Slashdot Mirror


NASA Seeks Proposals For Hubble Robotic Servicing

hcg50a writes "SpaceFlight Now has an article about NASA asking for proposals to mount a robotic mission to service the Hubble Space Telescope. Such a Hubble-servicing mission would occur toward the end of calendar year 2007. If you like politics mixed with your spaceflight, you can read NASA Administrator O'Keefe's speech in which the announcement was made."

7 of 182 comments (clear)

  1. International Space Station by turgid · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Now, if only they would make some robots to operate and maintain the International Space Station, they wouldn't have to risk peoples' lives going there for political reasons, and they can wait until they have developed a safer and cheaper launcher and retire the travesty of engineering unholiness that is the Space Shuttle.

    Or they could just pay the Russians to launch all their astronauts...

  2. Re:JUST SEND A FUCKING HUMAN. by earthstar · · Score: 3, Interesting

    hey!
    It isnt jus the lost of life that is a problem! Even greater problem is that the Reputation of NASAis at stake.
    People would then only be talking that " The NASA doesnt know to b ring back their people alive... -so would other countries comment!

  3. Hope this works but... by Linus+Sixpack · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Another article I read mentioned decomissioning a lot. NASA needs to attach some sort of engine to hubble to be able to crash it safely where it wont kill anyone.

    I hope they are able to service it, but I think they might be more concerned with how its going to fall.

    ls

  4. Re:JUST SEND A FUCKING HUMAN. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I've got news for you. The most exciting thing humans have ever done in space - the moon missions - was exciting exactly once. By the Apollo 12 mission, lots of people were complaining to the TV networks that their programmes weren't on because of all the boring moon stuff. Apollo 13 raised the figures again, but I don't think you're really calling for an "all disaster, all the time" approach to manned spaceflight, are you?

    Modern day manned spaceflight is as boring as you like. "The crew are a mathematician, a different kind of mathematician, and a statistician" pretty much sums it up. Who cares?

    So manned spaceflight is

    a) a regular PR disaster
    b) boring when it isn't being disastrous
    c) scientifically pointless

    whereas robotic spaceflight is

    a) not a disaster
    b) no more boring than manned spaceflight
    c) scientifically useful

    Robots win!

  5. Nuts by pubjames · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Finally, NASA's space astronomy activities are integral to the President's vision of extending humanity's exploration and discovery horizons.

    I hate how everything has to be stated as if it was Bush's ideas and vision that pushes the country. Why couldn't he say "NASA's space astronomy activities are integral to our vision of extending humanity's exploration and discovery horizons." Bush is neither scientist nor visionary.

    It's like the joke that Bush is supreme commander of American troops -- a man who has no real military experience. If I was in the armed services I would find that insulting.

  6. It will be interesting to see. by howman · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The article leaves the possibilitys open for unmanned launch and repair/upgrade systems to be developed. I can see some of the teams from the autonomous challange, as covered to death here on /. in recent months, being quite interested in developing this technology.
    I am all for sending people into space as being there is part of the point, but I am very interested in the technology that will come out of these proposals over the next 20 years.
    If we look at some of the things that have made their way into our homes thanks to r+d from NASA, I can see a time when not only is may car built a la Minority report Lexus, but it can be repaired just as easily in the same fashion.
    Here, in Japan, we have these great car washes that you park your car under and they move from the front to the back cleaning and then drying. I don't know if they are around the US, I have not seen any in Canada, but it would be nice , when my car breaks down, or that crazy useless check engine light comes on, if I can just pull into one of these things, pop in my warranty card, and have the machine fix whatever is wrong with it.
    granted lots of hard working people, as we see the workforce right now, would lose their jobs if it were to all of a sudden come into being, but given time and reclasification of jobs, I think that in the same way typesetters became typests become data entry clerks, assembly line workers will become robotic assembly line technitions.
    On another note... I started to fully understand 'whither' about three quarters of the way through his speech...

    --
    flinging poop since 1969
  7. Price of Robot vs new Hubble by gdesignrr · · Score: 4, Interesting

    While a custom robot designed to repair the Hubble sounds cool, how much is something like that really going to cost, compared to ... say... a new Hubble?