Slashdot Mirror


Is Atlas Holding Hipparchus' Lost Star Map?

cr0kin0le writes "The Farnese Atlas at the Naples National Archaeological Museum may be holding a celestial globe which accurately depicts the long-lost star catalog of Hipparchus, according to a physics professor at Louisiana State University."

22 of 421 comments (clear)

  1. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Probably an american thing.

    Remember this is the country that ground to a virtual halt at the sight of half a breast.

  2. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    How do you stop your kids from seeing their own genitalia?

    I bet they sneek a peek at it when they take a piss.

  3. Re:Interesting stuff by dn15 · · Score: 3, Insightful
    That's because most people now have better things to do than look up in the sky at night. Those people of the past didn't really have much else to entertain themselves with.
    Yes, people have much better things to do today. Why waste time learning stuff when you have an Xbox and the next episode of The Bachelorette is almost on?
  4. the amazing chaldeans by xconfig · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Reading this story, the most amazing thing to me was to think of the Chaldeans of Babylon laboriously making observations over at least half a millenium, before Hipparchus came along. Beats the story of Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler and Isaac Newton.

    1. Re:the amazing chaldeans by gilroy · · Score: 4, Insightful
      Blockquoth the poster:

      Beats the story of Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler and Isaac Newton.

      Ah, yes, yet another tale wherein the ancient peoples outdo their modern imitators. Except for the whole "found a system of the world wherein the mode of learning is a self-correcting, self-perpetuating mechanism that leads to heights, depths, and breadths of knowledge undreamt of four centuries ago, much less twenty."

      I don't know much about the Chaldeans' observations, so I'll concede that they might have outstripped Tycho. But I'm fairly certain that they did not point out that the planets move in ellipses with the Sun at one focus, or that the orbits of any planet sweeps out equal areas in equal time, or that the period of a planet's orbit is proportional to the 3/2 power of its distance from the Sun (OK, technically, its semi-major axis). So, advantage: Kepler.

      And I am absolutely certain that they did not then note that a universal attraction of each planet for the others actually pulls them off said ellipses and causes a more complex motion -- let alone actually providing a method to correct for this -- oh, and incidentally, crafting a system of mechanics that not only allows one to build skyscrapers and suspension bridges but leads to investigations and methods that eventually discover electromagnetism, relativty, and quantum mechanics.

      So I think advantage: Newton, as well.

      The ancients were not idiots. They were just as smart as we are today. But they knew less than we do about the physical universe and they didn't have a system even remotely similar to science, that allowed a steady and self-correcting accumulation of knowledge. I can honestly not understand the apparently fervent need of many to worship at the altar of mist-enshrouded nameless ancestors, who "have" to be better than the well-documented founders of the modern world.
  5. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by FrYGuY101 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Probably not. They all use stock photos, even the Greek.

    Remember the saying "Never attribute to malice what can be sufficiently explained by stupidity"? Yeah, works for sloth too.

    --
    "If we let things terrify us, life will not be worth living."

    - Seneca
  6. Re:Interesting stuff by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Most people then didn't have a working knowledge that came close to matching it, either.

  7. The Simpsons are bad? by Savage-Rabbit · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Guess that explains the Simpsons. What about the other 290 million?


    Ok, Homer turns to drink once in a while, but in which episode(s) did Bart rob a bank, Lisa become a pregnant crack addict and Marge become a whore?

    --
    Only to idiots, are orders laws.
    -- Henning von Tresckow
  8. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by herrison · · Score: 1, Insightful

    It worries me that if (as seems likely), the NYT can publish an altered photograph without indicating that it's effectively a montage - what else might have been changed?

    --
    You know what I miss? Leeches.
  9. Re:Old charts interesting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    And what wonders can we see (Mars, Titan, Venus, etc etc, everything seen by the HST, CXB, etc etc) which they could never have imagined?

    And our children 100 generations from now, what will they know that we cannot imagine?

    Hell, I will never have children, but if I did, I know they, just ONE generation from now, would know far, far more about the universe than I can possibly imagine. I hope I live to see some of it myself.

  10. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by Slur · · Score: 5, Insightful

    No, the prudish Americans are a tiny minority - bordering on a myth, really.

    The media props up this mythical form of being in order to Disney-fy the airwaves and make anyone who lives a normal flawed human lifestyle feel like a depraved piece of shit. This helps to prop up those capitalist endeavors that rely on a cowed populus, such as the snack industry, the advertising industry, and the defense industry.

    The underlying aim of the media is to teach ordinary Americans that they are in constant danger of being demonized as outsiders. They are told they can escape this alienation by joining the mass-consciousness. All they need do is practice the dubious virtues of jingoism and an unquestioning submission to authority and they will be accepted, loved, and embraced by the status-quo. ...They also have a lot to say about the relative value of light-skinned blonde daughters versus black-skinned kinky-haired daughters....

    --
    -- thinkyhead software and media
  11. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by R.Caley · · Score: 5, Insightful
    I have two young children and I absolutely WILL NOT put up with them being shown any nudity without my permission.

    I presume you put blindfolds on them when they shower in case they should happen to look down without asking first?

    I think the outraged reaction to the Janet Jackson things was funnier. After all, the primary purpose of breasts is to be presented to young children. How is someone who spent much of the most delicate period of their post-birth brain development with a breast the size of their head shoved in their face going to be adversely affected by a glipse of nipple?

    --
    _O_
    .|<
    The named which can be named is not the true named
  12. about astrology by dario_moreno · · Score: 2, Insightful

    This map also reminds us that astrology is complete bullshit since due to equinox precession ("wobbling" in the article) zodiac signs have changed once since the Romans and twice since the Egyptians devised occidental astrology. Makes the system of prediction wrong in principle...

    --
    Google passes Turing test : see my journal
  13. Re:Actually, the Americans have the better deal by thempstead · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Urm, whilst it may be illegal to do those things in _some_ contries in Europe, (in the first case Germany and the second France (i think)), but that does not mean that its illegal to do so all over Europe.

    In the first case it may e considered in bad taste everywhere though ...

    t

  14. Re:Interesting stuff by VanillaCoke420 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    They could do it, too. Nowadays there's so much light pollution. To go to a dark place during a night with a clear sky will give you quite a sight. Everyone should be able to experience that.

  15. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by superyooser · · Score: 2, Insightful
    A friend of mine showed me an interesting essay that starts with a mention of the Jackson wardrobe malfunction, and goes into European culture, morality, the censorship of art, and other issues.

    Freedom and Decency -- Here's a sentence pulled from the middle.

    Is good art suppressed more by rules of public decency (even when applied with a heavy hand) or by the barbarism of a culture whose sensibilities have become so debauched by constant exposure to the scabrous and the vile as to have become incapable of any discrimination, or of any due appreciation of subtlety or craft?
  16. Slahdot is going downhill by Merdalors · · Score: 5, Insightful
    This is a good example of how Slashdot is degenerating into irrelevance.

    The Farnese Atlas is an interesting example of [1] lost knowledge being rediscovered, [2] ancient wisdom forgotten during the Dark Ages, and what do we get?

    ... nattering about pee-pees.

    --
    Slashdot entertains. Windows pays the mortgage.
  17. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by benzapp · · Score: 2, Insightful

    But the problem is Chinamen are oriental mongoloids. The majority of people in Asia are in fact Caucasian. Saying "Asian Americans" more likely refers to Russians, Arabs, Turkic peoples, and Indians than orientals of any type.

    Just as a Scotsman is a man from Scotland, a Chinaman is a man from China. If it is the racial category that concerns you, "Asian American" is about as inaccurate as you can possibly get.

    --
    I don't read or respond to AC posts
  18. Re:Obsessed with wieners by lxs · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I mean, why were these guys so obsessed with sculpting wieners?

    They hadn't invented dick jokes yet? But seriously, when you're depicting the human body, why not make it anatomically correct? The hands are sculpted realistically, so why not the rest of the body. Don't forget that in the classical world, before thousends of years of christian puritanism, nudity was no big deal. Why were they obsessed with long hair? Why were they obsessed with feet?

    In this case I'm afraid you're the one obsessed with "wieners", they tend to (excuse the phrase) jump out at us, simply because we don't often see them depicted in everyday life.

  19. So much for astronomy by hcdejong · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Browsing at +1, the topic contains 181 comments in 3 threads. The majority (like, 175 comments) are in "What's up with the modified statue", discussing a frigging fig leaf.
    # of comments saying "Cool that we found this ancient star map", or otherwise even remotely related to astronomy: zero.
    (yeah, I know, "this is /., what else did you expect")
    So I'll say it: Cool that we found this ancient star map. Pity we don't have Hipparchus' complete works, though.

  20. Re:Don't be ridiculous. by Abcd1234 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Agreed. Truly dark sky sites are very hard to come by these days. The real problem, IMHO, is that, because they're so hard to come by, very few people no what a truly dark sky looks like! Thus, like the grandparent, they think a field an hour from a major metropolitan area constitutes a dark sky site.

    The secondary effect of this is that astronomers have a hell of a time convincing people that light pollution is a problem, because a) they don't understand *why* it's a problem, and b) they don't understand the sheer magnitude of the issue. The only bright side (no pun intended) is that the astronomers have economic forces in their corner (you can save money if you stop radiating half of your artificial light out into space).

  21. Re:What's up with the modified statue? by Vitriol+Angst · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The media seems to love controversy in France as much as America it seems.

    I would compare this to my Father-In-Law's opinion. He is Peruvian and learned English after coming to America. When the issue came up about a state language in Florida, he was strongly for kids being forced to learn English. I thought that was strange at first, but he said that they'd never get a good job if they didn't. I have to agree, if his daughter and I didn't speak the same language, we would never have met. There are times to self express and other times to not. But does a Burka really help these kids in school? It seems to me that they can respect or not their own religion with or without it. But with it, they are seperated from others.

    Of course, as an expression of modesty, it may be important to them. But personally, I see it as a way that has kept women as second class citizens in their culture--I may be ignorant, but that is my impression. I just think as kids, these people need to get to know each other before they get the chance to exclude eachother. Heck, I have a hard time being comfortable around neocons. Imagine if we had real differences?

    --
    >>"ad space available -- low rates!!!"