Slashdot Mirror


Rat Cunning May Allow For Island Colonization

weighn writes "It was assumed that most rat invasions begin with one or two rats coming ashore from ships. The journal Nature reports that a wild rat, captured and then released on a deserted New Zealand island as part of an experiment, amazed scientists by apparently swimming 400 metres through treacherous open water to reach another island." From the article: "Researchers wanted to know how hard it would be to spot a single invader, and how difficult it would be to capture. Razza had a small radio transmitter attached and was set free on the island. Scientists intended to recapture him within eight weeks, but Razza gave a new meaning to 'rat cunning'. He avoided all the scientists' traps, and after 10 weeks his radio signal failed. 'It would be fair to say that at that point we were worried,' Professor Clout said. The Conservation Department was also worried, as the island had been cleared of rats."

35 of 190 comments (clear)

  1. Just 1 Rat by powera · · Score: 5, Funny

    If it's just 1 rat, I wouldn't be too worried. It may be clever, but it can't mate with itself.

    1. Re:Just 1 Rat by isometrick · · Score: 4, Funny

      Unless there's frog DNA involved ... duh!

    2. Re:Just 1 Rat by PresidentEnder · · Score: 3, Informative

      The problem isn't that this one particular rat can self-fertilize, but that this means that rats can jump from island to island, specifically, to happy-special-rat-free island from evil-nasty-screwed-over-extinct-native-species-rat -filled island.

      --
      I used to carry a bottle of whiskey for snake bite. And two snakes. -Nefarious Wheel
    3. Re:Just 1 Rat by gronofer · · Score: 3, Insightful

      No, but how long would it live, and how many bird eggs etc. would it eat in the meantime?

    4. Re:Just 1 Rat by darkonc · · Score: 5, Funny
      It may be clever, but it can't mate with itself.

      Obviously, this rat was intelligent enough to figure that out too, which is probably why he swam to the next island. it's incredible what us males will do for just the hope of a nice piece of tail.

      --
      Sometimes boldness is in fashion. Sometimes only the brave will be bold.
  2. no respect. by silverkniveshotmail. · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Should have let the little dude go for his efforts. I mean shit, I know I couldn't swim the equivalent of 400 meters after adjusting for the size difference between the two of us.

    1. Re:no respect. by ErikZ · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "He speculated that Razza may have wanted female company."

      Would you do it for a woman?

      As opposed to: No women, ever again?

      --
      Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
  3. Somewhere... by Chairboy · · Score: 5, Funny

    Somewhere in the world, Jeff Goldblum weeps...

    "Oooooh, ahhh... that's how it always starts. Then later, there's running, and screaming, and standing on top of a stool in the middle of your kitchen waving a broom at Chucky Cheese the 'lone' mouse there. You think a single rat won't cause problems? My friend, if chaos theory has taught me anything... it's that nature will find a way..."

  4. The Amazing Swimming Rat by PresidentEnder · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Aw, crap. Now rats can swim 400 meters. That means we can't just clear one island of rats, we'll have to clear every island within 400 meters of rats. Jeez, now we'll never get rid of them.

    --
    I used to carry a bottle of whiskey for snake bite. And two snakes. -Nefarious Wheel
  5. In other news: by bmo · · Score: 4, Funny

    Male rats were discovered to self impregnate after being told "Go F***k yourself!". In yet other news, Darl McBride is pregnant.

    --
    BMO

  6. Wow by Comatose51 · · Score: 4, Funny
    "To our knowledge this is the first record of a rat swimming across open sea, and it's often quite rough water," Professor Clout said. "We assume he did it deliberately, but who knows what was in his mind?"

    He speculated that Razza may have wanted female company.

    And I thought some of us were desperate!

    --
    EvilCON - Made Famous by /.
  7. Rats are surprisingly smart by putko · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Rats are surprisingly smart creatures. They've been living close to humans for a few thousand years, and the humans have constantly been trying to kill them. They've managed to thrive (not just survive) because they are highly adapted to humans trying to catch and kil them.

    They do better on some problems than dogs -- e.g. they don't fall for bait. They are terribly suspicious (paranoid) of any changes in their environment. Supposedly they have "culture" in the sense that a colony of rats (and their descendants down many generations) can learn to avoid certain types of food that they have reason (e.g. humans poisoning them) to avoid.

    So it isn't at all surprising that the rat was able to best the humans! I'm surprised they caught the thing at all.

    --
    http://www.thebricktestament.com/the_law/when_to_s tone_your_children/dt21_18a.html
    1. Re:Rats are surprisingly smart by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Supposedly they have "culture" in the sense that a colony of rats (and their descendants down many generations) can learn to avoid certain types of food that they have reason (e.g. humans poisoning them) to avoid.

      They do this by sniffing a sick rat's mouth to find out what it has been eating and then avoiding that smell.

    2. Re:Rats are surprisingly smart by bm_luethke · · Score: 5, Interesting

      We had rats move in a quite a few years back under our porch. They borrowed into the subfloor of our house, they were eating the seed we feed the wild birds. My mother, not wanting to stop feeding them (she had some notion that they would die without her feeding them -uhh) we had to find another solution. Being hunters and avid target shooter we decided to simply kill them. We set up the bird feeders such that we had a good shooting area at the rats and scouted thier habits to get them when they were feeding (much the same thing we do with deer and such).

      We killed well over 30 of the things. At first they simply waltz out to the feeder and we pegged them with the pellet gun. After a while they knew what the noise of the window opening meant so we had to round the animals up 30-45 minutes before feeding time and open the window. They then figured out the lighting so we learned to shoot in our noral lighting (none in that room). They then figured out where the killing lanes were - itwas kinda funny. You could see them walk right up to the line - almost to the inch - and prepare for the run. In one go get one seed. Unfortunatly for them we are good shots and small running targets are fun - still killed them. Changing food sources was not an option - nothing else around here to eat and they didn't seem to take the hint to move.

      But, even with a high death rate - after the first month nearly all we killed were small young ones - we still could not remove them. They figured out our traps and avoided them and made it as hard as possible to kill them. We had to learn thier habits, restrict thier food sources to only a certain ones, practice shooting to be accurate enough, and specifically develope hunting strategies for them - in short everything we do for game animals. The thing that finally got them was nature - a 6 foot long black snake decided under our porch (same place as the rats) was a good place to live. Unfortunatly the neigbors killed the snake as a "nasty evil thing" a few months later and kill every snake they find - and they still have rats that refuse to leave thier house - which I say serves them right.

      --
      ------- Sorry about the spelling, I suffer from two problems. Dyslexia makes it difficult to spell well, lazy makes it
    3. Re:Rats are surprisingly smart by smashin234 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      The outwitting of humans only works because humans in general are ill-equiped to actually kill smaller rodents. The best thing to kill them is a smaller predator such as a large cat (maybe for smaller rats) and a dog (perferably a dachsund imo).

      As for us killing them off, well humans have for years helped them out inadvertantly.

      Being scavengers, our food stockpiles are great for them to use for an easy meal.

      And killing off their natural predators. Anything from the killing of the cats in the middle ages because they were "witches familiars" to killing off wolves and other predators in nature also helps them survive.

      In short, I am not sure if you could credit their survival of humanity to anything other then humans blundering when it comes to rats. Granted they are intelligent, but their survival of humanity has more to do with us not really doing the right things to kill them off. Traps, poison, and even isolation seem to not be enough as evidenced with this miracle rat.

      In addition, lots of people have rats as pets now, so the odds are even lower that we will ever rid ourselves of this "menace". Their long-term survival probably has more to do with how well they bond with humans then their intelligence.

    4. Re:Rats are surprisingly smart by putko · · Score: 3, Funny

      "We killed well over 30 of the things. At first they simply waltz out to the feeder and we pegged them with the pellet gun. After a while they knew what the noise of the window opening meant so we had to round the animals up 30-45 minutes before feeding time and open the window. They then figured out the lighting so we learned to shoot in our noral lighting (none in that room). They then figured out where the killing lanes were - itwas kinda funny. You could see them walk right up to the line - almost to the inch - and prepare for the run. In one go get one seed. Unfortunatly for them we are good shots and small running targets are fun - still killed them. Changing food sources was not an option - nothing else around here to eat and they didn't seem to take the hint to move."

      That's really something. If you read about guys who try to trap/bait rats, it isn't so different. Their habits are such that they won't fall for the traps -- even if you put in what you think is a tasty treat. I'm not shocked they figured out the kill-zone boundaries!

      I've also read that they'll develop a taste for certain foods --- e.g. if they habitually eat spicy food, they'll want spicy food. Also, quite interestingly, they like the foods that humans like. E.g. macraronic and cheese, banannas and Pasta. They hate the foods that we hate: raw vegetables. Fried chicken and pizza they really like! They are very human in their tastes.

      --
      http://www.thebricktestament.com/the_law/when_to_s tone_your_children/dt21_18a.html
    5. Re:Rats are surprisingly smart by Inda · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I've had quiet a bit of experience killing rats over the years.

      I remember when I was very young we had a pet rabbit. A single rat would steal its food each day. We set an old fashion trap and eventually, when food was scarce, it fell for the bait. We heard the rat scream from inside our house - it was painfully loud. My Dad tried to put it out of its misery with the back of an axe handle. He landed a perfect blow to its head and I've never heard a creature scream like it since. This blow would have smashed every bone in my foot had he missed, but the rat was still going strong... It didn't survive the second blow.

      I've also had rats in my roof several times over the years. Blame old Victorian houses for that. Poison is very effective. They will eat it when it's familiar to them and they're short of real food. It makes them bleed from the inside, their body feels cold as a result and they go back to their nest to keep warm. It doesn't take long for them to die. Some rats try and eat dirt to dilute the poison but it rarely works.

      I've also bought an electronic trap to deal with them. It consists of a few batteries, some sort of capacitor/coil/spark-plug thing and two metal plates inside. It looks like a shoe box with a hole in the front. When the rat steps on both metal plates at once, it gets electrocuted... They're not stupid though and have never climbed inside in the three years I've had it.

      The dirty, filthy creatures have to be admired in their strength and survive skills.

      --
      This post contains benzene, nitrosamines, formaldehyde and hydrogen cyanide.
  8. fastest mouse in erm.. water? by Tahir+Azhar · · Score: 3, Funny

    if only they had watched a few episodes of speedy gonzales.. all that research money could have been saved.

  9. Good plot for a video game. by torpor · · Score: 3, Funny

    You're the rat, see, and you have been placed on a foreign island, and .. well .. rats gotta do what a rats gotta do, and that means go find some love, make more rats, avoid the evil scientists and their probing machines, swim through treacherous sharky waters, get some love..

    Something for my GPX2 when it arrives next month, perhaps ..

    --
    ; -- the corruption of government starts with its secrets. a truly free people keep no secrets. --
  10. I Like This Version of the Story Better by TubeSteak · · Score: 4, Funny
    "It seemed like a good idea. Let a lone rat loose on a rodent-free island and then figure out how to kill it. That way, when other islands are invaded by rats, you'll know what to do.

    Scientists figured they'd trap this foot-long varmint in no time.

    Eighteen weeks later, they finally trapped it with some fresh penguin bait. On another island."
    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/9756077/
    This version of the article just seems to give a much better sense of "How Ironic, Hilarity Ensues" than the submitted one.

    And it includes little details, like they used PENGUINS as bait
    I can hear PETA cranking up their war machine.

    --
    [Fuck Beta]
    o0t!
  11. Not invading! by M.+Baranczak · · Score: 5, Funny

    The rats are not "invading"! They're trying to spread democracy!

  12. Re:CAT Cunning! by gronofer · · Score: 4, Funny

    Great, and what will you send to catch the cat?

  13. At Bondi? by musakko · · Score: 3, Funny
    ..amazed scientists by apparently swimming 400 metres through treacherous open water to reach another island.

    That island being Australia. Smart rat.

  14. Re:Easy solution by DrSkwid · · Score: 4, Funny

    sorry, the only acceptable story goes like this :

    Skinner: (Upon finding out that the lizards he wanted to wipe out ate pigeon eggs) Well, I was wrong. The lizards are a godsend.
    Lisa: But isn't that a bit short-sighted? What happens when we're overrun by lizards?
    Skinner: No problem. We simply unleash wave after wave of Chinese needle snakes. They'll wipe out the lizards.
    Lisa: But aren't the snakes even worse?
    Skinner: Yes, but we're prepared for that. We've lined up a fabulous type of gorilla that thrives on snake meat.
    Lisa: But then we're stuck with gorillas!
    Skinner: No, that's the beautiful part. When wintertime rolls around, the gorillas simply freeze to death.

    --
    There are places where the networks are not touching,and there are places where they are-Boeing's Lori Gunter
  15. OT: Fake Print Button by dave1212 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    OT: I can't stand when sites do this..

    I hit the 'print' version button on their site, expecting to get a nicely formatted, less cluttered version of the article. and instead it just sends the javascript command to choose 'print' in your browser.

    I'm seeing it more and more, and it bugs the crap out of me.

    1. Re:OT: Fake Print Button by InfiniteWisdom · · Score: 3, Funny

      So a "fake print button" is one that actually prints rather than taking you to another page?

  16. I tried to save a rat couple... by Shanep · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I had a rat couple visiting my Sydney, Australia kitchen at nights. They were getting stuck into our flour and who knows what else, so I purchased a humane trap to catch them so that I could set them free elsewhere in the wild (I've since found out that this would have been a very bad idea for the native bird life, since rats are known to raid nests for eggs or baby birds). The trap I purchased was primarily intended for possums, however it was very sensitive and suitable for rat capture.

    The man who I purchased the trap from, informed me that I should tie the trap open and leave food inside, because the rats will cautiously investigate it and would be likely to trigger it from the outside by crawling on it and then be scared away from it from that point on. I thought this was a bit of exageration and did not think they were all that smart, so in my great haste, I set the trap proper with some apple that night.

    In bed that night I listened, eager to hear the trap close... it did... I walked out into the kitchen to find a closed, empty trap.

    So I set it again and over a period of weeks those rats NEVER triggered that trap again. Smart little buggers. They were amazing to watch too. They would run right up and down the gas pipe from my oven to the ceiling so fast, as if they were on flat ground. They would even watch me enter the kitchen, turn on the light and stand at the door to look back at them... and they'd just continue to eat my food while they looked back at me. They would not run until I approached further.

    Unfortunately, the people down stairs from us used Rat Sack against them, so we were unable to save them and had a terrible smell coming up from the floorboards for weeks after that.

    I won't underestimate the rat again. I really wish I'd taken that guys advice too. I would have been willing to keep them captive to see out their lives, although I certainly would never handle wild rats. I've had run-ins with some domestic rats and they were VERY nasty little bastards, so I would not want to be bitten by a wild, potentially diseased rat. In hindsight, I think in the future I'd probably just used a normal old killer rat trap. As horrible as it may sound. I put native wildlife before them any day.

    --
    War crimes, torture, lies, illegal spying... Would someone give Bush a blowjob, already, so he can be impeached?
  17. Hmm. by hey! · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Hmmm. One of the limiting factors in human evolution is the caloric requirements of a massive, highly active brain. Some anthropologists believe that gaining the ability to hunt accelerated human evolution.

    On the other hand, success puts a lot less survival pressure on us, as well as huge breeding populations into which mutations diffuse and disappear.

    Now our friend the rat has plenty of calories, plenty of evolutionary pressure, thanks to us.

    Any guess on how long it will take Rattus norvegicus to surpass us?

    --
    Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
  18. As an owner of pet rats... by MourningBlade · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Let me just say that this is not surprising (it is, however, neat). They're mischief, they're wily, and they're single-minded.

    Most people, when they think at all of it, would place the rat near the mouse, the gerbil, and the hamster in intelligence. Play with a (socialized) rat for about 5 minutes and you'll see that that isn't the case at all: they're curious about their surroundings, they mess with things to see what they are (new things in my apartment are thoroughly inspected by the rats...whether I'd rather they did or not), and they have a concept of hiding as a means to an end[1].

    Also, for such a small creature, they are very hardy and cope well with infirmity. I had a rat who took a nasty fall and sprained a forepaw to where she couldn't use it for about two weeks. Since their food was on one level, water on another, and nest on yet another - with the only way between levels to climb the walls of the cage or jump - I was going to move everything to the ground area when I saw her get up to the top level of the cage (cage is about 4' high) by jumping, grabbing the bars, scrambling 3-legged up the side, jump at the level and grab the ledge with her right side paws, and swing her body onto the ledge...to grab a piece of dried macaroni and casually jump to the bottom. No issue.

    This is the norm for rats: they can lose a paw, lose inner ear functioning (ear infections can do that to them), be in a fair amount of pain, and they'll keep going. In fact, rat owners are cautioned that you need to check your rat for cuts and such because they won't make noise to let you know - the noise would betray them to predators[2].

    They have an excellent sense of smell and are good at foraging. Also, unlike many other hoarding animals, rats tend to remember where their stashes are. I gave the rats a ritz cracker apiece one night. About an hour later when I thought they'd eaten them, I let them out to play. Two weeks later I'm watching TV when the rats haul their ritz crackers out of some unknown nook in the apartment and leave crumbs on my couch. Also, they don't gorge: they have a concept of "saving for later" - you can keep a full bowl of food for them no problem. The only question of whether or not they'll get fat is whether they like their wheel.

    That's probably enough rat propaganda except to say that domestic fancy rats are incredibly cute and love people. a picture to give you an idea of the cute factor.

    [1] - many animals that hide do so whenever threatened or fearful. They stop what they were doing, and they hide. When the threat is perceived to be over, they stop hiding. Rats join coyotes and a few other animals in that they understand "cover" - getting close enough to check something out without being observed.

    [2] - that is, unless you have a little drama queen who squeaks and fusses whenever you do anything that wasn't her idea. I'd imagine that's a domestic trait.

  19. Re:They killed Razza! by noc_man · · Score: 4, Funny

    Well, now its proven that rats are, indeed, the smartest beings on Earth. This was one of their cruelest experiments on us yet.

  20. Re:CAT Cunning! by hey! · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Rats are tough though; not any cat is going to tangle with one if there is safer prey around -- probably the very critters we're worried about the gentle but efficient rats outcompeting.

    I once had a rat killing cat. She wasn't big, in fact she was the smallest cat we'd ever had. It was just that she was just a warhead of bloodlust mounted on a lean, stealthy, rocket of a body. We picked her up as a stray, and there was something not right about her. She grew up into the self-appointed deputy Angel of Death. Granted this describes most cats -- in any feline dreams they may have. But this cat made it her business to murder anything that crossed her path and was less than twice her size.

    Cat: "Meow" (Out.)

    Me: Out to kill something, are we?

    Cat: "Meow" (Out.)

    Me: Well, just don't bring in the house.

    Cat: "Meow" (What's left won't amount to much.)

    Me: Very well, then have fun. Bye.

    Cat (departing): "Meow" (Don't worry, I don't like you enough to bring you any presents.)

    --
    Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
  21. My experience by Macka · · Score: 3, Interesting


    I had a pet rat a few years ago too, an albino. I inherited him off my brother after my brother developed an allergic reaction to him (he was his second rat). At first I only took him on because my brother knew I liked animals and would treat him well. I knew nothing about rats before then. But I soon learned that as well as being playful and inquisitive, domestic rats are very social creatures, and enjoy human contact. Mine never bit me once. On the contrary, he would sit there quietly and close his eyes when I tickled him behind his ears, then he'd reciprocate by holding my fingers in his front paws and licking them. He was extremely affectionate. I had to have him put down in the end because he developed a tumor in his spine and lungs and started loosing the ability to use his back legs. One of the most upsetting moments of my life.

  22. Re:Serious questions about rats as pets by Headw1nd · · Score: 3, Interesting

    My family has kept four rats in my life (Templeton, Terra, Anistasia, and Maize, 1 male and 3 females, respectively) All were lab rats previous to our owning them. I have only been bitten hard enough to draw blood (barely) once, and I suppose at the time I deserved it. I was young and was reaching under the couch intending to drag Terra out. None of them ever bit anyone else as far as I know.

    domestic rats really are cute and playful, and can easily be allowed to run around with minimal supervision. One caveat: they chew. A lot. When we finally moved that couch that Terra liked to hide under, we discoved she had made a moonscape out of the carpeting, chewing big nestlike holes through both carpet and pad. They can chew a hole through thick cardboard in a couple of minutes, and thin wood in not much longer, provided they can get an angle to start at.

    Our male rat outlived his female counterparts by a pretty wide margin (we sometimes wonder if it was due to his lab work). I would say our rats have lived an average of four years, and have all died of cancer. He is generally remebered a being more sociable, but I can't say whether this hold true for all males. I wouldn't get a breeding pair, as you would end up with a *lot* of rats in a fairly short order. However, you can get them neutered.

  23. Re:Life finds a way... (was Re:Just 1 Rat) by mikael · · Score: 4, Funny

    I still don't see why they had to kill it instead of just recapturing it. I mean, after such heroic efforts, it surely deserved better?

    That rat gained invaluable combat experience that it would have passed onto others. Taking out this rat became essential if we are to maintain control of these islands.

    --
    Vintage computer adverts: http://www.vintageadbrowser.com/computers-and-software-ads
  24. Re:Serious questions about rats as pets by MourningBlade · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Do they bite?

    That's pretty much the most common question. The answer is: do dogs bite?

    If the rat is well-socialized (handled by humans since young) and not kept by himself[1], then pretty much no. If the rat gets a pineal tumor or the like, it is possible that they can develop aggression - then again, if the rat has a pineal tumor, he's not long for this world.

    None of my rats have ever bitten me. I stepped on Snow's tail once, and she screeched bloody murder, but she never bit me. I've fed them meat with my fingers (not a great idea with any animal, since your fingers then smell like meat) and they would start to chomp on my finger then stop when they realized it was me - a spooky feeling, but I never felt like they were going to bite.

    I'm really not sure what I'd have to do to get one of them to bite, but that's pretty much all I can say: it's never happened to me.

    The one almost-exception I'll make is for feet: for some reason, human feet drive rats wild. They'll rarely bite, but they will mouth them or groom them (slight nibbling). If you make a noise (like a squeak) they'll learn that they're hurting you and will stop.

    I suppose that the health and disease issues can be solved by purchasing a pet from a reliable breeder. How about the temperament, though?

    Well-raised rats are disgustingly healthy. They almost never need to go to the vet, there's no shots, nothing. They bathe themselves like cats (and they bathe all the time, it's a big deal). The one thing you have to keep in mind is to change their bedding on a regular basis. How often "regular" is depends on how many you have. I have 3 males (male rat urine is MUCH stronger than female) and have to change the bedding material about once every 4-5 days and their nesting material (what goes in their nest, like paper towels) about once every 2-3 days. You'll know when you need to.

    Lastly, as to temperament: rats have worked out very well for some of the pet therapy groups that operate at children's hospitals. Children who are confined to the hospital get to play with an animal for a while - it's very nice. Rats do well for kids who are confined to their bed, as the rat can play on their bed with them and not disturb any tubes and the like. Some of them are very "kissy" (they lick people), which is a big hit with the kids.

    You mention a drama queen rat. Are males more suitable for pets?

    Well, the drama queen in this case is actually a male. "Drama king" just doesn't sound quite right. He doesn't do anything, he just lets you know that he is Not Amused when you pick him up from something he wanted to do. Within about 3 seconds he changes his mind and decides that what he REALLY wants to do is play with you. So there you go.

    Both males and females work out great - but if you put them together they will breed like you can barely comprehend. Think litters of 10-16 every 5 months. Yeah.

    However, if you fix the females or the males, they can go together great. Male rats will not fight over females, and the females like the attention.

    Females are smaller and more busy than the males. Males tend to be a bit more affectionate, though the variation between rats is bigger than the variation between sexes. The females are prone to tumors, unfortunately, but if you get them fixed that subsides. The males are smellier than the females, but it's not bad.

    Oh, and the males wrestle all the time. It's a lot of fun to watch. It's how they establish the pecking order - and they just like to do it. Usually at least once a night I'll have Max and Abernathy pushing each other across the floor. They also usually push each other around to decide who gets to sleep on me when I watch a movie.

    [1] - rats are very intelligent and social. They do MUCH better in at least pairs. Most of the incidents I know of "moody" rats were those kept alone. They do okay-ish by themselves, but it's not as good.