in the drive I can vouch for that.

    I had a CD explode in the drive before. It apparently had a miniscule crack (in the CD), and I guess when it was spinning in the drive at full speed, the centrifugal force just made it blow apart. Sounded like a gunshot. Scared the crap out of me. I'll never use those crappy generic CD-Rs again.

    When I called up Dell support the guy scratched his head at first but then when he talked to other ppl he said a few others had gotten similar calls. His support advice:

    "Open the drive tray and shake the computer until all the bits of CD come out. It should be fine; they're pretty sturdy."
  9. Official Site by Drunken_Jackass · · Score: 3, Informative

    Here is the official site for the show. There are a few fan sites that are navigable off of the main site too.

    It's quite and entertaining and informative show, and should definately be Tivo'd (since, you know, we're all out on Friday nights).

    --
    There are 01 types of people in this world. Those that understand binary, and me.
  10. They were almost really buried alive by netringer · · Score: 4, Informative
    Did you see the one that went wrong?

    When they checked out the "Buried Alive!" urban legends by burying one in a metal coffin to see how long the air lasted, they didn't have all the information they needed.

    The funeral home was happy to sell them a metal coffin but didn't tell them they bury coffins inside a concrete burial vault.

    When the Mythbusters dumped several tons of dirt on the coffin with the tester inside the coffin began to collapse from the load.

    They never did explain why they had that problem - A modern coffin can't be - and isn't buried by itself.

    --
    Ever dream you could fly? Get up from the Flight Sim. I Fly
    1. Re:They were almost really buried alive by Geraden · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I saw this, and was very displeased that they took Jamie's safety so casually. Just a little bit of research would have led them to the concrete vault information.

      Shows that even though they take pains to try to ensure realism, even they can mess up sometimes!

  11. Re:topics topics topics by john_many_jars · · Score: 4, Informative

    Cecil at Straight Dope (http://www.straightdope.com) has answered these and many other thousands of questions over the past 20-30 years. There is an archive with several hundred questions including the three in the parent.

  12. Re:topics topics topics by Ed+Almos · · Score: 2, Informative

    you do not get any wetter running in the rain rather than walking. They proved this on a British TV science show a few years back by making a group of (volunteer) kids either walk across the school yard or run whilst wearing cotton t-shirts. As it was in England it was of course raining.

    At the end of the trip they weighed all of the shirts and there was no difference.

    As for urinating on the third rail, at your own risk !! I would not like to try as the third rail here in Budapest is at 6,000 volts.

    Ed Almos

    --
    The more corrupt the state, the more numerous the laws. - Tacitus, 56-120 A.D.
  13. Running In the Rain by chriso11 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Do you get wetter walking or running from point A to B in the rain? OK, let's make some key assumptions:
    The amount of rain falling is constant and is equal between point A and B. Wind is not a factor. Assume that the rain drops are at critical velocity. You move through the path at a constant velocity.

    Now, imagine freezing time - with all of the raindrops fixed in place. The rain that would hit you in 3s is maybe 100 feet up, while the the rain that hits you in 6 sec is 200 feet up. So, you simply convert the amount of time it takes to traverse A to B, and convert that to the vertical distance of the rain drops that would hit you when you get to point B. Then, you can simply use C^2 = A^2 + B^2, where A is the path length and B corresponds to the amount of time (rain height). So minimizing the C, total path length in the rain reduces how wet you get. Even if you moved at near-infinite speed, you would still get wet in the rain, but not as wet as someone who never moved.

    --
    No, I don't trust in god. He'll have to pay up front, like everybody else.
  14. Re:topics topics topics by Patrik_AKA_RedX · · Score: 2, Funny
    Just how dangerous is it to answer the call of nature on the electrified third rail of a train track?
    I sure hope it's leathal. Anyone stupid enough to pee on a electrified rail should be removed from the gene pool.