Slashdot Mirror


Old Film to DVD Transfers Examined

Richard W.M. Jones writes "Slate is running an interesting article on the process involved in Warner Brothers remastering films, the quality of the films being compared to the Criterion Collection discs. Going back to the original technicolor negatives, preserved in temperature-controlled rooms, the transfer begins with a 4,000 line scan, followed by digital alignment of each color." From the article: "In some ways, these DVDs have finer color and detail than even the original film prints. In the old days, it was difficult to align those three strips perfectly. The task became still harder years later, when the films were reissued, because the negatives had stretched or shrunk over time. If you need all three strips to get the right color, and you can't line the strips up precisely, then the colors and the sharpness are going to be a bit off."

16 of 306 comments (clear)

  1. important by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    First, there was a plan: how to bring together the different development groups at work? My boss said there was a sort of tension he thought could be eased by some social interaction. Not easy. Almost all of the different development groups despised each other, each thinking its "art" was more important and eloquent than the others'.

    There was the kernel extension developer group, coding mostly in C and some PowerPC and x86 assembler. They worked on making our PCI board work with Linux, *BSD, Mac OS X, QNX, and Solaris. They worked "special hours," coming in at one and staying late, supposedly, until seven or eight at night. They enjoyed Red Bull and had a penchant for ThinkGeek t-shirts and cracking jokes about Win32 API calls and the dreaded Blue Screen of Death.

    We had XML developers too. They worked on our website, documentation formatting, and simple apps to configure the driver software. They used HTML, XSL, JavaScript, and a bit of Java. They typically dressed casually, drank coffee and tea, and liked to work straight from the spec: no "Learn XSL in 30 Days" books were to be found in their cubicle farm.

    Then we had the guys who wrote full-out UNIX apps. These guys and the products they wrote had been acquired from another company, and were the source of most of the tension: they'd never really been integrated into our group except that they were physically present with the rest of us. They all had beards or mullets or long, unwashed hair. Many wore suspenders or the afore-mentioned ThinkGeek clothes; some even had Penguin tatooes or small C app code tattooed on them. Their cubicle farm was known for the bleating laughter that exploded when one of them found a "silly" bug on someone else's code, and for the rotten, fetid stench that could only be compared to three-day-old shit reeking from inside a rotting corpse's abdominal cavity.

    So, in order to get the guys to "know each other" my boss had asked me to organize a during-hours, alcohol-friendly party. My ideas ranged from a keg or two to live entertainment, AKA strippers. But as to what to get them to actually talk to each other in a human manner I had no clue. So I let it go til the last minute and decided to let my inherent creativity mull it over in the back of my head.

    When the day of the party had arrived, the catering company brought in a few trays of lunch meat, chicken, pizza, and side dishes, I had picked up the kegs (all four) from the local brewery, and the big-screen TV and DVD were set up ready to blast the Matrix into the eyes and ears of my co-workers. The eagerness in the the air was encouraging and I thought that loosening up and smiles going on even now were a good sign. I even saw some of the guys who'd known each other previously begin to bunch up, bringing along the co-workers they knew from everyday work.

    The first thing everyone did was hit the food line, loading up their plates and grabbing a cup for beer to wash it down with. A few approached me and thanked me for the food; it seems appeasing the belly really did tame the beast. After a few minutes of silence and eating and a few second and third courses, they guys were ready to sit down and be entertained. After asking if anyone needed anything else before the movie started, the lights went out and the Matrix began playing. I heard a few enthusiastic comments and jokes being told.

    About half-way through the movie I noticed a lot of the guys, especially from the UNIX app group, were getting up and presumably going to the restroom. No suprise, as the second keg was history by now and the third was probably half-way gone. I also noticed some of the guys bumping into things and stumbling. Alcohol's the social lubricant, eh? Well, not long after, my bladder beckoned and I answered. As I made my way to the restroom, I had a self-satisfied smile on my face: my little plan was working, my boss would be happy, and it might even a Christmas bonus or a promotion (even if in title only).

    Well, as soon as I

  2. Damn doctors... by Avyakata · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    "...then the colors and the sharpness are going to be a bit off."

    I guess I never really needed that surgery after all...

    1. Re:Damn doctors... by lucabrasi999 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Sorry about the offtopic. I thought that was pretty funny, myself.

  3. damn you, MPAA! by geoffspear · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How dare you keep those negatives locked in a temperature-controlled room? Movies want to be FREE!

    --
    Don't blame me; I'm never given mod points.
    1. Re:damn you, MPAA! by goofyspouse · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Free as in beer, or free as in ice cream?

    2. Re:damn you, MPAA! by pixelpusher220 · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      either...neither are very good warm ;-)


      --
      People in cars cause accidents....accidents in cars cause people :-D
  4. Who gives a shit? by anonicon · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Yeah, nice article on the transfar and cleaning process, but really, who gives a shit? We won't be able to record them, and we'll have the pleasure of sucking from our master's teet to view them on our FCC- and Corporate-approved viewing stations.

    Someone wake me up when the content industries don't insist on being a bunch of monopolitive, skull-fucking assholes and *then* I might care about restored, super duper restorations.

  5. Re:Digital mapping of film grain? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Yeah, once you get Geordi in the holodeck, it's virtually assured you can recreate an entire scene from the shadow of a grain of dust on some alien's mole.

  6. Re:I wonder what kind of noise removal they're usi by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    suck m y dick you little fag

  7. Re:Who Cares? by Oliver+Defacszio · · Score: 0, Offtopic
    Yes! Today's movies are innovative thinkpieces that absolutely do not exist solely to further the career of whom (or what) ever is "starring" and to add another layer of cash to the pockets of the producing studio.

    Tee hee.

    --

    -
    Inventor of the term 'pardon my French'.
  8. How to be a good slashdot reader or moderator. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How to be a good slashdot reader or moderator:

    * Linux is fucking great. The best operating system in the
    world. Everyone should start using it. You are an exception though,
    because you need to use Windows for games, using websites with video
    on them, and MS Office (for compatibility of course). You spend a
    decent amount of time fucking around with your window manager
    settings and trying to make hardware work in Linux though, of
    course.

    * Macs are also great. You can't understand why anyone would use
    anything else. You've read loads of slashdot posts about how good OS
    X is, but you've never used it yourself.

    * AMD is currently winning the performance battle against Intel, and
    this is fucking great. While Intel are a vile corporate entity, AMD
    fights for the good of humanity. Everything Intel has ever produced
    has always been utter crap which runs at a ridiculously high
    temperature (the high-end Athlon XPs don't count). That's why you
    only buy AMD - anyone who doesn't is an Intel fanboy.

    * Everything should be Open Source. Mainly because it's inconvienient
    for you to download commercial software off bittorrent and find the
    crack for it.

    * Competition is good, except when it's against Linux. Solaris is
    therefore crap. You've never used it, or even seen it working, but
    you have read plenty of slashdot posts to know that it's crap. It's
    pretty disgusting that Sun doesn't want people ripping bits out of
    it and putting them into Linux for you too.

    * Everyone should buy hardware that's fully compatible with Linux, to
    show the vendors that they should support it. You had to buy that
    ATI card though, because it gave you an extra 10fps on Half-Life 2.

    * Every human being on the planet has the right to download music and
    films - information wants to be free. The RIAA/MPAA are utter
    bastards for trying to do anything about it. Violation of the GPL,
    however should be punnishable by death.

    1. Re:How to be a good slashdot reader or moderator. by nick8325 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Shh! Don't let the secret out!

  9. I like these DVD's by agent · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Keep the South Strong.
    http://www.timelife.com/heehaw
    http://ww w.imdb.com/title/tt0068473/

    No more lighters on the planes.
    http://connected.msnbc.com

  10. Re:I know it's possible by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    "22 fans, 10 freaks. 32 people with too much free time "

    So what does it say about you that you have way more friends/foes than fans/freaks?

    To me, it says you're a jackass.

  11. DOS suit by Varg+Vikernes · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I don't know why Slashdot rejected my story but the creator of the DOS operating system is suing a book author, because he wrote DOS was simply a rip-off of CP/M. Paterson, 48 and now retired, alleges that Evans' facts misrepresent history. He told the Seattle Post-Intelligencer his goal with the lawsuit is to get the truth out. The lawsuit filed in U.S. District court in Seattle seeks unspecified monetary damages. This could be big and might involve even Microsoft. http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2005-03-02-ms-co ding-dis_x.htm

  12. Re:I know it's possible by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    it says he's far, far cooler than you are.

    the fact you have a stick up your anus over his sigline proves this fact conclusively.