Slashdot Mirror


Ask Slashdot: How To Enter Private Space Industry As an Engineer?

First time accepted submitter CtownNighrider writes "I'm in my senior year of high school currently in a selective program for future engineers. I have always been a good student and feel like I can get into most good schools (MIT is a long shot but RPI isn't). I plan on studying aerospace engineering (most likely getting a dual major with mechanical) in college and working for a company like SpaceX once I graduate. I would love any advice anyone can offer for my college search or being an engineer in general. I live in upstate NY and don't want to travel super far, I'm thinking about a 5 hour radius. I have the RPI medal so it's one of my top choices and MIT is my long shot but I'm having a tough time figuring out what schools are worth applying too. Academics come first hands down so male/female ratio and party scene aren't too important."

158 of 283 comments (clear)

  1. Co-op by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    Interview and get a co-operative engineer position at any space-related engineering firm. Sounds like your credentials could get you an interview. Can't be beat to get a leg up on that type of career; it worked for me...

    1. Re:Co-op by davester666 · · Score: 2

      Build a rocket and then upload the video of it blowing up just off the launchpad to youtube.

      --
      Sleep your way to a whiter smile...date a dentist!
  2. Go to a good state school by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Don't feel like you have to go to a hard-core engineering school. Go to the best state school in your area, the undergraduate curriculum is not much different from a really well regarded school like MIT. It will be cheaper and you will likely have a better social life.

    Recognize that with fancy schools you are paying for the prestige, the education is not much different. I went to a top five engineering school, most of my classes were giant lectures that would have been exactly the same at any state school. (the state school is often even better if they have good professors rather than uber-researchers who suck at teaching) If you really want prestige go to the best graduate program you can get into after you graduate. For good engineering students this is typically free and the high prestige schools actually are better at that level.

    You say you do not care about the quality of your social life now, but believe me, after 4 years of hardcore engineering school you will. Nearly everyone who makes this decision does

    1. Re:Go to a good state school by robbrit · · Score: 2

      +1 for the social scene: the majority of the jobs you'll get will be through your friends that you make at university, not because you have a fancy name on your resume. Being surrounded by creative, smart people and forming good relationships with them is easily just as important as learning engineering concepts and getting good grades. Since engineers are known to drink a lot, the party scene is not something to discount since it's quite a bit easier to form bonds with people over drinking games than over class projects.

      If you're looking for lower cost, there are a number of universities with good engineering programs in Canada such as McGill, Queens, University of Toronto, University of Waterloo that are fairly close to New York state. They're all publicly funded and so even paying the international student rate is often cheaper than private universities in the USA like MIT.

    2. Re:Go to a good state school by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Recognize that with fancy schools you are paying for the prestige, the education is not much different.

      This is just not the case for MIT. I went to MIT and what I got out of it was not just prestige. My classes were often taught by some of the greatest geniuses in their fields. E.g., when I took Computer Science 101 (or 6.001 as it was called at MIT), the class was taught by Sussman and Ableson, the two authors of SICP. Sussman is also one of the two inventors of Scheme. At the time SICP hadn't even been published yet, and Scheme hadn't yet been widely released. I was getting an education like no other place in the world.

      Being taught by geniuses of this sort was utterly inspiring. You'd think that such people might be great researchers but terrible teachers, but that was anything but the case, In actuality, they were usually great teachers, who exuded unbridled and contagious enthusiasm for what they did.

      MIT is also a bit unusual, in that it offers numerous opportunities for undergraduate students to wok with famous professors, doing real research. As far as I am aware, this is rather unusual, and is a great opportunity, if you take advantage of it. If you do interesting research as an undergraduate, then you are a shoe-in to a good graduate program.

      |>ouglas

      P.S. Though, one shouldn't discount prestige, either. I feel I rarely have a problem getting my foot in the door at a company due to having an MIT education on my resume.

    3. Re:Go to a good state school by FunkSoulBrother · · Score: 1

      I think you underestimate how much those non-engineering majors are drinking.

    4. Re:Go to a good state school by jorghis · · Score: 2

      I will grant you the value of prestige in getting your foot in the door at companies.

      However, I really don't believe in the value of having courses taught by famous people. Data structures is simple enough that being taught the subject by a pioneer in the field versus someone who only has a masters degree s/he got last month isn't going to make much of a difference.

      It's great that you had good teachers who were also famous, but realize that quite often there are equally good if not better teachers who are significantly less accomplished. You don't need to pay a bazillion dollars a year for an MIT education to get a good data structures professor. :)

    5. Re:Go to a good state school by meustrus · · Score: 2

      My advice based on some partial regrets: Don't just hang out at a "state school" (assuming that means University of ); take a couple of years at a community college. Assuming they exist in NY...I come from California where after two years in a CC you are guaranteed admission to a UC school depending on your grades (including UC Berkeley or UCLA). Not only that but IIRC you have an Associate's Degree which can come in handy in the interim if you're looking to get any short term academic work.

      The primary reason for this, however, is that community colleges have small class sizes and the professors aren't there to do research. The last place you want to be in your Calculus, Physics, Discrete Logic, whatever classes is a huge lecture hall with a hot shot researcher who can't teach and has a thick, almost indecipherable accent. The #1 problem with most larger schools is that because their funding is mostly research-based, most of the faculty are there to do research and therefore are completely unaccountable for their teaching performance. At my school many departments prohibit the registrar from publishing the instructor when students are signing up for classes because the advisors would tell students to stay out of Y professor's class so they'll actually learn something.

      All that said, from what I've heard MIT (also Stanford) is a little special. If you can get into the program (which you should try if you think you have any chance) it's probably worth it to skip the CC. Be thinking about how you'll pay for it though, because that's two extra years of high tuition compared to nearly no tuition for CC (might again be my California background). You should probably have some small-time job for some period of time to help pay and to put on your resumé, but even more fun, forward-looking, and worthwhile would be to be in some student group devoted to engineering in your field. What kinds of groups are available could be part of your college decision; this is an area where I've heard MIT and Stanford excel.

      --
      I sometimes ask revealing, often ignorant-seeming questions. Maybe they're harder to answer than you think.
    6. Re:Go to a good state school by vlm · · Score: 1

      If you really want prestige go to the best graduate program you can get into after you graduate.

      Look into transfer programs at the undergrad level. No one cares where you went to for freshman year. Frankly, no one in the educational-industrial complex wants to admit it, but no one cares where you graduated from, once you're older than about 30 yrs.

      Look in to transfer programs VERY carefully, don't make my "mistake". In my CS program I had to take calculus 3 times... once in high school (long story; I skipped a grade of math in high school) and once at "cheap" local school and once at "big" school. On the good side, I improved my calculus grade each time up to A+ level. The prof actually kidded me about how I wrote the answer key... well I darn well should have after taking the same class 3 times... By somewhat more careful planning I only had to take intro to sociology once, early american history once, C++ once, "world religions" once, etc

      Could I appeal the non-transfer? Eh, maybe. Could I have tested out? Well, since I achieved a A+ without much effort, I should think so. But I had full 100% employer tuition reimbursement, and an A pads my GPA more than a transfer credit, so ...

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    7. Re:Go to a good state school by robbrit · · Score: 1

      Haha, when I said "a lot" I meant on an absolute basis, not relative to the rest of the student population ;)

    8. Re:Go to a good state school by meustrus · · Score: 1

      Also, just figured out what RPI is. And I say, EW. Maybe it's just because Rensselaer sent me more glossy junk mail than every other university combined, or because I know that the schools that do that are trying to get more people to apply so they can turn more of them down, thereby looking more "selective" to the ranking agencies.

      --
      I sometimes ask revealing, often ignorant-seeming questions. Maybe they're harder to answer than you think.
    9. Re:Go to a good state school by cowdung · · Score: 2

      While I certainly think MIT is a great place to go. I went to a state school and was taught classes by world famous professors as well.

      State schools also have world famous professors. :)

    10. Re:Go to a good state school by comp.sci · · Score: 1

      You don't go to a fancy school for the classes, you go because of the research opportunities. If you are looking for a graduate education getting work done in a well-known lab (and get recommendations from the PI there) will be very useful.

    11. Re:Go to a good state school by bkmoore · · Score: 1

      For the B.Sc. degree, I agree with the parent 100%. Go to a good state school with a solid engineering program and learn as much as you can. Get some good internships during the summers to see what interests you and to gain experience. Get good grades, work hard and stay out of excessive levels of debt.

      In most engineering fields, a Masters Degree should be your initial goal. From there, you can decide what kind of work you would most like to be doing and see if a PhD makes sense given your career aspirations. I wouldn't waste time with dual bachelors degrees, unless your career goals require it, or it's a dual-degree program in four years; 2 x B.Sc. != 1 x M. Sc.

      The most successful students were the ones who put the most time into what they were learning, either through internships, student-assistant jobs, or technical hobbies. There is no substitute for experience. Also, don't blow off freshman and sophomore math. Engineering is really applied mathematics, and you need solid foundations. Most of all, have fun. If you're not having fun, you're in the wrong degree.

    12. Re:Go to a good state school by butalearner · · Score: 1

      +1. Neil Armstrong was an aerospace engineering professor at my undergrad alma mater, the University of Cincinnati (though admittedly he retired before I got there). Every American child coming out of elementary school knows who he is, so top that! I agree with the previous commenters on school...the university name on your undergrad degree almost doesn't matter anymore. Private space firms are small enough that they won't even see your resume without at least an MS on there, unless you know somebody that can get get you past the filter.

    13. Re:Go to a good state school by nessus42 · · Score: 1

      I didn't mean to imply that you can't get a great education elsewhere. What I'm saying is that at MIT (and other such prestigious universities) you are practically guaranteed to get not just a first class education, but an inspiring education. E.g., in all my life, I have never seen any other teachers who are as inspiring as Sussman and Ableson were.

      There's something about your reply that is indicative of the difference between an MIT education, and the education that you apparently got: MIT doesn't even offer a course in data structures. You are taught such stuff just along the way in other classes that are actually teaching you something interesting. E.g., MIT's CS 101 class, in which you learned data structures along the way, was all a joyous ode to functional programming. You'd pick up more on data structures in the class on software engineering and more in an algorithms class. You'd never stop to lazily rest on merely data structures. MIT has since taken this even further. There now is no CS101 class at all. You are taught CS101 just along the way in the engineering 101 class, which is all centered around robotics.

      Is this better than the kind of education that you might get elsewhere. Maybe not, but you are guaranteed to get an incredible education at MIT. Elsewhere, who knows? Maybe you will, maybe you won't.

      Re being taught by famous people, aka great minds: The difference is something you might not be able to appreciate until you've been taught by great minds. Watch all the online SICP lectures from 1985 if you want to have a clue about how inspiring it can be. Or watch the Feynman lectures from Harvey Mudd. Keep in mind that these talks are all a bit dated, and the concepts explicated have now propagated into the world at large. Imagine learning these things before any one else learned them. Imagine being a decade or two or three ahead of your peers in your field of study. E.g., programming languages are just now clamoring to add closures to the language. I lived, breathed, and dreamt closures 30 years ago in MIT's CS101. And many of the classes I took at MIT had no text book, only xeroxed course notes because the textbook had not yet been written.

      |>ouglas

    14. Re:Go to a good state school by nessus42 · · Score: 1

      The difference is that nearly every tenured professor at MIT is world famous in their field. And almost all of the freshman classes are taught by such tenured professors. At many universities, teaching freshman classes is considered the shit-work. At MIT the professors fight over who should have the honor.

      I've just casually mentioned at times that I took a class by such-and-such at a party, or whatever, and someone will say, "OH MY GOD!!! I can't believe you were taught by Susan Carey! [Or whomever.] She's the world's leading expert on childhood development." Well, huh! I didn't even know, but she was an excellent teacher.

      At less prestigious schools, you may have the occasional class taught by someone so distinguished. At MIT, it's the rule rather than the exception.

      There's a reason that prestigious schools are prestigious, and everyone should strive to get the best education that they can afford.

      |>ouglas

    15. Re:Go to a good state school by nessus42 · · Score: 1

      Unique, no? But at most places it's much less pervasive than at MIT for students to do research with the best professors. I also attended Harvard for a bit and worked at a research lab there. It was hard for us to find Harvard students as interns because it apparently just wasn't much in the Harvard culture for undergraduate students to work with professors or scientists. We had to recruit our interns mostly from other schools.

      At MIT, however, the UROP program (Undergraduate Research Opportunity Program) is utterly pervasive and well-funded. I.e., professors are very eager to hire undergraduates because most of the wages for the UROP students will come from a central pot of money, and they are guaranteed that any student they hire is smart.

      |>ouglas

    16. Re:Go to a good state school by Lemmy+Caution · · Score: 1

      It seems to me, most engineers start their serious drinking in the workplace. Especially civil engineers.

    17. Re:Go to a good state school by CtownNighrider · · Score: 1

      For an aero major at most schools getting a mechanical dual major is like 2 extra classes that's why I plan to do it. Thanks for the advice though, I will definitely ask around in the industry on whether they try to hire kids with masters degrees.

    18. Re:Go to a good state school by slew · · Score: 1

      Or watch the Feynman lectures from Harvey Mudd.

      Or maybe not, those Harvey Mudd ones might not be "legit" ;^)
      Feynman gave those lectures at Caltech and I'm pretty sure they aren't available on video (only audio and photographs of blackboards). AFAIK, the only videos you can actually see of Feynman giving lectures like this are another lecture series he gave at Cornell.

      If you do listen to (or read them), remember that although perhaps inspirational, in Feynman's own words

      My own point of view—which, however, does not seem to be shared by most of the people
      who worked with the students—is pessimistic. I don't think I did very well by the
      students. When I look at the way the majority of the students handled the problems
      on the examinations, I think that the system is a failure. Of course, my friends
      point out to me that there were one or two dozen students who—very surprisingly
      —understood almost everything in all of the lectures, and who were quite active
      in working with the material and worrying about the many points in an excited
      and interested way. These people have now, I believe, a first-rate background in
      physics—and they are, after all, the ones I was trying to get at. But then, "The
      power of instruction is seldom of much efficacy except in those happy dispositions
      where it is almost superfluous."

      Note that they don't really even use these lectures at Caltech anymore (except as supplementary material).

      And BTW, that RPI medal, I think they pretty much give one to 1 person in almost every high-school, so it really doesn't mean that much other than they science teachers at your high-school think you're the best in your high-school class at things that might matter to an engineering school (e.g., good at math and science), don't read too much into it.

    19. Re:Go to a good state school by Rakishi · · Score: 1

      It will be cheaper and you will likely have a better social life.

      No it may not be cheaper. Top private schools provide very very good financial aid options, to the point of costing less than state schools for many students. Free ride if parents make under $100k and all that stuff.

      The real advantage of top schools however is connections and networking. What you know never mattered. Who you know is what really matters. Followed by what you can convince them that you know.

    20. Re:Go to a good state school by slew · · Score: 1

      I guess I was actually quoting Feynman who was actually quoting Edward Gibbon.

      In any case, the quote is certainly notable and pertainate to this discussion...

    21. Re:Go to a good state school by nessus42 · · Score: 1

      Or maybe not, those Harvey Mudd ones might not be "legit" ;^)

      Yes, I'm sorry. The lectures that I was thinking of are from Cornell, not Harvey Mudd. It's been ages since I watched them. I.e., well before YouTube, and I had to go to lecture hall at MIT to watch them, when they would show them once every year or two.

      In any case, despite what Fenman may or may not think about the efficacy of instruction, his lectures have inspired many and they still do. Instruction may be overrated at times, but inspiration isn't. Also, I shouldn't think that it would be at all controversial to cite the truism that if you want to be a great writer you should read and steal from other great writers. The same is true in most other fields. Sure, you can study the greats anywhere, to the extent that you have access to what they have written. But, isn't it easier to study the greats if you go to be where they are? Going to MIT, for instance, gives you immediate access to many of them. They don't keep them locked in some ivory tower, where you can't get to them. They come down and teach freshman classes and let you do research for them.

      Also, in fast moving technological fields, they may not have written a textbook, or even published yet. If you're somewhere else, then you may have no access at all. Additionally, it was certainly true when I was an undergrad, that my friends who studied at other colleges often used textbooks written by people who were either decidedly not great, or that were rather out of date.

      |>ouglas

  3. Re:be smart by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    If you want to be an engineer, you had better learn how to start solving your own problems, or answering questions like the one you posed, by yourself. That's my best advice for getting into your chosen field.

    Crap. Asking questions is good. Building on the experience of others is great. Be ready to challenge the wisdom of others but don't refuse every source of existing information.

  4. Re:be smart by Brett+Buck · · Score: 1

    That's good advice. But if you start out with the idea that you want to get a very specialized job in a microscopic startup industry but don't want to travel more than a few hours from your location, the chances of success are negligible in any case.

  5. Re:be smart by jorghis · · Score: 4, Informative

    This is bad advice. Successful engineers spend lots of time asking questions and soliciting advice.

  6. Do the work before they pay you for it by whistlingtony · · Score: 5, Informative

    It sounds like you're on the right path... aerospace with dual major in mechanical.

    You have some time though, so I'd suggest you get a hobby in the field you're going into. Help out some open source rocketry projects. Surely they exist. Launch some things up really high. Rig up some cameras and get pictures. Write some code. etc. etc.

    One day someone is going to be looking at your resume. If it's one in a thousand, you probably won't get noticed. Hopefully they'll be looking at it because Bob down in the lab says he knows this one guy who really kicked ass on this one project. Hopefully you'll already know the guy through the right circles. Hopefully they'll look you up on the web and see that you have your hand in the right projects, that you do good work, and that you love what you do.

    Also, it would be good to actually do the work you're seeking to go into. It'll tell you if you're on the right path for YOU.

    The secret to Industry is that you don't get promoted to do work .... You get promoted and paid when it's noticed that you're ALREADY doing the work and oh, perhaps they should pay you for that....

    1. Re:Do the work before they pay you for it by werepants · · Score: 1

      From what I can tell, this is spot on. Don't focus just on grades, the school, and having a double major under your belt - work on extracurricular stuff, a lot of universities have undergrad research programs that would really improve a resume.

      University of Colorado at Boulder is the big aerospace school in my area, and they put motivated undergrads to work on various sounding rocket projects and even some orbital experiments. Getting involved with something like that will give you the contacts and experience to have a leg up vs everybody else graduating with you.

    2. Re:Do the work before they pay you for it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Something like this [http://ddeville.com/derek/Qu8k.html] would be a blast (in more ways than one)!

      You have some time though, so I'd suggest you get a hobby in the field you're going into. Help out some open source rocketry projects. Surely they exist. Launch some things up really high. Rig up some cameras and get pictures. Write some code. etc. etc.

    3. Re:Do the work before they pay you for it by JoeMerchant · · Score: 1

      If you want to get into SpaceX or a similar company, start by asking SpaceX or a similar company - ask them if they take summer interns, ask them what schools they take their interns from. Ask them where the majority of their engineering staff went to school. Ask them what their projected staffing needs will be in 6 to 8 years.

      The parent's advice about hobbies is also excellent, between two candidates, one with a 4.0 average and Masters' in Aerospace / M.E., and another with a 3.2 GPA, Bachelor's in Mechanical, and 6 years' history of pushing the envelope in hobby rocketry, me, personally, I'd hire the advanced hobbyist.

    4. Re:Do the work before they pay you for it by mlush · · Score: 1

      You have some time though, so I'd suggest you get a hobby in the field you're going into. Help out some open source rocketry projects. Surely they exist. Launch some things up really high. Rig up some cameras and get pictures. Write some code. etc. etc.

      This advice is widely applicable, Begin able to talk about your home automation/IT project, your latest Make or other cool project in CV and interview can really set you apart from the competition. as it portrays you as an enthusiastic, self starter who does the work because they like it rather than a jaded code wrangler who does it 9-5 for the money.

  7. learn Chinese by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    The USA is in a long term serious decline for anything to do with science and engineering. These fields are moving to places like China which put a larger value on education. You'd be well advised to consider moving overseas, because the trend is clear: less and less of this kind of work happens in the United States. The aerospace industry here has been gutted since the 1960's. It still exists to some extent, but not nearly like it used to, and it's declining all the time.

    1. Re:learn Chinese by JoeMerchant · · Score: 1

      The USA is in a long term serious decline for anything to do with science and engineering. These fields are moving to places like China which put a larger value on education. You'd be well advised to consider moving overseas, because the trend is clear: less and less of this kind of work happens in the United States. The aerospace industry here has been gutted since the 1960's. It still exists to some extent, but not nearly like it used to, and it's declining all the time.

      Somebody needs to refill their mood stabilizer prescription, and/or get a grip on reality.

      The US space industry is no worse off than anywhere else in the world, and if you think China would hire a US national from New York straight out of college to work anywhere near their national pride space program... maybe they'd snipe some disgruntled out of work NASA contractors, but a kid with no experience? They've got plenty of those already.

    2. Re:learn Chinese by vlm · · Score: 1

      The USA is in a long term serious decline for anything to do with science and engineering. These fields are moving to places like China which put a larger value on education. You'd be well advised to consider moving overseas, because the trend is clear: less and less of this kind of work happens in the United States. The aerospace industry here has been gutted since the 1960's. It still exists to some extent, but not nearly like it used to, and it's declining all the time.

      All true. Consider a dual major in a foreign language. I'd suggest Chinese for "general engineering and sciences" but for rocketry I'd totally learn French. Get a job at the ESA. The "official languages" of the ESA are English (check) French and German. 2 outta 3 isn't bad...

      The problem with becoming an aerospace engineer is those guys made fat stacks of cash in 1970 designing and testing the shuttle. Then, 40 years of driving taxis. Whoops. Don't want to try and pay off $400K of student loans delivering pizzas.

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    3. Re:learn Chinese by geezer+nerd · · Score: 1

      The 1960s were when engineering and science in the US was being built up. Remember Sputnik happened in 1957, and the US suddenly woke up to being behind in science/math/engineering. The post-Sputnik reaction to rapidly build-up and enhance US technical capabilities happened mostly in the 60s. I saw all that happening, and had some advantage when my undergraduate classes were enhanced by government aid during that time. The decline you mention happened more in the 90s, I think.

  8. Who you know MATTERS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    You go to fancy schools because many of the students with whom you get drunk there are tomorrow's industry leaders. They are good people to know, because they will be able to provide you with employment opportunities that you simply can't get by sending off resumes.

    1. Re:Who you know MATTERS by umghhh · · Score: 1
      well 'd say it is good to 'scoializing' with these assholes gives greater chance of outsourcing somebody's job to Zamunda than getting your own lost that way. Other than that pick your education based on what you like. In few years time i.e. when you finish your course the economics of your country and the profession that you wanted to be part of will change as well as you will so you can just as well enjoy yourself or get contacts for the future. This change of situation is actually a serious thing - just look in the news there is trouble and smell of gun powder.

      Coming on the contacts bit I just realized that majority of my contracts I got either because somebody I knew advised my poor ass over some other or the prospective employer knew somebody who knew me. Either way it worked well for me (so far) only I think you should seriously consider getting self employed at some point. Possibly as soon as you gain some experience. It is much more difficult to do if your first try is at 45.

    2. Re:Who you know MATTERS by dbIII · · Score: 1

      Which is one of the reasons why China, India and a pile of other places will bury the USA if that trend continues to dominate. Without competence being a selection criteria the obvious happens and shit gets pumped out instead of something useful.

  9. MOD PARENT UP by Bananatree3 · · Score: 2
    Developing your *love* for the work and showing it with publicly open projects is a great way to hone your skills with the subject, and get noticed for it! If you really dive into a project, it's likely some of the other members work for an aerospace company, or know someone who does. If you release some really cool stuff with a volunteer project, you'll be noticed more by head hunters who would be willing to pay you for it.

    In the end, you'd be demonstrating your love for the subject in a very visible way. Most resume submitters never ever do this.

  10. Blow lots of stuff up. by HornWumpus · · Score: 1

    I know lots of successful engineers. I are one.

    We were all blowing things up when we were your age.

    --
    John McAfee 'It was like that time I hired that Bangkok prostitute; to do my taxes, while I fucked my accountant'
    1. Re:Blow lots of stuff up. by darenw · · Score: 1

      Some schools are especially good for blowing up stuff. Look at New Mexico Tech in Socorro NM. They have Explosives Camp.

  11. Why the 5-mile radius? by excelsior_gr · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Don't limit you options based on the geographical factor. If the male/female ratio and the party scene are not important, then the location shouldn't be either.

    1. Re:Why the 5-mile radius? by spineboy · · Score: 1

      Here, here +1 for the above.

          Having said that, The Johns Hopkins University has a great engineering school, and so does Virginia Tech

      --
      ..........FULL STOP.
    2. Re:Why the 5-mile radius? by Kjella · · Score: 1

      How about existing friends and family? A 5 hour drive is roughly the limit where you can go home a weekend for $MAJOR_EVENT. I've lived one year abroad where I went home exactly once for Christmas, it's a choice but I fully understand those that wouldn't. Both travel time and cost tends to get rather prohibitive unless both ends are right at a major airport.

      --
      Live today, because you never know what tomorrow brings
    3. Re:Why the 5-mile radius? by syousef · · Score: 1

      Don't limit you options based on the geographical factor. If the male/female ratio and the party scene are not important, then the location shouldn't be either.

      I'd go much further than saying don't limit your options. I'd say that unless you're prepared to do just about whatever it takes, don't try for something so competitive. There are people who'd sell their grandmothers to do that kind of work. At least moving usually doesn't violate any ethical boundaries.

      Also have a backup plan. You should reach for the stars (pun intended) but have a much more sensible mundane fallback option that is less competitive. Not everyone gets to be a rockstar, even if they play an instrument well.

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
  12. Aerospace Engineering Graduate Student by riboch · · Score: 5, Informative

    I am an Aerospace Engineering/Mathematics Grad Student at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. I do more theoretical work now, but I think I can offer a little advice.

    If you want to stay state side I would also recommend (in no particular order) you look at U of M, Purdue, Georgia Tech, Cornell (Aero/Mech), Caltech, Stanford (Aero/Mech) and the University of Maryland (more aeronautical).

    The biggest thing is to get involved with research projects. Look at current professors and their research interests, see if they have anything related to satellite/rocket design. Do not be afraid to ask/e-mail. Professors and grad students alike love getting undergrads involved, perhaps because they usually come free.

    If you do look at Michigan I can recommend looking at Professor Cutler and his RAX project or professors in the Atmospheric, Oceanic and Space Sciences (AOSS) department. Several people from my graduating class who took Aerosp 483 went on to SpaceX, Virgin Galactic and Bigelow Aerospace, so there is a network.

    For more U of M information look at:
    Professor Cutler: http://aerospace.engin.umich.edu/people/faculty/cutler/
    RAX: http://rax.engin.umich.edu/
    AOSS: http://aoss.engin.umich.edu/

    --
    GO BLUE!
    1. Re:Aerospace Engineering Graduate Student by RightwingNutjob · · Score: 1

      Best advice so far. As an addendum, if you don't know how to code now, learn early (as in freshman year). That way, you can come to a professor early (end of freshman year, sophomore year) and be in a position where you can contribute to the analysis side of things as well as implementation. That's what gets names on publications, which are great to put on a resume, both for employment as well as grad school.

    2. Re:Aerospace Engineering Graduate Student by EccentricAnomaly · · Score: 1

      Mod parent up... although, as a Purdue alum, I can warn you that the Michigan student tend to be a bunch of arrogant fucks who talk too much shit about how great their football team is... But the Michigan alums that I work with tend to know what they are doing, and the small sat programs there are really cool... and SpaceX is full of a lot of Michigan people too.

      --
      There are 10 types of people in this world, those who can count in binary and those who can't.
    3. Re:Aerospace Engineering Graduate Student by ffejie · · Score: 1

      Cornell Engineering isn't part of the land grant part of Cornell, so you'll have to reconsider matching that with your public education schools.

      --
      Disagreeing with me does not mean you get to mod me troll.
    4. Re:Aerospace Engineering Graduate Student by discontinuity · · Score: 1

      The parent has a good point about getting involved in research. It is good for experience, connections, fun (you might get to work on some cool stuff, after all), etc. It is especially valuable if you intend to go to graduate school, but certainly won't hurt your prospects for getting a job with a BS.

      I notice lots of responders advising that you go to this or that school. I am faculty in mechanical engineering at a top-tier university and I can tell you the following: as long as you go somewhere reputable and work hard, you should be fine. Ask 10 different people and you'll get 10 different recommendations about what is the best school to put you on a specific career path. In my opinion, the identity of the "best" school depends on the individual. Personal happiness matters as much as US News and World Report rankings. (That being said, if you're capable of getting in to a top-10 engineering program then you'd have to have a pretty big personal reason to settle for someplace ranked 100+.)

      What you should do no matter where you wind up is try to get an internship with SpaceX or someone else in that industry. Internships are a great potential pathway to a full-time offer when you graduate as well as a great way for you to figure out if this is really where you want to work.

      Going back to the "which college" issue, I believe SpaceX and companies like them take interns from numerous institutions. Some intern hiring has a geographic bias (because companies do not always offer relocation benefits). But I never would choose a university solely for its proximity to a particular company.

      To convey my own observations: One of my graduate students interned with SpaceX this past summer (after working for Tesla Motors the summer prior). Although we are a highly reputable engineering school (ranked in top 15 by USN&WR), we're not MIT or CalTech and SpaceX isn't located where we are. Yet this didn't stop my student (and a few undergrads I know here) from landing internships with SpaceX.

      The bottom line is that the school is only part of the equation. You need to work hard when you get there and it helps an awful lot to go someplace you will be happy (or else you won't want to work very hard).

      Good luck!

  13. State school = less debt. by Bananatree3 · · Score: 5, Informative
    For undergrad work, it's perfectly legit to go to a well-regarded state school.

    Once you've nailed the academics at a state undergrad level and proven yourself (with less cost), then hit up the larger research universities like MIT. You'll have more track record on your academic resume, and you'll have tons of contacts from your undergrad years to help you get in.

    Transferring into a top tier University with less debt is not a bad way to go, if you're willing to do undergrad work at a state level. The majority of undergrad studies - Physics, Calculus, etc. are all pretty much universal whether at the state or Ivy league schools.

    It's when you get to the higher levels that your dollars will be well spent at a specialty school.

    1. Re:State school = less debt. by notea42 · · Score: 1

      I did precisely what you described - good state school undergrad followed by top-tier university for graduate school. I still met many of the leaders in the field while a PhD student and got paid to go - tuition waiver plus stipend. I came out with a PhD debt-free and have never regretted it. Paid internships or co-op work are definitely worthwhile.

    2. Re:State school = less debt. by mschiller · · Score: 1

      Not necessarily. IF you get into MIT and your parents aren't super rich [of course if they are super rich you probably don't have to worry about debt either because you've got $$$ from mom and dad], they will may make the financial offer competitive or even better than State school. MIT is need blind (on admission) and academic blind on financial aid. and they have a very big endowment / devoted alumni. They are committed to making MIT affordable to everyone.

      Take my example:
      HS Class of 1998 (yeah I'm getting old....)
      California Resident.
      Son of Vietnam Vet (at the time This meant FREE tuition at California State Schools.)
      Parents made ~$60,000 /year with 2 kids in college and 1 still living at home. [Solidly middle class, but not even approaching rich back then]
      NO college savings [Damn parents...]

      Cost of attendance (approximate numbers, after free money given by universities):

      UC Berkeley: $16,000 /year [NO Free money, some subsidized federal loans, some UNsubsidized federal loans]
      MIT: $15,250 /year [>$20,000 free money [MIT alumni scholarship] + Federal Subsidized loans

      Loans and Summer Internships covered that with no problem.

      Graduated FROM MIT with about $10,000 /debt. Not too bad. If I hadn't flown home to california 3+ times a year probably could have pushed that to under $5000, or not bought those two laptops at ~$2000 each....

  14. Suggest military education by vlm · · Score: 1

    I suggest some military (self?) education, because its a fairly effective way to analyze long term campaigns...

    So... your goal... what intel do you have about the goal? When you asked SpaceX what did they say? When you talked to the engineers there, and especially the engineering department management, what did THEY suggest? Tell them the truth and HR will filter / blow you off. Tell them you need to interview an engineering dept manager for a school report, you Might make it thru the filter. Get all 007 on this if necessary. Unless they're here on /. with us, which is possible, I'm not thinking your intel from /. will be worth much.

    Next check out the opfor, that being all the other applicants at SpaceX, what is your edge? Teachers naturally try to convince their students the most important techniques for success are being a follower and getting high grades, and many/most kids are stary eyed enough to believe them, the fools. I'm not 100% certain that is remotely relevant. I'm guessing that if SpaceX gets 1000 qualified applicants per position, if you are in fact the #1 GPA in the nation that might help, otherwise you need another strategy... join the model rocket club that the hiring manager is a member of? Something like that?

    Finally check out yourself. Very few people pick a career at age 17 and stick with it.

    --
    "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    1. Re:Suggest military education by prefec2 · · Score: 1

      This is utter bullshit. SpaceX does not know what they want in 7 years. And you do not know what you want in 7 years. Find out what you really like in engineering. Be aware that might change. Get your master degree. And make stick out of the crowd. Make a remarkable job in your master thesis. If you have the chance to go to conferences. Go there. Talk to people. Most job opportunities are brokered through friends and people you met. If they can remember you. Good thing.

      If you just run in one direction, because you decided so with 17 and then plotted a "campaign". Then you might end at the designated destination. However, most likely that is in 7 years from now not the place you wanted to be. Try to live and live with open eyes. Normally opportunities just come by. Do not hesitate to take them. As long as is does not mean to drop out of university. Never ever do that. In the long run you will loose that way.

    2. Re:Suggest military education by JoeMerchant · · Score: 1

      This is utter bullshit. SpaceX does not know what they want in 7 years. And you do not know what you want in 7 years.

      Very true, but better to run in the best guess direction now than dork around for 7 years, get a degree in Business / Liberal Arts, and then open your eyes and discover that regardless of what you want to do now, you are SOL if you still want to work for SpaceX.

      There's always time to change direction, at least until you've got a couple of years actual work experience, then you really are locked in.

    3. Re:Suggest military education by vlm · · Score: 1

      OP has no plan, I provide a plan, you say something like "no plan survives contact with the enemy".
      As a thought experiment if nothing else, the OP needs to at least think about my plan, and if the evidence he sees makes him change his goals, well, then I think all 3 of us win.

      Personally I agree with you, he's misguided. Best way for him to see that is for him to research further and come to our conclusion.

      If you're gonna do the wrong thing, at least do it effectively, or if you're gonna do the wrong thing, at least do it to excess...

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    4. Re:Suggest military education by prefec2 · · Score: 1

      A goal is always a good thing it gives you direction. However, you should not hesitate to change it if it does not correlates with your needs. When you are interested in engineering, building things than that variation might not be arts (most likely). But when you are interested to get into space being Captain Kirk, then you might reevaluate your goal. And that point of reevaluation will come. And when it comes, then do so and not dork around ;-)

      I have seen people running through their studies finishing their master in arts after 5 years. And then they realized that economics and politics was not their prime interest, but social sciences.

  15. MIT isn't the answer by bhcompy · · Score: 2

    MIT isn't the answer, CalTech is. JPL is managed by CalTech and there is some crossover and plenty of educational opportunities there. Also, since SpaceX is based in southern California, being there helps. Aerospace is very strong in SoCal.

    Also, SpaceX hires a lot from companies like Boeing, Northrop, etc(all of my friends that work there are from said companies). In order to get in as an engineer at those companies(to use as a stepping stone), you generally need your security clearance or military experience. The military is always looking for engineer graduates, and you'll be able to pay down your loans as well. With a degree, you'll go in as an officer as well generally.

    1. Re:MIT isn't the answer by JoeMerchant · · Score: 1

      I opted non-military in my college years, then spent 12 years at a medical company - the lack of security clearance has effectively locked me out of a BIG chunk of the available engineering jobs in Florida for the last 8+ years. If you might consider military service, consider how to work it in with your college education and do it just for the clearance. If I were going to do it, I'd go for one of the short grad-school programs (if they still have such things, enlist when you get your B.S., serve for 4 years and come out the other side with your M.S. in whatever they decided you should study.) It wasn't for me, but it was a good deal.

  16. Re:be smart by cyber-vandal · · Score: 1

    So you never asked a single question in your entire career?

  17. consider your strategy carefully by Surt · · Score: 1

    Job skills are secondary to 'soft skills' (networking, interpersonal, manipulation) in terms of getting you where you want to go. The people at the 'top' of their fields are almost always talkers rather than doers. If you want to be the guy who actually invents something, you probably want the absolute best training you can get, push hard for MIT. If you're not going to be able to get that, you won't be able to compete with the guy who does, so you may as well go down the other path, and get credit and patent for his inventions by being a direction setter.

    --
    "Who is the Journal of Quantum Physics going to believe?" --Stephen Hawking
    1. Re:consider your strategy carefully by vlm · · Score: 1

      The people at the 'top' of their fields are almost always talkers rather than doers.

      One slight problem with this advice is the guy wants to get into the engineering dept at spacex... the entire "private space industry field" is something like 5 guys and their boss. A small group like that can't afford specialists, especially specialists in schmoozing.

      Now if he wanted to get into a giant military industrial complex contractor, thats another thing.

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    2. Re:consider your strategy carefully by Surt · · Score: 1

      It'll be a bigger field by the time he graduates. People are talking about that being a multi billion dollar industry within a few years as the federal government continue to withdraw satellite launching options from the market.

      --
      "Who is the Journal of Quantum Physics going to believe?" --Stephen Hawking
  18. Choosing a school by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    I'm an aerospace engineering student, nearly done with my undergrad career at Cal Poly Pomona, and I've also done research during two summers at Caltech.

    I know people that have attended several of the more prestigious schools and notice that the level of education you receive is almost entirely up to you. If you have the drive to learn, the school you choose is secondary. I will say that the difference between Caltech and a school like Cal Poly Pomona is that the students are much more enthusiastic about learning theory as opposed to simply knowing enough to get a project done.

    I think the best thing you can do is actually visit the campus during the school year if possible and attend some of the seminars or group meetings in your field of interest. It will give you a feel for the kinds of students that the university attracts or the types of problems they like to tackle.

    Another thing to look for, and ask current students of those universities, is how difficult/easy it is to get funding and school resources for engineering projects and competitions.

    Lastly, I now have a math minor and find it much more valuable to have more mathematics (advanced D.E.s, tensors, numerical analysis, set theory) under my belt than classes on the specifics of bearings or fasteners (something that my aerospace curriculum doesn't cover at all, but M.E. majors do). The way I see it, the abstract concepts are harder to learn on your own, but specifics of equipment you tend to learn as you deal with the equipment, read specs from catalogs or from your employer's protocol.

  19. How to be smart by Runaway1956 · · Score: 1

    First, design and build your own space craft.

    Second, pilot that spacecraft to Mars.

    Third, gather some unique samples of stuff you find lying around on Mars.

    Fourth, preserve those samples for future experimentation.

    Fifth, pilot your spacecraft back to Earth, where you will turn over those samples to some carefully selected colleges and universities.

    Sixth, patent all the cool shit you used in your spacecraft.

    Seventh, patent all the algorithms and other cool shit you used to navigate to Mars and back - not to mention navigating around on the Mars surface.

    I see nothing but profit here. You might rival Bill Gates, Rupert Murdoch, and that guy in Mexico if you can pull all of that off! Don't forget the patents - they're more important than all the other cool shit!

    --
    "Windows is like the faint smell of piss in a subway: it's there, and there's nothing you can do about it." - Charlie Br
    1. Re:How to be smart by rwa2 · · Score: 1

      I second this. If practicable, go on to get your Professional Engineer license for your state, then go start your own business doing exactly what you want to do.

      If you get a job working for someone else, you will be doing what other people tell you to do regardless of whether you think it's a good idea or not. Or you'll spend all your time trying to convince them they should really be doing the right thing.

      Start your own project, even if it's just a hobby. It will be more rewarding and will keep you from getting frustrated.

      If you need to, get a job in the real world for a bit to learn a bit about the rest of the world and secure a bit of funding to get you on your feet. But don't get locked in.

      While you're in school, be sure to make some friends you trust to cover the legal/marketing/accounting aspects of the business, because you're probably not that interested in those things.

      Have fun!

  20. Re:be smart by Runaway1956 · · Score: 1

    That's about retarded, if you ask me. Engineers are pretty much specialists. Specialists aren't necessarily the best people to solve networking, social, and employment problems. I'm sure that you're not a retard - you've just had one of those infamous blonde moments, right?

    --
    "Windows is like the faint smell of piss in a subway: it's there, and there's nothing you can do about it." - Charlie Br
  21. Academics is not the most important by dlevitan · · Score: 5, Insightful

    A few questions/thoughts to think about:

    1) How do you know you'd enjoy working for the private space industry? Sure, it sounds cool, but until you try it, don't assume you'll love it.

    2) Academics is not the most important thing. More important is getting experience. Look at the schools you're interested in and see what professors have contacts with the industry. E-mail them and, ideally, try to meet them. Most professors are very approachable and interested in working with undergrads. Sure, you'll be essentially free/cheap labor for 4 years. But you'll get hands-on experience and learn a lot, and, if you're any good, the professor will drop a note to his former students at SpaceX or whatever other company, who'll get you a job as soon as you graduate.

    3) Take classes besides engineering. You'll learn a lot, meet new people (networking is the most important thing), and get a different perspective on life. And, you might decide something else is more interesting. Treat college as a chance to explore and learn, not a something to deal with on the way to what you think you want to do.

    4) Male/female ratio and social interaction in general is essential. If you go to a good school, you will be battered by problem sets, projects, etc... You survive that by having friends, a significant other, etc... You don't survive that by just working harder. Having a good social life (which does not mean partying all the time) is vital for having a good college experience and being successful. Plus, you never know when your friends will be able to help you later in life. And learning how to socialize (which you're probably not the best at right now) while in college means you have the skills to be confident both for future personal relationships and when you look for a job and need to deal with other people.

    5) If you/your parents don't have any money, go to a good state school or to a school that gives you a good scholarship and save >$100k. It's not really worth the hassle if you really take advantage of the opportunities in your school. And you can always work with a professor at another school during the summers.

    6) If you do have the money, go to the best school you can. The advantage of those schools is not that the education is better, but that the networking opportunities are much better and that the professors there have the best connections. MIT and RPI are good. Also Cornell has a top notch engineering program (and it's my undergrad alma mater). Carnegie Mellon is very good. Also Cooper Union, UPenn, Princeton, and Columbia. Probably some others as well.

    Good luck and remember, academics is not everything in life!

    1. Re:Academics is not the most important by CtownNighrider · · Score: 1

      I think that sentence came out wrong. When I said social life wasn't an important factor I meant that I know whatever school I go to will have a terrible male/female ratio but it won't matter because there will always be another college 20 minutes away or something. And I think I have pretty good social skills and have never had trouble making friends so I'll be able to find my niche anywhere and I don't want a school that's known for partying because every school has parties, I want a school where the student population cares about learning. Thanks for the advice though!

  22. do as well as you can in core engineering program by peter303 · · Score: 1

    Mechanical, aeronautical, electrical or computing. A good name school helps, but a 4.0 degree from a less stellar school is good too.

  23. Re:be smart by Quiet_Desperation · · Score: 1

    Absolute nonsense. When I was starting out, I asked lots of questions of the more experienced engineers. That's how you learn the ocean of practical knowledge they don't put into the books. Now that I've been at it for over 20 years, I'm the one getting asked the questions, and I'm happy to answer them. In your world everyone sits on little islands reinventing the wheel and never sharing sometimes completely unique experiences.

  24. Re:be smart by Rakshasa-sensei · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Actually it isn't good advice; there's nothing 'good' about a telling a young person not to ask advice on life choices. The roads in life are not just simple 'engineering problems', since they are more often solved through experience rather than analysis by an inexperienced person.

    For one thing those with experience can tell you when you're asking the wrong question, which is not that easy to deduce through analytical reasoning.

    E.g. the 5 hour radius limit is stupid, studying far from home is not a disadvantage. Hell, a stint abroad is definitely strongly recommended, not just for academic but life experience reasons. Also don't study something because you want to get into a company, study it because you love what you are doing and going to bed feels like a waste. (to the point where your personal projects end up competing for time with your 'real' schoolwork)

    You don't get into a place like SpaceX by wanting to work on spaceships, and then studying the right things. You get in by being exceptionally good at some skill they need, and to become exceptionally good at something you need to spend countless hours honing your skills, and only way you will be able to do that is if you like doing it. So don't fret that much about how to gain useful skills, instead do interesting stuff and the threads will connect in surprising ways.

  25. Travel Super Far by mbone · · Score: 1

    Don't consider any school within 800 km of home. (I would relax that some for MIT, but not for RPI.) It's a big planet, get used to moving around on it.

    As far as schools are concerned, check out MIT, Rice, Caltech and Ga Tech.

  26. Do you really want it? by Overzeetop · · Score: 1

    'Cause if you do, you need two things: wicked smarts and mad social skills. Unless you are one-in-a-billion smart and have your PhD by age 15 (which you clearly haven't), you need to be focused on making this your life, and by learning who everyone is in your field. The best way - and I mean this sincerely - to get into an existing is to know someone on the inside who wants you there. The best way to get into a startup is to know, or be one of, the founders.

    That sounds like political bullshit, but it's true. You know how I got into NASA? My mother was the dental hygienist for a scientist there, and they chatted at appointments over the years about what her son did (aero engr). One time, he asked if I might be interested in lasers. Next thing you know I'm meeting the teem and chatting with the techs - and I understood the science and asked meaningful questions. I knew some CAD - back when almost nobody did. I talked with the math guy, and it turns out they are so sensitive to performance that they program some of their routines for laser time-of-flight in assembly/ machine code, so we talked about that since I learned to code on the 6502 in the summer of my 7th grade year (I was too poor to buy a compiler, so I hand compiled assembly into machine code). And boom - some medium smart kid with a year of undergrad engineering, a middling 3.6 gpa, got a co-op position with NASA. My story isn't unusual - the stack of resumes that come in for the truly "open" positions in these firms are filled with 4.0+ gpas, high profile school names, and activities that make Mother Theresa look like Hitler.

    If you really, truly, want to make a go of it in a very selective field, you need to go where the contacts are. Visit colleges that (ideally) already have connections with companies. Make sure the professors are rubbing shoulders with the SpaceX guys regularly - actively collaborating if possible - and find out how you can get on whatever research project they're working on.

    Being smart and getting a good degree won't cut it unless you plan on starting your own company (which isn't a bad idea, but does involve risk and money). Don't get me wrong - that IS a prerequisite. But just that will only put you in with the thousands of other smart kids who like rocketry. You need to get contact with people. Until the SpaceX guys know who you are, you're just another faceless piece of paper.

    I'm not involved in aerospace anymore - the math is hard, the jobs are few, and I have too many other interests to be all consumed in my work - so I don't know where to tell you to go. Ideally, it will be a place with an active private-ish space department, and a place to "play" (launch things). I recommend taking an alternate approach - pretend you're looking for a PhD or Post-Doc program, not an undergrad. The shift in focus will put yo on the right track to find the PEOPLE you need to work with to get into the industry. Once you're in and people know you, you'll do well from there.

    Note: this is all stuff I wish I understood when I was in high school. I just didn't have the discipline back then. FWIW, today I run my own engineering firm, and play with rockets on the side. Still, it'd be nice to play with somebody else's money for my hobby ;-)

    --
    Is it just my observation, or are there way too many stupid people in the world?
    1. Re:Do you really want it? by prefec2 · · Score: 1

      If you are good, you can make contacts. It is important to stick your head out of the crowd. And remember only the squeaky wheel gets the drop of oil.

  27. Re:be smart by Hognoxious · · Score: 2

    Being an engineer is about learning how to solve problems. 'Asking Slashdot' is about getting other people to solve your problems.

    So you're saying he's destined for management?

    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  28. MIT and CalTech aren't good for space by EccentricAnomaly · · Score: 4, Informative

    Don't go to Caltech for aerospace unless you just want to learn airplanes. I work at JPL and have a lot of interaction with CalTech students who complain about the lack of space stuff in the aero department... they don't even have an orbit mechanics class. MIT is ok if you want to do systems engineering, but generally their aero department doesn't do much space stuff either (last I heard, their orbit class was taught by a grad student who took it upon himself to have some sort of orbit class).

    If you want to do SpaceX, I'd write them an email and ask for their advise, ask where they recruit from. They will probably want chemical prop and systems engineering people.

    From what I've seen the best schools if you want to do space are Carnegie Mellon, Purdue, Colorado, UT Austin, Georgia Tech, Stanford, Michigan, UCLA, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. Carnegie Mellon and Stanford have awesome robotics programs. Michigan and Caly Poly SLO have excellent cube sat programs. Michigan, Stanford, and UCLA have excellent electric propulsion. Georgia Tech and Michigan have excellent systems engineering. Purdue, UT Austin, and Colorado have excellent orbit mechanics. And Purdue has probably the best chemical propulsion program. Georgia Tech has a really amazing senior design class (best out of the 5 that I've advised as an industry person).

    If you don't want to go to far, I'd recommend Michigan, Purdue, or CMU. But try to email SpaceX and see what they advise (but be aware that the person who responds will be biased towards their alma mater)

    --
    There are 10 types of people in this world, those who can count in binary and those who can't.
  29. Forget about your end goals by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    Disclosure: I went to RPI, I work at SpaceX.

    Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, Rochester Institute of Technology, Clarkson, MIT, Johns Hopkins, Rensselaer, Olin, Columbia, etc are all very decent schools for engineering. The goal here should be to end up with an aeromech degree and no debt. Bring up a Google map of the northeast and search for university... huge list, right?

    Private schools like RPI are good schools, but the costs make changing your mind late in your education a pretty expensive mistake. I'd recommend taking a bunch of different engineering courses early on (Computer Science, Structures, Electrical, Robotics), so you can really identify if aeromech is really something you like. CAD, Matlab, Python, and knowing your way around Office-like suites are interdisciplinary engineering staples. Space systems blend a ton of different aspects of engineering together, and you've only begun to scratch the surface in high school.

    What will make your resume pop out for any aerospace employer is spring/summer/fall work experience. You can land engineering internships simply with good grades and common sense, but some will be 6 months long, and bump your graduation date by a semester or two. This adds more cost, so beware. Also, some classes are only offered in the fall or the spring, and you may need them to graduate.

    Research projects are also a good way to go to get experience, but you get as much out as you put in. Try to butt into every aspect of the project, not just what you're working on, and understand how all parts fit together. You should leave the project knowing how to start up your own research if you were given the money.

    When it comes time to apply to internships and jobs, don't focus too much on the qualifications - entry level engineers never meet the qualifications of entry level engineering jobs. If they did, they wouldn't be entry level. Some advice I got: If the qualifications are what you want to know, apply for the job. If they're already things you know, you will be bored. Use your college recruiting office for ideas, but spend time going to websites of companies you see in the news - they all have careers pages and open jobs, despite what the news says about the economy.

    Bringing it back to the title, I feel it's best if you try to ignore that you want to go to School X and work at Company Y. Focus on being well-rounded and multifaceted for the first 2 years of a 4-year program, and then spend the next 2 years chasing the one aspect you've preferred the most. The roundedness will get you in the door at big (or little) engineering firms, and the late specialization will get you a full-time position fresh out of college.

    1. Re:Forget about your end goals by CtownNighrider · · Score: 1

      I don't know if you'll see this since you posted AC but what didn't you like about the school? I've visited several times because its like 45 minutes away and each visit left me with a good impression but I know the tour guides are a self selected group that like the school.

    2. Re:Forget about your end goals by Xacid · · Score: 1

      When it comes time to apply to internships and jobs, don't focus too much on the qualifications - entry level engineers never meet the qualifications of entry level engineering jobs. If they did, they wouldn't be entry level. Some advice I got: If the qualifications are what you want to know, apply for the job. If they're already things you know, you will be bored. Use your college recruiting office for ideas, but spend time going to websites of companies you see in the news - they all have careers pages and open jobs, despite what the news says about the economy.

      Seconded on this. I've found a lot of people don't approach the job market this way but I just recently started after getting fed up being offered the same exact job I'm doing now. The "requirements" are typically for the best possible candidate of all time. Ever. But like you mentioned - they'll likely be bored out of their minds if they already know the entire job. For me - I've got to keep moving forward, got to keep learning.

  30. Re:do as well as you can in core engineering progr by EccentricAnomaly · · Score: 2

    Mechanical, aeronautical, electrical or computing. A good name school helps, but a 4.0 degree from a less stellar school is good too.

    You learn much, much more from a top tier school. GPA is for schmucks. I'd rather have someone with a low GPA from a good school where they learned the theory behind stuff than a 4.0 from some middling school where they only know how to do cookbook problems. Space is full of hard problems, and if you want to make a difference in aerospace you need to seek out a school that will expose you to hard problems.

    --
    There are 10 types of people in this world, those who can count in binary and those who can't.
  31. Worcester Polytechnic Institute by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Check out Worcester Polytechnic Institute, in Worcester Massachusetts. It has a great engineering program and is generally highly regarded as one of the top schools in the field (right below MIT). They're also a bit different than most other schools, in that they run on a quarter system instead of semesters and have an intensive project system as graduation requirements regardless of major (internships and/or study abroad is almost a requirement), but that's part of what makes their program so good.

    1. Re:Worcester Polytechnic Institute by ffejie · · Score: 1

      WPI is great, but I can't recommend it ahead of RPI. At best they're the same, and the post already seems to prefer RPI due to proximity to home.

      --
      Disagreeing with me does not mean you get to mod me troll.
    2. Re:Worcester Polytechnic Institute by glodime · · Score: 1

      The OP is looking for an alternative to RPI (i.e. a second choice or fall back). WPI is perfect for adding to the list of schools to apply to due to proximity quality and reputation of curriculum. He might even be able to intern at SpaceX or NASA to satisfy the graduation requirements. (My friend attended WPI and interned at NASA in Houston for 2 summers).

      Also, he should check out Rowan University in New Jersey. It has a good value for their engineering school. It is becoming well respected by graduate schools. High grades at Rowan could land you in a MIT in Graduate/PhD program. Though it might be a bit outside of the 500 mile radius from upstate NY.

    3. Re:Worcester Polytechnic Institute by chstwnd · · Score: 1

      you're delusional. WPI is NOT right beneath MIT in terms of "highly regarded schools". On top of that, it would be out-of-state tuition for him. OP, take a look at this list and pick the best compromise between cost/rank. http://grad-schools.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-graduate-schools/top-engineering-schools/eng-rankings/page+2 Looks like you're going to be paying high tuition if you pick off that list, but there are reasons that colleges make those lists. And, more than the people you go to school with, the school's name on your degree will help with your career. Well....maybe. I got my degree from UT Austin (#8 on the list above), and got a job at NASA after graduation. I got it through connections, so those are important, but not "sell yourself into slavery for life because of student loans" important. Engineering is different from most other careers; engineers are largely pragmatic, skeptical and antisocial. So, the rules of thumb that apply to things like business and marketing and other no-value-added careers don't tend to apply. Now onto the more editorial portion of my reply. You might want to consider going ME instead of ASE, because the degree itself (assuming you only want undergrad) could be a limiting factor on your career. Aerospace is one of the most volatile career fields to get into. It's blown by every wind of political change you can imagine, and, in the private sector, everything is so highly marginalized that the top companies usually resort to massive layoffs in order to make their bottom lines look better when projects start getting into cost overruns. If you'd like, I can continue this more later, after dinner.

    4. Re:Worcester Polytechnic Institute by ffejie · · Score: 1

      I didn't catch that. WPI is indeed a great alternative to RPI. In fact, I applied to both and would have been happy at either. I still think RPI has a higher profile than WPI, especially nationally. If you're going to NJ, maybe Stevens deserves a look? Not sure how their aerospace program stacks up.

      --
      Disagreeing with me does not mean you get to mod me troll.
    5. Re:Worcester Polytechnic Institute by glodime · · Score: 1

      I just realized that I wrote 500 mile radius (which is much of the US and Canada). 5 hour radius is what I meant.

  32. DON'T ASK AT SLASHDOT! by G3ckoG33k · · Score: 1

    DON'T ASK AT SLASHDOT!

    Asking at Slashdot is probably one of the few places which will give you an even higher number of competitors. Did you really think you were alone in that dream? ;)

  33. Have you considered the Academy by SpyPlane · · Score: 3, Insightful

    If you want to work in Aerospace, have you considered applying to the Air Force Academy? It doesn't meet your radius obviously, but going to a school based on location might be a mistake in general. I don't know your situation, but you asked here so you are going to get all sorts of answers.

    Yes will you have to put in some time to the Air Force when you get out, but if you have an aero degree and some time in the air force, you are almost guaranteed a job when you get out. This idea is obviously a long shot as the Academy is probably harder by the numbers to get into than MIT, but it might be the best decision outside of Caltech.

    --
    "We need a fourth law of Robotics: Stop Fingering My Wife"
    1. Re:Have you considered the Academy by Jubedgy · · Score: 2

      Nah, I can't speak for USAFA, but USNA is a very, very good engineering school (ABET accredited, no less). I majored in Aero/Astro, and am currently working on my masters in Astro Engineering at NPS, which is also a very well known and regarded engineering graduate school. By trade I drive submarines around, but my interests, clearly, are in space...so there is latitude to get an excellent education at a price that is hard to beat (if you don't mind signing away years of your life) in the subject you like. And best of all you'll be very attractive to companies due to your military background and the connections you've made.

      But you do sign away years of your life...

      As an aside, I left UCSD to enlist in the navy with no intention of going to the Naval Academy. So there are alternate routes to get in if you really decide you want to go.

      --
      Si hoc legere scis nimium eruditionis hebes
  34. Don't waste your youth. by TerranFury · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Seconded.

    Sure, you need to work hard in college. But it's also a once-in-a-lifetime to do things that, once you leave, it becomes much, much harder to do. You say the male/female ratio is unimportant? You say you don't care about social aspects? I suggest you reconsider.

    I'm not saying you need to become a binge drinker or a man-slut. But there's only one time in your life when you'll be able to date college-age girls respectably, and you don't want to waste it. If that sounds superficial, it's not entirely. As you get older, you'll find that people close up; they build walls; they get harder and harder to connect with. (Plus, college, unlike the real world, has admissions criteria.) You will never get closer to people than during college, and that's worth a lot. It's a learning experience for both of you, and without it you'll have lived quite a bit less.

    It's not unusual for students to travel, learn languages, see the world. For adults, this is discouraged. Once you get a job, you will get two or three weeks vacation annually. That's it. And time off on your resume is hard to explain. Don't waste your youth. You won't have the same socially-acceptable opportunities for exploration. Ever again.

    Sometimes I think that the purpose of life is to collect stories. How many stories will you have by the time you graduate?

    Connect with people. Travel. Learn a second language (You like engineering. German? Chinese?). Join organizations (Formula SAE, which builds racecars, is a good one) Become a well-rounded person. Don't waste opportunities, and don't fear failure. Just go out and do a bunch of stuff. Your 25-year-old self will have fewer regrets.

    1. Re:Don't waste your youth. by geoskd · · Score: 1

      Another aspect to note it that engineering groups are teams, and they tend to be very self selecting teams. You'll find that most engineering groups select new members by having one or more engineers interview applicants as a final step to the process. They are looking for your abilities and skills, but they are also interested in your personality. After all, they have to spend at least 40 hours a week with you, maybe significantly more. Being a workaholic bore doesn't cut it with most of them, I have worked with a number of engineering teams, and every one of them was also a social group. What I did in my spare time was *always* a question that came up in interviews.

      I have also been an interviewer for two non-engineering groups, and in both cases, social skills played the majority part in the selection process. I wanted to know two things: Can I teach this person the skills they need, and can I get along with this person. If the answer was anything other than an absolute yes, then I sent them packing.

      One last thing to note: The private space industry is very young. It cant really afford to take on unnecessary risks. As a new graduate, you would be just such an unnecessary risk. It is very unlikely that, by the time you graduate, this situation will have changed much. Your best bet is to go to school for a dual degree in electrical/embedded systems engineering and mechanical or aerospace engineering. These general skills will make you a viable candidate for a job in a similar field, which will get you the experience you will need to cross over into the private space industry. Breaking into the industry straight out of college is, unfortunately, very unlikely no matter your educational background.

      -=Geoskd

      --
      I wish I had a good sig, but all the good ones are copyrighted
    2. Re:Don't waste your youth. by Xacid · · Score: 1

      I'm not saying you need to become a binge drinker or a man-slut. But there's only one time in your life when you'll be able to date college-age girls respectably, and you don't want to waste it. If that sounds superficial, it's not entirely. As you get older, you'll find that people close up; they build walls; they get harder and harder to connect with. (Plus, college, unlike the real world, has admissions criteria.) You will never get closer to people than during college, and that's worth a lot. It's a learning experience for both of you, and without it you'll have lived quite a bit less.

      Shit, this just made me depressed. And I'm only 26.

      Time for post grad!

  35. Consider Georgia Tech by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I realize this is outside your preferred radius, but if you want to do engineering, I'd consider Georgia Tech. It's very similar to MIT, albeit slightly less well-known. The aerospace program, in particular, is excellent. On top of that, it's one of the cheaper engineering schools for out-of-state students, and is much easier to get into than a place like MIT. Just a thought.

  36. Re:be smart by ProfessorFreaksworth · · Score: 1

    The first sentence is true. The second is completele backwards. None of us know so much we can solve every problem. The more people you ask or collaborate with the more succesful you'll be.

    A little history before my advice (just like everyone else, I love to give my opinion)... I had to leave high school and start working full time because of one those curve balls life can throw you. On one hand I was quite angry because I was preparing to enter university to study sciences (in general to keep the story short) and on the other it was so exciting because I was a free bird and I could do whatever I wanted.

    I did do a lot of shit work over the first few years and thought this was what was in store for me because of my lack of education. However my interest in sciences did not end when I left high school and I continued to pursue my interests through library books and projects @ home. Then I figured out the key to start doing what I wanted... Ask questions.

    I asked. I sent resumes to companies that worked in my fields of interest. I called them to find out what they are doing and how I may get involved. There are a lot of really great people out there who respond to enthusiasm and you will find some that will give you the information you want and in some cases may even take you under thier wing.

    The internet has made it even easier to not only ask questions (of other people or to pursue on your own) but also to get involved with other people who have the same interest as you. I've used it since day one.

    The first 5 years of work sucked but the following 20 have been awesome. The only time I met closed doors was when I tried to get a job in government. It seems they will take someone fresh out of university over someone with 10+ years of relevant experience. Meh... I hate bureaucracy anyway.

    The short of it is asking questions has taken me everywhere I wanted to go. I still have no formal education but the work I do in the company I'm currently at has a lot of crossover with what the engineers are doing and it really pisses them off. :P

  37. Re:be smart by Luckyo · · Score: 1

    Notably, this is one of the biggest differences between engineers of pre-internet era and those of post-internet era. Pre-internet information was scarce, and skill to find information on your own was very valuable.

    Internet changed this upside down. Now it's a flood of information, and those who are considered best are those who can pick the needed information out of the constant stream of useless informational overload. In this regard, using slashdot and similar sites as a filter against general flood and a starting point to isolating which pieces of information are important is a mark of a successful modern engineer.

  38. something to bear in mind.... by shadowofwind · · Score: 1

    When marketing the 'private space industry', the word 'space' is often used as if there's some equivalence between rising out of the stratosphere and attaining a useful orbit. The reason past space programs involved gigantic rockets with huge tanks of fuel, is that's how much energy is required to get very far out of the gravity well. No amount of engineering advances can change this much. People also use the word 'private' as if its a synonym for 'makes sense in the market'. But in this context its more of a synonym for 'conning gullible people out of money without being constrained by the federal GS salary system.' My opinion is if you want to do real space related engineering, go to somewhere like MIT that has JPL connections, and forget about 'private' space industry. Space related engineering doesn't even potentially make sense for private industry beyond launching communications satellites with conventional rockets. A somewhat superficial exception is private companies that do engineering for government space projects, but that has always been how the space program worked. Most of the real engineering was done by employees of companies like Lockheed Martin, with government funding. Although significant contributions were also made by good engineers and scientists at NASA, the role of NASA was largely administrative.

    These days most NASA centers do a lot of pretend/junk science, and are very depressing places to work if you have much ambition or integrity. JPL is significantly better than most, and has had many good projects like the Mars rovers and some scientifically useful telescopes. I'm not sure what the prognosis is for the long term though.

  39. Coop/Intern! by paro12 · · Score: 1

    As a ME working in the racing/automotive industry I can tell you that experience is king in the engineering field. This becomes even more true when you are targeting a "small" industry (in this case Private space flight). Get into the best school you can, that as other people have said, gives you opportunities to work for professors doing research in the industry you want to work in. Unless you ABSOLUTELY can't leave home for whatever reason, follow the research.

    Most importantly though, from your first day on campus start contacting the companies you want to work for and inquire if they have coop/intern programs. Getting a job out of school in a highly competitive industry such as the one you intend to work for is nearly impossible, but if you have previously worked for them you already have a foot in the door so to speak. Coop is usually preferable over interning because the company will have already invested lots of time in helping develop you as an engineer, and you will have made personal relationships with them.

    Hope this helps and good luck.

  40. You need to go west by Spy+Handler · · Score: 1

    I live in upstate NY and don't want to travel super far

    Well, it's good that you want to have a life with friends and family in NY. However, if you want to be a rocket engineer for new space firms, you're gonna have to go west eventually.

    There are boatloads of aerospace companies here in southern California, including SpaceX and Scaled and Lockheed.

    You could write them (Elon, Burt, Bezos) a letter now, explain your dream about being an engineer in the coming age of commercial spaceflight, and asking advice on where to study, what to study, and summer internship opportunities. And get an internship as soon as you can and start being around engineers and talking to them. Knowing people and human networking is worth ten times a fancy degree from an ivy league school.

  41. Cornell by ffejie · · Score: 1

    Cornell. It's a no brainier if you can get in and want to stay in Upstate NY.

    --
    Disagreeing with me does not mean you get to mod me troll.
  42. Do a PHD in the field, then apply for a post-doc by loufoque · · Score: 1

    See you in 8 years.

  43. Some advice from an outsider by prefec2 · · Score: 1

    First, I've studied in Germany and while the universities here do (mostly) have no big names, they have high quality curricula. My guess is, that beside some low quality private universities, the US system also provides descend education on all state universities. So go there and try to master your stuff. Stick your head out of the crowd. Otherwise you may end up at SpaceX, but only as an unimportant minion who never comes near important and cool technology.

    The next thing is. Go to a university which matches your profile of interest. If it is 1000 km away. Go there. To be close to home will only make you go there too often. Try to stand on your own feet. You can visit friends and parents in your holidays.

    Ah yes. Don't ask Slashdot for advice. Wrong place. Most of us here do not work for SpaceX or other similar companies. SO how should we know?

    And one other thing: Study something you like. Don't look at the open job list, because it is todays list and nobody knows how the list will look like in 5 or 7 years when you got your master degree (don't drop out with a bachelor, please). You are only good in things you like. And you have to be good to go to the interesting places in engineering.

  44. Pick the research project by sgt+scrub · · Score: 1

    Look for related research projects you like. Get involved with them now if you can. Just communicating with the TA, and if your lucky the professor, will tell you if you will fit in. If you enjoy the project, the TA's like you, and you impress your professor, you are going to make the long haul. The name of a University is nothing compared to a professor with connections.

    --
    Having to work for a living is the root of all evil.
  45. 5 Hours? by Osgeld · · Score: 1

    Is that walking driving or flying?

    a 5 hour flight go anywhere
    a 5 hour drive go where you can and take what you can get
    a 5 hour walk go f yourself

    For an engineering student you are not thinking this out very much, "like spaceX" really? where are these private companies "like spaceX", I promise you they are not within your bubble

  46. Re:be smart by Raisey-raison · · Score: 1

    Being an engineer is about learning how to solve problems.
    'Asking Slashdot' is about getting other people to solve your problems.

    If you want to be an engineer, you had better learn how to start solving your own problems, or answering questions like the one you posed, by yourself.

    The act of asking a question shows you want to learn, understand that someone else may have the answer and are willing to listen. This is how science and engineering work. To suggest that asking a question is a problem is ludicrous.

    And btw, a book and a website are just efficient consolidations of (often but not always) one person's knowledge - it's really no different conceptually than asking a question.

  47. Re:be smart by JWSmythe · · Score: 1

    Don't forget the social networking and dumb luck factors.

    Being great in your field is great.

    Being great in your field, and you know someone who will make the right introductions, will get you the job.

    I may have skills that are extremely valuable to anyone. I won't make it past the applicant queue in most places, because they don't know anything about me yet. No amount of wording on a cover letters can fix that.

    --
    Serious? Seriousness is well above my pay grade.
  48. Sounds like you know what you're doing by Zackbass · · Score: 1

    I was in your situation about 7 years ago myself, was visiting RPI, applied to MIT as my long shot. Got into MIT somehow, got my SB MechE, MS MechE (had the chance to go PhD, decided not to), working in industry now and I think I've got a little bit of perspective on the engineering school experience.

    From working directly with lots of engineers, helping profs select grad students, my own job search, and helping hire engineers there's a couple things you can do that'll greatly help your success no matter where you go to undergrad. Be passionate about something, stay focused, and do substantial work on it. Whether it's Robocup, Formula SAE, rocketry club, etc, just do it and make an impact. Do design, learn, work with people, and have fun doing it. Add being friendly and reliable (don't underestimate these!) to that and you really can go anywhere.

    I think I could have gotten a similar education at most reputable engineering schools, everyone has the same statics and dynamics equations, but if you're passionate about what you do a top school can be a truly exhilarating experience. Besides getting the opportunity to do substantial work during undergrad for top PIs, there was just an intense forward current that came from living, working, and keeping up with brilliant people. Make sure you've got the humility to deal with people smarter than you and can take failures in stride and you really can come out with a tremendous life experience.

    Whether you do Aero+MechE, or Aero or MechE will really depend on the specific program where you eventually go. When you end up working on real projects you'll likely find the impact is small, and from what I've seen Aero and MechE resumes are often thrown into the same pile. Both programs should be teaching structures, dynamics, design, controls, thermo/fluids (different spin, but it's the same math) and you may find your time is better spent on your own independent study than the specific requirements of a double degree.

    YMMV and such. Good luck!

    --
    You gotta find first gear in your giant robot car
  49. Volunteer...Anywhere To Get Experience... by BoRegardless · · Score: 1

    On upper class student's projects, professor's research, with companies they know over summer break. Start talking to profs in the fall, so you get a job by next summer.

    Learn how to use real world shop tools, because everything you design needs to be built...right. Tear apart and put back together everything you can to gain experience on "what works", why and how mistakes get made & then fixed.

    Engineering is a profession where you never, ever stop learning...including the unsuccessful results which are just as much about learning as the things that work.

    Eventually you start to form an internal order of design thinking for your field that gives you the ability to take a desired end result and sort the 50 variables down to the key defining elements that dictate what designs are reasonably possible, so you don't waste design, construction & testing time. The more quickly you can get to real world possibilities, the more quickly your work and career can progress.

  50. Another vote for intern/coop school by MauiJerry · · Score: 1

    Several people have posted that co-op or internship (or diy) work is the way to go. I strongly agree. Pick a school that has intern/coop program and uses it heavily (ask what space companies use their interns too!) I interned (as comp.engr) many years ago and it made my career. I hired summer interns several times since. When I worked at Aerovironment in Moorpark CA, we hired a number of interns ... many from Cal Poly SLO. A couple of them got hired full time after graduation. (dual major aerospace/mechanical is good recommendation) Another option (although probably not before doing school work) is DIY. A good friend of mine had an idea for rocket engines, wanted to do space work, but was full time employed doing computer animation (sweat shop job! dont go there!) He got a small cnc mill, lathe, etc and set up in his local makerspace (crashspace in LA) and started building. He did some tests, got known in the biz, took a leave of absence from his day job, took some contract jobs making parts at crashspace.... and now he's living and working out in Mojave for some rocket company. If you want it, work for it, it may happen for you. Also if you are really serious about rocketry, get the heck out of upstate NY. There are no rocket companies there per se. Then again with that 5hr radius, you may not be really serious. If you want it -be realistic and do what it takes. See the world dude. Upstate is gorgeous but lacks a lot of industry. And forget the PhD. By the time you finish, no one will want to hire you, and all the fun work will be done.

  51. Very tiny field by Animats · · Score: 1

    US space, outside NASA, is a small industry. Space-X has only 1000 employees.

    In 1965, the Apollo program had 376,700 employees, about 36,000 within NASA and the rest contractors. NASA today has 18,000, which is too many considering how little NASA is doing right now.

  52. Major is more important by pz · · Score: 1

    Go to a technical school (MIT would be your best bet) and major in Aero-Astro Engineering. You realize that's a separate discipline, right?

    It's also the hardest one at MIT. I was in Computer Science and Electrical Engineering there, but had a handful of Aero-Astro friends. They were, every single one, intellectually impressive.

    --

    Put my fist through my alarm clock with its ding-dong death inside my ear. - The Blackjacks.
  53. Re:be smart by korean.ian · · Score: 1

    Indeed - reading Richard Feynman's "What do you care what other people think?" where he describes his role in the investigation into the Challenger disaster, one gets the sense that he asked innumerable questions. Now, Feynman may not have been an engineer, but he was a hell of a lot smarter than anyone posting on this board. If someone of his intellectual capability had no issues with asking questions, then there should be few reservations for anyone else!

  54. Re:be smart by djlowe · · Score: 1

    The act of asking a question shows you want to learn, understand that someone else may have the answer and are willing to listen.

    Not necessarily. The act of asking a question may show that, depending on the question and how it is asked. It might also show that the person asking is lazy, and doesn't care to find an answer on his/her own. If you are asked the same question by the same person repeatedly, it might indicate that you're not answering it clearly or that the person is incapable of understanding the answer.

    I do agree that believing that the mere act of asking a question is a problem itself is ridiculous, however.

    Regards,

    dj

  55. Re:be smart by Plekto · · Score: 1

    The truth is that if you want to do something like that, you need to not make being a corporate lackey and cubicle-worker as your life's goal. You need to be of the mindset where you want to beat SpaceX and their incredibly top-heavy corporate style where they feel as if they are gods or something and you should be grateful to work for them (despite having few actual successes, as is the norm in this industry) at their own game. If you're not going to aim at making your own company or working with a few friends to make one of your own, then you're really not going to be valuable to any company or actually get into space. It's a bit of a catch-22, really.

    Also, the best engineers that go places and do things are the ones that build things and basically, have patents. Schooling is worthless beyond a certain point unless you want to work at, say, a defense contractor or other government type job. What matters is what you can actually do and build. I'd be sure to take some classes in metalworking, welding, and fabrication in any case, as these are real skills that you'll need wherever you go. Also, CAD and similar software is good to know how to use.

    Look at job listings and note what skills and certificates and so on that they want. Because skills can get you a job. A degree is optional, really, and only "required" because they want to weed out the rank idiots and those without any skills.
    note - no job I have had actually cared one iota about my degree or used it as a factor - they wanted skills, pure and simple.

    I'd also at the least, build your own home based fabrication machine and start working with basic designs. Also, start building your own electronic and similar designs as you can manage. Say, if you want to get into designing rockets and so on, having built a few designs yourself (how Scaled Composites got started, btw), is a big plus. And who knows, maybe you'll be the one to make some design breakthrough.

  56. Experimental aviation. by sshack · · Score: 1

    Get into experimental aviation. Being able to show up in a plane you've built yourself is the best resume you could have.

  57. Don't have a narrow focus by rrohbeck · · Score: 1

    Times are changing too quickly to rely on something attractive to even be around 20 years from now. Be a well-rounded ME first, specialized in aerospace second, with a goal to work in private spaceflight third. It's OK to have a goal but do not ignore the potential to [have to] work in an unrelated field several years down the road. The economy is contracting long term. Do we still have the opportunity for supersonic travel? Do we still have reusable space transport? Do we still have a way to get to the moon? Bu the time you have finished your education this will be painfully obvious.
    Most of all make sure you don't have significant debt.

  58. Re:don't go china inless you want to die in a chea by trout007 · · Score: 1
    --
    I love Jesus, except for his foreign policy.
  59. Step 1: Get aerospace degree by Just+Brew+It! · · Score: 1

    .
    .
    .
    Step 5: Profit!

    OK, seriously...

    As with any other engineering field, don't pass up any opportunities to learn new shit. You're only as valuable to your prospective employer as your (perceived) skills and willingness/ability to learn new ones.

    I didn't start out in aerospace. I thought I wanted to write video games, but ended up doing stints in telecom, finance, and at a US DOE research lab for most of my career. I eventually landed in aerospace/military. Vast majority of the aerospace jobs are with companies doing government (read: mostly military) contract work... just so you know, in case that's an issue.

    Even if you don't get your dream job right out of school, stay focused. If you're genuinely interested in aerospace and have a clue, I think you will get there eventually.

    Disclaimer: I'm old enough to be your dad... not sure if that's a plus or a minus in your book. :D

  60. Get a NASA internship or Co-op by trout007 · · Score: 2

    Get a NASA internship or Co-op while you are going to school. You will meet a lot of people in the industry including those in private space. Also if you are a co-op and do well you will end up with a NASA job. Then you can apply for a Graduate Fellowship. They will pay you for 1 year of your salary while you go full time for grad school. This way you can get your education cheap. You do owe them a couple of years after that but use that time to build up your skills on great projects before applying to private space.

    --
    I love Jesus, except for his foreign policy.
  61. 5-Hour Radius by ProfessionalCookie · · Score: 1

    Five hours radius by Falcon 1, Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy or Dragon?

  62. Re:If academics are important... by Rukie · · Score: 1

    er, this was me

    --
    Support the source, Open Source! An entire site developed with OSS
  63. They want you... by taoboy · · Score: 1

    The big aerospace companies are grappling with the impending mass exodus of old people like me, and most are looking to hire enthusiastic young folk like you. Go to a decent (regionally accredited) school, get good grades, maybe look for an internship.

    One thing to consider: the larger the company, the more opportunity available to you over time. As programs and contracts come and go, you'll stand a better chance moving within a big company than one with just a few things going on.

  64. Union College by eliphalet · · Score: 1

    in Schenectady, not far from RPI. A small college with engineering since the early 1800's.

  65. RIT by AnonGCB · · Score: 1

    May as well say that as a college freshman, RIT is pretty sweet, and can help you get a job wherever you want considering how many companies kiss up for interns and such.

    --
    http://CryoLANparty.com/ A lan I'm staff on!
  66. Re:don't go china inless you want to die in a chea by Darfeld · · Score: 1

    The guy who design the space craft isn't one to ride it usually... So it seems pretty safe for him.

    --
    (\__/) This is Lapinator
    (='.'=) copy it in your sig
    (")_(") so it can take over the world
  67. SEDS by gyroidben · · Score: 1

    SEDS (seds.org) is a national student group in the USA and stands for Students for the Exploration and Development of Space. There are local chapters at a lot of universities so they'd be great place to make contact with people who are wanting to get into the same industry as you. They would also probably be good people to contact to get advice on choosing a university for your undergraduate studies. I attended one meeting of a chapter at the University of Arizona and they were doing some seriously cool stuff. A few of them had put together a microgravity experiment to study liquid lenses and got a grant to go up in a zero-g plane to test it out. They're currently starting a project to build a micro-satellite and arrange for it's launch. That this is being down by an undergraduate club on their own initiative is pretty impressive.

  68. Learn a foreign language... by ctrl-alt-canc · · Score: 1

    ...at your choice between Russian, Chinese or Persian. US space program is disappearing, so you will have to work abroad.

  69. Move to China by qualityassurancedept · · Score: 1

    Because there is no way you are going to get a job in a retro industry like Engineering anywhere in the US... space is a metaphor that we conquered decades ago here.

    --
    if your life is such a big joke then why should I care?
  70. Re:WPI by glodime · · Score: 1

    Mod parent up. WPI fits the bill perfectly as an option. If you plan on applying to RPI, definitely apply to WPI.

  71. Statistically Speaking... by gizmo_mathboy · · Score: 1

    I know for a fact that SpaceX has a ton of Purdue grads. Mostly because they have a fantastic propulsion research center.

    So, either go to undergrad at Purdue and stay for a masters, or go to your state school, do really well and do your grad work at Purdue.

    Blue Origin has a decent amount of Purdue grads as well.

    Above all else you need to do excellent work in school have a decent amount of ambition. I did ok in school and "settled" for being happy with life instead having much ambition. :-)

  72. Remember Mike? by gr8_phk · · Score: 1

    MIke Melville was not looking for a job. He build an airplane from plans (a Rutan design) and flew it out there to show Burt. Burt offered him a job, and that was that. No degree, he just demonstrated that he could do exactly what they were doing. That led him to be the first private astronaut. Sure others at scaled went to MIT or whatever. I sent a resume to Scaled (along with a number of other people I know) and I got a phone interview and the others didn't. Why? Probably because my resume is full of verbs from DOing stuff. Parent post is spot-on.

  73. Stick With RPI by thpdg · · Score: 1

    Your RPI medal will get you a half price discount at a great school and a degree that will easily unlock many doors just on the name alone.

    RPI is where so many key technologies have originated (including Ethernet!) and that will continue to be true going forward. It's also a school that encourages undergraduate participation in such projects. You'll never regret the opportunity.

    --

    -Patrick

    "They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we."

  74. Rankings by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    Here are the rankings for top 10. You can buy the full lists. but even better is send off questions to HR at SNC, SpaceX, Blue Horizons, etc and ask them. HR ppl are fairly stupid about the engineering and science world. They could not tell a total loser from Einstein. The reason is that most of them were losers from the business world (HR and Marketing is where the dredges of business worlds go to). BUT, HR WILL have a list of the top schools that they employ. And yes, they will be happy to tell you that.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  75. Intern at JPL, hang out in Mojave by DesertNomad · · Score: 1

    RPI is a fine school, you'll find plenty of company. Or, find a way into Caltech. JPL is a long way from your 5-hour radius, but you actually have the opportunity as an undergrad to get involved in some cool-ass stuff. JPL is a mechanical engineer's paradise, those of us who are EEs get treated OK %^).

  76. have fun by borgasm · · Score: 1

    "Academics come first hands down so male/female ratio and party scene aren't too important."

    Part of college is to have fun, because once you are older, you're not "allowed" to be irresponsible like you were in your college days. I studied engineering, and looking back, I wish I had been to more parties and met more people.

    When you start interviewing for jobs, you need to be able to hold a conversation, be interesting, talk about different things, and generally be a likable person. An active social life will help you with that.

    Life isn't all about academics - enjoy it a little.

  77. Re:be smart by JWSmythe · · Score: 1

        I know some people will argue with you about the degrees, but I'm one who won't. I've gone very far, and had quite a bit of success, without a degree. I don't hire on the merit of a piece of paper. I hire on the merit of the individuals skills. ... and I'll quote an email from Dick Rutan.

    "To dream is great and never give up. The dreamers that are successful are the ones that can go back into your shop build it and bring dreams to reality. Fly it then talk about it."

        I strongly suspect if anyone wants to really get in the door there, doing rocket and balloon launches, such as we've seen mentioned on here, and pushing the envelope are the ways to do it. Anything we do, should only to be to impress ourselves. If it happens to get us in the door with someone else, all the better.

        I have some of my own ideas that I'm working on. They're way outside of my experience. If it ever goes from electronic development (autocad and simulators), and the first scale prototype is built, I intend to impress no one but myself. If it gets past that phase, will it get me in the door with an existing company? Who knows. Maybe my ideas will be purchased, or maybe investors will help me build my own. But right now, I'm not holding my breath, and I'm not letting it interfere with the day job that pays the bills. What will happen in 5 years or 10 years? Most likely I'll still be doing IT work. Who knows though. Several years ago, I had worked at the same shop for almost a decade. I was sure I'd be there til I retired. A few years ago, I was looking for work. I've changed industries a few times since them. Who knows where I'll be in the future. I know just as well as any of us. I just know, I won't ever stay somewhere that I will stagnate in a cube, with the promise of advancement "someday". I don't want to die of old age, thinking of what I could have done.

    --
    Serious? Seriousness is well above my pay grade.
  78. Resources by jayrtfm · · Score: 1

    This has been discussed on the a-rocket list http://exrocketry.net/mailman/listinfo/arocket
    There are active members who are employees of several space companies.
    http://www.hobbyspace.com/ is probably the best collection of resources about space, get to know the companies and people.
    read "The Rocket Company" http://www.hobbyspace.com/AAdmin/archive/SpecialTopics/RocketCom/titlePage.html

  79. Re:Mental Note by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    Look, so you took insult to this. How many ppl in HR have you met that have a SINGLE clue about a technical ppl. FEW, if any. The ONLY time that I met anyone with even a tech background was a ex-CISer who was a failure in the tech world so became a star in the HR in the firm. THat is, until they realized that she was just as bad at HR as she was as a tech.

    Hell, for somebody that takes such exception, you do not even have the courage or backbone to post your login. It says a lot about HR and yourself. And if you think that it was horrible that I spoke about HR, what exactly is your background that you can judge tech ppl? Are you an engineer or even a scientists? Nuts, even GD lawyers have enough brains to insist that all lawyers that work in IP have a science/tech/engineering background.

    And to take this one step further, I had an old friend of mine that got his PdH in HR from NIU. He now works for a major 50 as their top HR. And he has commented many times that most of HR IS the bottom of the business world. And he would not presume to judge engineers/scientists/etc.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  80. MIT - JPL by Ithacacian · · Score: 1

    All the comments about getting out of your education what you put into it are spot on. Things are not taught at MIT; resources are made available, whether that's projects to glom onto, professor's time, the general atmosphere of extracurriculars, etc. The difference is who these companies come recruiting to, and the network of contacts available. I did CMU -> MIT -> JPL, and I wouldn't have made it despite perfect numbers and a host of paper projects without the support of my advisor at MIT, who along with another one of my SE professors pretty much provided a litany of filial academic connection lining the way past those couple days of interviews with golden, personal touches. As an aside, the advisor of my advisor of my advisor was von Karman. I'll also mention that I got an offer at Orbital, and they revealed they have the directive only to accept students from a short list of some of the better thought of schools people have mentioned. SpaceX is a bit more egalitarian. They will call you up and do the Google 20 questions to suss out your technical acumen. JPL has a wide mix too, though three out of four of my bosses are fellow MIT alum.

  81. Re:Who you know MATTERS... so true by anubi · · Score: 1

    If there is one thing I learned from Government aerospace contractors, its WHO, not WHAT you know that counts.

    If you are not good at doing technical stuff, but have good people skills with those above you, they will put you in charge of engineers,

    I found dealing with people who have management skills but limited awareness of the laws of physics the most frustrating experience I ever had.

    --
    "Prove all things; hold fast that which is good." [KJV: I Thessalonians 5:21]

  82. I went to RPI by aeroelastic · · Score: 1

    From what I hear, if you go to MIT you'll work 18 hours a day and have no social life. If you go to RPI, you'll work 12 hours a day and have no social life.

    The most important thing I learned from RPI was how to fail. It was an important life lesson, but it had nothing to do with my degree. I worked way harder and got way worse grades than I ever did in high school. From what I've heard MIT is a worse version of the same thing. I graduated with an embarrassingly low GPA. But I learned it's more important for me personally to fail at something hard than succeed at something easy.

    The upside is that pretty much everyone around the world have heard of MIT, where RPI is only know in the serious engineering community. My first job out of school was working for the Army. No matter how many times I corrected my boss, he still thought I went to RIT.

    --
    "It doesn't take a rocket scientist" -I guess I should leave then
    1. Re:I went to RPI by tehcyder · · Score: 1

      But I learned it's more important for me personally to fail at something hard than succeed at something easy.

      If a thing's worth doing, it's worth doing badly (Chesterton).

      --
      To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it
  83. Re:be smart by Plekto · · Score: 1

    It makes me wonder how many aerospace/aerospatial engineers even have class 3 rocketry licenses? How many have built their own rocket motor? (this requires tons of sub-skills as you might imagine)

    With the advent of portable CNC machines and fabrication devices that you can fit in your garage, a whole world is now open to many people.

    Of course go to school. But also do what you want in the meantime. Spend as little as possible while getting the most out of your education. Myself, I took as many classes as I possibly could (almost 80 credits) at the local community college before transferring. Be lean, mean, and inventive, and someone will want to hire you.

  84. Take the initiative in a hardware project by aeropreneur · · Score: 1

    I know of a guy who got hired by one of the biggest newspace companies, apparently they were very interested in a large model rocket he built himself and tested. This kind of thing used to be more common, but I guess not that many students nowadays grow up building Heathkits, flying models and other hardware stuff on their own.

    So at least take advantage of whatever student engineering projects are available at your school, or even better take the initiative to start one. You'll learn a lot in the process, and maybe even more importantly, build your confidence level.

  85. Check into Huntsville by Dravik · · Score: 1

    If you are willing to stretch your distances, the University of Alabama in Huntsville is a good engineering school(not n aMIT or Georgia Tech) that is collocated with a lot of space and missile companies. By going to UAH you can do Co-ops and internships with NASA, Army Missile and Space Command, Space X, and others. Almost every US space and missile company has a presence in Huntsville Alabama and takes students from UAH.

    --
    The purpose of language is communication, If the idea is clear the grammar ain't important
  86. to be smart and ask questions is not enough... by slew · · Score: 1

    Although I mostly agree with the part about seeking advice and asking questions, I don't think most folks understand the Challenger Commission. Basically the whole Commission was an exercise in politics (Feynman knew that General Kutyna and the engineering crew at Morton Thiokol knew what was the likely problem was, but they were politically unable to deliver the news, so Feynman simply delivered it for them).

    The one thing about this example that is about engineering is that Feynman (a very smart guy by the way), basically laid out for the public to see the all-too-common disconnect between managment and engineering. In this case, NASA managers presenting rosy pictures where the engineers were sweating the cost-cutting/corner-cutting. Since Feynman's job wasn't on the line, he got to ask the questions that many of the engineers dared not ask. Also because he was smart and articulate, he often got the answers where other askers did not.

    The moral of this story? Just being smart and asking questions isn't enough... You have to be able to communicate too. If you think people don't like what you are communicating, you'd better have a plan B.

  87. RPI/Hudson Valley Community College by zoward · · Score: 1

    When I was at RPI in the mid-1980's, several RPI professors sat on the board for the local community college - Hudson Valley Community College. At that time, you could do two years at HVCC and transfer all of it to RPI, assuming you kept a decent QPA (which any simian could do at HVCC). This would give you the first two years of RPI ar 1/10th the cost of RPI itself. I'd be surprised if this hasn't changed since then, but it's worth looking into.

    --
    "Can't you see that everyone is buying station wagons?"
    1. Re:RPI/Hudson Valley Community College by CtownNighrider · · Score: 1

      I asked about this (well really it was my mom because she dealt with financial aid for my brother that went to Fordham) and the guy said that as a rule of thumb they tell kids to expect whatever they get freshman year for all 4 years. The only way this will change is if there is a large change in income for the family or something.

  88. Schooling is essential by mangu · · Score: 1

    Schooling is worthless beyond a certain point

    That's true only for very high values of certain point.

    If you want to work in the space industry as an engineer, the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation will show you how the odds are stacked. To get anything into orbit with rockets you need a mass ration of something like 40:1, that is the propellant you need to carry weighs forty times everything else: engines, tanks, payload, etc.

    You cannot fine tune a system to that level with gut feelings alone, you must do a lot of calculations. It is rocket science, you know.

    Of course, practical experience is also a must, but experience will never bring you the theoretical knowledge you need. Without an engineering degree you can still rise to the top of the industry as a manager, of course, but that's not engineering.

    Without an engineering degree you may still build great rockets, but they will be rockets designed by someone else. You will not be the creator, only the hired hand labor.

  89. Go to a school with a student satellite team by zacinaction · · Score: 1

    I'm a PhD student in Aerspace at Cornell, where I also did my undergrad (and somewhere you should definitely check out, especially if you're in the area). At Cornell, we've very successfully competed in the university nanosat competitions (NANOSAT-4 with CUSat and NANOSAT-6 with Violet). Nearly everyone from these teams goes on to work in the space industry. In fact, SpaceX, Boeing, and others come to campus specifically to recruit from within CUSat and Violet.

  90. Re:be smart by Aeros · · Score: 1

    You should look at some of the companies you are interested in and see what types of internships they have. Also try to make some contacts there and see what they advise. But you should definitely study the things you are interested in and enjoy and take it from there. You don't want to end up doing something you are not interested in for the rest of your life right? Don't listen to some of the people earlier in this post saying 'asking here is dumb'. Asking questions is important.

  91. Remember it's not all about the classes by lewscroo · · Score: 1

    I went to Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) for ME (they have an aerospace option, which I didn't take). What was great about their program is that you have to do mandatory co-ops. You go to school for 5 years instead of the normal 4, but over a year of that time is spent working for other companies. And you have to hunt for the jobs and apply for them just as you would for any normal job after graduation. Even though it is tough sometimes to find a place to co-op that you want and who wants you in the end it is worth it for the experience of the job hunt and quite frankly it pays much better than most summer jobs you'd find (unpaid internships aren't allowed). And since classes are designed so you don't just co-op during the summer you may have a better chance at getting an internship in the Fall, Winter or Spring at a desired company since you won't be competing with so many other applicants during the Summer. While I did find a co-op at an Aerospace company and I was excited to get it, please remember that you may not enjoy all of the types of jobs that those companies offer. The co-op I did there was more related to Manufacturing engineering, so quality control and processes and lots of tedium. No better way to find out what areas of your field you DON'T want to do than to spend a few months actually doing it. Experience is key to finding out what you really like to do but it doesn't have to be all on-the-job training. Be sure to look for hands-on extra-curriculars that a school offers, not just courses you may think will interest you. Again, I know I'm pimping RIT, but they have an Aero Club that does more than just make simple RC model airplanes (they've sent stuff to space!), but also have clubs for other Mechanical enthusiasts like Formula-1 and FIRST Robotics that often can consume large portions (sometimes too much) of your free time. And remember, if you aren't happy at one school there is no shame in transferring. Don't force yourself to stay at a school you hate just because you feel like you have to finish what you started.

  92. My advice by tehcyder · · Score: 1

    Get drunk and get laid as often as you can when you're young, being happy should be your main goal in life.

    --
    To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it
  93. Network, network, network by caywen · · Score: 1

    I'm not in the aerospace field - maybe applying directly into the private space industry is your best bet. But, in my career, I've learned the best way to enter a field that is normally closed to you is to build a solid network. That doesn't mean shmoozing your way in, however. That means, work hard at the jobs you can get, and build great professional relationships with others. As the private space industry grows, it wouldn't be surprising that someone you worked with who has a high opinion of you will enter the industry and will be asked, "got any friends? we're hiring like crazy."

  94. Co-founder of Masten Space System's suggestions by mhmealling · · Score: 1

    I wrote this:

    http://rocketforge.org/?p=436

    a few years ago. As a co-founder of Masten Space Systems I would get this question frequently enough that I wrote a standard blog article about it. Here's the gist:

    Work for NASA but leave before it makes you cynical.
    Work in Mojave but leave or else you’ll never get married.
    No matter what, build something.
    Internships!
    Go to some key conference and meet people
    Use LinkedIn, VisualCV, and yes, Facebook
    Know your industry intimately
    Join Students for the Exploration and Development of Space (SEDS)
    Go get an advanced degree. Get it from the International Space University (ISU) if you can
    Become an expert at something
    Do something risky
    Spectacularly fail at something
    Be LOUD about it!

  95. Re:be smart by JWSmythe · · Score: 1

        You know, I'd be willing to bet that the wonders of the Internet have really advanced what they can do too.

        Not long ago, I was thinking back to when I was a kid. There was no Internet. Well, there was, but I had no way to get to it.

        When I graduated high school, there were less than 10 web sites. We did have BBSs. Most had porn and door games. And there were the collections of text files, from dubious sources. Oh, we shouldn't forget the experts that populated the newsgroups. Well, about the same ratio of experts, to liars who said they were experts, as Wikipedia has. :)

        I lived far enough from any major cities, where the libraries had scarce information. Good luck finding experts. The closest I found to civilian aerospace group was some folks who made model rockets, but never went above a Class C motor.

        Getting my hands on construction equipment was rough. Flea markets, yard sales for deals, or if I had money (ya, right), I could order through retail outlets.

        Now we can get tools and supplies through Craigslist and eBay. We can find and talk to experts world wide almost instantly (depending on when they read their email). We can read people's accounts of what they've done, and watch videos on how successful they were. And hell, if I were to start a project, I could present it to hundreds of thousands of people in just a day (submit the story to Slashdot), or possibly more attention by emailing press releases to every publication on the planet.

        I wish I was doing stuff that I did when I was a kid.. I had room to do stuff. Growing up on a farm sucked for socialization, but had it's advantages, like I could build a rocket at the house, and launch it in the back field. I could probably have done motor tests on some pretty big motors, and no one would have cared.

        Then again, if I was still out there, I wouldn't be making as much money as I am now, so I most likely wouldn't be able to fund crazy hobbies. :)

    --
    Serious? Seriousness is well above my pay grade.