Slashdot Mirror
Google To Host Ajax Libraries
ruphus13 writes "So, hosting and managing a ton of Ajax calls, even when working with mootools, dojo or scriptaculous, can be quite cumbersome, especially as they get updated, along with your code. In addition, several sites now use these libraries, and the end-user has to download the library each time. Google now will provide hosted versions of these libraries, so users can simply reference Google's hosted version. From the article, 'The thing is, what if multiple sites are using Prototype 1.6? Because browsers cache files according to their URL, there is no way for your browser to realize that it is downloading the same file multiple times. And thus, if you visit 30 sites that use Prototype, then your browser will download prototype.js 30 times.
Today, Google announced a partial solution to this problem that seems obvious in retrospect: Google is now offering the "Google Ajax Libraries API," which allows sites to download five well-known Ajax libraries (Dojo, Prototype, Scriptaculous, Mootools, and jQuery) from Google. This will only work if many sites decide to use Google's copies of the JavaScript libraries; if only one site does so, then there will be no real speed improvement.
There is, of course, something of a privacy violation here, in that Google will now be able to keep track of which users are entering various non-Google Web pages.' Will users adopt this, or is it easy enough to simply host an additional file?"
Compared to all the other crappy media that sites tend to have these days, centralizing distribution of a bunch of Javascript libraries makes almost no sense. I doubt it would even appreciably reduce your bandwidth costs.
This is only a partial solution. The real solution is for sites using AJAX to get away from this habit of requiring hundreds of kilobytes of scrip just to visit the home page. Couldn't you design a modular AJAX system that would bring in functions as they are needed? That way, someone visiting just a couple pages wouldn't have to download the entire library. Have each function in it's own file, and then when an AJAX call is done, make it smart enough to figure out which functions need to be downloaded to run the resulting Javascript. The problem with Google hosting everything, is that everybody has to use the versions that Google has posted, and that you can't do any custom modifications to the components. I think that what Google is doing would help. But the solution is far from optimal.
Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
As a developer, privacy of my users is of paramount importance. I have grown increasingly concerned with Google's apparently incessant need to pry into my searches and my browsing habits. Where once I was a major Google supporter, I have trimmed my use of their service back from email and toolbars to simple searches and now even won't use their service at all if I am searching for anything that may be misconstrued at some point by guys in dark suits with plastic ID badges. The last thing I am going to do as a developer is force my users into a situation where they can feed the Google Logging Engine.
public void karmaWhore(String url){addSlashdotComment(fetchContent(url));}
Yes, you've gotta be careful with those incompetant sysadmins that Google are hiring.
After all, they're constantly getting the servers hacked.
Additionally, if you're using compression, it is likely that one large file will compress more effectively than a collection of smaller files. (You *are* using compression, aren't you?)