Slashdot Mirror


Do Not Call Listings to Expire in 2008

Ant writes "Yahoo! News report that the cherished dinner hour void of telemarketers could vanish next year for millions of people when phone numbers begin dropping off the national/United States (U.S.)'s Do Not Call list. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which oversees the list, says there is a simple fix. But some lawmakers think it is a hassle to expect people to re-register their phone numbers every five years. Numbers placed on the registry, begun in June 2003, are valid for five years. For the millions of people who signed onto the list in its early days, their numbers will automatically drop off beginning next June if they do not enroll again."

47 of 247 comments (clear)

  1. Does the DNC list even mean anything? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    My mobile # is on the DNC list and I still get calls. I have filed complaints with them and still get the same people calling over and over again. Emperion Marketing (505 647 9618)is my worst offender. I keep getting calls from these asshats, though I have called them and told them to take me off the list. I have filed 4 complaints about them and it hasn't done a thing.

    BTW, register your number here https://www.donotcall.gov/register/Reg.aspx

    1. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by GreyPoopon · · Score: 4, Informative

      keep getting calls from these asshats, though I have called them and told them to take me off the list. I have filed 4 complaints about them and it hasn't done a thing.

      You do realize that you can take them to small claims court yourself, right? I strongly suggest that you keep a log of their calls and anything you tell them.
      --

      GreyPoopon
      --
      Why is it I can write insightful comments but can't come up with a clever signature?

    2. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by drspliff · · Score: 3, Informative

      I had a call today from a company trying to offer me a loan, did the usual stuff asking them to remove me from whatever list I was on and to stop calling - they said to call back on a number (national rate, about 10p a min) only to get transferred to the "customer relations" department which never picked up.

      Then 3 hours later I get an advertisment SMS from the same company, call back up, get transferred again, and the "customer relations" department never picked up - again.

      I've been on the UK TPS (Telephone Preference Service, the UK do not call list) for several years, but still get these stupid companies calling up that I have no idea who they are (so obviously they cant have a previous "relationship" with me).

      I finally got through to the customer relations department after 20 minutes on hold, explained to them that they can be fined upto £5000 for every offence only to be told I have to write in to their marketing department to get it removed.

      I mean seriously, WTF! I've spent about £5 on phone calls today just trying to sort it out with this asshole company, only to be flogged off with a standard excuse and a PObox address.

    3. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by Stripe7 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Anyone telemarketer or charity who calls me loses any chance business with me. I hang up take note of who called and never do business with them again.

    4. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by hedwards · · Score: 2, Interesting

      True, but with commercial ventures you can opt out if you have a business relationship with them. although what that actually is tends to be somewhat vague.

      Nonprofits tend to be the worst, and they are left completely unregulated. During the campaign season it gets really bad, with 7 or 8 calls a night from a computer program to deliver a message. I usually hang up on them.

      Even during the rest of the year we frequently get calls from somebody that isn't on the other end of the phone, usually all I get is a click and several seconds of silence. Those I just hang up on, if they can't be bothered to be present when I answer, I'm certainly not going to consider it important enough to wait for them to come to the phone.

    5. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by nurb432 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Those 'dead lines' are often automated dialer's. Once they get a connection they notify the first available person.

      I think they are banned here in my area. If you are going to bug me, you have to do it yourself :)

      --
      ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    6. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by dwarfking · · Score: 2, Insightful

      This is supposed to be true, but I keep getting hit with a loophole that I can't get anyone to do anything about.

      I moved 2 years ago and got a new number, which had previously been assigned to some woman who apparently bought all kinds of pharmaceuticals by phone. To this day we get calls 3 - 4 times a week from a call center manned by folks that speak accented English trying to sell us drugs. We tell them over and over to remove the number from their list.

      Once I finally got the idiot to put a supervisor on. He claimed that they had prior business with the phone number, not the person, and could keep calling back. I said even if that were true, which it wasn't, they hadn't had a relationship in over a year so now they were required by law to take the number off their list.

      His response: he asked if I wanted to buy any drugs.

      I've filed numerous complaints with the FTC, once found out what state the company was registered in and filed complaints with the Secretary of the State where they were and in my own state. No one does any damn thing about it.

      So as usual, all the DNC list is, is a worthless piece of guvment propaganda legislation to allow the elected officials to claim they did something about the problem. Best solution I have at the moment is to block any calls with "Unknown" in caller ID since they seem to hide their originating phone numbers now, probably to prevent using number block.

      Typical garbage.

    7. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by mhall119 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Even during the rest of the year we frequently get calls from somebody that isn't on the other end of the phone, usually all I get is a click and several seconds of silence. Those I just hang up on, if they can't be bothered to be present when I answer, I'm certainly not going to consider it important enough to wait for them to come to the phone. A better solution is to _not_ hang up, because once you hang up it frees a phone line for them to call someone else, every second you keep the line open reduces their call rate, which reduces the money they make. I frequently ask telemarketers to "hold on just a second" and put the phone on the table for like 5 minutes. Amusingly, sometimes the telemarketer is still there waiting, in which case I tell them "sorry, I'll be just one more second" and go about whatever I was doing for another 5-10 minutes.
      --
      http://www.mhall119.com
    8. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by mhall119 · · Score: 2, Funny

      All I need is some truly horrible hold music... I have toddlers.
      --
      http://www.mhall119.com
    9. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by QMO · · Score: 2, Funny

      I've done a couple of things like that.

      Once I asked to speak to a manager, which meant that I was using the phone line and 2 people. When the mnanager got on, I explained that I was just trying to make that business model a little less profitable.

      Once I offered to sell the telemarketer something (a doorstop-oblolete computer for $3000), and got pretty insistent about it.

      --
      Exam 4/C again. Maybe I'll do better this time.
    10. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by Lord+Apathy · · Score: 2, Informative

      Fuck the DNC list. When I had a land line, don't have this problem anymore, a few years ago. I figured there was only one way to handle it and build myself a call screening box. Here's how it worked. I got a modem that did the caller id thing. Then I sniffed around and found a program that would screen my calls. There where tons of them but the links I had to the free one are no longer any good. Do a google search I guess to find them now.

      Here is how it worked. I had two lists a fuck off list and ring through list. The program would ring on the computer when some one was calling so the computer would ring. I turned off the ringer on the phone. When someone called that was on the fuck off list, private number, or blocked or unlisted, the program would simply pick up the phone then hand up. It would never even ring.

      If you where not on ether list then you got dumped into voice mail to leave a message. Again the computer wouldn't even ring. If you got dumped into my voice mail and didn't leave a message I added you to the fuck off list. So if the computer didn't know you and you where to lazy to leave a message fuck you.

      If you where on my white list then the computer would ring letting me know I had a call. My annoying phone calls went to almost nothing. They went to nothing a year later when I ripped the fucking phone out by the wires.

      --

      Supporting World Peace Through Nuclear Pacification

    11. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by Oliver+Wendell+Jones · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I have a fancy Caller ID box that does the same thing. In addition to Caller ID and a phone directory, it has two additional lists - a Pager list and a Block list. Numbers you add to the Pager list will cause the box to dial your pager when you receive a call, and the Block list will pick up, wait a half second and then hang up - the phone does ring the one time which is still a bit annoying, but if you make it a point to wait for a second ring then you know that it's not one of the phone numbers you have blocked.

      --
      A computer once beat me at chess, but it was no match for me at kick boxing -- Emo Phillips
    12. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by Drathos · · Score: 2, Informative

      During the campaign season it gets really bad, with 7 or 8 calls a night from a computer program to deliver a message. I usually hang up on them. You think that's bad? Last fall, I came home from spending a half day with some friends to find 34 messages on my machine. Almost all of them were a recording: 'This was a political survey call. We'll try again later.'

      Then there was 'The Battle of the Answering Machine.' Opposing candidates were leaving pre-recorded messages on my machine smearing each other. Final tally was 178 messages (nearly 50-50 split) over the span of 3 weeks. Gotta love Virginia campaigning..
      --
      End of line..
    13. Re:Does the DNC list even mean anything? by drspliff · · Score: 2, Funny

      The irony of this is that the company I work for probably provides the 0870 number I called them on.

      Either way, their abusing the TPS by following the guidelines but presuming that people won't go to the hassle of reporting them or mailing in to get themselfs removed from the list.

      I really can't be bothered to go through the trouble of taking this to court, when they'll probably prove that I have a "technical" prior relationship with them through some sister company (any company I've entered my telephone number with in the past 6 months, like my bank or my co-lo company etc.) and that my claim isn't valid.

      I got bored with winding up telemarketers that called me and started getting angry instead, maybe I'll start winding them up again and play the "how long can I keep them on the line" game, passing them through to a never-ending "please wait while we transfer you" call queue that's usually reserved for difficult customers :)

  2. Not that tricky by PlatyPaul · · Score: 5, Funny

    Signing up on a web form every 5 years - 10 minutes Avoiding telemarketing phone calls during dinner, sex, and sleep - Priceless.

    --
    Misery loves company. Online misery loves unsuspecting random strangers.
    1. Re:Not that tricky by generica1 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      That's what I was thinking - "so what, it takes only a few minutes to sign back up again."

      Well worth the effort, compared to the alternative. At least there is a mechanism in place to get your number(s) off the list, because that was once not the case.

      --
      JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP IRRIGATE
    2. Re:Not that tricky by antifoidulus · · Score: 5, Funny

      Man, you have a regular eating schedule, get laid, and actually have time to sleep instead of spending all nighters at the office? I have to call your geek credentials into question.....

      Just out of curiosity, have you tried doing all 3 of those at the same time?

    3. Re:Not that tricky by maxwell+demon · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Man, you have a regular eating schedule, get laid, and actually have time to sleep instead of spending all nighters at the office? I have to call your geek credentials into question.....

      He didn't say how he gets dinner, sex and sleep. It's entirely possible that his way of getting those is:
      * dinner: Pizza eaten in front of the computer at some random time after 4pm.
      * sex: One-handed surfing.
      * sleep: When he dreams of the great new stuff he'll write soon ...
      --
      The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
    4. Re:Not that tricky by gardyloo · · Score: 3, Funny

      Ah, yes, because whatever the hamster is doing, it's going to be *more* disturbed by having a cell phone ring.

    5. Re:Not that tricky by Chineseyes · · Score: 3, Funny

      Man, you have a regular eating schedule, get laid, and actually have time to sleep...........

      Don't be too jealous of the parent his regular meals are a step above pig feed, he gets laid(raped) by his his cellmate bubba, and his cries himself to sleep.

      --
      I think the invisible hand of the market has its middle finger extended

      --A wise old fart named SC0RN
    6. Re:Not that tricky by hazem · · Score: 2, Funny

      Try a Barry White ringtone... it works so well you'll be begging for telemarketers to call just to get her in the mood.

  3. Simple by awkScooby · · Score: 4, Funny

    They should just hire some telemarketers to call people during dinner, to see if they would like to re-register for the do not call list...

  4. Let it expire ... by Average_Joe_Sixpack · · Score: 3, Funny

    I'm lonely

  5. people move, numbers change by OrangeTide · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's only fair that the enrollment is not permanent otherwise one day the list would include nearly every number. Even if some people who originally registered have switched numbers (moved to a different area code for example) or are deceased.

    An everlasting list would be equivalent to a soft ban on telemarketing. If you really want to do that, just do that instead. For now 5 years seems perfectly reasonable for me to re-register.

    How will I know when to enroll again? When I start getting annoying calls after 5pm.

    --
    “Common sense is not so common.” — Voltaire
    1. Re:people move, numbers change by belmolis · · Score: 4, Insightful

      No, there's another mechanism for dealing with this. Numbers are automatically removed from the do-not-call list when they are disconnected or reassigned.

    2. Re:people move, numbers change by pete-classic · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Actually, opt-in makes the most sense.

      -Peter

  6. Thanks by jtroutman · · Score: 5, Funny

    Thanks for the reminder, I just re-signed up. Can you post this story again in five years so I'll remember to do it then to?

    --
    I stole this sig from a more creative user.
  7. Irony continued... by packetmon · · Score: 4, Funny

    So I tried to call my local representative to have a word in with him about this and he hung up claiming he was on some form of Do Not Call list. Can you imagine that?

  8. How many? by Generic+Guy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'd say five years is a pretty good amount of time. What percent of the population keep a number for that long, anyway?

    If the Do-Not-Call list were to never expire, eventually it will fill to all available U.S. phone numbers. We might as well simply impose a Telemarketer Banning Law in that case.

    --
    { - Generic Guy - }
    1. Re:How many? by RedSteve · · Score: 5, Insightful

      If the Do-Not-Call list were to never expire, eventually it will fill to all available U.S. phone numbers.

      Um...so what would the problem be with that?

    2. Re:How many? by DragonWriter · · Score: 2, Informative

      What percent of the population keep a number for that long, anyway?


      Probably almost everyone who doesn't move outside of a local exchange (that is, excluding people that rotate numbers because they are repeated targets of harrassment); I'd expect probably a sizable majority of people and a slightly smaller majority of phone numbers (as second and additional lines may be more transitory.)

      If the Do-Not-Call list were to never expire, eventually it will fill to all available U.S. phone numbers.


      It would make some sense to make it so that you registered through your phone service provider, and they pulled the listing of the database if the subscriber discontinued use of the number. It makes more sense than a fixed 5-year period, at any rate.
  9. Not re-registering by Drathos · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I for one will not be re-registering my number. Hopefully it will get me fewer calls. The DNC has been a nightmare for me as my call volume has increased at least ten fold since it started. I'd rather get four or five calls a week with people who I can tell to take me off their list (what I used to get) than the 10+ calls a day from autodialers with forged Caller ID and noone on the other end of the line (so they can't be reported).

    Knowing my luck, however, I will get both..

    --
    End of line..
  10. Can't They Send a Reminder? by Slashdot+Parent · · Score: 5, Informative

    They have an email address associated with each phone number. Why can't they send out a reminder 6 months before your number's expiration so you can renew?

    FYI- You can renew your Do Not Call registrations at any time, even if they are not about to expie. I renewed all my numbers today, despite some of them not expiring for over a year.

    --
    They don't grade fathers, but if your daughter's a stripper, you fucked up. --Chris Rock
  11. Re:what happened to privacy? by belmolis · · Score: 3, Informative

    What I described is the existing procedure, not necessarily what I want. In any case, the phone companies don't need to submit identifying information, just a list of phone numbers. And note that this information is publicly available anyhow, with somewhat more effort. The government can easily enough check whether a phone number has been changed, as can you.

  12. Reminder by Dmala · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It's not a big deal to have to renew, but it would be nice if you could opt in for an e-mail reminder or something. There's pretty much zero chance I could remember on my own before it expired. I dropped off the list temporarily when I moved recently and had to change my phone number. My phone pretty much rang non-stop from the moment it was connected to the moment (a week later) when it got added to the list. I had kind of forgotten how irritating the constant harassment could be.

  13. Simple Fix by Joebert · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Why not just leave the numbers on the list untill the number changes hands or is disconnected ?

    This 5 year bit sounds like somthing to keep lobbyists from crying.

    --
    Wanna fight ? Bend over, stick your head up your ass, and fight for air.
  14. Why cron was invented by giminy · · Score: 4, Informative

    0 0 1 1 * wget --post-data 'ctlACPH1:txtAreaCode=&ctlACPH1:txtPhone=&ctlEmail:txtEmail=&txtConfirmEmail=' https://www.donotcall.gov/Register/Reg.aspx

    You could wrap the wget in an if-block to see if the year is divisible by 5, but I'm lazy.

    Reid

    --
    The Right Reverend K. Reid Wightman,
    1. Re:Why cron was invented by AeroIllini · · Score: 2, Informative
      Yeah, but that assumes the page won't change in five years. Better to just do this:

      0 0 1 1 * echo "Don't forget to update your numbers here: https://www.donotcall.gov/Register/Reg.aspx - Yourself" > tmp && mail -s "Renew your Do-Not-Call registry!" <your-email> < tmp
      --
      For security, the MD5 hash of this message and sig is 09f911029d74e35bd84156c5635688c0.
  15. If you want to stay off telemarketer phone lists by AnalogDiehard · · Score: 2, Informative
    Then get an unpublished (not unlisted) phone number.

    I've moved twice in the past six years, both times I got an unpublished number. When a telemarketer called, they were informed that this was an unpublished number and to please put it on their DNC list. That brought all telemarketing calls to a screeching halt.

    When I started my new job last year I moved to a new city and ordered a second land line phone number with distinctive ring for off duty support for work emergencies. Both numbers are unpublished. After the first couple of false alarms with telemarketers calling the "hot line", they stopped real fast.

    It does not cost much more for unpublished numbers.

    --
    Eternity: will that be smoking, or non-smoking? I Corinthians 6:9-10
  16. As a former telemarketer by ttapper04 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    We have to make all the calls through a "filter" of sorts, it references "the list." We also had the ability to add people to the list, and were mandated to do so upon request. Our company faced stiff penalties for calling people on the list as well.

    Bottom line:Tell the first telemarketer who calls you to add you to the list.

    A quick side note: The bank of phone numbers my company would call could be sorted by name, age, race, income, marital status, and sexual preference. I recall a time when we payed another company $1100 for a list of gay people in Illinois. No kidding.

  17. Last night by Dunbal · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Funny, I got a call last night from a telemarketer that went something like this:

          "Hi Mr. So and so? I wonder if you had a minute so I could remind you that your telephone number will be off the "Do Not Call list" next year, and to offer you our automatic "Do Not Call" list renewal service. For just $1.95 a month our company will track your telephone number and automatically renew your status on this list for you every five years..."

          I'm joking, of course. But how far away are we from this? :)

    --
    Seven puppies were harmed during the making of this post.
  18. Spam Assassin for PBX by y86 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I wish there was a product that just automatically -- never rang and just hung up on a large swath of numbers.

    Kind of like Spam Assassin does for email -- it's like the message was never sent.

    I see an IPO, a little black box that gets a list of telemarketers numbers from the net and blocks them all!

    Any takers?

    1. Re:Spam Assassin for PBX by sricetx · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Why not a product that whitelists numbers that will ring through? Why should I answer calls from random numbers? Those can go straight to voicemail. You would think the telcos would sell a service like this, but I've never seen it. I suppose one could route all calls through an Asterisk box and have rules set up for this...

  19. "White Knight" Hackers by maxchaote · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'm surprised noone's made a script to automatically start registering every US number. I just re-entered my phone numbers and was surprised that you only have to enter your phone number and click on a confirmation link in an email to register. There's no verification that the number is yours or even a captcha. It would be very easy for someone to game this system.

    Then again, that might be the perfect excuse for the telemarketing industry to call for a lengthy and expensive overhaul of the system and wind up screwing us all...

  20. Do Not Call -- Ha.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I added all my numbers, phone and fax, to the do not call list, back when do-not-call started,
    and it was the first thing I did after establishing a new phone whenever I moved, and I still
    get about two calls a day to the voice line, and one or two junk faxes a day. Sometimes more.

    I have a two inch pile of junk faxes from 2006; I kept them all, just to see
    how many I get. I also get regular automated voice calls for the same crap over and over;
    credit card debt relief and to clean my rugs (I have hardwood floors, and no credit card debt).
    At least it's easy to tell it's a recording and just hang up.. but the same thing over and over?
    Someone's wasting their junk advertising dollars.

    The automated calls give an option at the end to either 'press 1 to make an appointment,
    or press 2 to remove you from our call list', and of course when you press '2' it says
    it's an invalid option, likely some kind of loophole in the law..

    I've searched the web for the caller-ids, and it seems this happens all over
    the country.. some folks were successful at tracking down who actually makes the calls
    (often a Florida address), and some interrogated the people who picked up when you
    'press 1' finding they're just working for some unknown entity out of their basement.
    The caller-id numbers are from all over, sometimes local, sometimes from other states,
    and others 'Blocked', but often it's the same message.

    And if I ever give money to a police or goodwill charity, for the next three months
    I get calls from every police and charity organization asking for money at dinner,
    lunch and breakfast. After a few cycles of this, I've simply stopped giving to charities..
    screw 'em all.

    I don't know how many calls do-not-call is preventing, maybe a lot, maybe a few,
    but there's obviously some kind of loopholes..

  21. I miss those calls by jbeaupre · · Score: 3, Funny

    I kind of miss telemarketer calls.

    Would you like to subscribe to our newspaper? No, I'm illiterate!

    Would you like new windows? No, this house is so run down I'm abandoning it.

    Would you like to donate to the children? No, I don't like children.

    Would you like to donate to the police fund? Will you let my brother out of jail?

    and so on. Come up with a response that is not on their list and it's comedy gold.

    --
    The world is made by those who show up for the job.
  22. Already renewed by amigabill · · Score: 2, Informative

    I started getting telemarketing calls again a couple months ago and reregistered all my numbers. I'd rather not have to, but it's worth the couple minutes involved. I get very little phone spam, mostly mortgage offers which I turn down by saying "It's illegal for you to be talking to me right now".