Slashdot Mirror


Making a Child Locating System

celtic_hackr writes "Well, I never thought I'd be an advocate for placing GPS devices on people. However, since it took less than three days for my local school district to misplace my daughter, I have decided that something needs to be done. By the school district's own admission it has a recurring problem of placing children on the wrong buses. Fortunately, my daughter was located, with no thanks to the local school district. Therefore, I would like input on a way to be able to keep track of my child. I know there are personal tracking devices out there. I have nothing against these systems. But I want more than this. My specification are: 1) a small unobtrusive device I can place on my daughter, 2) an application to pull up on any computer, a map with a dot indicating the real-time position of my child, 3) a handheld device with the equivalent information, 4) [optional] a secure web application/plug-in I can install on my own domain allowing me to track her from anyplace in the world, 5) a means of turning it all off, 6) a Linux based solution of the above. I believe all the pieces for making such a system are out there. Has anyone built anything like this? Is there an open source solution? How would I go about building my own? Has anyone hacked any of these personal trackers before, to serve their own purposes? How does a tinfoil hat wearer engineer such a device to make sure Big-Brother isn't watching too? Can these devices be locked down so only certain devices can pick up the GPS location of an individual locator? What other recommendations do you have?"

33 of 1,092 comments (clear)

  1. Holy Crap! Calm down by FredFredrickson · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Holy crap- you are, what we in the biz call, an over-reacting parent. Calm down and take it easy before you destroy your daughter's life.

    That being said- verizon has an application for cell phones that lets you track your children- it's on get it now. I'm sure other carriers have something similar.

    --
    Belief? Hope? Preference?The Existential Vortex
    1. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by tekiegreg · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Duh-boy, cue debates on how much surveillance for your child is really necessary.

      I'd say just let him be a parent and decide what's necessary. He knows his daughter better than we all do.

      --
      ...in bed
    2. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      you're assuming the guy in the article is honestly trying to track his daughter. one of the clients i work for is a bettered womens advocacy group and shelter. they have horror stories all the time of guys who do the same thing to their wives, ex wives girlfriends etc. its easy enough to rig a cellphone thats GPS enabled to create a tracking device and discreet survailence tool. if you ask me, the whole thing is shady. perhaps its my paranoia light flashing because of my client, i can understand your concern, but 10s of thousands, nay 10s of millions of kids make it thought the school system every year without their parents needing to freak out like that.

    3. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by blueZ3 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      This isn't mean to be a flame, because as a fellow parent (of toddlers, no less) I understand that it can be an extremely stressful and fear-inducing thing to lose track of your child. But I agree with the parent: get some perspective on things by waiting for a bit before subjecting your daughter to Big-Brother-like monitoring.

      Not only do I think you are overreacting, you are sending the wrong message to your school-age daughter. She doesn't need 24-7 tracking, she needs lessons in dealing with unexpected situations. Instead of jumping directly to an electronic device, teach her what to do if she gets lost... the same strategy that's been used successfully by parents for many, many years: find a "safe" adult (police officer, female adult with kids) and tell them that she's lost. If she's old enough to attend school, she's old enough to learn her phone number and address.

      Besides, if she's anything like most kids, anything you "attach" to her (short of a steel shackle) she is going to remove and leave behind or lose. :-)

      Again, I understand your reaction (on one level) but I think you're overreacting.

      --
      Interested in a Flash-based MAME front end? Visit mame.danzbb.com
    4. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by Etrias · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Because we should all live our lives in fear and worry, right?

      I'm not trying to make light of that situation, but I picked up the phrase "fear fuels the economy" from somewhere and if you look around, it does. Watch the news? How many times are they telling you about something dangerous or about how so-and-so is horrible and bad for you. For every fear, there's a market to be sold to. Yes, bad things happen, but in terms of history, we are living in one of the most safest times ever.

    5. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by westlake · · Score: 4, Insightful

      He knows his daughter better than we all do.

      He also knows his school district better than we do. These decisions are never made in a vacuum.

      I would question pursuing the Linux or Open Source solution if others do the job better. It's the safety of your kid that matters here - not your own political correctness.

    6. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by raju1kabir · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Yes, because if one bad thing happens to one of seven billion people anywhere in the world, then it makes perfect sense to focus all your energies on making sure it doesn't happen to you.

      More and more proof that the human brain just wasn't meant to comprehend societies as large as ours. The in-built statistical heuristics break down completely and start recommending the most irrational things.

      --
      "Patriotism is your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it." -- GBS
    7. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by LWATCDR · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I think that you and many other people are missing the real problem. Elementary school children can be as young as four at the start of kindergarten. Elementary schools are just too big these days!.
      One elementary school in my town has several thousand students. That is just insane.
      Schools should start small and grow in size. The elementary school should be in your neighborhood. The idea of shipping kindergarten kids like UPS packages to child warehouses is the problem.
      Of course to build more but smaller schools costs money.....

      --
      See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
    8. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by JWSmythe · · Score: 5, Insightful

          When I was in kindergarden, they went with the low-tech system. Every kid had a name tag that they had to wear all day. It had their name, grade, teacher, and bus number. Teachers aids were by the buses and would verify the bus number on the tag matched the bus. If they kid got on the wrong bus, they were turned away and walked to the right one.

          How much does it cost for a 3x5 index card and a safety pin? A whole lot less than an electronic tracking system, and recurring cell bills for your kid.

      --
      Serious? Seriousness is well above my pay grade.
    9. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by vlm · · Score: 5, Insightful

      When I was a kid, we had an even simpler and even lower technology plan, which was, never go anywhere without "Matt" and "Dawn".

      If your bus stop has only one kid whom uses it, then move out of the retirement village.

      Another ultra low tech strategy that worked well at various times in my youth, and currently works well for me as a parent, is "buy a house two blocks from school". It is of course uphill both ways in the snow, but, at least its a short walk.

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    10. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by Critical+Facilities · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I have to second this comment. Also, to the posters who are bashing this person, and asking him/her to take the issue up with his/her school system, I think you're all overestimating the ability of many school employees as well as the efficiency with which requests get accommodated in many school systems. In my area, the public schools are completely overrun, mismanaged, and underfunded....badly. Now, I'm not advocating that the person asking for suggestions should try to exert some influence over the school system, but to act as though "fixing" the school's "problems" is easy doesn't really help.

      Besides, is it really that crazy of an idea for the kid to carry a cell phone (with or without GPS)? Nowhere in the post does it say how old the child is. I think some of the people jumping on this "overprotective parent" bandwagon are thinking this kid is some 12-13 year old kid. They might change their tune if (as the parent post points out) it's a 4 yr old girl/boy.

    11. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by raju1kabir · · Score: 5, Insightful

      As a parent with a mentally disabled child, I do not agree.

      As a parent with a mentally disabled child, you are talking about a situation that is more challenging and complex than the situation the rest of us are discussing. Apples and oranges.

      --
      "Patriotism is your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it." -- GBS
    12. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by _Swank · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Only one of the two solves the original problem; the technology-based tracking system is useless in ensuring the kid gets on the right bus, while the index card system should generally work.

    13. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by Cedric+Tsui · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Agreed. Here's an idea.

      Next time you go to the mall with the family, teach your daughter to talk to strangers.
      What? No way! Strangers are BAD. BAD EVIL people who want to randomly inject her with drugs so she'll become an addict and a regular client.

      Next time you go to the mall with the family, teach your daughter to talk to the right strangers. Mall clerks at security booths. Other parents. Security guards. Bus drivers. If you can teach your daughter to become street smart, she will be able to take care of herself when you're not around. She'll be safe even if you are unable to access your handheld, or the internet is down, or the power goes out...

    14. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by cayenne8 · · Score: 4, Insightful
      "But don't let it substitute for your kid being responsible for giving you a call later on to let you know what they're up to when they aren't following the usual plan."

      Hear hear!!

      Goodness...how did we EVER survive as a species before cell phones and GPS trackers??!?!

      When I was a kid, I roamed all over the neighborhood, and ones near us. When really young, I had to call home on a neighbor's phone every couple hours or so to check in. If both parents were working, I called Mom at work.

      Geez..with all these new 'needs' for tracking kids, and apparent law changes or whatever, I imagine my parents and most of my peers parents would be sued by the state these days for child negligence for how we were raised.

      And let's not forget we as kids weren't drugged by our parents like they are today. Amazing we learned in school and survived at all, truly.

      --
      Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.........
    15. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by psychodelicacy · · Score: 5, Insightful

      It's morally different, perhaps, but not in effect. The school accidentally places the child on the wrong bus; the child ends up who-knows-where without a parent at the other end to collect him/her. The child ends up unattended even though that was never the intention.

      --
      A closed mouth gathers no foot.
    16. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by ArsonSmith · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Goodness...how did we EVER survive as a species before cell phones and GPS trackers??!?!

      Much higher birth rates.

      --
      Paying taxes to buy civilization is like paying a hooker to buy love.
    17. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by lgw · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Child predators are almost a myth, and certainly not a meaninful risk. Children are abducted by relatives, especially the losers in custody battles. Being abducted by a stranger is about as likely as being struck by lighting (unless you live in Florida, then lightning is the bigger risk).

      --
      Socialism: a lie told by totalitarians and believed by fools.
    18. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by ChefInnocent · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I know when I was in kindergarten (back in the 70's), I was daydreaming when my bus stop came up. When the bus driver said we were at the last stop, I explained I had missed my stop. Fortunately, he had to drive past most of the bus stops on the way back to the school yard. When my bus stop came up, I pointed out which one it was, and was let off.

      I'm curious why his daughter wouldn't have known she was on the wrong bus, and simply been driven back to the school where an administrator could call her parents. Once she knew she was "lost", she should have explained to the bus driver, who could then call into the school. The school should then call the parent(s) to let them know when they can pick her up from the campus.

      I'm not seeing why this should be a big deal unless both his daughter and the administrators needs special assistance.

    19. Re:Holy Crap! Calm down by shmlco · · Score: 5, Insightful

      A child is about a 1,000 times more likely to be killed by drowning in a neighbor's pool than abducted by a total stranger. 10,000 times more likely to be seriously injured or even killed playing school sports. And 100 times more likely to be struck by lightning.

      Parents need to stop watching CSI and Criminal Minds and Law & Order.

      --
      Any sect, cult, or religion will legislate its creed into law if it acquires the political power to do so.
  2. Cell phone by Spazztastic · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Buy your daughter a cellphone and have her use Google Latitude? Set up speed dial to call you, your wife, etc.? Just kicking ideas around...

    --
    Posts not to be taken literally. Almost everything is sarcasm.
  3. Placing children on the wrong bus? by rob1980 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    When I was in middle school they gave all the kids a laminated bus pass with the bus number in big block type, and had the bus numbers spray painted on the sidewalk so everyone who had to ride the bus knew exactly where to line up. Nobody ever got on the wrong bus because nobody ever got in the wrong line. So why is this a recurring problem for your daughter's school district?

    I say make them fix the problem instead of forcing you to shell out money to cover it up for them.

  4. GPS + SMS. by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    You probably don't want it continually transmitting. Easiest way would be to it respond to a 'ping'. http://www.mightygps.com/smsgps.htm looks to fit the bill perfectly. There are probably cheaper Chinese clones.

    Get it a SIM card and you'll be able to track her anywhere there's AT&T Signal (so you're equally fucked anyway). Google Maps API kicks ass. It's not hard to write some code to take that SMS and turn it into a dot on a map.
    -
    However I agree with the other posters. Your kid's fine. How many kids have they PERMANENTLY lost? So the kid gets on the wrong bus. Teach your daughter English and she should be able to find out where she is at any time.

    Reminds me of the mother who caught a ton of flack for letting her young son find his own way home (he asked to) from a big store in NYC.

    The people that want to rape and molest your daughter statistically are yourself or one of your brothers(-in-law)

  5. Simple Solution by Dr.+Evil · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Teach them their phone number and give them a bracelet or something with their address on it.

    You should also probably stop watching television. Give up on the news especially. It's just scare mongering crap.

    Oh and watch Finding Nemo. It's got some lesson in there about being an overprotective parent.

  6. You're solving the wrong problem by dkleinsc · · Score: 5, Insightful

    However, since it took less than three days for my local school district to misplace my daughter, I have decided that something needs to be done. By the school district's own admission it is a recurring problem of placing children on the wrong buses. Fortunately, my daughter was located, with no thanks to the local school district.

    The problem isn't that you don't have a tracking device for your daughter. The problem is that your local school district isn't doing its job correctly and regularly putting kids on the wrong bus. Instead of posting on Slashdot for a technical solution, a far better solution would be a call to your local news organizations about how the school district is getting kids lost on their bus system and admits to doing that regularly. Raise a stink at school board meetings, PTA meetings, and so forth. Get other parents involved. You're talking about a school district's incompetence endangering not only your own child but all the children in the district.

    Pretend, for instance, that you get a perfect tracking device for your daughter. That sorta solves your problem, in that you can go and pick up your daughter from wherever she was left, but doesn't solve your neighbor's problem, and doesn't solve the problem of what happens to your daughter when she's standing around in a strange neighborhood.

    --
    I am officially gone from /. Long live http://www.soylentnews.com/
  7. Wrong Solution by causality · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If this question came up a generation ago, before GPS trackers and similar devices were available, you would be looking for ways to better plan school events and to hold the schoolteachers and other school staff accountable for these kinds of mishaps. I think that's the right way to deal with this, though it's not the easy band-aid solution that installing a tracking device would be. In other words, the technological development of a wrong solution doesn't change what the right solution was all along.

    I just don't believe in this widespread approach of dealing only with the symptoms of problems. I might consider it (though wouldn't like it one bit) if it were a material object, but the fact that this is a human being should be all the more reason to address the actual problem. The irresponsibility of the school system and the fact that it has taken its obligations lightly is the actual core problem here. A tracking device only provides an incentive for letting them off the hook when they should have to answer for their failures. Yes, that would be much harder to arrange and would probably require political pressure from other like-minded parents, but it would be so much more worthwhile in the end.

    --
    It is a miracle that curiosity survives formal education. - Einstein
  8. It's amazing really by 0racle · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's really amazing how any of us, and humanity in general, ever lived past their 10th birthday without all the 'safety' gear that is available now. What a truly wonderful time to be alive, we now finally have the tools to live on past childhood.

    --
    "I use a Mac because I'm just better than you are."
  9. Re:Drive her by starglider29a · · Score: 5, Insightful

    True. Why use a public, already-funded, low MPG-per-rider system when EACH parent can drive their SUVs to drop the kids off? In fact, why don't you just home-school your child and save lots of resources. And if you all buy hybrids, you can save the auto industry.

    I hope I broke the needle on your sarcasm meter.

  10. Re:Drive her by that+IT+girl · · Score: 5, Insightful

    You do realize this is impossible for an increasing percentage of the population, right? Hence the existence of buses to begin with.

    --
    10 FILL MUG WITH COFFEE
    20 DRINK COFFEE
    30 GOTO 10
  11. Educate her by blhack · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This happened to me when I was a kid. The school thought that I had signed up for Hockey, but hadn't. They sent me across town to hockey practice.
    Instead of freaking out, I got there and started playing hockey. Then I called my mom and told her to come and pick me up.
    Why? Because I didn't have psychotic over-reacting parents. I was smart enough to go "there is a problem here, I should fix it."
    And I did.

    Teach your daughter this same thing. Make her memorize your phone number.

    --
    NewslilySocial News. No lolcats allowed.
  12. escape by Lord+Ender · · Score: 4, Insightful

    My specification are: 1) a small unobtrusive device I can place on my daughter, 2) an application to pull up on any computer, a map with a dot indicating the real-time position of my child, 3) a handheld device with the equivalent information, 4) [optional] a secure web application/plug-in I can install on my own domain allowing me to track her from anyplace in the world, 5) a means of turning it all off, 6) a Linux based solution of the above.

    Wow. Perhaps she was trying to get away from you.

    --
    A slashdotter who didn't build his own computer is like a Jedi who didn't build his own lightsaber.
  13. How about teaching by BlowHole666 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    How about you just teach your child what bus to get on. Or pick your child up from school. In 20 years are you going to want your child to think it is ok to track a person? Will your child be one of the ones that says "Well my parents tracked me as a child and I was fine, so lets let the government track us". The buses have numbers written on them just teach your child what number theirs. Once you advocate tracking people as a valid solution to a problem everyone is doing it.

    --
    I smoked pot once. But I DID NOT inhale. Will you hire me?
  14. Please don't think of the children. by Dutchmaan · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Remember folks, it's been said over and over and over again... First it will be tracking criminals, then it will be tracking children for their safety, then it will be tracking the general populous because they grew up with it.

    With technology come vigilance on how it's used and how it could *potentially* be used.

    Humanity, sliding down that slippery slope since 1984.