Slashdot Mirror


Bob Young's Open Letter to SCO/Darl McBride

Oskie-wee-wee writes "Infoworld is carrying a story about Bob Young (Red Hat, Lulu, Classy Formal Wear, Hamilton Tiger-Cats, etc.) and his open letter to SCO and Darl McBride - in response to Darl's open letter 'defending, in one breath, the SCO suit, the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, and the Supreme Court Decision in the Eldred vs. Ashcroft case.'"

22 of 263 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Not this again by herrvinny · · Score: 5, Funny

    Open Letter To SCO, From The Guy Who Owns scoreport.com:

    Dear Darl,

    You Suck

    Signed,
    herrvinny

  2. DMCA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    It is paramount that the DMCA be given full force and effect, as envisioned by Congress. The judgment of our elected officials in Congress is the law of the land in the U.S. copyright arena, and should be respected as such. If allowed to work properly, we have no doubt that the DMCA will create a beneficial effect for the entire economy in digital technology development, similar to the benefits created by the 1976 Copyright Act.

  3. celebrate him! except his letter was dumb by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Mr. Young's letter made it obvious that there are far more educated people than him fighting this fight. Can we please not champion his mediocrity, /.? Thanks.

  4. An Open Letter To Linus Torvalds: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Dear Linus,

    I have always felt that Linux is a nice operating system (for hobbyists and
    geeks), but there are some areas where it is seriously lacking, especially when
    compared to its main competitor, Microsoft Windows.

    * File sharing. Windows has long been superior when it comes to making large
    amounts of files available to third parties. Even early versions of Windows
    automatically detected and made available all directories thanks to the built in
    NetBIOS-powered file sharing support. But Microsoft has realized that this
    technology is inherently limited and has added even better file sharing support
    to its Windows XP operating system. "Universal Plug an Play" will
    make it possible to literally access any file, from any device! I think
    universal file sharing support needs to be built into the Linux kernel soon.

    * Intelligent agents. With innovations like Clippy, the talking paperclip
    and Microsoft Bob, Microsoft has always tried to make life easier
    for its customers. With Outlook and Outlook Express, Microsoft has built a
    framework for developers to create even smarter agents. Especially popular
    agents include "Sircam", which automatically asks the users' friends for advice
    on files he is working on and the "Hybris" agent, which is a self-replicating
    copy of a humorous take on "Snow-White and the Seven Dwarves" (the real story!).
    Microsoft is working on expanding this P2P technology to its web servers. This
    project is still in the beta stage, thus the name "Code Red". The next versions
    will be called "Code Yellow" and "Code Green".

    * Version numbers. Linux has real naming problems. What's the difference
    between a 2.4.19 and a 2.2.17 kernel anyway? And what's with those odd and even
    numbers? Microsoft has always had clear and sophisticated naming/versioning
    policies. For example, Windows 95 was named Windows 95 because it was released
    in 1995. Windows 98 was released three years later, and so on. Windows XP
    brought a whole new "experience" to the user, therefore the name. I suggest that
    the next Linux kernel releases be called Linux 03, Linux 04, Linux 04.5 (OSR1),
    Linux 04.7B (OSR2 SP4 OEM), Linux 2005 and Linux VD (Valentine's Day edition).
    Furthermore, remember how Microsoft named every upcoming version of Windows
    after some Egyptian city? Cairo, Chicago and so on. I think that the development
    kernels should be named after Spanish cities to celebrate Linux' Spanish
    origins. Linux Milano or Linux Rome anyone?

    * Multi-User Support. This has always been one of Microsoft's strong sides,
    especially in the Windows 95/98 variants, where passwords were completely
    unnecessary. Microsoft has made the right decision by not bothering the user
    with a distinction between "normal" and "root" users too much -- practice has
    shown that average users can be trusted to act responsibly and in full awareness
    of the potential consequences of their actions. After all, if your operating
    system doesn't trust you, why should you trust it? (To be fair, Linux is making
    some progress here with the Lindows [lindows.com] distribution, where users are
    always running as root.)

    With Windows XP, Microsoft has again improved multi-user support. Not only
    does Windows XP come with a large library of user pictures that are displayed on
    the login screen, such as a guitar and a flower, it also has "quick user
    change". This makes it possible to login as a different user with a simple
    keyboard shortcut, and the good news is: programs from the old user keep running
    in the background! Beat that, Linux!

    * Programmability. Microsoft has always been known for making computer
    machine power accessible to end users. The operating system comes with many
    helpful tools such as VBScript, a programming language especially useful for
    developing intelligent agents as mentioned above, and QBASIC, a truly innovative
    "hacker" tool that makes it possible to

    1. Re:An Open Letter To Linus Torvalds: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
      I think that the development
      kernels should be named after Spanish cities to celebrate Linux' Spanish
      origins. Linux Milano or Linux Rome anyone?

      Celebrating Linux' Finnish origins would sound like a better idea to me. "Linux Kuopio", "Linux Tampere" and "Linux Pihtipudas" sound all cool, don't they?
  5. Mirror: santa claus operations by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    here is a mirror of the bbspot article
    http://bbspot.com/News/2003/12/sco_christ mas.html

    SCO Must Prove Existence Of
    Santa Claus in Thirty Days
    By Brian Briggs

    Salt Lake City, UT - Supreme Court Judge Isaiah Moore ruled that SCO must show proof of Santa Claus in the next 30 days, or he will dismiss their lawsuit against all Christians and companies profiting from the Christmas holiday.

    A new look for SCO CEO Kris Kringle (formerly named Darl McBride)

    SCO, formerly known as Santa Cruz Operations, recently changed their name to Santa Claus Operations. This change was widely regarded as a move to improve their image after their controversial claims about Linux. Critics of the name change say it's just another fantasy created by SCO CEO Kris Kringle, formerly known as Darl McBride, to profit through litigation.

    In a recent press release SCO said it would begin sending out invoices to anyone who celebrates or profits from Christmas in the next couple of weeks including corporations and individuals. A price list for SCO Christmas licenses which companies and individuals need to celebrate the holiday without violating SCO's intellectual property rights were released as well.

    "Children can avoid penalties by sending 10% of their Christmas gifts to SCO," said Kringle.

    Followers of the case consider the judge's decision a defeat for SCO, because they feel the company cannot prove the existence of Santa Claus.

    Kringle was confident that SCO would prevail in the lawsuit. He said, "We have hundreds of e-mails addressed to Kris_Kringle@sco.com. Under Federal law it is illegal to route e-mail to the wrong location intentionally. This proves without a doubt that Santa Claus exists and he works at SCO."

    Chief Counsel for the company Fred Gailey said he planned to print out these e-mails and place them in giant mailbags to dump on the judge's desk. "When the judge sees the number of e-mails we've received he will have to rule in our favor, or face breaking the hearts of his grandchildren."

    Related News

    Office 2003 Editions Compared

    Notepad Rallies for Extension Name Change

    Office Jesus Will Work Miracles for Food

    "Christmas existed long before the existence of SCO," said VP of marketing for Giantco, Clayton Moneybags. "In fact I heard that at one point it was about celebrating the birth of Jesus."

    SCO Vice president, Jesus Christ countered, "Don't you think we thought of that one too?"

  6. Re:I had this idea by Geek+of+Tech · · Score: 5, Funny
    >> Also, if the DMCA is ever repealed, freakin' party of the century at my place!

    You bring the keg and I'll bring the magic markers, shift key, single session cd drive and anything else that at one time was not allowed by the DMCA.

    --
    Stop the Slashdot effect! Don't read the articles!
  7. When this is over.... by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 4, Funny
    When this is all over, and Darl is inevitably tossed in federal pound-me-in-the-ass prison for securities fraud, I think I will design a "Free Darl!" t-shirt, much in the style of the Kevin Mitnick ones. I think it will be really interesting to see the kinds of reactions I'd get from fellow geeks.

    On second thought...perhaps I should put the design on a kevlar vest as opposed to a t-shirt.

    --
    Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
  8. Good Luck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Good luck with that, ummm, letter thing.

  9. Re:Not this again by dilby · · Score: 2, Funny

    Although I don't necessarily consider Bob young a moron.

    I am waiting for the front page article....
    Goatse man's open leter to SCO



    Oh ... that's right....

    --
    This post patent pending.
  10. Re:I had this idea by Stonent1 · · Score: 3, Funny

    Linus Torvalds subpoenas Darl McBride under the DMCA for violating the GPL. This results in a repeal of the DMCA in the supreme court.

    This sounds very Douglas Adams to me. It goes something like this. God exists on faith. Proving that he exists will only negate the need for faith, and thereby, God disappears in a puff of logic. (I know that is nowhere near the exact phrasing, but you get the idea)

  11. Re:Hey by segment · · Score: 4, Funny

    I heard it was "stop hitting her with the leather retard she's into bdsm she really does like it"

  12. Re:Damn buncha cluebies around here... by segment · · Score: 2, Funny
    Bob Young is the FOUNDER and CEO of REDHAT

    Not only is he the founder... He's also a client

  13. On other news... by ivern76 · · Score: 4, Funny

    Darl can't even spell properly. "The FSF and Red Hat believe that the progress of science is best advanced by eliminating the profit motive from software development and insuring free, unrestricted public access to software innovations." Insuring? I never knew the FSF was in the insurance business...sure hope he meant ensuring.

  14. Re:Umm, not everyone by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    $ifconfig -a
    $s0: flags=1000843<UP,BROADCAST,RUNNING,MULTICAST,IPv4> mtu 1500 index 2
    inet 127.0.0.2 netmask fffffff8 broadcast 127.0.0.1
    ether 8:0:20:b4:2:ee
    $ipf -f - block in on s0 from 0.0.0.0 to 127.0.0.1
    $echo h0h0h0

    There now no one benefits from IP

  15. If the SCO-Linux battle was moderated on /. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Darl McBride: -1 Troll
    Linus Torvalds: +1 Funny
    Groklaw: +1 Insighful
    Bob Young: -1 Redundant

    Sorry Bob. You're on the good side, but you really contributed nothing.

  16. Re:Not this again by mattjb0010 · · Score: 3, Funny

    Thanks for that, I just submitted it ;)

  17. Re:Not this again by sirsnork · · Score: 3, Funny

    Sorry in advance, but brings whole new meaning to the word "open"

    --

    Normal people worry me!
  18. Re:sticking it to Darl by Ohreally_factor · · Score: 5, Funny

    That's my favorite quote from the open letter: you might want to be less vocal.

    And just to quibble, I think Bob is incorrect where he writes, " It is the crook who should be sent to jail, not the tool. . . "

    Darl has proven many times over that he is a tool that should be sent to jail.

    --
    It's not offtopic, dumbass. It's orthogonal.
  19. In other news today... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    In other news today SCO anounced they were switching to use the services of the law Firm "Dewie, Screwem & Howe" Expect more action shortly!

  20. In other news... by Xconnect · · Score: 1, Funny

    I sure hope you meant "in other news". I don't think the news casters would enjoy having Darl's ass on their heads. :-)

    --
    --- root@127.0.0.1
  21. Re:Do we have to give up "Niggle" too? by FiloEleven · · Score: 2, Funny

    "I think you would have a very hard time convincing a group of average (insert any race here) that this word is useful at all in today's modern vocabulary."

    humans?