Slashdot Mirror


Stay Home When You're Sick!

theodp writes "If you've got Google CEO Larry Page's billions, you can reduce your chances of getting sick this winter by personally providing free flu shots to all San Francisco Bay Area kids at Target pharmacies. 'Vaccinating children,' explains the Shoo the Flu initiative's website, 'will not only improve children's health, it will also dramatically reduce the risk of the flu spreading to adults.' But Tim Olshansky doesn't have Page's money, so he'll have to settle for trying to get it through people's thick heads that they really have to stay home when they're sick. 'Why do people still come to the office when they're coughing up a lung?' asks the exasperated Olshansky. 'Because unfortunately, there is a still a strong perverse culture that equates staying at home when sick with weakness. This is a flawed belief and should be questioned. Given that we have the tools now to complete most tasks from home, there is no strong reason to compel people to come to the workplace.' So, does your employer encourage employees to stay home when they're sick? How?"

35 of 670 comments (clear)

  1. Uh, nice try by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    So, basically, stay home, but keep working? Remember when sick days were to allow you to actually rest?

    1. Re:Uh, nice try by xaxa · · Score: 5, Interesting

      So, basically, stay home, but keep working? Remember when sick days were to allow you to actually rest?

      Like yesterday. A colleague phoned in sick, but we received an email from her a little later.

      We told our manager, who emailed the sick colleague and reminded her that she should rest if she's ill (or otherwise follow medical advice). It's stupid to worry about work, or do any work, when that's likely to delay your return to work.

      Of course, this wasn't in America.

    2. Re:Uh, nice try by QRDeNameland · · Score: 5, Insightful

      There's different kinds of sick. You might just be getting tired very easily (so you really need a bed in reach) but otherwise feel quite ok.

      Or as I've said in certain occasions, some days you can work OK, but you don't want to be outside of a 15 foot radius of your own toilet. TMI, perhaps, but it happens to all of us from time to time.

      --
      Momentarily, the need for the construction of new light will no longer exist.
    3. Re:Uh, nice try by mellon · · Score: 5, Insightful

      When I first started working, it was common for employees to have a certain number of sick days and a certain number of vacation days. If you got sick, you took sick days; if you didn't get sick, you didn't take them. Obviously this was ripe for abuse, but it had the virtue of meaning that employees who got sick could go home and get better rather than infecting the whole office with their bug.

      Nowadays, we have PTO (paid time off), which is a combination of sick days and vacation days. Typically, PTO is the same number of days that you used to get for vacation back in the day. So now, whenever you take a sick day, you are losing a vacation day. So duh, of course people come in when they are sick, or else work from home; if they didn't, they'd be burning vacation days. If you ever wonder why the burger-flipper behind the counter at McDonalds sneezed in your burger, this is also why. It still shocks me to see people in food service jobs sneezing, but that's the brave new world we live in.

      I think most 20-something and 30-something workers in the U.S. never experienced "sick days." So maybe this all seems puzzling to you, but it's dead obvious to me: if you want employees to go home sick when they are sick, don't dock their vacation time.

      Of course, I'm completely glossing over the fact that lots of employees are part-time and don't even *get* vacation time. We have really impoverished ourselves over the past thirty years, with the invention of "PTO," with the rise of part-time work as a way to avoid paying benefits, with the rise of lifetime minimum wage employment, and a variety of other innovations.

    4. Re:Uh, nice try by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 5, Insightful

      My answer: Because if I stay home, I likely would just be goofing off...

      That is true for many people. I worked at a company that tried to implement wide scale telecommuting. About a third of the people had equal or better performance. But for the rest, their performance fell. In many cases it fell to nearly zero. When I called one woman to discuss why her productivity had plunged to nothing, she had to pause the phone conversation several times to tell her rug-rats to shutup while she was on the phone. The following Monday, she was back in the office, and her kids were back in daycare. Telecommuting works for some, but not for many others, and it requires significantly more management bandwidth.

    5. Re:Uh, nice try by wadeal · · Score: 5, Informative

      You blame someone else? How is you not doing anything about losing your rights anyone's fault but yours?

      What have you personally done to stand up for your rights? Have you taken your concerns to management or talked with your union (if part of one)?

      As an Australian I cannot begin to fathom what it must be like to live in that shit hole over there - you work for nothing, with no rights, 90% of people are fucking broke, half your country is retarded and refuses to allow public healthcare so all those poor people stay sick and poor and while all this happens you allow your country to spend TRILLIONS on defence - while people die from basic medical conditions that would cost a small percentage of your defence budget!?!?

      Do you even get how fucking mentally handicapped your entire country seems? AND IT'S PEOPLE LIKE YOU WHO ARE TO BLAME FOR NOT DOING ANYTHING.

  2. How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by fustakrakich · · Score: 5, Insightful

    By firing us if we don't show up to work!

    --
    “He’s not deformed, he’s just drunk!”
    1. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Indeed, it's not about appearing weak, it's about being terminated.

      And this includes hospital nurses. Seriously, you want to see a group of people working when they shouldn't, go to your local hospital.

    2. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by msk · · Score: 5, Insightful

      It's high time for the creators and enforcers of policies like this to be held liable for endangering the public.

    3. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by Cro+Magnon · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I've always thought that a supervisor who insists that a sick employee come to work should talk to the employee in person. In close quarters. After they recover, maybe they'll be more generous with sick time.

      --
      Slow down, cowboy! It has been 4 hours since you last posted. You must wait another few hours.
    4. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by who_stole_my_kidneys · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Some people literally cant afford to be sick, I.E. you don't work you don't get paid.

      I've known people to get bad yearly reviews because they used too much sick time.

      I've known people to not get promotions specifically on the grounds that they used too much of their sick time.

      Not more than they had but too much.

      Oh and if your out more than 2 days don't forget your doctors note, because you have to goto a doctor and pay your non-reimbursable copay (if you have insurance) for them to confirm: yes you are sick and should stay home.

    5. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by gorzek · · Score: 5, Insightful

      No offense, but not all workplaces are run the same way, and there certainly are employers who will fire you for taking even one sick day. This doesn't generally happen to people on salary, but it does happen to people who are paid by the hour, especially in jobs where you are easy to replace (such as retail sales and food service.)

    6. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by AwesomeMcgee · · Score: 5, Informative

      It's not even about the work, it's more sterile than that. I had a hospital stay, used up all my (very little) sick time, then was given 1 week of unpaid time after which they it ran into the HR's cut-off where HR rules dictated termination occurs for non-attendance, and thus I was let go. End of story. It's a matter of our culture accepting these ~2-3 days of sick time a year, what a joke. I'm not using that time for a cough, sorry, I might break something between now and the end of the year at which point I'll actually *need* that little bit of time.

    7. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by AwesomeMcgee · · Score: 5, Informative

      Ironic you refute your own statement "taking a day off because of a minor cold, perhaps they should get fired" You apparently don't understand what this article is saying about when people should stay home. You realize that "minor cold" is 100% contagious and could soon be in half your other employees some of which may have poorer immune systems where that cold develops into something serious? You're belief in firing people over this is precisely *why* we don't stay home, meanwhile you're saying you won't get fired?

      On a side note, I was fired from a job after a hospital stay had me out past my PTO, 1 week unpaid after the 3 days sick time ran out and they canned me. So sorry but not everywhere will avoid firing people for getting *really* sick, and you're suggesting firing people for getting mildly sick, so frankly, screw off.

    8. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by thomasw_lrd · · Score: 5, Informative

      My wife is a nurse, and yes they are not allowed to call in sick. It's an automatic write-up and that's if you have a doctors note stating you were sick. I'm sure it's close to termination if you don't have note.

    9. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by somersault · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I only found out last night (because a friend is applying for jobs in the US right now) that the US doesn't even have a statutory minimum holiday time for workers.

      Employees in sweatshop countries like China and Taiwan have better vacation time than some US employees.t's atrocious, and people being fired for being sick is horrible too. Just another reason for me to dislike the US government. I just can't believe that a supposedly "developed" country would have such a policy, on top of things like no real national healthcare. The US must be an awful place to live if you're poor.

      --
      which is totally what she said
    10. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by Rob+the+Bold · · Score: 5, Funny

      I've always thought that a supervisor who insists that a sick employee come to work should talk to the employee in person. In close quarters. After they recover, maybe they'll be more generous with sick time.

      Here's where you, as the employee, can take the initiative. When I worked for a supervisor that didn't like people out sick, I dragged my miserable ass to the office in the morning to pick up some work to do at home and visit the boss's office for a personal check-in -- you know, to see if there was anything special that came up that I needed to deal with before/instead of what it was understood I was working on. Maybe i had to borrow his desk phone to track him down when he wasn't right there. Proactive stuff. It's what conscientious employees do.

      Now I'm an engineer, not a doctor, so I don't know if that had any relation to the boss not showing up the next week.

      --
      I am not a crackpot.
    11. Re:How do they 'encourage' us to stay home? by ces · · Score: 5, Informative

      If you are in the US and got fired because you used up your sick leave and hit some arbitrary cutoff set by HR for unpaid leave that was less than the statutory amounts your former employer is opening themselves up for a lawsuit and Federal fines. The Family and Medical Leave Act entitles you to up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave per year for illness or medical conditions that leave you unable to perform your duties: http://www.dol.gov/whd/fmla/#.UMIqn7SmClI

      --
      Happy Fun Ball is for external use only.
  3. Going home sick = communism. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Going home sick means using sick time. Getting sick time means getting paid not not work. Getting paid to not work means socialism. Socialism = communism.

    QED.

  4. Come to work or else by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It's not the sign of weakness that keeps people coming in, it's the threat of being fired. Some employers are really good about giving sick days (and bless them), but some bosses I have worked for took the line that "you come in, or else". Given the choice between spreading a cold around the office or losing my job, guess which option I took?

    1. Re:Come to work or else by gfxguy · · Score: 5, Interesting

      We sort of eliminated "sick" days by combining sick, personal, and vacation days all into Paid Time Off (PTO). Nobody had a problem taking a sick day when they were sick, nobody was going to get fired for it (although when there was crucial stuff going on you might be asked to provide a note from a doctor - but I've never heard of anybody actually being asked to). But now people treat all the days as vacation days - so they come in when they're sick because they don't want to blow a vacation day on it. Some of us have the luxury of working at home; if the illness is not that bad - i.e. the main reason I won't come in is because I don't want to make other people sick, then my supervisor has no problem with it.

      --
      Stupid sexy Flanders.
  5. Incorrect conclusions by Scutter · · Score: 5, Insightful

    "Because unfortunately, there is a still a strong perverse culture that equates staying at home when sick with weakness. This is a flawed belief and should be questioned."

    That's not it at all. People still go to work when they're sick because:

    A: They don't want to use up sick days unless they absolutely have to because if they get sick without having any time left, they don't get paid
    B: Some employers equate staying home sick with "not being a team player" (or some variant thereof) and will actively discourage any time off unless forced

    --

    "Tell me doctor, with all of your defenses, are there any provisions for an attack by killer bees?"
    1. Re:Incorrect conclusions by omglolbah · · Score: 5, Informative

      I can be on 100% medical leave for a -year- with full pay with approval from my doctor.
      This is the same for all Norwegian workers.

      "Sick-days" is called "Egenmelding" or "Self Message" directly translated, basically if you're sick and dont see a doctor you have 4 of those a year, up to 3 days each. If you need more than that see a doctor and get medical leave.
      After 15 or so days the company no longer pays medical leave and the state system takes over paying it.

      Hell, at the company I work we get 24 sick days a year (used in 1-7 day chunks, depending on what you need). These sick days are with full pay.
      Those with children below the age of 12 get an additional 12 (I think) days of leave to be home with sick child.

      This system works great for keeping people the hell away from the office when sick :)

  6. What a fucking idiot. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Who uses sick days to be sick? If I'm going to be sick and miserable, I'd rather be at work!

  7. People don't want to go to work when they're sick. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    What the hell is it with people thinking that people actually want to go to work when they're sick?

    They have to because they only have so many sick days and, being unable to control how many days per year they'll be sick, it's only smart to save the things until they're desperately needed. Otherwise you end up vomiting one day and have to cut into your vacation time by taking a vacation day. Wonderful vacation there, staying home vomiting all day long.

    Also, don't forget that employers hate it when their employees aren't at work. "You're sick? Fuck you, get your ass in here and earn me some money. I'll be sure not to give you such a large share of it that you can even afford to think about not coming in to work when you're sick, you selfish bastard. Worship my job-creating awesomeness!"

    People go to work when they're sick because they don't have a choice. Same reason they drive to work even after some unavoidable event kept them awake all night.

  8. Policy change by boristdog · · Score: 5, Insightful

    My company used to have a policy of "stay home when you are sick" and didn't force you to use vacation leave when you were sick. You just called in sick and that was it. And the company did fine. Sure, a few people abused it, but that happens with any benefit.

    Then they changed the policy so that sick time came out of your vacation. Now people show up to work sick all the time.

    Stupid, I tell you.

  9. Contagious before Symptoms. by wisnoskij · · Score: 5, Insightful

    From what I understand contagion and symptoms are not really linked.
    In many cases you are most contagious before you even know you are sick, in others you are still very contagious after you recover completely. It depends on the specific illness.

    Staying home when you feel bad is about not working when you physically cannot work and not really very good at all at stopping the spread of these illnesses.

    Now personally, I like working when I am sick. I would rather work when I am sick and have time off while I am healthy. But that depends a lot on the nature and severity of the illness, as well as the job.

    --
    Troll is not a replacement for I disagree.
  10. indeed, sick days aren't for sickness by rubycodez · · Score: 5, Funny

    everyone knows sick days are for:
    1. hangovers, or continuing benders
    2. doing something important or fun that can only be done during workday
    3. job interview

    but as for going to work and making your boss or asshole coworkers sick, so what? fuck 'em!

  11. Re:Wasting Sick days by thisnamestoolong · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I have a better idea; how about you don't drink so much on a work night that you will be unable to come in to work the next day! That way, you will have sick days left for when you have communicable diseases, and I won't have to catch them!

    --
    To the haters: You can't win. If you mod me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine
  12. Re:Flu can last a week or more by Greyfox · · Score: 5, Funny

    Fuck that noise! If the company policy is encouraging me to come in when I'm sick, I'm going to lick every goddamn doorknob in the building! AND set up base camp in a hotel cube smack in the middle of HR.

    --

    I'm trying to teach myself to set people on fire with my mind... Is it hot in here?

  13. F2F [Re:Uh, nice try] by Geoffrey.landis · · Score: 5, Insightful

    What is the exact reason you think that you need all of your people actually nose to muzzle on a day to day basis?? If its the real time "Face to Face" thing then for all that matters you could have everybody meet on your corporate sim on the SL grid

    Short answer is, because despite the antisocial tendencies of the computer community that reads /., human interactions --meaning "real time face to face" interaction, as you put it (what used to be called "talking to people" in the old days)--are valuable, and that doesn't mean text and document exchange, nor even skype. And "corporate sim" is not actually face to face.

    --
    http://www.geoffreylandis.com
    1. Re:F2F [Re:Uh, nice try] by QRDeNameland · · Score: 5, Interesting

      What is the exact reason you think that you need all of your people actually nose to muzzle on a day to day basis?? If its the real time "Face to Face" thing then for all that matters you could have everybody meet on your corporate sim on the SL grid

      Short answer is, because despite the antisocial tendencies of the computer community that reads /., human interactions --meaning "real time face to face" interaction, as you put it (what used to be called "talking to people" in the old days)--are valuable, and that doesn't mean text and document exchange, nor even skype. And "corporate sim" is not actually face to face.

      As someone who works for a firm where most of our people work remotely, I have to agree. At a certain point it does become an impediment to productivity when people are only communicating over the wire. Some companies will manage this better than others, but I think there's always some level of overhead to working remotely.

      But that said, in today's day and age, if your job is done primarily in front of a screen or on the phone, there is really no good reason not to at least have the ability to work from home for times when you are either not all that sick (but potentially contagious), or your kid's sick, or even if you just have to be home for the cable guy. I have one regular work at home day per week, and if for any reason I want or need to work from home any other day, I won't get any grief unless I was blowing off an important meeting or the like. The technology to do so is ubiquitous, and I don't think there's as much of an issue with sometimes working from home than with working 100% remotely.

      At a previous job, not only would people routinely come in sick, it was not uncommon for someone to show up at work with their sick child who can't be in school or day care. Sorry but rarely, if ever, is one single person is so valuable that the need for their presence in the office outweighs the cost of them being a disease vector to everyone else. I don't really understand why more employers don't look *down* on showing up sick.

      --
      Momentarily, the need for the construction of new light will no longer exist.
  14. 12 days a year, 100% pay by tantrum · · Score: 5, Informative

    Here in Norway it is required by law that every employee has the possibility to call in sick for 4x3 days per 12 months (not by calendar year). This is with 100% pay, no questions asked. If you're reall sick, and has to get sickleave, this will not count in on the 12 days as long as you get medical confirmation. Sickleave is also with 100% pay btw.

    In addition every parent has the right to stay home when their kid/babysitter is sick, I believe that is upto 20 days a year. This is also with 100% pay.

    A fun thing is also that if you get sick on your vacation days, you'll get replacement vacation days. This is only for the 5 weeks of required vacation, not the national holidays though.

  15. Telecommuting isn't an option for most people by sjbe · · Score: 5, Informative

    quite frankly Businesses should consider trying to get as many folks to work from home as possible.

    My business and the business of nearly $4 trillion of the US GDP is in manufacturing. You cannot manufacture most items from home. It is quite literally impossible. You need to be at your place of business to do most useful work in manufacturing. The same applies to retail, transportation, food service and health care industries among many others. You have to be there to be useful. Add in the fact that many, many workers are hourly employees and beyond a limited amount of sick/personal time they don't get paid if they aren't present.

    IT is an exception when it comes to telecommuting. Most jobs require having a body in the office/plant for a very good reason. I know there are a lot of IT workers here on slashdot but recognize that your situation is somewhat unique compared to most.

  16. PTO < Vacation + Sick leave by erice · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The problem in the US isn't just that vacation and sick leave are combined. The total is usually less. It is a slight of hand that management uses to reduce time off while making it look like they offer more. There is usually not enough time to get sick, handle unexpected situations, and fit in a actual vacation. That leaves two solutions

    1) Give up on the idea of a real vacation and accept that an extended weekend is the best you are going to get.
    2) Don't take sick days