Slashdot Mirror


Museum Director Indicted for Stealing NASA Artifacts

NBrooke271 writes "Max Ary, former Director of the Kansas Cosmosphere, has been hit with an eleven-count federal indictment, charging that he sold NASA space artifacts on loan to the museum, including an astronaut's in-flight T-shirt, a control panel from Air Force One and an Apollo 12 water valve for a personal profit of around $180,000. 'Mr. Ary, on behalf of the Cosmosphere, continued to sign documents reporting and verifying to NASA that the watch was still in its possession and collection,' said U.S. Attorney Eric Melgren. Ary currently serves as the Executive Director of Omniplex Science Museum in Oklahoma City, where he has taken a leave of absence. Read official statements from the Cosmosphere, the Omniplex, and Ary's attorney regarding the indictment."

52 of 178 comments (clear)

  1. Watch? by ackthpt · · Score: 5, Informative
    'Mr. Ary, on behalf of the Cosmosphere, continued to sign documents reporting and verifying to NASA that the watch was still in its possession and collection,' said U.S. Attorney Eric Melgren.

    What 'watch'?

    The NASA Omega Mock-up Watch 38. Sometime prior to January of 2000, the exact date being unknown to the Grand Jury, the Cosmosphere loaned several artifacts to a space exhibit in the Philippines. The Cosmosphere became aware that some of these items were lost or damaged when some of the items were returned on or about April 1998. The items loaned to the Philippine exhibit included: a Shuttle In-flight garment, a Russian Soyuz Space Suit, American Space Food (five packages), an Apollo Liquid Cooling garment, a Beta cloth stowage bag, an Omega 17
    mock-up watch, an astronaut ink pen, a Gemini spacesuit, an Apollo In-flight garment. 39. The Omega astronaut watch was a mock-up watch that the Cosmosphere had received pursuant to an exhibit loan agreement from NASA.

    Sounds more like mismanagement, if it was still reported as present, yet missing or damaged.

    Though a href="http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/ks/press/apr2005/a pril7a.html">this looks pretty damning and has more of the detail.

    --

    A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
    1. Re:Watch? by 14erCleaner · · Score: 3, Funny
      an Omega 17 mock-up watch

      Thank god he didn't sell off the Omega 13!

      --
      Have you read my blog lately?
  2. Conversion? by tektek · · Score: 4, Funny

    How much is that in $2 bills?

    1. Re:Conversion? by TheViffer · · Score: 5, Funny

      Still $180,000.

      --
      -- Knowing too much can get you killed, but knowing who knows too much can make you rich.
  3. A properly embedded link.. sigh. by ackthpt · · Score: 2, Informative
    Link to DoJ charges

    I'd personally like to thank the people who made sure the keyboard loses USB focus (or whatever it is) every few seconds and drops keystrokes.

    --

    A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
    1. Re:A properly embedded link.. sigh. by TheViffer · · Score: 4, Funny


      A nose cone.
      A NASA silk screen
      A photographic spot meter
      An RX3 spacesuit component.
      Apollo 8 silk screens.
      An Apollo 11 silk screen.
      An Apollo13 bus bar battery cable that had been flown in space.
      A sextant crown assembly that had been flown in space.
      An in-flight crew shirt.
      An Air Force One control panel.
      A Noun 70 Code panel, loaned to the Cosmosphere by NASA that had been flow in space. It sold for $3,400. On April 4, 2001, Ary signed a report to NASA falsely stating the panel was still in the museum's collection.
      An Apollo 12 water shut-off valve that had been flown in space.
      A rotation controller.
      A purge valve for a spacesuit.
      A film canister.


      Makes me want to go buy an airplane/auto salvage yard and Ebay off parts as "possible relics of the Soviet space program" which "may possibly" have crash landed in Bumfluck, Nebraska.

      "No, No sir, that's not a hub cap from a 1971 Duster, thats the nose to Sputnik!"

      --
      -- Knowing too much can get you killed, but knowing who knows too much can make you rich.
    2. Re:A properly embedded link.. sigh. by ackthpt · · Score: 3, Funny
      Makes me want to go buy an airplane/auto salvage yard and Ebay off parts as "possible relics of the Soviet space program" which "may possibly" have crash landed in Bumfluck, Nebraska.

      How about that guy in Florida, years ago (IIRC) who found a depleted uranium nose cone in his junk yard. He thought it made neat sparks when he hit it with a screw driver.

      Be the govt would go ape-sh!t if something like that moved through the mail.

      Mr Beasely: "Your package sure is heavy, Dagwood, what's in it?"
      Dagwood: "About 20 pounds of uranium."

      --

      A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
  4. I used to work for this guy by NBrooke271 · · Score: 5, Informative

    Submitter here. Incidentally, I used to work at the Omniplex when Mr. Ary was in charge. We were very excited when he came to the museum; we had heard that he practically built the Cosmosphere with his bare hands. He pioneered the Smithsonian Affiliate program, one of the best ways for museums to get their hands on great government collections. This indictment has come as a shock to everyone.

    --
    Free messageboards and more! Your girlfriend's seen myWang
    1. Re:I used to work for this guy by Uptown+Joe · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yeah, well now we know where he got the $$ to build the Cosmosphere...

    2. Re:I used to work for this guy by Peldor · · Score: 5, Funny

      1. Establish world class museum.
      2. ?????
      3. Profit!

      And so at long last, we know what secret lies behind the mysterious step 2: Secretly sell off all the good stuff!

  5. Hey! by ShaniaTwain · · Score: 4, Funny

    drop the Apollo 12 water valve and step away from the car!

    1. Re:Hey! by mr_jrt · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'd have gone with "...drop the Apollo 12 water valve and make one small step away from the car!"

      --
      Boo.
  6. Shouldn't be hard to get it back by pr0t0 · · Score: 5, Funny



    I heard that NORAD tracks all kinds of space junk.

    --
    I'm sorry, but your opinion seems to be wrong.
  7. More information by TripMaster+Monkey · · Score: 5, Informative

    In the interest of promoting more enlightened discussion, the news release from the DOJ regarding this case can be found here.

    --
    ____

    ~ |rip/\/\aster /\/\onkey

    1. Re:More information by DikSeaCup · · Score: 2, Informative
      "enlightened discussion"

      You must be new here.

      Considering the number of folks that don't even bother to click on the hyperlinks provided by the Slashdot listing itself (IOW RTFA), the number of folks that will follow yours will be considerably diminished.

      Honestly, thanks though - I followed a link to the DOJ site but it went to a front page, and not the specific article of interest.

  8. ANother moron as a director.... by jim_v2000 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    How do stupid people get such jobs? I mean, the guy sells NASA stuff, then keeps signing papers that say he still has them. Didn't he wonder if someday NASA might want their stuff back, and when they found out it was gone, who they would look to first?

    --
    Don't take life so seriously. No one makes it out alive.
    1. Re:ANother moron as a director.... by op12 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Seriously, anyone who has seen any movies knows you have to replace the things you took with elaborate replicas or holograms.

    2. Re:ANother moron as a director.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Keep in mind, it's only the stupid ones who get sensationalized press coverage. The 99 other directors who do a satisfactory job are never mentioned in headlines like: "Museum Director Continues to do a Good Job!"

      And no matter the position, no matter how much research is done, eventually one hires someone who's not right for the job or changes after being hired. Mistakes happen, people change. The best way to prevent major incidents is to have a system of checks and balances to catch any wrongdoings at the first stages, and for the public to not fall too much into the sensationalism of the press.

    3. Re:ANother moron as a director.... by identity0 · · Score: 3, Funny

      Ooh, I can imagine some intrepid Indiana Jones type going up to the altar of the bottle of tang, and very quickly and carefully replacing it with a bottle of Evian.

      Then he hears an ominous rumbling, and looks up to see a very rotund 800 pound NASA engineer who has been living on nothing but Cheetos and tang rolling towards him, yelling "My Taaang! Bring back my Taaaaaanngg!".

      A chase scene between shelves of old NASA junk ensues.

    4. Re:ANother moron as a director.... by Dun+Malg · · Score: 3, Insightful
      How do stupid people get such jobs? I mean, the guy sells NASA stuff, then keeps signing papers that say he still has them. Didn't he wonder if someday NASA might want their stuff back, and when they found out it was gone, who they would look to first?

      People do all sorts of stupid crap like that. Probably because 95% of the time, you can get away with fooling the government. There are certain things, though, that you just can't cover up. Like those interns at NASA-Houston who stole a safe containing moon rocks which they then tried to sell on eBay. When it comes to unusual items, particularly stuff from the space program, they keep a pretty good accounting of it all and they almost certainly will catch you eventually. Stealing and trying to sell moon rocks is, of course, DOUBLY stupid because virtually all terrestrial moon rocks are property of the US government and never for sale...

      --
      If a job's not worth doing, it's not worth doing right.
  9. Intresting trades considered... by grumling · · Score: 2, Funny
    including an astronaut's in-flight T-shirt

    I wonder what kind of van you could trade for that?

    --
    "Well, good luck finding a judge that doesn't run a bestiality site."
    1. Re:Intresting trades considered... by Dance_Dance_Karnov · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'll trade you john voight's car for it.

  10. "Hmm" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Museum personel always felt something was Ary...

  11. The big question... by lordsilence · · Score: 2, Funny

    Anyone got a URL for the ebay-auction of that stuff?

  12. Have I missed something? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    1 - The prosecuters contend that Ary sold items and a figure of $180,000 is mentioned.

    2 - Ary's lawyer mentions tens of thousands of items. The defense will be that he is at most guilty of careless management.

    I have trouble putting 1 and 2 together. Presumably the prosecutors have disclosed their evidence to the defense. Do they have evidence that Ary sold anything to anyone? I think if they had any real evidence of that sort that Ary would quietly plead guilty and try for a reduced sentence. This has the smell of a case where all the evidence is circustantial.

    I'm sure not calling this guy guilty without seeing a lot more evidence.

  13. This is disgusting by jessecurry · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I am about to read the article, but I find this to be a horrible offense. Our national treasures are here for the entire population to enjoy. Anytime I hear about someone stealing or selling items of this type I am appalled. I can't believe that people can be so motivated my money. And it's only $180,000 that's not even that much.

    --
    Those who know, do not speak. Those who speak, do not know. ~Lao Tzu
    1. Re:This is disgusting by youknowmewell · · Score: 3, Funny

      Not that much? You saying $180,000 for a t-shirt is cheap? You obviously haven't been to Wal-Mart.

    2. Re:This is disgusting by IceWing_mk1 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      You think that a control panel for Air Force One, a mock watch, a pen and a couple of t-shirts are our National Treasures? As opposed to things, like say, the Declaration of Independence. The Constitution. Bill of Rights... But then, somehow, am not surprised given the common attitutes which have become prevelant in our country.

  14. Seinfeld by Reignking · · Score: 2, Funny

    Is this how Seinfeld got the astronaut's pen that writes upside-down?

    --
    One man's Funny is another man's Offtopic.
    1. Re:Seinfeld by CokeBear · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Unfortunately, this is an urban legend. The reason not to use pencils is the tiny particles of graphite would get into the air, and that would be really bad to breathe, and also have an adverse effect on some systems.

      --
      Reality has a liberal bias
    2. Re:Seinfeld by d34thm0nk3y · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Unfortunately, this is an urban legend. The reason not to use pencils is the tiny particles of graphite would get into the air, and that would be really bad to breathe, and also have an adverse effect on some systems.

      Graphite is a conductor. Graphite dust + sensitive/small electronics = shorts.

  15. Innocent until proven guilty? by Bnderan · · Score: 4, Insightful

    An indictment not being a conviction, most news organizations would try and work the word "allegedly" into such a report as this one. But It seems /. is exempt from that kind of responsibility. eh ... Fuck it ... let's hang him!

    1. Re:Innocent until proven guilty? by NBrooke271 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well, seeing as how our Slashdot readership surely knows the difference between an indictment and a conviction, it seems a little redundant to me.

      --
      Free messageboards and more! Your girlfriend's seen myWang
  16. what a waste by CompMD · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The Cosmosphere is one of my favorite museums. For the midwest, there is no better air and space museum. Aerospace technology and innovation is huge in Kansas, but there are a lot of people around here that can't go the the Smithsonian in DC or the EAA museum in Wisconsin. I would be very disheartened to learn that the allegations against Mr. Ary are true. The collection at the Cosmosphere is fantastic, and I hope there isn't any other fallout from this.

  17. I'll be rich, and quick! by Kimos · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It's surprising how much some people will pay for a tap. A tap! I should go buy some water valves, scratch off the brand name and write NASA on it with a marker. The only thing more reliable than a get-rich-quick scheme, is the stupidity of people.

  18. How to make money with space by rbanffy · · Score: 4, Funny

    This is an example of how much money the private space industry can make. This guy made US$ 180,000 without even leaving the planet...

    Amazing

  19. An even more pressing question... by Mancat · · Score: 5, Funny

    Who the hell would buy this crap? $180,000 for this junk?

    Oh, I must have that water valve! Jeeves, fetch me my coat and have the Rolls Royce ready!

    --
    hello dear sirs my name is jamesh i are india (bihar) can u guide me install red had linux 9?
  20. What are they thinking? by jmoriarty · · Score: 4, Insightful

    How are the brains wired in people who commit crimes like this? In an "honest" bank robbery, you are committing an obvious crime and only trying to conceal your identity. In fraud, you are creating a deliberate facade to hide what you are doing until you can safely vanish.

    To sell highly visible pieces of property that you do not own, then lie quite openly (with documentation!) that you still have them, seems to require being out of touch with reality. How can you not get found out?

    Do crimes like this indicate some mental issue, perhaps like kleptomania? I would be his driving force wasn't even the money, but some other compulsion or need.

  21. Love the Cosmosphere by MrNiceguy_KS · · Score: 5, Informative
    If you've never been there, the Kansas Cosmosphere is an answer to anyone asking "Why the hell would I want to go to Kansas?" While it's not as big as the Air and Space Museum in DC, it has the largest collection of space artifacts in existance. You want to see Oddessey, the Apollo 13 command module? The gloves Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin wore on the moon? I was just there (again) this weekend and, had I not had my wife and daughter along, would have easily spent another 2 hours just walking through the museum. (by the way, the artifacts I mentioned are still there)

    They also have a planetarium and IMAX theater, but the museum is the real draw for me. It's a walkthrough the history of space exploration, from the early experiments of Goddard and Von Braun, to the German WW2 missle programs, the cold-war era space race, up through the Shuttle, ISS, and Space Ship One.

    The on-site restoration and replication studio does amazing work. They produced most of the props for the Apollo 13 movie. They later restored the Apollo 13 command module and the "Liberty Bell" Mercury module (which had sat on the ocean floor for decades) They received a retired SR-71 plane, and added on to the building to display it in the lobby.

    If you're anywhere near Hutchinson, Kansas, it's well worth driving out of your way to see.

    --
    Redundancy is good And also good.
  22. Re:Iran launches space shuttle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Yep, I'm sure a water valve, a control panel, and a filthy t-shirt will get them real far. McGyver's got nothing on the Iranians.

  23. Omniplex by enforcer999 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Hmm...now this makes me wonder about the true reasons why the Omniplex is in such mess.

  24. Max was anything but a moron. by wowbagger · · Score: 5, Insightful

    How Max got the job at the Cosmosphere is simple.

    He built the place. It started out as a planetarium at a state fair, and Max (and Patty Carey) worked their asses off to make it one of the leading space museums in the world.

    He is ANYTHING but a moron. He was one of the cageiest individuals around. He spent years combing junkyards in Florida, Huston, and Huntsville, finding gear that NASA had thown away when the program it was associated with was no longer funded.

    He found the best people to restore the artifacts, and built a museum collection that was the envy of other space museums.

    Before you spout off on the subject (and moderators, before you moderate this tripe as insightful) you might want to actually do some research on the history of the Cosmosphere.

    All of that makes this EVEN WORSE - Max could have just as easily continued to do as he had done, locating artifacts in junkheaps, having Spaceworks (the artifact restoration arm of the Cosmosphere) restore them, and legally sell them. He didn't have to do this!

    And if he did indeed misappropriate artifacts (and while it sure looks that way, do remember - he has not yet been convicted in a court of law), then that was not merely a carrer-limiting move, that was a carrer-ending move - no museum will ever touch him again.

    1. Re:Max was anything but a moron. by rob_squared · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Wait. He stole stuff, from a place he built, when he didn't have to. And how does this not qualify him for moron status?

      --
      I don't get it.
    2. Re:Max was anything but a moron. by Ioldanach · · Score: 2, Insightful

      If the place was in the business of selling off relics it no longer wanted to display, it could be a bookkeeping error. A big one, granted, but with a collection that size someone may have overlooked that these dozen or so items weren't owned by them and sold some off.

    3. Re:Max was anything but a moron. by Buran · · Score: 2, Informative
      The space.com version of this story (where I originally heard about this) goes on to say:
      Disclosure: collectSPACE Editor Robert Pearlman is among the collectors who unknowingly purchased items stolen from the Cosmosphere. In response to a request by NASA, he has surrendered the artifact - an Apollo spacesuit strap-on pocket - to NASA's Inspector General.
      If the items are showing up in the hands of other people, who know where they got them from (if you're a serious collector, you keep records) then there's definitely something fishy there.

      Source: Former Museum Director Indicted in Theft of Space Artifacts
  25. Re:In a small way - who cares by ornil · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You cant alter it, improve it, use it.

    Do you think the private collectors who probably bought this are going to alter, improve or use it? No, it'll be in a glass case that only one guy can look at, instead of tens of thousands of people.

    I think precisely the opposite, private (i.e. for personal use only) collections of objects of this sort should not be allowed or at least be discouraged (unless the object in question is of secondary importance), because the guy who really wants to see these objects often can go to a museum like the rest of us. Or start a museum and let other people see the objects.

  26. Re:In a small way - who cares by LWATCDR · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Ayn Rand was as big of an idiot as Marx was. They where both clueless.
    "thing about "public" property is that its definitely not "public". You cant alter it, improve it, use it."
    Really? I go and use mountain bike trails at a local park that a club built. That is "Public" land. Do you not use your streets? Public property also. Never go to a park or a beach? Never helped to pick up trash at a park or beach? Helped to build a playground. Here are a few concrete examples of people using, altering ,and improving public property. So here are also concrete examples that the statement is wrong.

    --
    See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
  27. This guy is a jerk anyway by redshield3 · · Score: 4, Informative
    I worked at the Omniplex (the latest place this man was the director) over the summer, and had previously volunteered there for over four years.

    When he arrived at the museum he made a lot of sweeping changes without really consulting anyone. He fired most of the upper level people and replaced them with people he worked with in Kansas and I believe in Houston as well.

    His changes affected the character of the Omniplex in a detrimental way. The focus seemed to shift from educating people to making money. His management & leadership were piss-poor and had a negative effect on morale that trickled down to us lowly types who actually had to interact with visitors. Turnover was high all throughout the employee structure, and in the summer I worked there no less than 8 people were fired (the total staff is under 100).

    I hope that he is forced to leave and that his groupies he brought in leave too. Good riddance.

    1. Re:This guy is a jerk anyway by redshield3 · · Score: 3, Informative
      It's not that a 'little temp worker' got caught up in the politics of the place. I care a lot about the Omniplex and I want to see it do well. My relationship with the museum and it's staff extends back about 15 years. I've watched the place take a pronounced nosedive since he took his position.

      These firings (from May to August of 2004) weren't related to any new management structure; these summer firings were people that actually do a lot of the work around the museum. Some of them had been there for over twenty years. They had spoken the truth about the negative effects some of the changes that were made in order to affect a change for the better; instead, they got the boot.

      When staff member after staff member gets fired for telling the upper managment that things they were trying to do just wouldn't work, and then lo and behold, they don't work, and things continue to get worse, it's hard to not notice.

      Not to mention the detrimental effect on personell morale - people were scared to tell the truth for fear they would lose their jobs.

  28. So stupid it might not be true by deacon · · Score: 2, Insightful
    I realize that most criminals are stupid, but this is just silly. This guy is accused of selling stuff from museum inventory, but then attesting that the items are still present.

    The items alledged to be sold are obviously very rare, some must be on-off pieces, and anything made for the govt. is going to have a serial # on it.

    A museum curator is going to have a record of each object, its serial #, description, photos, restoration record, provenance, etc. etc... That's what curators DO!

    So while it's fun to grab a pitchfork and torch and join the mob, let's step back a bit and see how the evidence plays out here.

  29. Keep an eye on the Air & Space Museum by Hoi+Polloi · · Score: 2, Funny

    "Hey Fred, wasn't the Spirit of St Louis hanging up there before?"

    "Ahhhh, I think it is out at the cleaners."

    By the way, if anyone approaches you in a parking lot with a genuine V2 rocket in the back of their van it is ok to be suspicious.

    --
    It is by the juice of the coffee bean that thoughts acquire speed, the teeth acquire stains. The stains become a warning
  30. I do not know much of US justice by aepervius · · Score: 2, Insightful

    But does not indictment means you are accused, and now it is the job of the prosecutor to proove the accusation : aka he is not yet judged ? If this is right then you have no ground of putting a statement like "he stole" or "he is a moron". Reserve your judgement until the end of the prosecution. And moderator, how can you moderate the parent post as insightful ? the guy has only been charged, not yet judged ! Is innocent until proven guilty only empty words in the US ??

    --
    C. Sagan : A demon haunted world:
    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0345409469/
    visit randi.org