6 Burning Questions About Wireless Networks
alphadogg writes "Answers to wireless network questions such as: What impact will 802.11n have? Which wireless security threats are scariest? What of wireless VoIP? Will your organization need to change to support enterprise mobility? How do you control costs in an expanding mobile and wireless environment? What can you do to stop wireless denial-of-service attacks?"
Here's my question. When are router manufacturers going to start requiring people to use WPA security? I got a Wii a couple weeks ago, and used the wireless part of my wireless router for the first time. Setup of WPA was very easy. I also found about 5 other open networks that I could have connected my Wii to. I find it amazing that people are leaving their connections open when setting up a secure connection is so easy.
Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
Q: "Is wireless [Wi-Fi-based] VoIP worth the bother?"
A: "Generally, no."
Sponsored by AT&T
This article is pure FUD (thats Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt). The questions in TFA are not so much burning or on fire as the title would suggest..
--
Wi-Fizzle Research
Censorship is obscene. Patriotism is bigotry. Faith is a vice. Slashdot 2.0 sucks.
I voted for Tesla coils.
No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
1. Why can't Router manufacturers make WPA the default and use "no security" instead?
2. Why can't we get the information just how far away the "full bandwidth" works, instead of finding out without fail that most APs can hardly provide the promised bandwidth over distances more than 5 yards?
3. How long 'til we can't use WiFi anymore because all frequencies are already taken by your neighbors and the companies around you? Worse, can you soon be forced to discontinue your WiFi use because the company next door needs your frequency? (Because, yes, it's unusable past 20 yards but can easily interfere with networks a few miles away, it seems)
4. What's the legal implication when someone uses my WiFi AP without my consent by hacking into it and distributing illegal material through it? I'm waiting for the first verdict where you have a completely secure AP, someone still manages to break it and then...?
5. In turn, what about "free" APs, kept open deliberately. What about town wide WiFi networks, a few cities already started a project but they never went anywhere. Care to tell us why?
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
What the heck are we going to do about everyone and his bro having his own wireless router? It's a special kind of heck when you've got an apartment complex with 7 or 8 or 10 wireless networks all in range and all competing. Add to that cell phones, wireless cameras, printers, etc, etc, and wireless is rapidly becoming useless...
Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
Yeah, I know it looks like some dodgey mailer script, but it just uses Javascript form elements to fill in bits of their standard printer page, instead of making a proper URL. Of course GET vs. POST is not checked ;-)
#include <sig.h>
When is wireless not going to suck? Seriously. I don't use it because of absolutely rotten reliability. Inconsistent speed, and intermittent connections are a rotten tradeoff for being able to save a few wires here and there.
I don't respond to AC's.
How about creating a LAN over the power lines in your residence?
Here is some more information from wikipedia: Power line communication for home networking
I have a friend who did this at his house and it worked out nicely for him.
Good luck!
--
Wi-Fizzle Research
Censorship is obscene. Patriotism is bigotry. Faith is a vice. Slashdot 2.0 sucks.
The article seems to assume that 802.11n offers so much more bandwidth that no-one will bother with ethernet any more. Unless the new standard is less susceptible to neighbouring networks, that's just not the case
18 months ago I set up a MythTV setup based around an 802.11g wireless network and, at first, it worked flawlessly - two clients and the server could simultaneously stream TV to/from the router. Then my neighbours started using own networks in anger and the bandwidth available to me gradually dissolved.
Now my network can't come close to supporting one streaming device. Even surfing the net wirelessly is painful, with regular 2-3 second dropouts when the whole street hits the airwaves simultaneously. I've long since given up on wifi and switched to homeplug.
I'm not alone. Most people I know who live in densely populated areas have the same problem. Does 802.11n suffer from the same problems? I imagine that the increased range will just lead to increased contention when its popularity increases. I'm not about to buy it.
1) all the vendors that I've seen have WPA turned on by default. They didn't use to, but then cars didn't have seat belts years ago, either.
2) you can find lots of information about bandwidth. The same site as the article cited has product reviews on ftp throughput; it's about a max of 3/5ths stated bandwidth or less.
3) this already happens. Use 802.11a instead. There are tons of non-interfering channels and you can get double-data-rate schemes with them.
4) someone using your wifi might be legal, but it depends strictly on where you live and what laws apply there. Generally, it's not legal in the US, but there have been few prosecutions. 'Hotspots' are generally thought to be legal to use if they self-identify as 'free wifi' or 'hotspot' etc.
5) use free WiFi sources where you find them. Go to muniwireless.com to understand how muni-wifi projects are tougher than they seem. Nice idea. Expensive and tough to do, and to manage (low) expectations.
---- Teach Peace. It's Cheaper Than War.
Maybe they could put an LCD Display on the front on the router that can display the default password. The default password is randomly generated when it it plugged in for the first time. It can be regenerated by pushing some button on the router. 1 hour after the first connection has been made, the password stops displaying. I'm not sure what the best solution is, and I realize that it should still be possible to create an open access point for those that wish, but I think they should make it a lot harder for the average joe to do that.
Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
The article mentions VoWiFi quality as poor, which makes me believe that the writer is handling the truth somewhat irresponsibly.
I work for one leading VoWiFi company that currently installs a lot of systems at US hospitals. Do you think the hospital administrations should accept anything than perfect performance?
A MOS of 4.2 using ETSI's own measurements and seamless handover is what we are talking about. Not FUD about dropped calls etc. Our i75 passed Cisco's own certification program before their own product and has won a number of prices for best product.
Y.T.
Break the sound barrier - bring the noise.
What impact will 802.11n have?
It will replace 802.11a/b/g, but beyond that, none. Speed really doesn't count as the biggest problem with wireless - I'd personally put "reliability" at #1 and "security" at #2.
Which wireless security threats are scariest?
The DOJ sniffing your traffic from outside rather than needing to at least enter the building (and thus possibly get caught on your security camera(s)).
What of wireless VoIP?
What of it? Whether you use a VOIP set that connects via 802.11, or a VOIP set that connects a base station via ethernet and has a cordless handset makes no difference. Except, perhaps, that while the 2.4GHz spectrum has gotten rather crowded lately, the 800MHz range used for cordless phones has become less congested in recent years.
Will your organization need to change to support enterprise mobility?
Probably, because most enterprise apps tweak if they lose their network connection even momentarily - See my first answer.
How do you control costs in an expanding mobile and wireless environment?
"The only winning move is not to play".
What can you do to stop wireless denial-of-service attacks?"
1) Use a wire.
2) Wait for the entropic death of the universe.
Seriously, no realistic solution exists between those two - A wireless DOS doesn't take anything high-tech... A spark-gap transmitter will do nicely. And don't forget "unintentional" DOSs... At my house, I suffer one every few second due to a nearby airport's radar (again, see my first answer), thus I almost exclusively use a wired connection except for totally noncritical and connection-state-less uses such as surfing the web from my couch.
It is much like a gun. If you don't properly secure it, and your child gets a hold of it and shoots someone (accidentally or otherwise) they're going to be pretty hard on you if you left it loaded on the couch.
What a complete load of crap.
Is there some law that says access points have to be controlled like guns?
Did you need to get a license for your wireless router?
Was there a 3-day waiting period to get one when you went to Best Buy?
Have you told your local Starbucks/coffee-shop or University that they better turn off their open access points or risk going to jail because they are essentially throwing around loaded guns?
No???
Having an open wireless access point isn't against the law. Why would they 'be harder on you' for doing nothing more than having an open access point? Either you have kiddie porn on your machine or not. If you don't then don't be a wimp and live your life in fear.
Do you put boots on all four tires of your car each night to make sure no one steals it and kills someone with it? Why not? THEY COULD!!!
Don't give in to the overreaction and ignorance. Fight it. We need to fight it.