Slashdot Mirror
Hi-speed USB2 Flash Drive Round-Up
An anonymous reader writes "Ars Technica has a USB
2.0 Flash drive review featuring 8 drives from different manufacturers. What's so interesting about the review is that not all Flash
drives are created equal. Some have very unique features while some are clearly
better than others. They also took a detailed look
inside one of the drives as well as put two
drives in a RAID-0 array (a la Mac OS X). Now that's cool!"
in a raid array has to be the geekiest thing I've ever heard of. What is this world coming to?
On the playground?
In a raincoat?
I'm just saying...
not always, in my office we share usb drives to save time, so far they're the handiest things i've found so far... but if you really need biomectrically locked drive that looks like an inkpen, go right ahead
The issue of durability and/or reliability wasn't addressed in the review but I have to say that I was impressed as hell when my Cruzer-mini went through both my washer and dryer with no apparent effect. That was several months ago and it still works great.
To ensure perfect aim, shoot first and call whatever you hit the target
Low Speed (1.5Mbps)
Full Speed (12Mbps)
Hi-Speed (480Mbps)
You are in a maze of twisted little posts, all alike.
Gotta love it. Remember this guy. He used USB floppies in pretty much the same manner. I actually emailed him because I was curious about portability(traveling kind). Apparently all the raid information is stored on the drives so the entire raid array could be plugged into another machine and would work with no problems.
NAND Flash is what's making this possible. It's denser and faster than NOR Flash.
If you haven't heard of MRAM, that's definitely another technology to be on the lookout for. According to IBM and Infineon Technologies, it's supposed to start shipping this year.
Basically, it has the density of DRAM, 15ns access time, and doesn't loses it's state even when powered down.
Google turns up some articles: here, here, and here.
Regarding the SanDisk Cruzer Mini, Ars Technica mentions:
Unfortunately, we were unable to ascertain the type and strength of encryption.
Apparently, even the product packaging neglects to mention it. Neither is it listed on SanDisk's website. It could be as simple as rot-13 or as complex as multiple cascading one-way secure pads with quantum elliptical entanglements. Do you dare probe further to figure out what it's doing? Certainly not; you could well violate the DMCA.
Now all we need is a small motherboard, lcd display + keyboard + network card, and we have a nice (cheap?) QUIET portable xterminal.
I Am My Own Worst Enemy
Conclusion
When we started this review, we only had an inkling of what we might come up with. By the time we finished, our perception that USB drives were a commodity was completely erased. While every USB Flash drive is essentially the same in that they carry data, they are all slightly different and not every drive will meet everyone's needs.
Drive summaries
PNY Attache: As drives go, this one was stylish and sturdy. It comes with a full assortment of accessories, including the USB extension cable and a neck strap. Aside from that, the drive itself is a rather lackluster offering. While much faster than any USB 1.1 device, the read and write speeds are rather slow for Hi-speed USB. The other unfortunate thing about this drive is the lack of extra software outside of the Windows 98 drivers. While it may be possible to find this drive for as little as US$15 to US$20 (after Mail-in-Rebate), it typically goes for US$30+. That is too expensive for such a mediocre drive. --- Score = 5/10
SanDisk Cruzer Mini: Of all the drives in this review, this drive is the thinnest. Some might even call it sexy, but we would not go that far. Unlike most other drives, it does not block dual-stacked USB ports in the slightest. Other positive things include the excellent LED visibility, good read/write scores, and it even works in unpowered USB hubs. Even the CruzerLock encryption software was solid and pretty easy to use. Some complaints would be the lack of a write-protect switch and that the plastic loop for the lanyard is rather weak. (It's fine for hanging around your neck, but it certainly is not load bearing in the least.) That said, the prices found for the 128, 256, and 512MB models make this a good deal. --- Score = 8/10
Mushkin Flashkin: We had mixed feelings about this drive. On one hand it offered a full complement of accessories and features, such as the standard neck strap, USB extension cable, write-protect switch, security software and it even worked in unpowered USB hubs. Yet despite this, everything about the drive felt like it was cheaply made and the security software felt like it was coded as an afterthought. The plastic body was very bulky and felt extremely hollow. On top of this, the slow read/write performance was troubling and the one-year warranty made us wonder how long this drive would last. Overall, the drive is not that bad, but what really lowered the score is that the price for the drive is more expensive than most of the other drives (which are notably better equipped.) --- Score = 6/10
SimpleTech Bonzai Xpress: This drive has the best physical design of the bunch. It is both strong and sturdy, yet still compact and a comfortable to carry. While it does not come with a USB extension, it does have a write-protect switch and some very helpful file synchronization software. What makes this USB drive especially nice is the strong read/write speeds, the solid two-year warranty, and the very nice price (considering how much is included.) --- Score = 9/10
Fujifilm USB Drive 2.0: Two words: speed demon. Without a doubt, this drive is fast! With top read speeds reaching 8.5MB/sec and write performance that destroyed the competition, this drive is perfect for anybody who is impatient or never seems to have enough time. Unfortunately, this drive has its drawbacks. The drive is the largest of the bunch, has no accessories included, no write-protect switch, no low-power support, and a higher price than most. Fortunately, it does come with decent security software and a lifetime warranty. --- Score = 8/10
Verbatim Store 'n' Go: In a nutshell, this drive was consistently above average. Never spectacular, but never terrible either. Read/Write performance is definitely strong, but nothing amazing. It comes equipped with neck strap, USB extension
Well, for those that are interested in the 'bulk' data, you can pickup a 1GB SanDisk Cruzer Mini for only $162 after an instant rebate...
m as terid=1956584/search=1gb%20usb
http://www.pricegrabber.com/search_getprod.php/
How about fixing USB 1.1 support in Linux first?
USB must be the crappiest kernel subsystem in existence: I can crash 2.4 in a number of ways just by plugging in and removing USB devices. Bug reports are being ignored, sometimes people sugggest moving to 2.6.
Well, 2.6 freezes dead hard when I plug in my USB audio device.
USB is the primary reason for the short (several days) uptime on my laptop.
Thou Shalt Not Use GIF for Screenshots!
f
http://arstechnica.com/reviews/004/flash/RAID0.gi
GIF really makes that screenshot look bad. The gradent in the window bar was reduced to just two colors and the icons and RAID tab are a dithered mess.
I've had a 256mb Fuji for 18 months now, and a 8mb DiskOnKey for 2 years before that (the Fuji is a re-branded DiskOnKey drive). The complaints from Ars Technica are only valid if you keep your flash drive on a lanyard. As I can't stand anything hanging off my neck (too much like a tie!), I keep mine clipped to my keyring. I've never had it come unclipped, nor have I lost the drive part (the clip is on the cover, not the drive itself). In fact, having the clip on the cover is very useful, as I can leave it connected to my keyring while the drive is in use.
I'm surprised the review didn't cover performance under GnuPG and PGP -- I keep my keyrings on it, as well as my Quicken backups. Plus tons of room left for mp3s to listen while at work. The SiSoft benchmarks are nice, but I'd like to know how slow/fast they are relative to an IDE drive.
Chip H.
But I'm wondering if they reviewed anything that was inside of this little beastie.
And if what some of the above posters have put up about washer/dryer incidents is true, you can STILL take it into the bath with you!
. . . as opposed to the UNIX influence, where everything is defined as a file.
If the cap/lid comes off, there goes your USB Flash HDD! SanDisk and others are smart to put on the Flash drive, not the cap/lid! My 512 GB PNY brand (not the same one in the article) has it on the cap! I don't bother to wear it on my neck anymore since I can lose it easily.
Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
Can you dual boot a bootable USB drive? Sounds like a fun way to waste a few hours....
Rob
FWIW: I have a MUVO NX (128MB, USB 1.1) and it rocks! The sound quality is great, I get at least 20 hours of play time on a single rechargable AAA battery, it's small, and durable. My only complaint is the headphones seem to be designed to tangle their wires as quickly as possible.
The MUVO TX was announced about a week after I bought my NX. Such is life with technology. Grrr....
You'd think this place was run by /. editors or sumptin.
I noticed that some of these flash drives have "write protect". However, I noticed that some manufacturers claim that Linux cannot use the write protect functionality:
" When you put the write-protect switch to "ON" position, you cannot write any file or data into the device. You still can view and read the files and data in the device. You can switch the "Write-Protect" switch even you do not disconnect the device. Due to Linux OS limitation, the write-protect switch will not work on-line."
Flash drive manual
But I see in status messages when people plug in the flash drives that it says "write protect is off".
Does anyone have experience with these products in Linux and whether write protect works with the flash drive connected?
Okay, troll. I normally don't read down at these depths, but since I had mod points which I'm now not going to use in this thread...
Riddle me this, asswipe. I have a hard drive in a computer. Let's say it's running Linux. Let's say I get another hard drive and I want to make it RAID 1 (mirrored) with the first drive. It's a 30 second operation in OS X, a 30 second operation in NT, a 60 second option in Win2k (gotta make it dynamic first).
How long will this operation take in Linux? Yes, you can use all three mouse buttons, and no, I don't have a backup....
I wish they had tested the PQI Intelligent Stick. It's the smallest drive around and looks pretty sweet. Pricing isn't bad either if you look on Froogle.
I guess I could always pick one up and return it if it sucks. But really, how much could it possibly suck as long as it works? I can't imagine I'm going to get horrible transfer speeds with it.
Need Free Juniper/NetScreen Support? JuniperForum
Actually, Win95 OEM SR2 was the first to support USB without third party support. It's commonly called Win95B.
The grass is only greener, if you don't take care of your own lawn.
I actually got in to discussion today about people wearing usb sticks in a neck strap.
Seems like there would be a considerable market niche for stylish sticks. None of the drives I've seen look ugly but it would be nice to see some real variety. Something little bit more unique.
So does anyone make something "special"..?
Um, yes, the article did mention the impact of size on stacked ports. Several times in fact.
Actually, we didn't ignore it. The article was focused strictly on Hi-speed USB 2.0 Flash drives. I don't know if you're aware of how many USB devices there are on the market, but there are a ton. If we had included the Muvo TX, then we would have had to include like a hundred other devices.
Anyway, we are planning a follow-up article which will feature more exotic USB devices such as the one you mentioned.
Cheers!
Actually, you're thinking of OSR 2.5 that comes with USB and AGP support.
Win95b (OSR 2.0) only added FAT32 and other minor improvements. It does not support USB without a patch.
Man is the animal that laughs.
And occasionally whores for Karma.
We didn't review it for a few reasons.
1) We wanted to focus on USB 2.0 Hi-speed devices (the link you have is for the slower "full speed" - a.k.a USB 1.1)
2) We wanted embedded memory drives only. Upgradable models would have made the article more confusing.
But don't worry, we have a follow-up article in the works that will feature more exotic devices.
As a floppy replacement they are great. I've had mine since the middle of Janurary. My kids have gotten ahold of it a few times and it has survived that I used to carry it in my pocket now I just carry it in my bag it seens to work fine. But here is the thing that you mentioned that is just what it is a a floppy/burning less than 256 meg to a cd replacement. For example I use mine to carry music between work and home. I use it to grab config files off of machines that are on another network/domain. I use it for putting VPN clients on lusers machines that aren't on the network. In short I use it for temporary storage and transfer where doing it that way is faster/easier than doing it over the network. Sometimes I do it just to impress chicks. :) But I would never use it for long term storage of anything I care about and don't have in another spot, they just aren't designed for that. But then again back in the day I know plenty of folks who would do just that with floppies.
:) Count your blessings.
Wish I could get work to buy me another one.
Cypherpunks: Civil Liberty Through Complex Mathematics. Those who live by the sword die by the arrow.
How about selling something like Knoppix on a USB drive? It'd boot faster, fit in your pocket, not need a CDROM drive, allow for customization by being re-writable, and you could keep some of your data files on it. Even better, if you eventually decide that you don't want to use Knoppix, you get a handy USB drive...
I love my MuVo. It's small and works great with Linux. You can store any file on it, but only MP3 or WMA files show up in the song list. The MuVo NX and the MuVo TX look good too if you need more storage capacity.
You would think that if it's a 256meg drive then you would know the size, 256 megs, right? But marketing has struck again, I've found that 32 meg drivs I have actually seem to have about 30 megs of space on them, and vary by drive. A 64 meg device is also short several megs (as are some flash cards I have). I would have found it really handy if the reviewer had bothered to tell us how much space each of these devices really delivers.
I'm an American. I love this country and the freedoms that we used to have.
I built a RAID5 array from jaz drives! It was the only way to get ANY reliability out of them! :D
-Foxxz
Every object in the universe is unique, for if two objects were identical in every way, they would be the same object. Furthermore, no objects are unique because they all have something in common with every other object: they are all unique.
Degrees of uniqueness exist because there are different contexts for evaluating an object's differences from its peers. Every evaluation has a context within which it has more than two degrees.
If one in a billion oranges looks like Elvis, that's pretty unique. If one in a billion of those Elvis-shaped oranges is a life-sized bust of The King, that's an extremely unique orange. The uniqueness of the non-bust Elvis oranges is not undermined by discovering another instance because within the context of people's knowledge of oranges, two Elvis oranges would be rare enough as to be unique from an individual's point of view.
Absolute uniqueness is only a useful concept in abstract contexts like math and philosophy. In the real world we use the word loosely within implicit or explicit contexts which give the seemingly redundant expression 'very unique' a meaning which is different from other degrees of uniqueness.
People who fall into this trap often also argue that
* Black is not a color (it is not a hue, but it is a color)
* Zero is not a number (it is not a counting number, but it is a number)
* A logical statement must either be true, false, or a paradox (it depends on what you mean by 'logical', 'statement', 'true', etc.)
So yes, something can be 'very unique', or only 'slightly unique'.
Personally, I think they should all be renamed to the following:
The official Swiss Army Knife company has come out with a USB flash drive enabled Knife. If I didnt already own a SanDisk this would be the one I'd get. They seem to be decently priced for Victorinox at $70 for 64 megs. http://www.victorinox.com/newsite/en/news/news_swi ssmemory.htm
-val1s