Slashdot Mirror
The College Majors Most Likely To Marry Each Other
schnell writes: The blog Priceonomics has published an analysis showing students in which college majors end up marrying another student with that same major. Religious studies (with 21% of students marrying another studying the same field) tops the list among all students, followed by general science. Perhaps unsurprising is that some majors with gender disparities show a high in-major marriage rate among the less represented group — for example, 39% of women engineering majors marry a fellow student in their field, while among men 43% studying nursing and 38% studying elementary education do likewise. The blog concludes that your choice of major may unwittingly decide your choice of spouse, and depending on how well that field is paid, your economic future.
I would think.
With computer science classes typically 90% male, how are 15% of the people marrying eachother.
I mean I know its statistically possible (so keep your smarter than thou bullshit to yourself) but seriously.. those odds are astronomical...
The Comp Sci stats are interesting. 79% will remain unmarried for life. 9% will marry a computing device. 7% will marry a web browser or JavaScript. 3% will marry their left hand. Only the last 2% will marry another adult human being.
Seems to be this is more related with the gender distribution in each major more than anything else.
Engineering and sciences have a high percentage of males vs females. Therefore is logical to think that any woman in that field has a lot of possible partners to choose from.
The backwards can be said about Nursery. Mainly a female oriented vocation, any male nurse will have a rather large pool to select a partner from.
Seems pretty obvious, I 'unno...
0.5% of the men marry 0.5% of the women. 7.5% of the men marry the other 7.5% of the men.
Or it could be that if you enter a field with a large gender disparity in its members, that implies you're willing to overcome any social stigma to engage in that field--ie, you're dedicated to it--and that by the same token you'll find plenty of people of the opposite sex to consider as possible spouse candidates. On the opposite end, because it's so uncommon to see members of the opposite sex in your own gender dominated field, you're inclined to believe they must really be dedicated for it just as you are--ie, those expensive student loans (or even the years of educations) indicate a long-term (possibly life-long) desire in that field.
Golly, who would have thunk the obvious.
The line "Religious studies (with 21% of students marrying another studying the same field) tops the list among all students..." is incorrect. Theology and Religious Vocations is at 21%. Religious Studies (which is connected to philosophy) is 43rd on the list at 5%. Theology and Religious Vocations is a completely different field from Religious Studies (a.k.a. the Study of Religions).
The College Majors Most Likely To Divorce Each Other
Ipso Fatso Forgetso
Because computer science classes are not actually 90% male.... the actual figure is closer to 80%, depending on the institution. I believe the actual average number of male graduates from computer science is 82% in the USA.
Of course, that also suggests that computer science is an exceedingly likely place for a single woman who is interested enough in the field to have something in common with most of her peers in class is also quite likely to also find a mate. The exact opposite can be said for men.
This is anecdotal, but almost all of the women I knew while I was taking computer science eventually hooked up with someone else in class before graduation. I do not know how permanent those relationships were after graduation, however.
File under 'M' for 'Manic ranting'
It's no surprise that many students pair with others in their major, especially in harder disciplines. You ask someone you find attractive if they would like to study for the big test. About two hours into it is the perfect time to trade massages to work out the study kinks. Whether you get back to studying is never guaranteed after that.
There may be no "I" in team, but there's also no "F" in way.
Are majors allowed to marry each other now?
Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
...observed in plenty of schools and jurisdictions. ;)
The reasons are left to speculation of the readers...
Most people I know started long term relationships with somebody they happen to spend time with, or that they are just nearby: same high school, same college, same circle of friends, same workplace. Study does not bring much information unless it is comparing likeliness of other situations like the ones I listed. Unfortunately I can only add anectodorial evidence. By the way, only a few ones were due to predatorial skills at night.
I've watched enough television to know that female defense lawyers are ALWAYS married to - or at least dating - policemen.
#DeleteChrome
... plus there's the issue with basic hygiene...
Oh wait - I thought we were talking about women's studies.
#DeleteChrome
That insightful tidbit has really piqued my curiousity and I'm going to read the rest of that blog real soon now. Pretty soon I'll be a genius.
As Mark Twain said: Nothing propinx like propinquity
My wife's a nurse, I'm a mechanical engineer.
How does that work into the study?
Political debates have me rolling my eyes so much I think I got optical whiplash. I should sue. - Foamy The Squirrel
The classroom is a place to meet new people, as is the work floor. It just happens naturally there, people are partnered up to do tasks, you have to work together, etc. When you take a bunch of strangers and start to introduce them to one another, good chance that at least here and there romantic sparks fly. Add to that that most students are in their early 20s, an age for many people to start looking for a life partner, and the great number of marriages that follows is just expected.
The greater number in religious studies is also not too surprising as the people there will have strong religious beliefs, and strongly religious people like to marry people that are also strongly religious and of the same faith. Here is even more reason for people to actively search for a partner within their study group, as it's much less likely to find a suitable partner (i.e. sharing the religious beliefs) randomly in the outside world.
"My college major was computer programming, and I married a girl who types in computer programs for a living!"
"What's her name?"
"Rosie."
(-1: Post disagrees with my already-settled worldview) is not a valid mod option.
Yep, ran into a female non-bather several years ago where I use to work. The girl was absolutely brilliant with a background in theoretical physics working in the IT department. But damn....we use to light candles to help freshen the air right next to the server room. I finally had to move into the server room because i couldn't take the smell anymore. We would complain to our manager constantly but he wouldn't do much. Eventually she figured out what the candles were for so she left. Still though one of the smartest persons I've ever met.
Ally McBeal? Nope. She dated other lawyers... oh, and a doctor.
Take your pick of LA Law characters. I don't think any of the major characters dated a cop.
Political debates have me rolling my eyes so much I think I got optical whiplash. I should sue. - Foamy The Squirrel
In my country, there are pretty much no women in IT. Only gay dudes find their partners in the same field here.
The few girls I've seen are all immigrants or exchange students.
Down at the bottom of the list is "Communications Disorders Sciences and Services" at 2%. Somehow that seems fitting.
I guess you missed the memo from SCOTUS - same sex marriage is legal now.
someone with class and elegance, and who probably makes/inherits more money than you, you should spend your free time at a Trump hotel or Casino.
The divorce rates for marrying in your major would be a much more interesting study. I would think engineering and CS would top that list.
For the "grossly underrepresented group," though dating in your major is like shooting fish in a barrel.
This cannot stand. Two people with the same major marrying each other is completely against my just-now-made-up religion. It says that Frank (my just-made-up religions version of god) specifically wrote that "Thou shalt not lie with a fellow computer science major as you would with a psychology major".
The government needs to make a constitutional amendment to prevent people of the same major from marrying each other. After all, if we let two people with the same major marry, we're on a slippery slope to marrying dolphins with snack cakes. And then where will it end?
Yaz
Proximity.
"If any question why we died, Tell them because our fathers lied."
People with confluent majors end up working side by side in the field.
I'm guessing it has something to do with that 80 some odd hours a week that a number of CS workers are forced into. When you have to spend 80% of your waking hours working, it kind of limits your dating pool.
An enigma, wrapped in a riddle, shrouded in bacon and cheese
The data does not at all suggest that your major will decide your spouse. I would suggest that this journalism major marry someone who had to take at least one statistics class.
They need to look the rates in the context of how many people are in the other major and assess the expected probability. As others have commented, men are unlikely to find women in their engineering class, so the rates will be low. OTOH, if the engineering class is 10% women/90% men, and 15% of the men marry a woman engineer, that would be a statistically significant finding.
The divorce rates for marrying in your major would be a much more interesting study. I would think engineering and CS would top that list.
Engineers have one of the lowest divorce rates. As an engineer married to another engineer, I believe there is a big benefit to having a spouse that has been trained to use logic and systematically solve problems. We settle most of our arguments by drawing Venn diagrams on a whiteboard. Having two six digit salaries helps too.
But that would imply 83% of female CS majors end up marrying male CS majors. And let's be honest, why would they want to do that?
Sure they can have their pick, but well...the odds but the goods are odd, as they say.
Does that mean that for women in computer science, the chance of marrying someone in computer science is up >75%?
Same here. We think and solve problems similarly, so there isn't much "talking past each other" when we disagree. If a problem can be reasoned through, we usually come to agreement. If it's squishier, we both sort of recognize that it's probably not worth fighting to the death over. Money and worry about unemployment is never a problem, so we don't fight over it or nitpick how it's spent (in fact, we each have a mix of private and shared accounts after 10 years of marriage, and we each handle a subset of the household financees without much oversight from the other). Beyond that I suppose everything else is pretty normal, but those are two big issues that cause a lot of relationship trouble that work out to a pretty strong built-in advantage for us.
We're both pretty mellow people who don't usually get wound up about stuff that's not really important, but I'm not sure if that's just who we are or if it's associated with how we were educated and how we work. There seem to be certain types of people who genuinely get bored and need a certain amount of drama in their human interactions and will create it if it's not there. Those people seem to be less common in engineering, although I don't have a lot to quantify or support that. Those people are usually not fun to be around and seem like they'd be a nightmare to be married to.
An interesting anagram of "BANACH TARSKI" is "BANACH TARSKI BANACH TARSKI"
Come on Slashdot! This article should be titled "Most Incestuous Majors".
The divorce rates for marrying in your major would be a much more interesting study. I would think engineering and CS would top that list.
Engineers have one of the lowest divorce rates. As an engineer married to another engineer, I believe there is a big benefit to having a spouse that has been trained to use logic and systematically solve problems. We settle most of our arguments by drawing Venn diagrams on a whiteboard. Having two six digit salaries helps too.
A low divorce rate across the board, for all types of professional engineer. I'm a PhD engineer and am married to another PhD engineer. We've been married more than 20 years, and were together a couple of years before that. Our kids are more-or-less grown up (youngest in high school, oldest at University).
Yeah. I am still an unmarried single virgin after I got my CS BS major after 15 years. Where are those women for me? D:
Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
> but almost all of the women I knew while I was taking computer science eventually hooked up with someone else in class before graduation.
This was literally rape and part of geek patriarchial culture. Those women were sexually abused. All of you deserve to be shamed and punished collectively until this stops and no more males terrorise computer classes. This is just triggerring me.
Please... if you are going to troll, at least try a little harder to make it sound like you might actually have put some reasoned thought into the perspective you may be trying to present, instead of simply uttering nonsense whose phrasing appears to only be an unimaginative attempt at provoking an emotional reaction.
File under 'M' for 'Manic ranting'
Packers and Movers Bangalore | Packers and Movers Chennai | Packers and Movers Delhi | Packers and Movers Faridabad | Packers and Movers Ghaziabad | Packers and Movers Greater Noida | Packers and Movers Gurgaon | Packers and Movers Hyderabad | Packers and Movers Mumbai | Packers and Movers Navi Mumbai | Packers and Movers Noida | Packers and Movers Pune | Packers and Movers Thane |