Slashdot Mirror
Putin Gives Federal Security Agents Two Weeks To Produce 'Encryption Keys' For The Internet (gawker.com)
An anonymous reader writes: The President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Putin, has ordered the Federal Security Service (FSB) to produce "encryption keys" to decrypt all data on the internet, and the FSB has two weeks to do it, Meduza reports. The head of the FSB, Alexander Bortnikov, is responsible for accomplishing such a task. "The new 'anti-terrorist' laws require all 'organizers of information distribution' that add 'additional coding' to transmitted electronic messages to provide the FSB with any information necessary to decrypt those messages," reports Meduza. "It's still unclear what information exactly online resources are expected to turn over, given that all data on the internet is encoded, one way or another, and in many instances encryption keys for encrypted information simply don't exist." Some of the details of the executive order include requiring telecom providers and "organizers of information distribution" to store copies of the content of all information they transmit for six months and store the metadata for three years so the Kremlin can access it whenever they want. In order for that to happen, ISPs would need to build new data centers capable of holding all that information and buy imported equipment, all without state subsidies, where they risk going bankrupt. To actually operate the data centers, the Russian government would need to upgrade Russia's outdated electrical grid and cables, which could cost between $30 and $77 billion. What about the "encryption keys?" In addition to storing all the transmitted information, "organizers of information distribution" have to turn over "any information necessary to decrypt those messages." Therefore, "additional coding" will need to be added to all electronic messages to act as instructions for the FSB to "decode" them. Many services and websites don't have "keys" or are fundamentally unsharable, like banks and financial institutions. Nearly all electronic information needs to be "encoded" in some way. Bortnikov has two weeks and the clock starts now. Good luck!
and you can't do that one, simple thing.
There is no such thing as keys that would decrypt "all data on the internet", which hopefully everyone here already knows. Empty, dead, pointless parody of law. The war on encryption is doomed to fail
I think Putin knows full well that this task is not achievable, but wants to use it to shove someone out of their job in disgrace. I guess we'll find out who that is soon enough.
How is the Riemann zeta function like Trump rallies? Both have an endless number of trivial zeros.
Contents of Official FSB Decryption kit:
Wrench
One way train ticket to Siberia
The only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for it to be pitted against a slightly greater evil
So why is he pretending to be stupid?
Don't waste your vote! Vote for whoever you want, unless you live in a swing state it won't matter anyways
for (i=0; i0xffffffffffffffff; i++)
printf("%16x\n",i);
printf("ffffffffffffffff");
or something along those lines. That'll produce all 128bit keys. Just don't ask me to match each key with each piece of data...
And here I thought it was only U.S. Politicians that didn't understand how to computer. Someone get that man 4 Internets Please.
Terrorism is king. It trumps privacy or freedom.
The west has been using this justification for many years now and it would seem that Russia too last learned that to justify anything Orwellian, all you need to say is "because terrorism." Case closed.
Maybe because if Putin is assassinated, it only empowers someone even worse to stroll up and say "see, this is why we need to be even stronger and more secure". Maybe. I'm not an expert.
Possibilities in order of likelihood
1) This reporting is wildly inaccurate, and misses key details, like for example only part of the implantation must be completed in two weeks or similar.
2) Putin is doing this for political cover, he has intelligence there is going to be another terror attack in Russia or one of its surrogates. The intel is not good enough to prevent it, but he wants to look like he is 'doing something'. The argument will be if only people had got out of his way an let him do this sooner the tragedy would have been avoided. It both bolsters his strongman persona and gives an excuse to expanding executive power.
3) Putin is created a legal excuse to punish people who are otherwise political enemies, noncompliance with this new law will provide a legal cover an a veneer of legitimacy.
4) Putin is perfectly aware this is impossible but it will produce a flurry of activity from people who will be trying desperately to save the careers by at least appearing to comply in good faith, in hopes others will take the blame for the obvious eventual failure. Putin plans to utilize all this activity as a distraction to enable some other covert objective to be completed.
5) Putin has totally left the reservation.
Repeal the 17th Amendment TODAY! Also Please Read http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
I can give them to you but it might take a while for you to read them. (Lists every binary number storable in 512 bit space)
and in many instances encryption keys for encrypted information simply don't exist
Ahh keyless encryption: for when you really don't care to ever get the data back.
Many keys are ephemeral. Once the information has been received and acknowledged, both parties discard their keys. If you intercept one of these messages, no one will ever have a way of decrypting it. The only way to get the information is to double back and beat it out of one of them.
Why does gawker keep publishing unsubstantiated bullshit, and why do people believe it? There are no references, no substantiation of any of this. How would Gawker know what the orders of Putin are? Christ. Stop republishing Gawkers crap.
ISPs fail to have this system in place within 14days. Putin "takes over" all internet providers, claiming full share ownership of them.
See - Russian Oil, coal, gas, solar, farms, manufacturing, Processor Manufacturer (MCST) etc. All now 100% owned by Putin.
and in many instances encryption keys for encrypted information simply don't exist
Ahh keyless encryption: for when you really don't care to ever get the data back.
Many keys are ephemeral. Once the information has been received and acknowledged, both parties discard their keys. If you intercept one of these messages, no one will ever have a way of decrypting it. The only way to get the information is to double back and beat it out of one of them.
Sure, you can use TLS for instance and get a new key for each transaction. There is still a key, however and one could intercept a TLS key, for instance, by way of a man in the middle attack.
Exactly. It is very difficult to get populist support when things are going well, much easier to blame others and rally the troops when things aren't perfect.
The solutions is simple:
"It will be ready any day now" for about 6 months,
"Ready for testing" Followed by 6 months of failures
"Ready" With some sample data.
"Make stuff up" from then on
Russia isn't evil. Russians aren't evil. Putin most certainly is. He's like a Russian Donald Trump.
Trump is America's answer to Putin. America cannot be outdone by Russia, so Trump is our strategy to out-Putin Putin.
Note to ACs: I usually delete AC replies without reading them. If you want to talk to me, log in.
This is happening more and more here on Slashdot. Entire conversations are being hidden from view, even when browsing at -1 (which I always do). If you are logged in when you post, you can still see that comment and its children if you look at your posting history, but it will be gone from the main comments section of the article.
I'm not surprised, however, as the new owners are just here to actually and finally destroy the site due to it's unwavering support for free and anonymous speech and the only moderation system that is actually fair. If they can't rig it, or sink it (dice), they'll just break it.
Is that enough time to pack and get a travel visa to ... doesn't matter, just OUT OF HERE!
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
Evil is dusty?
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
There were a lot of assassination attempts at him. Fortunately none of the succeeded. Just imagine what could have happened if a capable military strategist had that army, that technology and that industrial capacity at his disposal. We're talking about an army that could wage a war against Russia + USA for roughly 4 years, and an industry that could supply that war under stress of bombing for the same period. The very last thing you'd want in the mix is someone actually able to handle that power.
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
There is a huge difference though. He issued a pointless decree, the west actually has a framework in place to DO it...
If stupid trends like what Putin wants continue, at some point there won't be and Internet anymore, all there'll be are Walled Gardens within national borders, never interconnected at all, all of them with their own peculiar set of rules dictated by technologically-incompetent politicians, and for the most part completely unsafe for anyone to use for any reason whatsoever -- except the governments of those Walled-garden countries, who will use the strongest encryption possible, forbidding it to anyone else for any reason. So much for the age of information! As usual, involving too many Humans in it is mucking it up so thoroughly that it might not be possible to save it.
Are YOU using the TOOL, or is the TOOL using YOU? Think about it!
But I think the USA is still operating on the strategy that we must keep that part of the world unstable. I think the US intelligence agencies would oust anyone more capable than Putin. They like evil crackpots, not powerful leaders.
Trump is America's answer to Putin. America cannot be outdone by Russia, so Trump is our strategy to out-Putin Putin.
Dear God please no pictures of Trump with his shirt off.
he certainly is trying his damndest to reinstate the Soviet state.
Well, the Soviet state without all the lies about it being "for the masses."
I wonder if President Obama still thinks Mitt Romney was wrong about Putin...
Sure, the next step will be that any ISP or Internet-connected data provider will be required to assist in providing these "encryption keys". Which is also impossible, but gives the government a lot (more) of control and legal justification for raiding facilities, interrogating people, etc.
Downmodding is the refuge of the weak. Don't downmod, make a better argument!