Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

AnalogWhole, an Alternative To FairUse4WM

Posted by ryuzaki0 on from the digital-is-so-XX-century dept.

Squidmarks writes, "AnalogWhole is a free application that allows any file that can be played in Windows Media Player to be transferred to iTunes as an MP3. It uses, you guessed it, the 'analog hole' to re-record any DRM'ed song as an MP3. Because the analog signal doesn't actually leave the computer, but is simply looped back in the sound card, sound quality of the re-recording is excellent. All meta data is transferred as well. The MP3 file is automagically added to iTunes. Just show it where you store your DRM music and walk away."

5 of 168 comments (clear)

  1. Still loss of quality by amplusquem · · Score: 5, Informative

    It is still looped through the sound card, so while quality may still be "excellent", there is still loss. I would rather use a program such as QTFairUse which doesn't lose any sound quality.

    1. Re:Still loss of quality by Threni · · Score: 5, Funny

      > It is still looped through the sound card, so while quality may still be "excellent", there is still loss.

      mmm...but just listen to that lovely analog warmth! I'll take that over digital accuracy anyday...

    2. Re:Still loss of quality by gameforge · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I know a number of audiophiles who detest MP3s. I've tricked them into saying that the actual CD was an MP3 and the MP3 I ripped from that CD was the real CD. They couldn't actually tell a difference and were taking guesses.

      If you use LAME, set your Q to 9. A 320kbps MP3 with Q=1 and 320kbps mp3 with Q=9 are WILDLY different, while both the same bitrate and same size. Whatever garbage MP3 files you have, re-encoding them as 320kbps/Q9 files isn't going to make them sound any worse to 99.9% of humans. Of course it takes more time to encode them this way.

      Another point, not for you, but for some of your parent posts - think about a soundcard with a digital out. That means, the bits get decoded and sent to the amp - if the amp (or whatever you plug the digital line into) can capture the bits, you've got a perfect/lossless rip - no DAC was involved. Volume controls and DSP's may change the bits somehow, and it will take playing-with to get it right... but it will produce satisfactory results once you do.

      I would test this for people, but I own (and will always own) absolutely ZERO DRM content.

      I own a Creative SoundBlaster Audigy... I know even a cheap SBLive! can do this... I would try the following to get a pure digital copy, in this order:

      1. Play a DRM'd file, set the recording channel to "What U Hear", and record. If that doesn't work...
      2. Get a LiveDrive (plugs into SB Live's & Audigy's) cheap on eBay, and an optical cable... then plug optical out into optical in and try to record the optical in. If that doesn't work...
      3. Get two computers, one with a digital out and one with a digital in. Try it that way. If that doesn't work...
      4. Uninstall iTunes or whichever thing is giving you this unplayable worthless crap to begin with, and tell their distributor to go to hell. Then take your stereo equipment and hurl it at Sony-Poo's nuts, and sing to yourself until a better solution comes along.

      I can actually guarantee positive results with that last one.

  2. Secure Audio Path is in Windows ME, XP, and Vista by tepples · · Score: 5, Informative
    what are the chances that Vista could block off access to mixer output except for low-level (driver) access

    Very high. Windows Millennium Edition and Windows XP operating systems already support the Secure Audio Path, which places the (WHQL logo approved) decrypter, (WHQL logo approved) decoder, and (WHQL logo approved) audio output driver in kernel space. Part of the WHQL logo requirement is that no driver may mix Secure Audio Path audio into any cleartext digital output, and no driver without a logo is a valid Secure Audio Path playback device. However, few if any WMA files that require the Secure Audio Path are in the wild yet. However, record labels will begin to change their requirements as WMA stores' customers replace their computers that came with Windows 98 or Windows 2000 with newer computers that come with Windows Vista.

    For WMA files that use Secure Audio Path, you'll need a $5 audio cable and Audacity.

  3. If you don't want to lose quality... by gregorio · · Score: 4, Interesting

    ...build your own USB "converter". Companies like Texas Instruments have lots of devices like PCM2704, that allow access to an unprotected sound bitstream. It's pretty simple to build a fake digital speaker that just redirects the data to a fake digital line in. Some microcontrolled usb sound devices contain both input and output devices on the same IC, so you can software redirect the output (coming from the computer) to the input (going back to it).

    So you don't even need an "Analog hole". You can use a digital hole and don't lose any quality at all. And this kind of device is perfectly accepted by any "content protection" driver schemes.

    It's impossible to protect sound files.