Slashdot Mirror
How To Bet Money On Your Future Success
waderoush writes "Say you're in your early 20s, you're finishing college or graduate school, and you're smart but poor — and you've got some big student loans hanging over you. You're pretty sure that within 10 years you'll be selling your first startup or earning a high-six-figure salary. But you need some money *now* so that you can actually start the company, and avoid taking a corporate job. Shouldn't there be a way to calculate how much you'll be worth, and borrow against that promise of future success? Upstart, a new Palo Alto investing operation founded by a group of ex-Google employees, thinks the answer is yes. In a new spin on the crowdfunding model, the organization gathers data from recent graduates such as schools attended, academic transcripts, job offers, and credit scores. Its 'pricing engine,' based partly on techniques developed to assess job applicants at Google, determines how much each aspiring 'upstart' should be allowed to raise from investors per each percentage point of their future income. Upstart has already helped 35 young people raise amounts varying from $10,000 to $170,000; the upstarts, who must pay the money back over a 10-year period, say they're using the funds mainly to retire student debt or bootstrap startups. 'We can look at a 25-year-old and very quickly assess whether he or she would be successful at Google,' says Upstart founder Dave Girouard, formerly the head of Googles $1 billion enterprise apps division. 'My whole thesis was, if you could use the same algorithms to predict whether he or she would be successful beyond that, in the business world, that would be pretty useful.'"
The position this person is in is that they are mortgaged to the hilt, have no income and are too young to know what life is about and they want to borrow even more?
Why not just sell yourself into slavery?
If someone is so confident in their startup idea, why not try to get actual investors instead of an "investment" you have to pay back?
This is just the next step up from student loans.
Must be getting a lot dumber. I'm willing to bet an insane amount of money relative to my income that the credit cards companies are FAR FAR better at predicting who to loan money too than any Googler. They have the advantage of having Googler level employees, years of experience, and financial greed driving them.
You can not predict what they will be worth in 10 years, they don't have any idea what they'll even like NEXT YEAR, let alone 10 years.
Once you get a little older you realize that the person you were when you got out of school is entirely different than the person you are 10 years later. Its well accepted fact that no one under 25 knows who they are, and no one under 30 is really sure who they are.
Persistent Volume manager for Kubernetes - https://github.com/dwimsey/openshift-pvmanager
I'm faced with a dilemma here: I'm an algorithmist, and believe most questions can be more accurately be answered, in the long run at least, by a well developed algorithm than even the most skilled human being. This should be a good thing, then, finding a better answer for funding projects, and accurately determining loans.
Where I became concerned, is that a lot of success is then predicated on some system determining that you'd be successful, and might therefor create a systemic problem sorting the undeserving into future success, by virtue of predicting it, and leaving those who have the spirit to succeed, but not the resources, to languish without recourse. It seems it could make the rich richer, and the poor poorer, even more than our current system, which already does so.
I feel this approach fails to account for its own effect upon the market. A world where you get divided into upper class and lower class on factors beyond your own control should scare just about anyone.
student loan interest is TAX DEDUCTIBLE
these crazy loans are not
the US has the lowest interest rates in a generation. smart thing to do is to consolidate your loans and lock in the low rates.
Someone at Google thinks that a) they have figured out a way to predict future success and b) this is the best way they can take advantage of that knowledge? Just... wow.
Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
See "The Unincorporated Man" by Dani Kollin and Eytan Kollin for a full explanation of this idea, and some ramifications. A bit hyperbolic (I think the authors have a bit of a libertarian streak) but a decent read.
You're pretty sure that within 10 years you'll be selling your first startup or earning a high -six-figure salary.
Ya, many may be "pretty sure" of all that, but most are not that smart, inventive, resourceful, connected, and/or lucky.
It must have been something you assimilated. . . .
Almost impossible to prove. Unless you posted your plan on /.
John McAfee 'It was like that time I hired that Bangkok prostitute; to do my taxes, while I fucked my accountant'
That was my thought. Take out student loans, go to school, get one of these loans after you get out, use it to pay off your school loans, default on this new loan, wait for it to come off your credit record in 7 years. Far better than having that school loan that stays on your record forever otherwise.
Persistent Volume manager for Kubernetes - https://github.com/dwimsey/openshift-pvmanager
I was sure I'd be rich by the age of thirty, and several other people thought I would too. I'm a government code monkey at the age of 37. Thank God I didn't saddle myself with a 7% debt.
...
Okay, so I did sell a business or two, but once the IRS was done with that