Slashdot Mirror


San Francisco Fiber Optic Cable Cutter Strikes Again

HughPickens.com writes: USA Today reports that the FBI is investigating at least 11 physical attacks on high-capacity Internet cables in California's San Francisco Bay Area dating back to at least July 6, 2014, including one early this week. "When it affects multiple companies and cities, it does become disturbing," says Special Agent Greg Wuthrich. "We definitely need the public's assistance." The pattern of attacks raises serious questions about the glaring vulnerability of critical Internet infrastructure, says JJ Thompson. "When it's situations that are scattered all in one geography, that raises the possibility that they are testing out capabilities, response times and impact," says Thompson. "That is a security person's nightmare."

Mark Peterson, a spokesman for Internet provider Wave Broadband, says an unspecified number of Sacramento-area customers were knocked offline by the latest attack. Peterson characterized the Tuesday attack as "coordinated" and said the company was working with Level 3 and Zayo to restore service. It's possible the vandals were dressed as telecommunications workers to avoid arousing suspicion, say FBI officials. Backup systems help cushion consumers from the worst of the attacks, meaning people may notice slower email or videos not playing, but may not have service completely disrupted. But repairs are costly and penalties are not stiff enough to deter would-be vandals. "There are flags and signs indicating to somebody who wants to do damage: This is where it is folks," says Richard Doherty. "It's a terrible social crime that affects thousands and millions of people."

17 of 198 comments (clear)

  1. Routing around by mwvdlee · · Score: 4, Insightful

    At a large scale, the internet was designed to route around individual problems such as this.
    Can't this same principle be applied on a smaller scale?

    --
    Slashdot social media options: AIM, ICQ, Yahoo, Jabber and Mobile Text. Why no MySpace?
    1. Re:Routing around by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I'm not sure you understand the scale of the fiber being cut.

    2. Re: Routing around by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

      There should be both logical redundancy (take a different path) and physical redundancy (diversified paths on any one logical link). I've done backbone work for these and other major players.

      Of course, while much is, plenty isnt. Or you'll have documented A/B paths that shouldnt ever share a single point of failure but in reality run side-by-side for miles in places.

      And thanks to that, most never notice the dozens of fiber cuts/maint. activities that can occur on any large network every night.

      I always suspect an inside job on things like this. Sure, sometimes its a crackhead hunting for copper. But too many of these occur a just the perfect point of failure.. or people know which two runs to hit simultaneously.... and there are a lot of overworked, poorly treated and disgruntled employees in this field.

    3. Re:Routing around by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      So the Internet was designed with resilience unless someone has a strong pair of garden shears?

      Just goes to show that security is 99.9% people just being nice and not wanting to fuck things up for the rest.

    4. Re:Routing around by schnell · · Score: 5, Informative

      So the Internet was designed with resilience unless someone has a strong pair of garden shears?

      The Internet will do just fine. Your personal ability to access it, watch a movie or dial 911 will not.

      The big networks all have many data centers and diverse physical routing paths between them. But most people seemingly fail to realize that your house, your neighborhood - heck, maybe even your county if you're rural - probably does not. There is more than one physical path to get data from a colo facility in San Francisco to one in Seattle (even if it adds a lot of latency). There is probably only one physical way to get data to your house. Yes, even your cable provider and the telco almost certainly share a conduit somewhere near you. Mostly that's because there are simply a limited number of good rights of way to run fiber (frequently railroad tracks, gas pipelines, etc.) in any given area.

      And that's also because it makes doesn't make financial sense to spend the money to ensure that your house has two redundant cables coming out of it that take two separate paths out of your neighborhood to different COs, etc. That's true not just for houses but in many cases for cell towers, Central Offices and other telecom points of presence that make last-mile connections rather than backbone connections. So that's why a fiber cut is so bad - everyone served locally by that fiber will be out of luck, even if the Internet as a whole is not.

      --
      "95% of all Slashdot .sig quotes are incorrect or completely fabricated." -Benjamin Franklin
  2. How did Rockefeller protect his pipe lines? by 140Mandak262Jamuna · · Score: 4, Interesting
    Rockefeller built up Standard Oil in the era of unfettered capitalism. It was a no holds barred fight. He had secret agreements with railroad companies to undercut his competition in transportation costs. As his oil competitors went bankrupt he picked their properties on the cheap. Then he bypassed the railroad companies by building his own pipelines to transport oil. He had enemies in the oil business, railroad business and his workers. His enemies hounded him for decades and eventually that billionaire was reduced to fleeing in a rickety car dodging federal subpoena. But they did not sabotage his pipelines.

    You could understand the railroad companies not sabotaging pipelines because the railroads too have long equally vulnerable railroads and they did not want to trigger retaliatory sabotage from Rockefeller. But his disgruntled bankrupt oil competitors, the labor they would not be above sabotage. It was really war. Carnegie hired the Pinkertons to kill agitating workers. His henchman was shot, and survived, by one of the workers. Corrupt sheriffs would break up labor organizers and the anger and hatred was mutual and ran very deep.

    Still, mile after mile of tin pipes traversing and crisscrossing Ohio, Western PA and later Indiana were left unmolested. How was that defended? How could one defend the fiber optic lines?

    --
    sed -e 's/Chuck Norris/Rajnikant/g' joke > fact
  3. Someone doesn't like being left of the new economy by Crashmarik · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Best guess on who it is ?
    Somebody that lost their job in IT because they were too old, didn't fit the diversity quota, or just had a SOB for a boss
    Someone who is sick of trying to pay rent in SF ?
    Criminal extortion scheme we haven't heard the details of yet ?

  4. Fake signs by aurizon · · Score: 4, Funny

    We need to immediately install 10,000 fake buried cable signs at scattered locations, and remove the real ones...

    1. Re:Fake signs by gtall · · Score: 5, Interesting

      It worked for Kansas, the band. As related by the band, when they were starting out they were to open for Aerosmith once. Steven Tyler had gotten a reputation for pulling the power cables to the amps if the opening band was doing too well, it might make Aerosmith look bad when they came on afterward. Kansas' stage manager had been informed of Tyler's antics, so he rigged up the amps to take power from the other side of the stage using hidden cables and put in fake cables to where all could see.

      So Kansas goes on and kills, Kansas was very hot, tight band. During the set, Tyler is pacing the sideline backstage getting more and more incensed. Kansas does one encore, Tyler is livid. They do a second encore and Tyler loses his brain cell and rips out the fake cables, which only pissed him off more since that didn't stop Kansas. After that song, Dave Hope, Kansas' bass player, threw down his bass and went to over to explain to Tyler using very colorful language what he was doing wrong. Dave Hope was a big guy back then so it was very impressive. Afterwards, other members of Aerosmith apologized to Kansas for Tyler's behavior.

  5. Dat Explanation by O('_')O_Bush · · Score: 4, Funny

    It is possible they are dressed up as Telco workers, but given their knowledge of the fiber lines, they couldn't possibly BE Telco workers...

    --
    while(1) attack(People.Sandy);
  6. Which Is It? by pubwvj · · Score: 4, Funny

    "thousands and millions of people."

    Make up your mind.
    Which is it.
    Thousands or Millions?
    Why not throw Hundreds and Billions into that sentence.
    Might as well exaggerate all the way and confuse.

  7. Slow internet? by Wowsers · · Score: 4, Funny

    Maybe it's the MPAA and RIAA latest attempt to stop people sharing copywritten material on the internet? Didn't they say they want to cut pirates off?

    --
    Take Nobody's Word For It.
  8. Re:False Flag by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Why don't we have a -1 crackpot mod.

    Because it's getting harder and harder to tell reality and crackpot theories apart.

  9. Re: Not enough punishment by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    The south really misses their slaves, don't they?

  10. Someone without Internet by Hardhead_7 · · Score: 5, Funny

    As someone who has a fiber line running in front of their house (literally, there's a "Do Not Dig Here, Fiber" post at the bottom of my driveway), but has access to only DSL, I can't say it isn't tempting.

  11. Re:Terrible. by turbidostato · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "When an act of vandalism affects many thousands of people, it's pretty fucking serious."

    It depends on how those many thousands are impacted. When biggest impact is not being able to download kitty videos at full speed, no, it is not "terrible". "Annoying" comes to mind, but not "terrible".

    "Many people and businesses have their telephone service over the fibre"

    Even if we accord at calling this "severe", severily impacting business is, well, "severe" at most, still not "terrible".

    Adjective inflation lets you without terms for really big things. If "people may notice slower email or videos not playing, but may not have service completely disrupted" is "a terrible crime" what does this leave to, say, 09/11attacks? "a terrible crime indeed, I really mean it"?

  12. FIOS 100 Yards from my house Cant Get It by ZippyTheChicken · · Score: 5, Informative

    I live in what might be considered a rural area by some but I am 5 miles from my state capitol. There are underground fiber lines going down the main highway and fiber up my road to about 100 yards from me.. I actually walked down and watched them snake it under a road with a pneumatic torpedo.. cant get it.. the guys who install cable are Russian Illegals hired by a third party contractor for Verizon .. I talked with them for a while .. If our country ever gets attacked a few well placed people in these third party contractor companies that don't get checked will be able to take out our whole country in hours. They will know every weak point.