Slashdot Mirror


Researcher Says the Hawaiian Islands Are Dissolving

SternisheFan writes with a snippet from Science Recorder: "Reporting in the journal Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, researchers at Brigham Young University say that the Hawaiian Islands are slowly dissolving. Eventually, Oahu's Koolau and Waianae mountains will dwindle to little more than a flat, low-lying island like Midway. While erosion is certainly a guilty party, researchers contend that the mountains of Oahu are, in fact, dissolving from within. Researchers spent several months collecting samples of groundwater and stream water to determine which source removed more mineral material. They also put to use surface water estimates from the U.S. Geological Survey to calculate the quantity of mass that vanished from the island each year. Researchers point out that Oahu is actually rising in elevation at a slow but steady rate due to plate tectonics. [BYU geologist Steve Nelson] and colleagues believe that Oahu will continue to grow for as long as 1.5 million years. Beyond that, the force of groundwater will eventually win and Oahu will begin its transformation to a flat, low-lying island like Midway." (If you have journal access, or don't mind forking over $40, you can read the original paper.)

37 of 55 comments (clear)

  1. Oh Shit by binarylarry · · Score: 4, Funny

    Larry Ellison isn't going to like this...

    --
    Mod me down, my New Earth Global Warmingist friends!
    1. Re:Oh Shit by radiumsoup · · Score: 1

      you mean Larry Ellison's robotically-stored consciousness isn't going to like this... (you know, the part of him that will survive the next 1.5 million years)

    2. Re:Oh Shit by davester666 · · Score: 5, Funny

      That's fine because he won't let it be stored in anything but an Oracle database, running an Oracle OS on Oracle hardware. It'll never be big enough to hold his entire ego, and it certainly won't last the decade...

      --
      Sleep your way to a whiter smile...date a dentist!
    3. Re:Oh Shit by roc97007 · · Score: 1

      Not to mention, too slow to be useful.

      --
      Oliver's law of assumed responsibility: If you're seen fixing it, you will be blamed for breaking it.
  2. Hmmmm by Dishwasha · · Score: 5, Funny

    colleagues believe that Oahu will continue to grow for as long as 1.5 million years.

    So what you're saying is, we've got some time?

    1. Re:Hmmmm by Nationless · · Score: 1

      Think of the children's [times 1500] children's children's children's children!

      And yes, I tried to copy paste 1500 "children's", but apparently slashdot has some sort of "spam" protection... Who knew!

    2. Re:Hmmmm by iggymanz · · Score: 1

      and just think of the timescale after that for the shrinking.we're talking of timescale of Midway's wearing down which is couple tens of millions of years. the human race could go back to being like apes or some other kind of unintelligent animal in a tenth that time....

    3. Re:Hmmmm by PolygamousRanchKid+ · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      So what you're saying is, we've got some time?

      It's never too early to start thinking about building a big glass dome over the island, before it goes Atlantis. These big construction projects always take longer and cost more than estimated. Just look at Boston's Big Dig. 1.5 million years is about the norm for big government projects.

      Hey, wait and see if Las Vegas can top that! An underwater resort!

      If this had happened on December 7th, 1941, this really would have confused the Japanese.

      "Flight leader here. I see the ships. But there ain't no island! Can I yell Tora! Tora! Tora! anyway . . . ?"

      --
      Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
    4. Re:Hmmmm by jd2112 · · Score: 1

      Think of the children's [times 1500] children's children's children's children!

      And yes, I tried to copy paste 1500 "children's", but apparently slashdot has some sort of "spam" protection... Who knew!

      Not spam, soylent green.

      --
      Any insufficiently advanced magic is indistinguishable from technology.
    5. Re:Hmmmm by LordLimecat · · Score: 1

      Thats not the real issue. Ive heard that in the next few years, Guam is likely to tip over and capsize!

    6. Re:Hmmmm by Austerity+Empowers · · Score: 1

      Yeah I don't think we'll need millions of years for that...

  3. TL;DR... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    TL;DR 1.5 million years form now, Oahu will stop growing. Then it will start to shrink.

    Be afraid! Be very afraid!

  4. Of course by jfdavis668 · · Score: 5, Informative

    This is how islands form and erode. This is some kind of surprise?

    1. Re:Of course by CapOblivious2010 · · Score: 1

      This is how islands form and erode. This is some kind of surprise?

      That's what I was thinking.

      "And in other news, the sky is expected to remain blue and scientists predict that water will remain wet for the foreseeable future"

    2. Re:Of course by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I figured that islands erode from the ocean waves beating on them, not from groundwater dissolving the rock inside of it.

    3. Re:Of course by houghi · · Score: 5, Informative

      While erosion is certainly a guilty party, researchers contend that the mountains of Oahu are, in fact, dissolving from within.

      Erosion is not the interesting part, From within is.

      --
      Don't fight for your country, if your country does not fight for you.
    4. Re:Of course by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 1

      What, like an underground network of rivers in a porous rock, also referred to as a cave?

    5. Re:Of course by Anne_Nonymous · · Score: 2, Funny

      >> the sky is expected to remain blue and scientists predict that water will remain wet

      Your misguided promotion of the radical scientific agenda won't fool Jesus.

    6. Re:Of course by peragrin · · Score: 1

      Or you know lava tubes formed when the volcanic island was formed.

      Also any one who has looked at the Hawaiian islands should note one fact the biggest islands are the most recently formed. The oldest islands are the smallest. The older they are the smaller they are.

      --
      i thought once I was found, but it was only a dream.
    7. Re:Of course by PlusFiveTroll · · Score: 4, Informative

      Seamount style landmasses do not tend to get built up, unlike continental land masses (which still erode way more then they gain from the sea, just more slowly). The steep sides tend to deeply deposit any eroded materials. Once the island is below sea level the most of the most active erosion ends and the island slowly sinks back in to the lithosphere until the time it is finally drug back in to the earth in a subduction zone.

      The Hawaiian islands do get a lot of rainfall in most places each year, the nature of its porus volcanic soils is especially dissolvable to fresh water.

    8. Re:Of course by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2

      Seamount style landmasses do not tend to get built up, unlike continental land masses (which still erode way more then they gain from the sea, just more slowly). The steep sides tend to deeply deposit any eroded materials. Once the island is below sea level the most of the most active erosion ends and the island slowly sinks back in to the lithosphere until the time it is finally drug back in to the earth in a subduction zone.

      The Hawaiian islands do get a lot of rainfall in most places each year, the nature of its porus volcanic soils is especially dissolvable to fresh water.

      The rainiest spot on earth is on Kauai. Hawa`i receives so much rain because of the mountain heights. The mountains force the moisture-laden air up where it can't keep all that water. This is what causes the leeward side. As an example, the North Shore of O`ahu is wet, but Honolulu side doesn't even receive a quarter of the rain. Once the mountains sink, nothing will force the air to give up the moisture as rain.

  5. Here's what I don't get by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    In the 70s, all people heard was "save the oceans!" and such. Now, we're making MORE ocean and people are still upset. We just can't win.

  6. But this is wrong. by bmo · · Score: 1

    >Beyond that, the force of groundwater will eventually win and Oahu will begin its transformation to a flat, low-lying island like Midway."

    What do you mean "begin?" Begun it has, already. /yoda.

    Oahu's eventual metamorphosis is to that of a seamount, like all the other seamounts that stretch along the ocean floor all the way to the Aleutians and Kamchatka.

    This is not news at all for Geologists, or anyone for that matter, who has seen a map of the ocean floor on Google Earth or the globe at the Boston Museum of Science in the 70s (yours truly).

    --
    BMO

    1. Re:But this is wrong. by runeghost · · Score: 1

      The "new" part of this news is HOW the erosion will happen - from subsurface groundwater instead of just surface erosion.

    2. Re:But this is wrong. by bmo · · Score: 2

      But we already know that subsurface groundwater causes erosion.

      We've known for a long time. We have national parks dedicated to pretty examples of this. Insurance companies hate extreme examples of this like karst topographies, especially when a house falls in a sinkhole.

      Somehow someone thought that this didn't apply to islands and needed a study to find this out? How do I get a grant to do a similar study in another tropical paradise to prove the obvious?

      --
      BMO

    3. Re:But this is wrong. by bmo · · Score: 2

      An interesting result would have been "strangely, groundwater doesn't cause erosion here" because groundwater causes erosion everywhere.

      Even here in New England, groundwater does a bang-up job of dissolving the iron out of granite and producing what is known as "rotten rock" and causing bathtub-rings of rust in ISDS test pits that make seasonal water table estimations easy. Water also dissolves out feldspars giving the classic pitting of granite rocks.

      This wasn't interesting in the least. "Yup, groundwater is causing erosion here too." Wow.

      Show me where water doesn't cause erosion. THAT would be pretty cool.

      --
      BMO

    4. Re:But this is wrong. by chmod+a+x+mojo · · Score: 1

      Don't forget all the sulfides from granitic plutons as well. Thats why untreated well water tastes like.... well water. Sulfides, irons, and arsenic's all (mostly) from the Pyrites from Felsic rocks being leeched by groundwater.

      --
      To err is human; effective mayhem requires the root password!
  7. birthers by brainstem · · Score: 1

    Man, those birthers will do just about anything to show Obama wasn't born in the US. Did someone catch Donald Trump tossing shovels of sand into the ocean on the backside of the island?

  8. Midway by cvnautilus · · Score: 1

    Why does the summary keep referencing the flatness of Midway? I don't think many people are familiar with Pacific island topography.

    1. Re:Midway by PPH · · Score: 1

      Looks pretty flat to me.

      --
      Have gnu, will travel.
  9. Could someone tell me by skitchen8 · · Score: 1

    what kind of island Midway is? Its mountainous right?

    1. Re:Could someone tell me by reboot246 · · Score: 2

      It's an atoll. It's barely above water.

  10. This just in... by roc97007 · · Score: 1

    Everything will be gone, given enough time.

    --
    Oliver's law of assumed responsibility: If you're seen fixing it, you will be blamed for breaking it.
  11. $40 ripfoff by CuteSteveJobs · · Score: 1

    > (If you have journal access, or don't mind forking over $40, you can read the original paper.)

    You might ask why the journal is charging $40. Usually the journals - run by companies - have nothing to do with writing the original paper, contributing only academic review (possibly by unpaid volunteers) and publishing. They won't print the article unless the author signs a copyright transfer agreement which means they no longer own the copyright, and can't even put the paper on their own website. It's a ripoff, but academic institutions made the mistake of crediting publications by their employees which count towards promotions. The academic publishers in turn charge institutions extortionate rates - many thousands of dollars - to see papers by other academics they didn't pay a cent for. These people are the academic version of the RIAA: Redundant Middle-men ripping off both sides. There are papers written as far back as the 1960s which academic publishing companies still hold copyright over, standing in the way of ongoing research.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_transfer_agreement
    "Princeton goes open access to stop staff handing all copyright to journals - unless waiver granted " - http://theconversation.edu.au/princeton-goes-open-access-to-stop-staff-handing-all-copyright-to-journals-unless-waiver-granted-3596
    "One of disadvantages of this publishing model, is that the published research is only available to those researchers who have a subscription to the journal or can afford to buy the book. Often subscription and book costs are prohibitively expensive. Many libraries, particularly smaller ones, cannot afford these subscriptions." - http://www.unimelb.edu.au/copyright/information/new/research/publishing.html

  12. yawn by pbjones · · Score: 1

    the time frame puts this out beyond my care factor. Don't worry, rising sea levels will flood the Island first.

    --
    There was an unknown error in the submission.
  13. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  14. Not surprising by Codifex+Maximus · · Score: 1

    "Eventually, Oahu's Koolau and Waianae mountains will dwindle to little more than a flat, low-lying island like Midway."
    Considering how Midway is the remnant of an island created by the same volcanic hotspot that created the Hawaiian island chain, that's not surprising.

    --
    Codifex Maximus ~ In search of... a shorter sig.