Slashdot Mirror
Early Look at Steampunk Action-Adventure Game Dishonored
Dishonored is an upcoming first-person action-adventure game in a steampunk setting. It's being developed by Arkane Studios and published by Bethesda Softworks. As the game nears its October 9th release, Jim Rossignol of Rock, Paper, Shotgun got some hands-on time with the game, and was impressed by how it is shaping up:
"The level I played saw me overpowering a government official from his laboratory high on a building above the lavish pseudo-London cityscape, and lugging him out to a riverside rendezvous. Initially I went in through the front door, bluntly killing the guards with a knife and sneaking inside. But I could have used all manner of other entrances, and other powers. I could have slipped in undetected by distracting the guards. I could have possessed a rat – zooming into the hapless thing in a manner of bodily possession/transformation reminiscent of forgotten FPS Requiem: Avenging Angel – and then rematerialized once I’d run in through grates and rat holes. I could have possessed an NPC and used the meatsuit to pass through the energy-field barricades. Or I could even have employed a short-ranged teleportation power, blink, and leapt and mantled my way up across the rooftops."
Now certainly the goth chicks at school will be into me.
Anymore when I hear the word "steampunk" I think "bad writing". It was an interesting fad at one time, but now it just means your creative people are lazy.
So what you're saying is that we only need a few books set in space, or a few books set in magical lands with wizards and dragons, and a few books with zombies and a few books with vampires and we're golden?
... Imagine hundreds of books set in ... the Star Wars Universe ...
I actually count 320 so no imagination is required. I don't really have a point, just that everything is already run into the ground.
I agree. We should allow some sort of limited monopoly on ALL genres! Each genre gets 7 books, first to file wins.
Yeah, THAT'LL encourage creativity and new ideas...
Support the EFF and Creative Commons. The war is coming, and they're supporting you...
There are 20+ dune novels, even more books about dune, and comics. There are also movies and tv shows.
How is a steampunk setting any different than a post-apocalyptic setting or a space setting or an alien world setting?
Bad examples. Those are all vastly more general settings than steam punk.
Everyone's just waiting for Bioshock Infinite to come out.
How so?
Steampunk could be on any planet, at any time, with little to no problem. All it needs are fancy clothes, overly elaborate gadgets and some dirigibles.
So I take it you think all high fantasy, World War II, or western settings are complete crap too?
A genre can be redone well a million times over. The creativity doesn't lie in the setting, but in the execution.
Arcanum, or if you prefer Planescape:Torment?
Also Corsets?
And I don't get how people can use the word "frack" unironically (and outside of the oil industry). But you learn to suppress the vitriol and just pass on by. Let the steamfolks be, because we all have our own quirky little vices.
Everything is better with chainsaws.
Isn't Dune a bit steampunk?
The cesspool just got a check and balance.
Depends on the millennium. Dune spans like 50k years.
I drank what? -- Socrates
... Imagine hundreds of books set in ... the Star Wars Universe ...
I actually count 320 so no imagination is required . I don't really have a point, just that everything is already run into the ground.
I see what you did there....
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
How is a steampunk setting any different than a post-apocalyptic setting or a space setting or an alien world setting?
The difference is that steampunk is not defined by setting, but rather by use of devices that defy science (even future science). I don't think of it so much as a genre, but as an excuse for poor creativity.
All the talk of whether or not Steampunk is total rubbish aside... is it just me or is this guy a terrible writer? Is this what passes for journalism these days?
Obvious troll is obvious.
The Kruger Dunning explains most post on
When did this start? Game previews (especially ones this far out) are a total waste of time. They're controlled by the publisher, and positive 100% of the time. It's nothing more then free PR for the publisher.
Why is this now something worth being posted?
-- "So they told me that using the download page to download something was not something they anticipated." - Bill Gates
No, not exactly. What he's saying is that only one author should write books set in a magical land with wizards and dragons, and while that author could write a whole series of such books, no other author should have wizards and dragons in their books. So I guess that means any fantasy author other than Tolkein sucks and can't come up with their own ideas. Then again, I'm pretty sure Tolkein didn't invent dragons and wizards all by himself, so you shouldn't give him a chance either, let alone all the other fantasy authors.
Same goes for space-based sci-fi. Whoever the first author to dream up a sci-fi book involving aliens on another planet was, all others after him suck and can't come up with their own ideas, so you shouldn't bother with them. I'm guessing that means only HG Wells is OK.
but rather by use of devices that defy science
I am sure the alchemists of the day had a perfectly cromulent scientific explanation for manipulation of the phlogiston to power those devices.
No there aren't. There are six Dune novels.
And then there is the cash grabbing series written by his son and Poul Anderson because they needed more money.
Actually it might have started with good intentions, but that didn't last past the first series. Well, maybe not good intentions, since his books always seemed more based on the David Lynch movie than his fathers books...
A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government. -edward abbey
Wow, really? Poor creativity? Because the devices defy science/"future science"? It's "creative" as long as it has warp drives and phase inverters?
I can't believe you seriously included "future science" into your argument. If there's anything that makes an absolute mockery of real science, it's scifi science.
The difference is that steampunk is not defined by setting, but rather by use of devices that defy science (even future science). I don't think of it so much as a genre, but as an excuse for poor creativity.
It's called "suspension of disbelief".
Steampunk, list most subgenres within the science fiction/fantasy umbrella, has little or nothing to do with the technology described... it's a backdrop for the story actually being told. Done well, it's fun and whimsical. Done badly... well... ever seen Wild Wild West? If you're getting hung up on the "science" of it, you're missing the point completely.
Ok - so one series of books in such a setting by one author - I can accept. A whole fracking genre?
Sreampunk tech is fun to draw and fun to animate, with a lot of personality --- but little that is magical or over-powering.
You can see how the machine works.
Things tend to move within a late Victorian and Edwardian world. That has always been an extraordinarily rich lode to mine for the writer of pulp fiction, the weird tale, and the classic adventure story.
The fantasy RPG looks back to the myths and legends of an distant and comforting agrarian past. You'll find damn little of that in Lovecraft or Doyle. You cannot move back, you can only move forward.
"Do not raise up what you cannot put down."
The spectral Hound of the Baskervilles is a theatrical illusion.
What is real and terrifying is to see the face of a later-day killer exposed in the centuries old portrait galleries of the Baskerville clan and to know that this has happened again and again.
Imagine hundreds of books set in the Dune Universe or the Star Wars Universe or Cory Doctorow's shitty wet dream of a universe he calls a novel...... crap.
There ARE hundreds of books written in the Star Wars Universe. And there are hundreds written in the Star Trek Universe.
But you know what is worse, there are THOUSANDS written in the real universe. OMG! The horror! Imagine all of the unimaginative novels written by authors that suck and couldn't come up with their own ideas, so they wrote about our own real universe.
I must point out that "suspension of disbelief", in most circumstances, only works if the system gives the initial impression of being internally consistent. So no writing a story about wizards and magic and then having the protagonist nuke the villain in the last five pages. The audience doesn't expect that. It's cheating. However, a magical device equivalent to a nuclear bomb is clearly fair game, especially if it doesn't appear out of nowhere and is otherwise consistent with the level and possible distructiveness of magic in the world.
Obviously, you've never tried Girl Genius
Give it a whirl.. come back.. and let us know what you think.
The start of the Girl Genius comic is here: http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20021104
It's really quite simple
Steampunk is what happens when Goths discover the color brown.
I don't mind some of the aesthetics, but over all, Steampunk holds no real attraction for me - Maybe I've just got too much of an investment in black clothing and spider-themed jewelry. ;)
The Digital Sorceress
You can see how the machine works.
I played with steam engines as a kid. I made miniature hot-air balloons, with candles and large thin paper bags. I rebuilt car and bike engines as an adult, because I understand how these things work. I don't understand electrons. I don't really know how my PC works - I built it, but it was just a question of assembling the components in the proper order and loading up a ton of software that someone else wrote. When it goes wrong, my only usual recourse is to switch off and on again, and in severe cases, re-install Windows.
I think a lot of the appeal of steampunk is that people do understand it - dirigibles, semaphore, steam and diesel engines are things you could explain to any educated person of the last few hundred years in a few minutes. Mobile phones might as well be magic boxes to 99% of the people who carry them around - Clarke's Law has kicked in with a vengeance.
You're all a bunch of whiney bitches.