Slashdot Mirror


Control-Alt-Recycle

klevin writes "Grist magazine's running an article on what to look for when the old PC's running out of gas and you want to avoid trashing the environment even further. Their suggestions include: upgrade instead of replacing, go for LCD monitors instead of CRTs and, if replacing, reuse the old one as an MP3 server on your home network."

27 of 334 comments (clear)

  1. Reuse a good option by JohnGrahamCumming · · Score: 3, Informative

    Since Linux is so darn lightweight and easy to use I took my old laptop, removed the broken screen, installed base SuSE Linux (no X) and networked it. With an installation of rsync I've got an instant backup server for all the machines in our place.

    Sure that machine's processor is only 750Mhz, but a laptop with no screen and a large hard drive makes a nice "blade server" sitting on the shelf and with a core operating system running the CPU load is never high.

    John.

  2. In the UK... by Tet · · Score: 2, Informative

    ...my local council collects electronic compenents for recycling every fortnight.

    --
    "The invisible and the non-existent look very much alike." -- Delos B. McKown
  3. goodwill does it too by misterspo · · Score: 5, Informative

    goodwil has computer centers where they take your trash computers and build systems for the less privelidged...or..just the cheap for that matter. I've gone into their center to buy parts for my older machines before.

    1. Re:goodwill does it too by misterspo · · Score: 3, Informative
      put them on the curb...someone will take them.

      I put out a few old monitors, a few GUTTED 486 systems, and a ton of cables. they were all picked up by a metal salvage guy within a few hours.

      apparently there's a fair amount of gold and copper in them thar boards if you know where to look.

      the guy was going to essentially strip them down to scrap and sell the metals.

      doesn't exactly deal with some of the other issues (all those parts he DOESN'T salvage...

      but at least the guilt is off my back.

    2. Re:goodwill does it too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      The 'metal salvage' guy, particularly if it's a private scavenger, will snip off the pieces that have gold in them and pitch the rest in whatever is the cheapest location he can find.

      Then the components with the gold in them will be shipped to a state or location where the nasty chemicals and polluting methods used to recover the gold are permitted. Back in the day photo film recycling of Minnesota scrap was always done in South Dakota. That meant burning all that polyester film and venting the fumes right into the air.

      The 'guilt' is off your back, so long as you remain ignorant.

  4. The Three R's by Analogy+Man · · Score: 4, Informative
    In general there is too much of a focus on recycling. The other two legs of the triangular head to tail graphic are Reduce and Reuse.

    The recent announcment where Intel is building greener chips is an example of reduce...as is simplified packaging, reusable containers, using your own coffee mug instead of a disposable cup etc.

    The next best thing is Reuse. I recently turned my old box into a file server for example. The downside is this machine is always on (i.e. I have two heaters in my basement instead of one). I can reduce my power consumption a bit by clocking it down...but not eliminate that electrical demand completely.

    All in all I think a general awareness of the "Total Cost of Ownership" on a global scale will hopefully lead to more enlightened decision making. That some of the big players are taking part is a good sign.

    --
    When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty.
  5. Regions around Quebec, Canada.. by Bilange · · Score: 3, Informative

    You can donate your stuff to http://www.usedpccanada.com - enterprises can also get rid of pallets of old pc's too.

    --
    "...a generation of kids has grown up thinking Trance is the shittiest music since country and western." - Paul van Dyk
  6. Re:I've done this, but... by csirac · · Score: 2, Informative
    Did you know it takes 1.8 tonnes of material to manufacture a new PC?

    - Paul

  7. Re:what happened to the UPS program? by bcolflesh · · Score: 3, Informative

    You are thinking of the IBM product recycling plan, which includes a UPS pre-paid shipping label.

  8. Energy costs ARE factored in! by neonfrog · · Score: 5, Informative
    Probably 60% of posts will say that power munching dinosaur-machines are killing the planet, but that article actually said:

    "... released a ... report on the environmental impact of computers, from production through USE and disposal." (emPHAsis mine)

    A friend of mine just measured his power consumption on a 24/7 P166 MP3 server machine and concluded it costs 52.3 kwh/month ($6.14/month for him). Even if the monitor were constantly in use (~double the above numbers) he'd have to save $150 a year with NEW equipment (cost to make/buy + (cost to dispose x2) VS cost to run) to justify trashing the old. If he used a clever timer system so it was only on when needed, then he'd save lots more and REALLY have to work hard to justify new equipment.

    The math seems very in favor of careful reutilization in most cases. You have to have something really sucky to justify getting a new thing and THROWING OUT the old thing. The materials almost always cost more to deal with than the energy consumed for use, apparently.

    --

    I'm thinking about it, therefore I might be.

  9. The whole recycling system needs to be built by 47PHA60 · · Score: 4, Informative

    There are a lot of limitations on what I can do with old computer equipment. True, CRTs contain all sorts of horrible stuff, but LCDs contain a lot of mercury, so they too will need to be reclaimed in a responsible way. It's not enough to put it on the curb with the correct sticker and claim that you are "recycling." It is likely that the thing is still going into a landfill, maybe a lined one, maybe not.

    As for donations, the schools in my area won't accept anything less than a Pentium III, so the whole "the only need an old P75" isn't going to work anymore.

    Recycling never takes off until the law says it has to. Until real recycling is a requirement, it just is not profitable enough to build that infrastructure.

    1. Re:The whole recycling system needs to be built by ChristTrekker · · Score: 2, Informative
      As for donations, the schools in my area won't accept anything less than a Pentium III, so the whole "the only need an old P75" isn't going to work anymore.

      That's because school's are run as a bureaucracy, which always seem to think they need the latest/greatest to justify the budget they're given. They don't, of course, but there's no incentive for them not to. (I learned the same basic WP/spreadsheet skills on an Apple ][e that would probably still run if they hadn't thrown it out. You don't need a 3GHz computer for that.) If they were privately funded, it would be a different story.

      But I'm getting off-track...

      This just means you have to do a little more work on your own. Dropping 'em on the school's curb is easy...anyone can do it. It takes more effort to meet people, build relationships with them, discover if they have a need you can help fill. I've collected a number of x100-era Macs from donors who know I fix them up and give them away, mostly to poorer kids from my church.

    2. Re:The whole recycling system needs to be built by 47PHA60 · · Score: 3, Informative

      The theme of my comment is how to effectively prevent the dumping of toxins into the environment.

      You are doing great work, but it only prevents those computers entering a landfill for another couple of years (or for Macs, make it 4 years).

      I disagree with you about the school problem. First of all, not every school is run the same way. Also, why should they be taking my old junk? Since an Apple ][ is good enough, why do I replace my computers? Personally, I do it because newer ones use less power and accomplish more work, I need to run Final Cut Pro and Photoshop, and I want Mac OS X which won't run on my old dual PII.

      The person buying a new machine, or his first machine, may only run e-mail, but he can't buy an old P75 easily, and he can get a new PC from Gateway for 400 USD. And, that old P75 will not run Windows XP. That is why I think the problem of toxins has to be dealt with on the supply side.

  10. Re:hmm by Lord+of+Ironhand · · Score: 3, Informative
    An MP3 server doesn't need to have the monitor on for more than maybe ten minutes per bootup, which saves quite a bit of electricity.

    It doesn't really need a videocard either. Or a harddisk, if you already have a server for other purposes that can provide an NFS root filesystem. My MP3 (or rather OGG) server is a Pentium 75 with a fanless lightweigh PSU, an AWE 64 Gold soundcard, a network card and a floppy drive for the kernel (which I could replace by a boot ROM if I ever get to it). As a side note, the lower CPU requirement for OGG decoding (vs. MP3) really shows on this system (any background task causes MP3 playback to stutter, while OGG playback still goes fine).

    Can anyone show me an easy-to-setup MP3 streamer for Linux?

    I simply installed Debian Sarge with some useful player programs. I can't give you a complete HowTo, but once you've got the base system running it should be trivial to browse through the Debian "sound" section of programs and find whatever you need.

  11. Re:reusing by __aagctu1952 · · Score: 5, Informative

    Except running a PC, especially without a monitor, probably draws less power than the light bulbs in your apartment. The "300W" you see on PC power supplies is just the peak power they can produce - normal usage doesn't even draw close to that. And there's also the fact that if you live in a cold climate, none of that energy is really wasted during 3 out of 4 of the year's seasons (it doesn't matter if you heat your apartment with oil power, electric radiators, light bulbs or a computer - the total amount of energy required for heating will still be the same).

  12. Re:reusing by squiggleslash · · Score: 2, Informative
    Define efficiency. Most older machines use less power overall, though megahertz for megahertz they use more power per cycle. But megahertz is only one part of the equation, and clearly if you're using a 3GHz Prescott (~100W just for the CPU alone) to power your firewall/router and PPPoE client (my 40MHz Sparc Classic does the job just fine, go OpenBSD!), then you're wasting power, massive amounts of power.

    If you need a seperate box, it's most efficient to use the lowest power-consumption one that can do the job it needs to do.

    --
    You are not alone. This is not normal. None of this is normal.
  13. Re:MP3 server by Bazzargh · · Score: 2, Informative

    That was my immediate reaction too. A bit of digging and I found out that the next firmware rev of the SqueezeBox will incorporate Wireless Wake-on-lan, so your mp3 server can be running on very low power when not in use, and your slimserver (or other wireless client) can kick it into life. Nifty.

  14. Re:Good Distros for older machines? by jawtheshark · · Score: 2, Informative

    I know you want Linux, but most modern distros (except Slackware and Debian who are highly customisable) are geared to at least P-III class machines. Do what I did, and try either NetBSD or OpenBSD. Small memory footprint (depending on what you run), and not much CPU usage. Of course, it's mostly meant as server usage. I never tried to make a desktop of OpenBSD or NetBSD.

    --
    Ahhh...the great dumpster continuum. Many a free computer will be found there. -- sowth (748135)
  15. mp3 server software by hateyerstate · · Score: 4, Informative

    As far as I know, not much people know about this, but if you plan on using your old machine as a server this will probably come in handy. http://www.gnu.org/software/gnump3d/

  16. Re:reusing by mafelixs · · Score: 2, Informative

    (it doesn't matter if you heat your apartment with oil power, electric radiators, light bulbs or a computer - the total amount of energy required for heating will still be the same).

    True for your house, yes. But not necessarily for the total amount of energy. If you heat your house with oil, almost all chemical energy in the oil is used to heat the house. But if you use electricity (be it through the computer or whatever), it takes much more energy to produce the same amount of (electric) energy, if it's produced in a fossile fuel power plant. A coal plant that only produces electricity has, what, 50% efficiency maximum(?). The rest of the energy is wasted in the process. If the electricity is produced in, say, a hydro plant, that's another story

  17. Re:hmm by stevey · · Score: 4, Informative

    I wrote that software, cheers for the pimping! As a small note though you should use either the GNU Address, or the gnump3d.org domain.

    Since it became part of the GNU Project everything was migrated away from SourceForge.

  18. Re:hmm by stevey · · Score: 2, Informative

    As a bit of self-promotion, since it was already mentioned:

    apt-get install gnump3d

    It's included in Debian's unstable distribution and will have you up and streaming in a matter of minutes.

  19. Re:How best to implement an MP3 server? by tarsi210 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Depending on what network sharing method you are using, you can usually have the protocol buffer some to avoid hiccups. I run an MP3 server that decodes from a fileserver across a 10Mbit link. NFS happily buffers the connection so not only do I get some insurance against network bumps but if the fileserver goes down, the player just blocks until it comes back up and then happily continues on its way. Works like a charm.

  20. Portland's "Free Geek" Recycling Effort by StefanJ · · Score: 4, Informative

    Portland, Oregon is home to "Free Geek," a really neat PC recycling / refurb effort:

    http://freegeek.org/

    They charge $5 to recycle a PC or monitor. If it has usable parts, they strip them out and use them to build Linux-loaded PCs for schools, nonprofits, and the like.

    Labor comes from volunteers. They will give you a PC for every six you build / refurb.

    Stefan

  21. Linux-Ecology-HOWTO (TLDP) by wehe · · Score: 2, Informative

    You may find much more tips and tricks how to use a computer with ecological awareness in the Linux-Ecology-HOWTO, which is also available at the The Linux Documentation Project - TLDP and in Japanese.

  22. go ahead by The+Tyro · · Score: 2, Informative

    Yes, you can hit OfficeMax, or Fry's, or Best Buy... and as you do, yet another computer goes into the landfill. Go ahead... purchase whatever black box you can buy the cheapest... but that's not what this article is about.

    Also, I'll wager the uber-cheap router you just purchased doesn't have any IDS capability (like Snort), or a cacheing proxy, or eye-candy graphs, or remote management via SSH, or any of the other nifty features that smoothwall offers.

    Yes, your hardware might not last... but the point is this: It still works. If you could keep it as a useful tool instead of turning it into a groundwater-polluting hazard, why wouldn't you?

    --
    Even if a man chops off your hand with a sword, you still have two nice, sharp bones to stick in his eyes.
  23. High Voltages by CyBlue · · Score: 2, Informative

    When they're taking them apart, becareful of the capacitors. I assume you're already aware, but they can hold a few hundred volts for quite some time. An old guy with a heart problem might have a bad day.