Slashdot Mirror


India Debating Manned Space Flight

alphakappa writes "India's moon mission and other space programs have been covered before on Slashdot. India is now debating sending a manned space mission and has acknowledged it's technological preparedness to do so in the next 6-7 years if given the go-ahead. The issues being debated before starting work on the mission include cost-benefit and other space priorities. (These missions also play host to international experiments) What does the general slashdot crowd think of these space plans?"

17 of 406 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Does Anyone else have this image. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    only in the same way that whenever the ISS is mentioned I expect them to be widening the doors to accommodate americans' girth

  2. I for one by John_Allen_Mohammed · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    hope that the Indians and Chinese both send manned missions to space, the moon and mars. I'm frankly sick of all the damned jingoism and nationalist fever in the red states.. please, india and china, stick it to the "greatest nation" in the universe. Seeing chinese astronauts walking on Mars will be the greatest blow to american jingoism and self delusion, ever.

    --

    Skype Me! username: john_allen_mohammed
    1. Re:I for one by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait
      I for one would rather see them walking anywhere except in America! And as for outsourcing...I'm all for it! In fact, I'd like to outsource my foot right up your ass!


      You prick!

    2. Re:I for one by xott · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      I think this is a great development also.
      Making sure that the vastness of space does not end up W.A.S.P. is very important.
      Very little of the Earth's population is white, even fewer of any religon at all, yet nearly all astronauts have come from this group. (Tokenism notwithstanding).

      The greater variety of people to enter space, the greater amount to survive any threatening situation. I say, Go India

  3. Here's a q by scaaven · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Can a turban fit inside a space helmet?

    --
    I know I'm going to be modded up on this
  4. I can see the future .... by dustpuppy · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    and it is a future of hordes of Indian 'cab-drivers' piloting the equivalent of SpaceShip One back and forth between earth and orbit .... not to mention they will be the first to open a 'Kwik-e-mart' aboard the ISS. Thank you, please come again!

  5. Good way to test ICBM technology by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    This way the nationalist, expansionist Indian goverment can threaten The USA, China and the Muslims and make it sound peaceful.

    Good thing their second tier engineers are writing Java code here in the US as H1-B indentured servants.

  6. How about they work on... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Indoor plumbing for everyone...
    Spread the idea of soap and paper towels for cleanliness...
    Inform the people that picking your nose while talking to people is impolite...

  7. slight math error by RealProgrammer · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Sorry, this is a government project. Every attempt to decrease costs results in their doubling. You'll have to adjust your figures somewhat, but in the end it shouldn't be significant (as governments caluculate things).

    Since it's a government project, only the highest quality will be acceptable. These jobs must be outsourced to the People's Rebublic of China, where quality is ... more easily controlled.

    In response, the Germany will attack Poland and the French will surrender to Belgium.

    --
    sigs, as if you care.
  8. Re:not trying to be flamebait but by vk2 · · Score: 0, Flamebait
    Read this and come back and tell me where did US find the WMD. Program is just an intent and not actual weapons.

    If weapons were the central issue - why the Bush gov is not invading North Korea - where its believed they have the weapons material and means to parcel it near the US.

    Accept it - this WAR was just for oil and nothing else.

    --
    No Sig for you.!
  9. Re:Go for it by LWATCDR · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    There was a great joke once on Johnny Carson. "A cure for dysintary, literacy, and indoor plumbing. Name three things India needs more than nuclear weapons." India is buying SU-27s fighters, renting an Oscar Class SSGN, and working on building it's own aircraft carrier. All of which are more of a waste of money than space travel. I love the old we should spend the money on the problems on earth first line. What a load. As to the US not being an example. Also a crock that could only come from someone that has never been two a third world nation. Just for the record the US's Space program is under 1% of the budget. Maybe just maybe if India puts more effort into space they will put a little less effort into nukes, aircraft carriers, and subs. Come on India I dare you, you backward 3rd world nation try and put a person in to orbit, try to go to the moon, I bet you can't match what the US did over 40 years ago. What the EU still has not done on it's own yet. I bite my thumb at thee.
    And I hope all your crews come back safe, and that you reach a little farther.

    --
    See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
  10. Late night talks shows called harmful by Nexus7 · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    I mean, c'mon, you have a Slashdot OD, would it be too much to get your opinions from someplace other than a late night talk show?

    What effing good would eradicating illiteracy do to India if they're ruled by the Chinese, as in Tibet? It's strawman to begin with, because the Indians are debating whether or not to put a man on the moon, unlike Kennedy, who declared we would (to one up the CCCP, among other things).

    Besides, to address your silly lil' list:
    dysentery : India's already got the largest first class drug industry in the world; they're not the ones who are out of anthrax and flu vaccines

    literacy : They're not the ones teaching creationism (intelligent design) in school

  11. Re:not trying to be flamebait but by b-baggins · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Because we all know that we should only wait until the planes are actually flying into the buildings before taking any action.

    The cognitivie dissonance the left engages in never ceases to amaze.

    Bush is incompetent for not preventing 9/11. Bush is a warmonger for trying to prevent another 9/11 from Iraq.

    Bush is incompetent for not dealing unilaterally with North Korea. Bush is incompetent for dealing unilaterally with Iraq. Bush is incompetent for not invading Iran to stop their nuclear program. Bush is incompetent for invading Iraq to stop their nuclear program.

    Want to spot a liberal? Look for the guy pressing his hands against his temples trying to keep his head from exploding from all the contradictions he's shoving into his brain.

    --
    You can tell a great deal about the character of a man by observing those who hate him.
  12. Re:not trying to be flamebait but by phloydde1 · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    howdy..
    I was just wondering which right-wing radio/tv talk show host you swiped those comments from.

    I'm not saying you can't think for yourself, just saying I've heard this spiel before.

    Us 'liberals' do hold multiple contradictions in our head. Why? because we think issues through and judge them on their own merit according to the information we have!

  13. Re:not trying to be flamebait but by banzai51 · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Please outline again how IRAQ had anything to do with 9/11? Oh wait, you can't. But yet another incompetent conservative that won't let the actual facts of a situation guide his actions. The cognitive dissonance of the right is nothing short of sad.

  14. Re:Considering.... by Electric+Eye · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Well, as I said you idiot, I HAVE BEEN THERE. And, no, maybe not all of the people there are poor, but a majority of them are. You want to know how hard it was to even get a phone call out of there to the US? How about how long it took my lungs to recover from an 11-day trip? How about my plane being delayed for hours because of poor visibility...due to dense pollution in Mumbai?

    You try to pin me as this teeny-bopper cyber dork, but you're the ignorant one. I've seen a good portion of the country FIRST HAND, as I'm sure you certainly have not. Much of it was beautiful, but what had been touched by human hands had been virtually destroyed.

  15. bullshit. fucking telugu moron by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    telugus are the most uneducated smelly morons on earth.

    northies know english. southies dont know any YINGLISH.

    lol... you must be a dosa-eating monkey. mf.