Ask Slashdot: Why Buy a Raspberry Pi When I Have a Perfectly Good Cellphone?
scorp1us writes "I've been looking into getting a Raspberry Pi, but I end up needing a case, a display, and some way to power it, and wanting some degree of portability. It seems to me that even the most outdated cellphone has far superior features (screen, touch screen, Wifi, 3g/4g camera(s), battery etc) in a much better form factor. The only thing that is missing are the digital/analog in/out pins. So why not flip it around and make a USB or bluetooth peripheral board with just the pins? I've been looking for this and can't find any, but does anyone know of any in the corners of the internet? I don't care what phone platform."
Done in one (pun intended)
Solid, lots of add-on modules, vibrant hacker community. And it has its own programmable processor so if your application permits you don't even have to have it attached to your PC to collect and process data.
How about this? - http://www.adafruit.com/products/885 - IOIO Mint - Portable Android Development Kit
If your use-case is "leave attached to my TV" then a Pi makes a lot of sense. If you want to have a resilient case, be portable, have a small screen attached, etc, then maybe a phone makes more sense.
I'd have had trouble doing this with a cellphone:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m_c9cxoM8tg
Part of the usefulness of the Pi is *because* it lacks those things; you have the option of adding what suits your application.
An Arduino will get you pretty close to a box with pins attached to a USB cable, though the USB cable is emulating a serial port.
A Raspberry Pi is like an original iPhone with the screen removed a few ports added and all the Arduino GPIO features built onboard so you get GPIO support built in.
Persistent Volume manager for Kubernetes - https://github.com/dwimsey/openshift-pvmanager
Oh shit, the hosts files have become self-aware and started hacking accounts.
Captcha: vibrator
"I've been looking into getting a Raspberry Pi, but I end up needing a case, a display, and some way to power it, and wanting some degree of portability. It seems to me that even the most outdated cellphone has far superior features (screen, touch screen, Wifi, 3g/4g camera(s), battery etc) in a much better form factor. The only thing that is missing are the digital/analog in/out pins. So why not flip it around and make a USB or bluetooth peripheral board with just the pins? I've been looking for this and can't find any, but does anyone know of any in the corners of the internet? I don't care what phone platform."
I think this might be adaptable. Although its original intent was as an XBee interface, the catalog explicitly states it can be used for USB-to-TTL. Presumably by tapping the points where the ZBee's GPIO pins break out:
http://www.jameco.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product_10001_10001_2159285_-1
I'm not sure why the comparison with a cellphone. Currently I'm using it as XBMC and using my Android phone as the remote. It was a toss up between the Pi and the ultra cheap AndroidTV dongles that are kicking around (Why I think AppleTV is dead on arrival), and overall I couldn't be happier stupid setup errors aside [power supply too weak on the pi to power the usb; couldn't get wifi working on the minimal distribution?] Otherwise its incredible, and using the phone as a remote control has changes my life.
There are a few compromises with the pi [512 memory & missing sata] otherwise I'm overjoyed with the source. Killer feature, you mess up you wipe your card and your good to go.
The bottom line is your old phone is less versatile with less support, but its great at being a phone...which if its the task you want go ahead. Otherwise its such an incredible strange question.
It regularly manages to crash the USB stack if you put load on the USB stack, so considering that the LAN on the RaspberryPi B is connected to said USB...
You should look at the other ARM boards out there e.g. pcDuino. More memory, more I/O, onboard flash, Linux or Android.
However there are some things that you can do with a micro-controller that can not be done with a full OS - e.g. bit-banging I/O to one-wire temperature sensors. I've even used a full USB 1.1. HID driver implemented completely in software, which would be impossible with an full OS running!
plus your phone already has a screen, storage, battery and reliable wifi.
That's fine if one's phone is a smartphone running Android. A lot of people especially in the Americas and western Europe carry an iPhone, for which development of accessory hardware is far more expensive. And a lot of other people carry a dumbphone and a separate other device because too many U.S. wireless carriers appear to refuse to activate a voice-only plan on a smartphone: CDMA2000 carriers don't use a CSIM in that country, and some GSM carriers are known to forcibly change the user's plan if the SIM is used with a "smartphone" IMEI.
Because one of them doesn't actually cost 35 bucks to produce.
Actually, if you select the 'outdated' hardware correctly, you can do all of that with a used cell phone. Several have HDMI out through an adapter for the USB interface, and some of the latest have wireless video capabilities as well. xbmc has been ported to the Android platform.
Now that's not to say that it's the best solution in anyone's book, but my experience with Raspberry Pi is that it makes a mediocre xbmc interface as a front end to something like MythTv. It is capable, just as a 3/4 ton pickup is capable of hauling more than 5 tons if it's done right, but in my experience it's not really the right tool for the job. The real power of the Raspberry Pi comes in figuring out what you can do with it that no-one else has done. At some point people have made their own dropbox alternative with the platform, which tells me that the system would work well enough as a plug server as well. household environmental management seems like a reasonably trivial thing to work out, though you'll have to create your own vent management system to be able to control air flow for thermal regulation in some cases. I can see someone developing their own home surveying system using poles, hoses and water level sensors, then capturing the property topography and feeding it into their own CAD software to figure out how they want to do building projects, how much earth will have to be moved, where it might go, etc. Then hand off the same Raspberry Pi to their daughter who builds a scanner using nothing more than an led and photo-resistor, and a couple of stepper motors to move the sensor they built. Or use a few rotary encoders and a button to build their own 3d scanner.
Note, I'm not saying that using a Raspberry Pi as an xbmc set top box is a bad idea, just that there are a lot of things that you can do if you get out of the mindset that it's an entertainment device and recognize that it is so much more.
You never know...
Read the question, please.
The only thing that is missing are the digital/analog in/out pins. So why not flip it around and make a USB or bluetooth peripheral board with just the pins?
What "context" are you talking about? There's absolutely no mention of Android in TFS, and in fact he says, "I don't care what phone platform."
The context comes from knowing that he's talking about a programmable phone platform that has a touch screen, camera, etc - customizable enough to allow a driver for a USB I/O board to be loaded. There aren't many phone platforms that meet those criteria, and an feature phone is not one of them.
Only a nitpicking pedant would say "Hey, wait a second, he said "Cell Phones", but the Nokia 1100 has no camera, a monochrome non-touch screen display, and no known SDK to allow custom apps to be developed for it, so that proves that any old cell phone is not what he's looking for, so obviously he doesn't know what he's talking about!"
A lot of people especially in the Americas and western Europe carry an iPhone, for which development of accessory hardware is far more expensive.
Only if you plan to sell it. If it's for personal development, just jailbreak the phone and connect to the serial port pins of the dock connector as per this SO post.
Obviously anyone looking to build custom hardware can handle the simple task required to hook up to it.
Optionally of course, you can do anything you like with Bluetooth LE without any licensing from Apple - and commercial apps are allowed to do BTLE communications in the background because of the low power consumption. That's what I would start with as an approach unless you need more bandwidth for some reason.
"There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
If you can't figure out that the asker has already figured that out that they're not the Pi's target market, and isn't questioning the Pi's utility for its target market, you're not insightful.
You're a fanboy. Go play with your Pi.
1. price- no cell phone is that cheap
2. better documented hardware with FOSS drivers.(NO cellphone has FOSS drivers, or firmware). In fact its hard if not impossible getting firmware extracted, or proprietary binary drivers for a general purpose OS for your cell phone.
Its not like desktop OSs, where you can just download the latest nvidia or ATI drivers for linux from the vendor
3. Cell phones are made for android which is NOT a General Purpose OS, and can be restrictive.
4. Rasberri PI by default boots from an SD card, making running whatever OS you want, without hacking easy. There is also no need to root it.
5. the Rasberri PI also has hostmode USB ports, for plugging devices in, your phone most likely does not, if your lucky OTG.
6. There are other ARM protoboards and dev boards that are not the PI which have ARM class CPUs. Most of them run any OS you put on them. RasPI is not the first nor will be the last.
Sell it and buy something they can use as they see fit? I hear Apple fans gibber on constantly about the resale value of their devices, so you should be able to get a good price I suppose.
Oh sure, but the RPi draws about 2W idle, less than 5W if it is really working overtime. Plus it's fanless and silent. It makes a nice little headless server for lots of things. And even used, cheap laptops aren't often under $50...
Monthly contract, suckiest gift ever.
Why Buy a Raspberry Pi When I Have a Perfectly Good Cellphone?
Because you can install your own operating system on your Raspberry Pi, but not on your cellphone?
Because you want to support the Raspberry Pi foundation?
There are many possible answers.
It seems to me that even the most outdated cellphone has far superior features (screen, touch screen, Wifi, 3g/4g camera(s), battery etc) in a much better form factor.
If the combination of those is what you're looking for, then maybe you want a cellphone. Why are you comparing a cellphone against a Raspberry Pi?
The only thing that is missing are the digital/analog in/out pins. So why not flip it around and make a USB or bluetooth peripheral board with just the pins? I've been looking for this and can't find any, but does anyone know of any in the corners of the internet? I don't care what phone platform.
What are you going to do with it? How are you planning to do it? You don't care what phone platform? Don't you at least want one that you can run your own code on? Preferably with enough privileges that you can actually drive your shiny peripheral?
Here's the thing: Tell us what you're trying to do, and maybe we can help you, possibly by giving some recommendations for hardware to work with.
As it stands, your question is more flamebait than helpful. You're stating that you think even outdated cellphones are superior to a devices that some of us really like, without stating what purpose you think cellphones are superior for. That gives us little opportunity to be helpful, and plenty of opportunity to feel slighted.
Please correct me if I got my facts wrong.
Does anybody know of any widely-available Android phone that directly exposes 2 or more GPIO pins via some usable-connection point, like the headphone jack or Samsung USB port pins (via some officially-nondocumented WDC USB crossbar-chip setting or resistor value)?
I know some phones expose a UART (with nonstandard levels) on the headphone jack (Original G1) and repurposed usb pins (original Galaxy S?), but I've never come across a real reverse-engineered schematic for the HTC HeroC, Samsung Galaxy S/Epic4g, Motorola Photon (as if it would matter, since the evil bastards permalocked the bootloader & ruined it), or Krait/US-variety Galaxy S3 that shows what's sitting between the headphone jack & SoC and what the jack is physically wired to inside.
The big prize: if the 3 headphone jack pins (plus gnd) are connected to real gpio pins (normally tristated, or even directly-driving/sampling the headset)... THEN bitbanged SPI becomes possible. A real UART is a distant second consolation prize, moving up a notch if it can do Atmel-like 1mbps and/or 9-bit serial. I2C would be cool, but I won't hold my breath. DMA-able ADC (== mic) and DAC (== audio out) would be nice IF they aren't forcibly intercepted by a codec chip that can ONLY do mp3 &| audio-bitrate P[W|C]M.
As others have noted, IOIO is great, but USB limits you in some serious ways if you're trying to do raw realtime bitbanging. The main problem with USB is that it basically forces you to move your realtime logic to dedicated hardware at the other end of a USB cable (like ioio, or an AVR-based ADP. A Raspberry Pi gives you directly-bitbangable gpio. AFAIK, no Android phone does.
The Pi's problem isn't that it wasn't invented in America. The Pi's problem is that the only way to get one in America is from a distributor who imported it from Britain (paying import duties to the US) from a distributor who imported it into Britain from China (paying more import duties, and probably VAT, to the EU and Britain), ultimately shipping it halfway around the world, then halfway back... turning it into a $29 board with ~$60 worth of shipping charges & taxes.
If Rasberry would just get a fscking local in Shenzhen to sell them on eBay & ship directly to the US from China, they'd cost ~$35 here instead (China-US shipping is practically free, and the US Customs agents responsible for scrutinizing packages from China alleged to be "samples" worth "$10" seems to have permanently gone to lunch).
If you can't be bothered to read the summary carefully enough to see that you're putting words into his mouth and that was NOT the question he asked... you are Slashdot's target demographic. (Judging by the fact that at least 4 mods so far agree with you.) Um, stay right where you are, I guess, and keep stabbing that 'reply' button.
In case anyone wants to break with tradition and not reward factually incorrect posts, the OP said/asked... "It seems to me that even the most outdated cellphone has far superior features... in a much better form factor. The only thing that is missing are the digital/analog in/out pins. So why not flip it around and make a USB or bluetooth peripheral board with just the pins?" See? SEE? He wants to hack... just a like a proper Pi owner!
Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
And this, dear friends, is why geeks are often considered to be antisocial.
Are you saying someone gave you an iPhone and locked you into a contract? What a thoughtful gift! Here, I'll buy you this thing that you will have to pay for yourself for next two or three years, I hope you enjoy it!
I don't know what the ETFs are these days, but I'm sure sale of a new iPhone will cover it -- used iPhone 4s 16GB still fetches almost $400 on ebay.
You're on your own to get a phone that better suits your needs after that, though.
Never underestimate the bandwidth of a 747 filled with CD-ROMs.
People often fail to understand why the Arduino is so fucking popular. It is NOT because it has the most powerful processor. It is NOT because it has the most pins. It is NOT because it is the easiest to develop for. It is NOT because it is the most standardized.
This.
Just yesterday I had an 'argument' with a guy over how Arduino is dead because such-and-such a chip is way more powerful than AVR (AVR=the chips in Arduinos), how it has hundreds of MegaHertz and Megabytes and all that stuff.
I simply don't care! I don't need a board that has 512Mb of RAM and runs Linux just to light up a few LEDs (even with a motion sensor!). I need something that works well enough, can drive a LED directly from an I/O pin (5V outputs, tada!) and has a huge online community with thousands of web pages/blogs/forums to browse, plus source code to download.
PS: Can you build your own dime-sized clone of that fancy ARM board for $1.50? I can do it with Arduino... (ATtiny85)
No sig today...
Not everybody who uses an iPhone chose an iPhone. What should somebody who received an iPhone as a gift do?
Sell it on eBay?
No sig today...
Shouldn't the precious snowflake just be fucking grateful their doting parents have given them an over-priced unnecessasry toy?
To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it