Slashdot Mirror


Palm and RIM to Collaborate on Treo Software

Rayaru writes "Palm and RIM have apparantly signed a deal allowing the Treo 650 to use RIM's email software. "The partnership with RIM is unique in that it is Palm's first chance to give Treo customers automatic synchronisation with calendaring." It's interesting that the deal also includes "future Treo products with the Palm operating system." Perhaps a Treo 670 Palm version is in the works?"

71 comments

  1. Good Move by jamesgamble · · Score: 5, Interesting

    This is a really good move on both sides. RIM's software is proven, while their hardware still has some crazy quirks. Palms hardware is proven, as is Palm OS, but a combination of the two pieces will make a great product.

    1. Re:Good Move by doublem · · Score: 0, Troll

      Palms hardware is proven, as is Palm OS

      Let me guess, you're using a Palm III or Palm V device, aren't you?

      If so, then I could see your point, but if you're talking about the newer kit, then I'd have to ask what planet you're on, and how you get that unstable crap to sync without crashing and requiring a plethora of hardware resets.

      --
      "Live Free or Die." Don't like it? Then keep out of the USA
    2. Re:Good Move by 3TimeLoser · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I hate PDAs and I have to support several of them (Palm & Blackberry). Those little bastards can take up more time and cause more interruptions than most of the servers I deal with.

      However, the beauty of the Blackberry (with a BES sever on the backend) is that desktop sync is not necessary for mail & calendar. It's all managed at the server, happens over the air, and it's one less thing to deal with at the desktop. Add this to the Treo 650 and you have a pretty potent combination. Now, some Treo users will still most likely sync with their desktop, but at least the mail & calendar sync issues should ease.

      I have a Treo 650 and BES server. The sooner I get my hands on this, the better.

    3. Re:Good Move by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Palm hardware has been quirky for a long time.

      I haven't used the old III models, but the V, mxxx models, Tungsten, and Zire models I've used have been quirky. Some behaviours were spontaneous resets, spontaneous hard resets, loss of calibration (which, from what I understand, is common with any touch screen as the mechanical parts--esp a tension spring--wear out and need physical recalibration after some years), or screens easily scratched by the default styli.

      Not all the quirks are awful, but placing various, multipurpose computer parts in a mass-produced, palm sized unit still seems like an art we haven't mastered.

    4. Re:Good Move by Eric+Giguere · · Score: 2, Informative

      Note that this announcement is for BlackBerry Connect, which essentially gives Palm access to the protocols that BlackBerry devices use to talk to the BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES). You still end up using the Treo's mail client -- the actual BlackBerry software (which is all written in Java and runs on top of RIM's own VM implementation) is not part of this deal. (That's covered by a different program called BlackBerry Built-In, which includes the VM and everything needed to run the standard BlackBerry software.) This is all about improving the Treo's ability to connect to different mail/contact servers. It won't improve the software on the Treo itself.

      Eric
      BlackBerry programming stuff
    5. Re:Good Move by Val314 · · Score: 2, Funny

      and if any manager has something to say, the'll end up with RIM's Hardware and Palm's software (emulated under WinCE)

    6. Re:Good Move by CharlieHedlin · · Score: 1

      That's why I used Goodlink. I worked with BES, and Goodlink was far less work to manage and did away with the desktop sync long before RIM did. (back with the Rim 950 and 957 was common and Goodlink used their hardware). Goodlink has been availible on the Treo for quite some time as well.

    7. Re:Good Move by 3TimeLoser · · Score: 1

      I've also heard good things about Goodlink. I looked into it when we only had a couple of Treos, but it did not work with Lotus Notes (at the time, anyway). After that, we had a management change and the new boss came with a Blackberry. Thus it was decreed that we'll be a Blackberry shop.

      Oh well...

  2. Not 670 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Informative

    The newer treo's series number is actually 700. Apparently this is News for Proofreaders.

  3. Patents? by anonicon · · Score: 4, Informative

    I may have missed something, but wasn't RIM's Blackberry software found to infringe on a software patent held by someone else, and they were ordered to shut down their wireless e-mail service in the United States? I'm wondering if they will be developing software based on the patented tech that RIM was already slapped down for.

    1. Re:Patents? by jamesgamble · · Score: 5, Informative

      Apparently RIM just needed to change a few key parts of their push software to get around the patents. It makes you wonder if going to court was really worth it. They should have just made the changes when the other company complained and been done with it.

    2. Re:Patents? by og_sh0x · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So does this mean that Blackberry service will definitely not be shut down? Could you cite a source, such as a news article?

    3. Re:Patents? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It won't be shut down, but it might lose a feature or two, possibly something really petty. -- RIM insider.

    4. Re:Patents? by jamesgamble · · Score: 3, Informative

      I work for T-Mobile. :) BlackBerries are a large portion of our business. Trust me, I know.

    5. Re:Patents? by Rude+Turnip · · Score: 0

      I think some companies are paying the "patent holding company" in question a protection fee so that they may continue to serve out their Blackberry services. Nokia is doing this, for example.

    6. Re:Patents? by Jonny_eh · · Score: 2, Funny

      It's like Jack Bauer on 24: "There's no time! You have to trust me!"

  4. Palm goes both ways by skitheboat · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Could Palm have a strategy that is any more confusing? I hope that they have some master plan in all of this and that it doesn't leave out making their hardware (smart phones) more reliable. Mine crashes more than Windows and my friends in on his 5th one. I can't imagine how they can improve quality when working on so many platforms.

    1. Re:Palm goes both ways by Lumpy · · Score: 2, Interesting

      wierd I have the exact opposite eperience..

      my Treo 600 is rock solid. my Journada was nothing but a reboot moster that ended up smashed and thrown in a drawer the 12th time it lost everything just when I needed to use it.

      I can not stand pocketPC devices while ever cince I switched to palm with Sony and then to the treo, I have yet to be disappointed. I even run unstable software. I watch mpeg4 videos on my treo every day and that app people mention about crashes due to the beta software.

      There really is no rhyme or reason to pda instability.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    2. Re:Palm goes both ways by Monkelectric · · Score: 2, Interesting

      My 650 crashes constantly, and my dell axim does as well :)

      --

      Religion is a gateway psychosis. -- Dave Foley

    3. Re:Palm goes both ways by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yet all those disgusted with the treo 650's instability still try to get $350-$450 for the thing on ebay.

      guess it's not that bad if you are not willing to firesale it at $180.00

  5. Yoinks... by gowen · · Score: 5, Funny

    Palm and RIM to collaborate?

    Look, there are those of us looking to make a cheap, sexually explicit joke about the headline and get some (+5 Funny) love.

    But guys, you're just not making it difficult enough anymore.

    --
    Athletic Scholarships to universities make as much sense as academic scholarships to sports teams.
    1. Re:Yoinks... by wiredlogic · · Score: 1

      I've got to hand it to you. You've done a great job pointing this out for us.

      --
      I am becoming gerund, destroyer of verbs.
  6. Good by Wireless+Joe · · Score: 3, Insightful
    "...unique in that it is Palm's first chance to give Treo customers automatic synchronization with calendaring."
    Maybe I didn't understand this statement, but I have always had automatic calendar sync, albeit with GoodLink software.
    1. Re:Good by topham · · Score: 2, Informative

      Palm was going to include this functionality before, but (if I recall correctly) RIM sued them over a patent violation.

      Amusing considering RIMs current legal problems with patents.

    2. Re:Good by Darkforge · · Score: 2, Informative

      They mean automatic "push" synchronization, where your phone's calendar and e-mail are updated wirelessly over the cellular network. That's where the Blackberry has the default Treo beat. (Though there is a really nice piece of non-free software called Chatter that can do push e-mail for the Treo 650 with IMAP servers like fastmail).

      --

      When I moderate, I only use "-1, Overrated". That way, I never get meta-moderated!

    3. Re:Good by presidentbeef · · Score: 1

      They mean automatic "push" synchronization, where your phone's calendar and e-mail are updated wirelessly over the cellular network.

      GoodLink provides this as well.
      Of course, GoodLink is a third-party solution, but it works well with many models of phones, so it could be worth it if only because you are not tied down to a particular brand.

      --
      Everything I need to know about copyrights I learned from Slashdot.
    4. Re:Good by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Exactly. Goodlink supports push Email, as well as calendar, notes, tasks, and contacts.

  7. With any luck... by MoxCamel · · Score: 4, Funny
    Hopefully this will lead to more Palm and RIM jobs. The world needs more Palm and RIM jobs...

    Mox

    1. Re:With any luck... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't believe that got +4 Insightful. Seriously, are you all asleep today?

    2. Re:With any luck... by fox9397 · · Score: 0

      So now instead supporting different devices, I'll be supporting the same device all running different software. I'm just getting jerked off here. There's something I ought to tell you ...I am not left-handed either.

    3. Re:With any luck... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      As someone who used to work at RIM, let me tell you:

      Grow up! You are not clever! Everyone and their dog has heard that joke before!!!

  8. Support for open source calendar servers? by IGnatius+T+Foobar · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Ideally, I would like to see this fancy new combined software package contain support for either SyncML or GroupDAV. It would be nice to connect to open source calendar servers, using a sync server like Sync4J or even natively on standards-compliant calendar servers.

    --
    Tired of FB/Google censorship? Visit UNCENSORED!
  9. Still comes up short. by Eric_Cartman_South_P · · Score: 2, Interesting

    From what I read, it will sync Mail and Cal. People are getting used to the latest Blackberry Enterprise server, which also does Contacts and Tasks. MS Outlook 2003 Exchange + Mobile 5 (read: Treo 700) will support Mail/Cal/Con/Task/Notes. If this really is only e-mail and Cal, it's not enough IMO and people will flock to Treo 700 because they want "all of outlook" and not "some of it".

    Palm has also said this was in the works for well over a year and a half, with no resolution. What gives that they finally got this out the door, all-be-it in a feature-missing version?

    1. Re:Still comes up short. by doublem · · Score: 1

      Palm has also said this was in the works for well over a year and a half, with no resolution. What gives that they finally got this out the door, all-be-it in a feature-missing version?

      The stock price must be slipping. Since they don't have anything like a stable, reliable product to release, they have to announce a new feature.

      If it works as well as the rest of the Palm OS, then we can expect it to crash regularly, and a non-trivial percentage of the e-mail to vanish into the ether.

      --
      "Live Free or Die." Don't like it? Then keep out of the USA
  10. Insightful? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Boy, do we have some moderators who don't get out of the house much.

  11. Re:Now that this deal has been signed.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    A friend of mine got a RIM Job some time ago and he really enjoys working there, but he's had some problems in the work place. His private member is a dangling pointer which can only be accessed by his friends. He could always make his private members public, but then he might lose his RIM Job.

  12. still "synchronizing" with desktops? by Douglas+Simmons · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I'm thinking that by now these devices are advanced enough and people are dependent on them to the point that coordination with a "primary" unit at home with the on-the-go device is getting phased out.

    By the way, way back I remember a slashdot article about a thing you hook up to a PDA that projects a laser keyboard onto any flat surface, and with it you can type away and it would somehow detect which non-existing keys you're hitting. Are they any good (if they're still being sold that is)?

    1. Re:still "synchronizing" with desktops? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You synchronize to the Exchange server, NOT your desktop. If your company doesn't install the agent on the Exchange server, then yes, you have to do it to the desktop but that's not what it was designed for.

    2. Re:still "synchronizing" with desktops? by Eric+Giguere · · Score: 2, Informative

      If your company doesn't install the agent on the Exchange server, then yes, you have to do it to the desktop but that's not what it was designed for.

      Actually, the BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES) came later. The devices (remember when they were called the Inter@ctive Pager?) were originally designed to sync via your desktop. The direct sync to the mail server was a later addition, and of course now that's the standard (and most reliable) way to do it.

      Eric
      Some BlackBerry programming stuff
    3. Re:still "synchronizing" with desktops? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "By the way, way back I remember a slashdot article about a thing you hook up to a PDA that projects a laser keyboard"

      And, let me guess, some idiot company hired you as PR for that very same, lame, non-functional product ?

      Fark off.

    4. Re:still "synchronizing" with desktops? by Douglas+Simmons · · Score: 1

      No, I'm unemployed. You insensitive clod.

  13. +4 Insightful? by HugePedlar · · Score: 2, Funny

    Here's an "insightful" link to go with that...

    http://www.zug.com/gab/index.cgi?func=view_thread& head=1&thread_id=31642

    For some reason firefox won't let me cut & paste, so I hope I got the link right.

    --
    Argh.
  14. Soooo - when in 2006? by Dark+Paladin · · Score: 1

    I've been hearing rumors and people running "Treo RIM Betas" for some time now - at least when I finally got my Treo 650 (and luckily, I don't seem to have some of the reset problems some have, but I will admit at least once a week - usually when I'm surfing the web - it reboots itself).

    So if they want to announce this for 2006 that's fine, but are we talking "early because we're almost done" or "We're just going to do it sometime 2006 and we're just yankin' your chain again because we're really just going to do it about the same time as the Treo 700 with Palm comes out".

    I'd like this, as my employer doesn't support any other mail hookup but RIM to their system, but I'm not going to hold my breath.

  15. Lawsuits in Motion by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So, this means PALM will be served papers from RIM sometime soon, right?

  16. BES by Tikicult · · Score: 0

    It will be especially cool if the Trio will connect to a Blackberry Enterprise Server. I installed one a month or so ago and it's great. We use the Groupwise version. It was a really easy install, and the features are awesome. Live, wireless connection to Email, Contacts, Calendar. Also, no need to EVER tether the device. All sync is done wireless.

    http://www.blackberry.com/products/software/index. shtml

    - Tiki

  17. No strategy beyond "Screw the user" by doublem · · Score: 1

    Palm's strategy is simple. They used to make decent, reliable devices. Now, they just make crap that crashes on a regular basis and scrambles user data.

    They had two options.

    They could have rallied and done their best to return to the days of producing quality devices worth the money.

    Instead, they chose to ride on the value of their brand name, coasting until they run out of steam.

    The company is on a long, slow death march, and the quality of their recent products demonstrates that.

    This is just another cynical attempt to delay the inevitable. They don't want to put REAL work or money into producing something good, so they toss some dollars at implementing something that will get press and sucker in a few more buyers.

    --
    "Live Free or Die." Don't like it? Then keep out of the USA
  18. big words are hard to sp3|| by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative
    >Palm and RIM have apparantly
    "apparantly" is not a valid spelling. One should use "apparently".

    Please, don't become just another statistic.
    >>Results 1 - 10 of about 1,390,000 for apparantly
    >>Results 1 - 10 of about 110,000,000 for apparently

  19. Palm - Mail and Calendar SYnc by futuresheep · · Score: 3, Interesting

    We've been using the Intellisync Mobile Suite for our enterprise users with great success. The client does an excellent job of providing email/calendar/contact sync via sms push. It's almost as fast as the Blackberry's we support, depending more on the users phone provider than on our Intellisync server.

  20. Goodlink by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Goodlink has been doing this for a long time. They even have a version of their software that runs on the Blackberries! Currently they're working on a version for Symbian for the pimp new Nokia phones.

  21. No, that will be the FARK headline by StressGuy · · Score: 1

    but I'll leave it the the experts...

    --
    A goal is a dream with a deadline
  22. Seems likely, but I hope not by skitheboat · · Score: 1

    I hope that they haven't hopped in to the same basket that is bound for a trip over the falls. There needs to be good competition in any market to keep even the best of companies from going astray. It would be sad to see any company own this market because they are still so far away from an ideal smartphone at least IMHO

    1. Re:Seems likely, but I hope not by doublem · · Score: 1

      The problem is, the Palm platform has been going downhill for ages.

      The only reason they still get new customers is because of their brand name. As they spend that name recognition capital, they'll either fade away or be forced to refocus on quality.

      I don't see them focusing on quality. Before long, the only reason left to buy a Palm will be "It's not from Microsoft" which is hardly a good reason to choose a product.

      --
      "Live Free or Die." Don't like it? Then keep out of the USA
  23. It will be a great move if... by StressGuy · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Palm and RIM are smart enough to realize that simplicity could be thier greatest asset. Let Windows based handhelds have all the toys while the business world sucks up units that can perform the necessary day to day functions reliably with minimal power consumption. If you want toys, add a way to store photos of your kids (great to show to customers/clients on the road) or an MP3 player to listen while stuck in the airport.

    If I want to play video games or watch movies, I'll go with something that has a bigger screen. If I want to type a document, I'll use my laptop (I usually need AutoCAD when I do documentation anyways).

    Simple and elegent is the real power here.

    --
    A goal is a dream with a deadline
  24. Treo always has used Palm by DJStealth · · Score: 1

    Don't you mean future RIM products with Palm OS? Or Future Treo Products with RIM e-mail or OS?

  25. like gymnastics... by rainmayun · · Score: 1

    Think of these jokes as the compulsory part of the competition.... freestyle joking commences later in the thread.

  26. What about the Treo 600? by Archimedean · · Score: 1

    Is there anything particular about the Treo 650 that would prevent using the Blackberry e-mail stuff on the Treo 600? Inquiring Treo 600 users want to know!

  27. The real loser in this by dbodner · · Score: 1

    (besides slashdot readers have to deal with (palm/rim)job jokes):
    Chattermail

    Great little program that got me through 2 years of Treo use.

  28. The disappearance of choice / competition by sipfounder · · Score: 1

    So if Palm was going to choose an OS, you'd have thought that they'd have picked something that allowed them to differentiate and to control their own destiny. An OS like embedded Linux, or Symbian perhaps. But no, they had to move to the only OS I suspect I'm going to have hard time syncing my Mac with; the same one used by every other freaking PDA phone out there (all of which suck).

    And, now they add insult to injury by emphasizing the Blackberry software, and if -- in the process -- they make it "hard" for us IMAP client users to use what we want, again I'll be stymied.

    So I guess I hope Apple actually gets into the business for real and not just partner with Moto. If they do, maybe they'll get real-time audio, WiFi, VoIp, and various bits of software right.... :-)

  29. verbificationicity by RumbaFlex · · Score: 1, Informative

    calendaring - daring to calen?
    language is raped on a daily basis..
    just remember that fist can be a verb without verbification.

    -

    --
    -By attempting the impossible we can achieve the absurd..
  30. Pardon my french... by Nijika · · Score: 1

    But this sounds shit hot! Do you know how long I have been eyeballing a Treo, only to take pause when looking at RIM devices? A long, long time. Long time.

    --
    Luck favors the prepared, darling.
  31. Have a Treo and access to IMAP? Get ChatterMail. by wernst · · Score: 1

    There's a great email program for Palm-powered smartphones (like the Treo 650) called ChatterMail (http://www.chatteremail.com/) that works as you'd expect with POP3 mail servers, but given an IMAP server, you can have email pushed to your treo as it arrives, normally within a few seconds.

    The whole experience is pretty much just like Blackberry mail, except it is on a versitle hardware platform (heh heh heh).

  32. Smart Phones just aren't a mature product yet by skitheboat · · Score: 2, Informative

    After 3 stages of support I got to a high-level support person at Verizon and he said they see far more problems with all of the combo devices than phones only. It's still just too tough to pack the combined functionality and get a reliable product. Some will work just fine but the stars really have to align.

    1. Re:Smart Phones just aren't a mature product yet by PierceLabs · · Score: 1

      I might believe that... if the "PDA only" devices were actually stable as well. I dunno. I've used devices based on Symbian OS that didn't reboot themselves constantly or do a soft reboot when a phone call ended ... and then rebooted again with the radio off, and then again with the radio on.

      I'm no longer interested in anything that runs Palm OS and not particularly interested in anything from Palm. My Treo650 has been a marginal buy at best and Palm isn't interested (or hasn't shown any interest) in making it do all the things they advertised it would do so I'll vote with my dollars and get something from SonyEricsson. Hopefully the device after the P990 won't be as bad at the current one is (in hardware design).

    2. Re:Smart Phones just aren't a mature product yet by skitheboat · · Score: 1

      Good Point! I just felt that the Treo 650 was so far removed from stable that it makes Windows look good. I hope they can fix this soon but I just can't rely on what is out and plan ot go back to a simple phone very soon.

  33. A day late... by kbjnash · · Score: 0

    And a dollar short. Good Enterprises has had this technology for several years available on both the Palm and PPC platforms. It frankly kicked the crap out of BES.... http://www.good.com/