Slashdot Mirror


NSA Targeting Domestic Computer Systems

The NSA was originally supposed to handle foreign intelligence, and leave the domestic spying to other agencies, but Presto Vivace writes with this bit from CNET: "'The National Security Agency's Perfect Citizen program hunts for vulnerabilities in 'large-scale' utilities, including power grid and gas pipeline controllers, new documents from EPIC show.' 'Perfect Citizen?' Who thinks up these names?" "The program is scheduled to continue through at least September 2014," says the article.

36 of 105 comments (clear)

  1. Imperfect citizens by davidwr · · Score: 4, Insightful

    'Perfect Citizen?' Who thinks up these names?"

    Answer in subject line.

    --
    Knowledge is how to play a game, intelligence is how to win, wisdom is knowing what game to play.
    1. Re:Imperfect citizens by slick7 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      'Perfect Citizen?' Who thinks up these names?"

      Answer in subject line.

      Hitler had his youth organization that turned in their parents.
      We have GTA IV, HALO, Gears of War, etc. De-sensitizing children to violence leads to cold-blooded adults. War does the same thing, but it's more expensive and messier; and it is "these" people that will become the storm-trooping, hob-nail booted thugs to keep the peace. Peace through violence. Serving their masters, which you undoubtedly are not.
      There will come a time where there will be only two choices to pick from; prisoner or prison food.

      --
      The mind conceives, the body achieves, the spirit manifests.
    2. Re:Imperfect citizens by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I believe that "Perfect Citizen" is the English version of the Russian "novy sovetsky chelovek".

      --
      Ezekiel 23:20
    3. Re:Imperfect citizens by NoNonAlphaCharsHere · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The same kind of people who dreamed up "Operation Enduring Freedom". At least they got the "Enduring" part right.

    4. Re:Imperfect citizens by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      no, the differences be tween seeing it death on a 72' screen and watching the man/woman in front of you pulled off to the showers/killing room are so far different in reality. Now if you ask those same children or adults stop this stuff before it happens, why no they just like watching their movies with violence and killing on the tv to be concerened about the brown people being taking to the camps.

    5. Re:Imperfect citizens by Runaway1956 · · Score: 5, Informative

      I can't speak for AC, but a lot of things in life are different than a video portrayal. Automobile accidents, for instance. I don't watch television much at all, but the most catastrophic accident on television is - just a little messy. Being a first responder even at a relatively minor accident can be unsettling. I've tossed my lunch at major accidents, and had a hard time falling asleep that night. Few people can appreciate an injury as simple as a broken leg, until they put their hands on that broken leg, and can feel how the bone grinds away, cutting muscle and other tissue as it does so.

      Naturally, I've never lived through what AC posted. No concentration camps for me, but I can sort of imagine the difference from what we've seen in movies and television. Very different, indeed.

      --
      "Windows is like the faint smell of piss in a subway: it's there, and there's nothing you can do about it." - Charlie Br
    6. Re:Imperfect citizens by ubrgeek · · Score: 2

      Was thinking the same thing. Unless the PDF specifically calls out the National Security Agency actively targeting and attempting to compromise domestic SCADA systems, the posting reads like something Drudge would write about Obama (countdown to Drudge flame war in 3 ... 2 ...)

      --
      Bark less. Wag more.
    7. Re:Imperfect citizens by GumphMaster · · Score: 5, Funny

      +1 for the sig... best chuckle I've had all morning :)

      --
      Patent litigation: A doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction... in which everyone seems willing to push the button
    8. Re:Imperfect citizens by Beardo+the+Bearded · · Score: 2

      Well Mr. Godwin, you could also say that games like GTA IV, HALO, Gears of War, etc show us the difference that one person can make.

      --

      ---
      ECHELON is a government program to find words like bomb, jihad, plutonium, assassinate, and anarchy.
    9. Re:Imperfect citizens by Zontar+The+Mindless · · Score: 2

      I had similar experiences as a reporter in the 90s, getting called out numerous times at 2 or 3 AM to cover various fires and accidents.

      I was exposed to enough blood and guts and other misery during that time that I learned to appreciate just what difficult and unpleasant jobs first responders and fire/rescue people have, and I have to admit that I don't think I could handle it for very long myself. My compliments to you and your colleagues, Runaway.

      --
      Il n'y a pas de Planet B.
    10. Re:Imperfect citizens by davydagger · · Score: 2

      no, we have the TIPS programs, and the sort of paranoia and fear that happens after every media frenzied tragedy

      Do your friends/family look mentally ill derranged?

      Do your neighbors looks like terrorists?

      And urges you to report them.

      Even when you are doing now, is more of the same. Do you know someone who plays violent video games? report them to authorities.

      Fact: Before violent video games, there where violent movies, before than, violent books(in english going all the way back to gilgamesh, the first known english book).

      Fact: Before kids played violent video games, they played violent games outside, like "War", "Cowboys and Indians"(horribly politically incorrect too)", "Cops and Robbers", etc....

      don't blame this on video games. Stop doing the type of disinformation you mention.

    11. Re:Imperfect citizens by tendrousbeastie · · Score: 2

      Gilgamesh is not an English book.

  2. The prisoner by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I am not a number i am a free man.....
    we want ...infor-matin infromation

  3. Multiple missions, people seem to forget that. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    People seem to forget that Intelligence gathering is only part of NSA's mission.
    They are also tasked with ensuring the security of the nations computers, cryptosystems and more recently critical infrastructure. But people will believe what they want to believe, so any more when people ask me if stuff in Enemy of the State is accurate I tell them 100%. They're not likely to believe that no, it could actually take weeks-months to get reliable intel data and it's usually generated by some analyst that's 17-25 years old sitting in some windowless building with a crappy computer.

    1. Re:Multiple missions, people seem to forget that. by Jetra · · Score: 2

      Because it's not like we have a hundred other agencies already watching over us to make sure we're not doing anything illegal. (Cough, HackNSA FBI CIA TSA CTU cough hack)

    2. Re:Multiple missions, people seem to forget that. by budgenator · · Score: 4, Insightful

      i seriously doubt it would take hours to get intel on joe blow,with all of the technology and power of the government they would know you from seed to coffin in an hour or less.

      They can assemble a lot of raw data pretty quickly, but so can anybody; for example I applied for credit at Dell they ask which street I had lived on, one was arround the corner from where I presently lived, two were out of the blue, and the correct answer was where I had lived 40 years ago when I was 10 years old! What we have to remember is raw data isn't information, it's a lot easier to take a person of interest and assemble a dossier from available data, than it is to take the raw data and deducing who the person of interest is. Even with the incredable resources the law enforcement and intelligence agencies have, most cases are broken through serendipity.

      --
      Apocalypse Cancelled, Sorry, No Ticket Refunds
    3. Re:Multiple missions, people seem to forget that. by um...+Lucas · · Score: 2

      Critical in that backup generators only last so long, besides which there would be quite a bit of chaos if our power grid went down unexpectedly and for a long period. Best just to head that off.

      I'd really be fine with this if it wasn't a spying agency doing this. ; but I guess all the know how is in the nsa's headquarters, so we can't just have a
      Domestic computer security agency doing this, one with no ties to the intelligence community...

  4. somebody has to make these plans by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    And who better than somebody who knows how the other side thinks?

  5. So ? by eric_herm · · Score: 2, Insightful

    So the NSA is looking at the vulnerabilities over stuff deployed in USA ? What is the problem ? They also have a mission of protecting and giving advice for the national security ( heck, national security agency, do people fail at english comprehension test ? ).

    NSA publish guides on how to secure linux or windows, do explain what the federal agency should do to be secured, so that seems logical to do the same for lots of things not "computer" related, if that can be used to disrupt the country. That's not different from checking a router for problem, or checking a phone if officials use them.

    That's truly a fucking non news.

    1. Re:So ? by reboot246 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Exactly. Speaking as someone in the utilities business, I welcome the NSA and the work they're doing. It's scary how vulnerable the nation's utility systems are.

    2. Re:So ? by alcourt · · Score: 2

      Scary implies I'm not numbed to the state of affairs by years of apathy by management.

      --
      "I may disagree with what you say, but I will defend unto the death your right to say it." -- Voltaire
    3. Re:So ? by alcourt · · Score: 2

      Two other examples I can think of include SELinux and the hardening of what became DES against differential cryptanalysis, twenty years before the attack was widely known.

      --
      "I may disagree with what you say, but I will defend unto the death your right to say it." -- Voltaire
  6. Some perspective by HangingChad · · Score: 4, Insightful

    >hunts for vulnerabilities in 'large-scale' utilities

    It's not like they're spying wholesale on American citizens...wait, they're already doing that, too.

    I think the whole foreign/domestic spy division is pretty much gone at this point. Not saying it's right, just the reality.

    --
    That's our life, the big wheel of shit. - The Fat Man, Blue Tango Salvage
    1. Re:Some perspective by Threni · · Score: 2

      Exactly. I'm sure TOR is effectively broken, at least in the US, as I'm assuming the NSA has access to every single exit node. I'm sure there's either official or unofficial access to all traffic at ISP level. It's just an extension of Project Shamrock. The NSA has the money to build and make the kit and do the maths to crack a lot of encryption but it was probably decided at some point in the last 20 or 30 years that they couldn't continue to assume that domestic or foreign traffic could always be defeated technically and that other means would be required.

    2. Re:Some perspective by budgenator · · Score: 2

      Our 3 letter agencies don't spy on Americans, they spy on the Austrailians, the Austrailians spy on the British, then the British spy on the Americans. When anybody discovers anything interesting, an anonomous file is sent through back channels to the respective government.

      --
      Apocalypse Cancelled, Sorry, No Ticket Refunds
  7. Q&A by girlintraining · · Score: 2

    'Perfect Citizen?' Who thinks up these names?"

    People who are so deluded they think destroying our way of life is the same as saving it.

    --
    #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    1. Re:Q&A by spire3661 · · Score: 4, Funny

      "By your actions, sir, you are risking the future of the human race!" "To guarantee the American way of life... I'm willing to take that risk." ~Spies Like Us

      --
      Good-bye
  8. Dual responsibility by PPH · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The NSA is tasked with collecting intelligence from foreign sources as well as securing US government information systems from attack. As the private entities listed are components of our nation's critical infrastructure, keeping them secure is probably a good idea. I wouldn't wait for Siemens and its ilk to step up to this task.

    Its probably not a perfect separation of government, private industry, domestic and foreign intelligence tasks. But since the NSA has the expertise, I say let them help out. Its not like operating utilities and other infrastructure companies isn't already subject to extra regulation and oversight. Its just a shame the SEC/CFTC doesn't keep as close an eye on our banks.

    --
    Have gnu, will travel.
  9. Re:NSA is domestic, you idiots. by schwit1 · · Score: 2

    Up to 9/11 the FBI was the domestic counterpart to the CIA. After 9/11 all lines got blurred.

  10. Re:NSA is domestic, you idiots. by Trepidity · · Score: 4, Informative

    That's not what its charter says, which restricts it to "foreign intelligence or counterintelligence" and prohibits the NSA "acquiring information concerning the domestic activities of United States persons".

  11. Re:NSA is domestic, you idiots. by elucido · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Up to 9/11 the FBI was the domestic counterpart to the CIA. After 9/11 all lines got blurred.

    The FBI never had the power of the CIA. The CIA can do clandestine ops while the FBI does not have the authority to do clandestine ops without the specific and expressed permission granted by the President. This is a major difference.

    Domestic clandestine operations are operations which can be said to not exist at all. The CIA for example could run a clandestine CIA operation which does something clearly illegal such as hack a bunch of websites and then claim the terrorists did it. I'm not saying this sort of false flag is something the CIA would do, usually the FBI would do something like that but it's a possible example of a clandestine operation. The civilian government would believe criminals or cyber-terrorists did it.

  12. Re:NSA is domestic, you idiots. by EmagGeek · · Score: 2

    Hah, but this is the US Government. Since when does "what the charter actually says" have anything to do with what the TLA actually does?

  13. s/scary/stupid/ by SpaceLifeForm · · Score: 2

    There is ZERO reason for SCADA systems to be connected to the Internet.

    --
    You are being MICROattacked, from various angles, in a SOFT manner.
    1. Re:s/scary/stupid/ by gtall · · Score: 2

      Nope. There's an economic reason, i.e., otherwise you must built out a network by yourself, and the fellow over there must as well, and that next guy. SCADA systems are connected to the internet because it is cost effective to do so. Terrorism could change the economics, but it would have to be very effective terrorism.

      Now you could argue that SCADA should be constructed in such a way that the control part is kept separate from the data distribution part. And you would be correct, yet economics bites you in the ass again. It is cheaper to combine them.

      This might be a place for government regulation. Essentially, it is used to shift the market in a way that is contrary to economics. That might work, but there is still the underlying driver, economics, that will always work against that.

  14. No surprise really by dbIII · · Score: 3, Insightful

    With the homeland security monolith growing into a huge machine that consumes cash and excretes bullshit and the FBI and CIA so dysfunctional and jealous that the FBI managed to depose the head of the CIA on "moral" grounds it actually makes sense to pass things over to a bunch that look like they actually work for a living, no matter what their current responsibilities are.

  15. Now how long until the NSA hooks up w/ the IRS by sethstorm · · Score: 2

    That is, using the lists generated by people that denounce their US citizenship sorted by income by their last two years of citizenship?

    In addition, I'm quite sure that the NSA can always trade with other friendly countries for what its charter does not allow them to have.

    --
    Twitter supports and protects racists - by smearing their critics with the "Hate Speech" label.