Slashdot Mirror


Increased Smartphone Screen-Time Is Associated With Lower Sleep Quality, Says Study (medicalxpress.com)

A new study from the University of California is the latest to show that increased smartphone screen-time can lower one's quality of sleep, which can lead to various negative health conditions such as obesity, diabetes and depression. Medical Xpress reports: Christensen and colleagues sought to test the hypothesis that increased screen-time may be associated with poor sleep by analyzing data from 653 adult individuals across the United States participating in the Health eHeart Study. Participants installed a smartphone application which recorded their screen-time, defined as the number of minutes in each hour that the screen was turned on, over a 30-day period. They also recorded their sleeping hours and sleep quality. The researchers found that each participant totaled an average of 38.4 hours over this period, with smartphones being activated on average for 3.7 minutes in each hour. Longer average screen-time was associated with poor sleep quality and less sleep overall, particularly when smartphones were used near participants' bedtime. The authors state that their study is the first to measure smartphone exposure prospectively, but caution that the study also had some important limitations, including the self-selection of study participants and self-reporting of data. The study has been published in the journal PLOS ONE.

61 comments

  1. Get with the times by Tablizer · · Score: 5, Funny

    I don't need sleep, I have an app do it.

    1. Re: Get with the times by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      get an app to help you move to Mexico, stupid california

    2. Re: Get with the times by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It would be pretty awesome if you could pop some pills or chug a drink which performs the same function as sleep. And no I'm not talking about caffeine or cocaine, but the actual benefits of real sleep. Though on 2nd thought, if we had that, they might expect us to work longer hours...

    3. Re: Get with the times by lxs · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I think the problem with this world is people wanting everything to be fixed for them by a pill, a service, an app or a politician.

      Take responsibility for your own life and good health.
      Fix broken stuff.
      Cook your own food.
      Keep learning.
      Don't rely on external factors to fix your broken life and bad habits.
      Now help others to do the same.

      (Add a blurry Instagram photo for a background and we're done.)

    4. Re: Get with the times by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please explain to us how you plan to simulate the physiobiology of sleep with any of that shit?

    5. Re: Get with the times by Calydor · · Score: 2

      Actually, I think I'm gonna skip #5 and wait for someone else to get to #6.

      --
      -=This sig has nothing to do with my comment. Move along now=-
    6. Re: Get with the times by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      honestly, i can do without the politicians. i can't think of one way that a politician is improving my quality of life

    7. Re:Get with the times by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Modern app appers app their sleep with apps, not with LUDDITE unconsciousness!

      Apps!

    8. Re: Get with the times by david_thornley · · Score: 2

      I have several problems that are partly fixed with pills and other medical technology, which would be real problems if I manned up and turned to self-reliance like you seem to be suggesting. I rely on external factors to fix stuff in me that's broken because I bloody have to. Get to be old enough, and you'll do the exact same thing without a second thought, or you'll probably get unnecessarily crippled and die early. Taking responsibility means relying on pills and services. My memory isn't quite what I remember it as being, so I have a calendar app on my phone to make up for some of that (missing meetings and appointments and such would be irresponsible). I'd be considerably worse off without certain laws that restrict pollution, and those are from politicians.

      Most of the stuff that breaks around here I can't fix. Things in general have become a lot less fixable. Fortunately, they break a lot less. Anyone else old enough to remember the tube testers in hardware stores? If your electronic device wasn't working, you'd pull the vacuum tubes (if you were smart and/or doing this the second time, making notes on which sockets they came from), take them down there, test them, and buy replacements for the ones that didn't work anymore. Carburetors? They were fairly simple. They don't exist on most modern cars.

      So, you seem to be saying I should use ancient technology and just accept medical conditions that were untreatable when I was a kid. I don't agree.

      --
      "When you have eliminated the unacceptable, whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truthiness" - Holmes
  2. Post hoc ergo propter hoc by niks42 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If you RTFA, you'll find one HUGE get-out clause saying "These findings cannot support conclusions on causation. Effect-cause remains a possibility: poor sleep may lead to increased screen-time"

    Meaning if people have a poor night's sleep, they may be spending more time on their phone BECAUSE THEY ARE AWAKE.

    I wonder how much these geniuses spent to work out yet another statement of the bleeding obvious?

    1. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by NoNeeeed · · Score: 2

      Yeah, not impressed by this study. With this sort of approach it's hard to disentangle the various possible causes and effects. For example, people who spend longer on line may have more stuff going through their minds or are people who find it difficult to switch off, which affects their sleep pattern. I know that was one of the causes of my life long insomnia.

      There have been much better studies demonstrating the effect of artificial light on sleep patterns. We know that blue light in particular seems to affect our circadian rhythm, so using screens, especially close up in the evening, can send things out of whack.

      I've been a life long insomniac, and one of the things that *seemed* to help was to use software like F.Lux on my laptops and similar apps on my phone. They adjust the colour temperature of your screen towards the red later on in the evening. Obviously that's an anecdote, but there does seem to be some pretty reliable basic science behind in.

      Personally, I found that the thing that helped the most was a strong routine. The moment I start slipping out of that for more than a couple of days I know I'm going to struggle to sleep. One of the things that will do that is aimless browsing.

    2. Re: Post hoc ergo propter hoc by bistromath007 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, as somebody with... A great deal of screen time, I definitely feel like it's something I do to cope (poorly) with my various other quite severe sleep disruptions.

      honk if you're reading this in your twentieth hour of wakefulness, tho

    3. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Meaning if people have a poor night's sleep, they may be spending more time on their phone BECAUSE THEY ARE AWAKE.

      Except there are plenty of reports on the web about people having sleep and eyesight problems after being exposed to LED backlight screens. Rumor has it that it's due the high amplitude "blue" wavelengths emitted by LED lights. And it's oh so nice that *all* screen manufacturers have stopped manufacturing CCFL backlight screens, so consumers have no alternative to LED screens. Thanks a lot!

    4. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, not impressed by this study

      Link to study here:
      http://journals.plos.org/ploso...

      Reading through their methods - they had a single variable they were testing - whether the screen was in use or not. They were not testing why the phone screen was in use. They did have controls across various demographics and some preexisting health conditions - such as sleep apnea.

      I really wish the study had gone into why the phone was in use. Simple example - I personally enable night shift and use the Kindle app in low light mode. That helps puts me to sleep each night - not keep me awake. As parent noted, other studies outside of smartphones have gone into this level of detail and shown some interesting results.

    5. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yes, the study has its limitations. I applaud those conducting it for clearly stating those limitations. Its refreshing to see as so often they are not even mentioned or buried deep in the details under misleading headlines. Just stating those limitations makes this better science, IMHO, than many of the crap reports we see here on /.

    6. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by Rich_Lather · · Score: 1

      If they had published a study showing that Facebook causes insomnia they would risk getting sued.

    7. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >Meaning if people have a poor night's sleep, they may be spending more time on their phone BECAUSE THEY ARE AWAKE.

      Umm, in the past if you 'came to' in the night you may roll over and go back to sleep. Even if you had some nagging thought you could get past it and fade into sleep.

      Now one feels compelled to collect from digital farms, attack, complete a level, or collect timed rewards BECAUSE of the way these apps are designed... they're time-sensitive. And throw in the social-clan-alliance-village hook and people WILL tune in at any moment, any where, under any conditions. Because they're conditioned to respond to external rewards. It's very compelling. And responding to such midnight-interruptions is just too easy, plus the hand-held formfactor makes it even easier.

      So yeah, people awake in the middle of the night, (or put off sleeping), but ask why. The answer is not biology.
      Throw in some energy drinks after dinner, and it's even worse. Have young kids? SLEEP BECOMES EVEN MORE ELUSIVE- YOU WILL NEVER SLEEP.

    8. Re:Post hoc ergo propter hoc by swillden · · Score: 1

      I wonder how much these geniuses spent to work out yet another statement of the bleeding obvious?

      Meh. Lots of what is "bleeding obvious" turns out to be untrue. It's worth doing a study to check whether or not what seems obvious is actually the case.

      --
      Note to ACs: I usually delete AC replies without reading them. If you want to talk to me, log in.
  3. smartphones? by MancunianMaskMan · · Score: 1
    you guys in the US aren't going to buy smartphones anyway once DJT hikes up import tariffs from "Gina" to 45%...

    Good night everyone.

    1. Re:smartphones? by Oswald+McWeany · · Score: 1

      Who wants a smartphone that's been in a 'gina anyway?

      --
      "That's the way to do it" - Punch
  4. too much screen time also by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    fucks up who you vote for.

    1. Re:too much screen time also by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      too late

  5. I know the reason by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Since when Samsung introduced the Galaxy Note 7, people are kept constantly awake by explosion noise!

  6. Whatever! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    (As I read this on my mobile, while awake in bed at 2am...)

  7. New study shows increased open book time... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    This just in: Insomniacs do more things with the things they own when they can't sleep.

  8. Open book time linked to insomnia! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A new study shows: Insomniacs do more things with the things they own while not sleeping.

  9. Lower Sleep Quality good for Creativity by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I write some great code during fitful sleep!

    1. Re:Lower Sleep Quality good for Creativity by Oswald+McWeany · · Score: 1

      Poor sleep has been scientifically linked to increased creativity. There again, it's also linked to shorter lifespan.

      Write bad code, get some sleep. (if you can)

      --
      "That's the way to do it" - Punch
  10. Addiction a human weakness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I think in general over consumption is a human weakness for many. We many times think of addiction as being from a addictive drug or someone addicted to alcohol. But technology to some seems addictive, and the increasing need for constant connections, quick response and a lack of common sense. Is driving people to do stupid things, like texting, talking while driving, avoiding face to face communication, and trying to live lives through apps and devices. Has it really helped our lives, or just made us more accessible and gives others the ability to this instant access society.

  11. Anecdotal by codeButcher · · Score: 3, Interesting

    During some health/hormonal issues I started paying attention to my sleep too. I absolutely feel it is vital to being productive. (Everybody's mileage may vary, obviously.)

    I've become a big fan of screen reddening apps, incandescent/warm-white light sources, and wearing yellow/orange glasses some hours before bedtime - all the general melatonin-killing blue light avoidance being punted for years now.

    What people do seem to often miss however, is the thing about timing. Melatonin is produced only for a certain window period during the early evening. Trudging on through that window period by forcing yourself to stay awake, makes me unable to fall asleep later on, no matter how tired. So no late-night reading or surfing past bedtime, no matter how thrilling the novel or how .... uhmmm... interesting american election memes, how compelling the conversation, or how urgent the deadline. The corollary of this is that one has to work out a good bed-time routine and stick to it 7 days a week.

    --
    Free, as in your money being freed from the confines of your account.
    1. Re:Anecdotal by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Spot on comment. Also, pamper yourself when it comes time to sleep. Adjust the room temperature, wear what's most comfortable, make sure the room is dark and quiet (or wear ear plugs), and don't go to bed mad at your partner (yea I know, this is slashdot...).

    2. Re:Anecdotal by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If people are taking too long to get to sleep exposure to blue light in the morning could help.
      But absolutely avoid blue light in the evening and at night.

      I think there are two issues with modern lighting. First, the disappearance of soft light.
      The second is brightness. It is crazy how bright modern light is in comparison to everything else.
      I think it is also crazy how overlit every business (indoors and out), and every street has become in my city.

      It's a shame that the people deciding to install bright, blue light everywhere don't know anything about how the human eye works, or consider how we evolved. We should only be exposed to blue light during the daylight hours. Daylight temperture light bulbs should be used during daylight.

    3. Re:Anecdotal by apoc.famine · · Score: 1

      I've set up Phillips Hue (not hacked yet) to force this behavior in my house. In the evenings they come on automatically as it gets dark, and throughout the evening they sunset, getting lower and redder as it gets later. Near bedtime they hit a dim reddish-purple to mimic an hour or two past sundown, deep purple, and out. About 30 minutes before I wake up they come on as purple-red, transition through reddish about the time the alarm goes off, have hit daytime yellow-blue-white by the time I'm eating breakfast, and then they turn off once I leave the house.
       
      This forces me to stick to a regular bed-time, and it means that when I go to bed I generally go right to sleep. And I'm usually awake before my alarm. Now, I do occasionally override them, but that takes a little effort, which is a good way of persuading me to go to bed.

      --
      Velociraptor = Distiraptor / Timeraptor
    4. Re:Anecdotal by david_thornley · · Score: 1

      I have a C-PAP machine to help me sleep. When I turn it on or off, there's a bright white screen that lights up for a few minutes. Sometimes when I can't sleep I stop to appreciate the irony.

      --
      "When you have eliminated the unacceptable, whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truthiness" - Holmes
  12. F'ing correlation is not causation! by monkeyzoo · · Score: 2

    Post hoc ergo propter hoc!

    Nothing in the article says screen time can lower one's quality of sleep!! That is entirely the hasty conclusion of the editor here.
    Perhaps people who are up with isomnia turn to their phones?!?

  13. I wonder by kilodelta · · Score: 1

    If the study extends to the larger screens on laptops and computers in general? I don't think so.

    1. Re:I wonder by Oswald+McWeany · · Score: 1

      I don't know about this study, but I've seen articles in the past linking the light from monitors being bad for sleep.

      Supposedly, the theory goes that bluish lights are associated with the brain with early morning, and waking up. (light from the sun has more blue reaching us in the morning). Light in the evening has more red/yellow in it.

      Light from monitors, phones, tablets, etc supposedly contains more light in the blue light than is conducive to our brains thinking it is night time.

      That's the theory; whether it is really the cause, I don't know.

      --
      "That's the way to do it" - Punch
  14. Does not disprove causality chain by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So you would rather have them throw a sensational conclusion instead of telling you the thruth? I decided to write a comment about how this study doesn't proove causality, because most studies (or the journalistic interpretation) usually ends with a baseless conclusion, but it seems like this study had integrity enough to say it like it is, so that I didn't have to put out any rant this time.

    It is a valid data set, which can be used in combination with further studies. It's easy to observe that it's not without consequences to use a smartphone. It might not cause bad sleep, but it certainly doesn't make it better. You can't use the study to disprove a correlation just because it makes you feel better about your obsessive smartphone abuse.

  15. Blue Light by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Blue light stimulates wakefulness, is produced by LCDs, and the obsessions powering the social media craze prompt frequent and long exposure. That is causation.

    1. Re:Blue Light by Falos · · Score: 1

      PSA that everyone should consider using Twilight or an equivalent screen tuner if you aren't already. iOS added it to stock preferences, desktops can use f.lux

  16. e mail marketing by Disparo · · Score: 1

    e mail marketing Turbine suas vendas com e-mail marketing e potencialize suas oportunidades de negócio!

  17. of course the causation runs both directions by epine · · Score: 1

    Of course the causation runs in both directions here.

    It's likely that poor sleep leads to poorer function; it's likely that poorer function leads to stress, anxiety, and more screen time; and its likely that this in turns contributes to poor sleep. All three "likelies" have support within the existing literature.

    Which doesn't stop a likely threesome from coming out upside down.

    The next study requires an even larger budget. But first, you're probably going to do a cheap study to at least suggest that the two effects move in the same direction, once any kind of measurement enters the room.

    Doh! they're so stupid for looking before they leap.

  18. uhuh.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My phone doesn't make me depressed. I stare at my phone all night because I *am* depressed.

    1. Re:uhuh.. by Oswald+McWeany · · Score: 1

      Cyclical. I'm depressed because I stare at my phone; which makes me want to stare at my phone because I'm depressed. Only the Chinese can save me by taking out our satellites.

      --
      "That's the way to do it" - Punch
    2. Re: uhuh.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      staring at Tinder makes me depressed

  19. Averages by John+Allsup · · Score: 1

    They give the observed averages, but nothing about how it varies from person to person, or with usage habits. Like a reading with unspecified error.

    --
    John_Chalisque
  20. I know this guy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is my cousin who researched this! Very proud.

  21. blah blah phones sleep quality blah blah by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Okay we get it, blue light fucks up sleep quality, we get it. We don't need the same fucking fluff piece click bait bullshit story repeated week after week. Sheesh.

  22. LCD TVs by Luthair · · Score: 1

    So why don't we ever hear about the effect of LCD TVs on sleep? Surely a 60" TV blazing at you for hours is worse than a 6" screen.

    1. Re:LCD TVs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps it does. Perhaps a percentage of the population is less affected by it. Good questions would be:

      Do you have a consistant sleep schedule?
      How long does it take you to fall asleep?
      How many hours of sleep do you get?
      Are you exposed to any blue light in the morning?
      Are you exposed to any blue light three hours before going to sleep?
      Do you use electronic devices three hours before going to sleep, and if so for how long?
      Are you able to wake up at a consistant time in the morning, without the aid of an alarm clock?

      Falling asleep shouldn't be difficult. Humans have been doing it for a long time. It does turn out that humans are even more sensitive to light than was previously believed. Avoiding bright light before sleep is good, avoiding blue light before sleep is even better.

      That said, it's possible that some people are more strongly affected by blue light, and other people are less affected by it. There are many studies about blue light but there don't seem to be very many that address all of the questions I've asked above.

      It is also interesting to consider what does all this exposure to bright light do to our eyes? With smartphones, monitors, television screens, headlights, and streetlights, we are constantly looking directly at, or have in our line of sight, extremely bright light.

      On the flippity flip, perhaps people who sleep during the day enjoy not having monochromatic lighting on the streets at night.

  23. Re: The truth about 9/11 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    building 7 is the key to unraveling the truth of 9/11

  24. Blue light is bad by yithar7153 · · Score: 1

    It's not actually surprising to see why this might be true if you look at this link, which explains that blue light suppresses secretion of melatonin and interferes with sleep. And I doubt everyone installs Twilight or CF.lumen on their phone if it's Android, and previous versions of iOS didn't have Night Mode if I remember correctly.

  25. "They" said the same thing... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...about Television and Computer monitors.

  26. Not new information..? by poofmeisterp · · Score: 1

    FTA:

    ...particularly when smartphones were used near participants' bedtime.

    Uh, yeah. That information has been known for decades. The amount of brain activity, light color and intensity, and distance of device from sleeping space (disassociation of device activity with sleep area) are known causes of trouble getting to sleep and maintaining a healthy sleep pattern. Unsure what this is supposed to be telling us that was previously unknown.

    1. Re:Not new information..? by poofmeisterp · · Score: 1

      Damnit. Forgot to mention that this is previously from television. Smartphones aren't much different other than using interactive body motion in coordination with perception and processing. That makes them kind of worse.

  27. An hour of sleep per night? by techno-vampire · · Score: 1

    TFS says that the participants averaged 38.4 hours of sleep over 30 days. That's just over one hour per night. I don't think so. Either there's a major typo in TFS or whoever wrote up the study is missing a very obvious error.

    --
    Good, inexpensive web hosting
  28. no way by Smiddi · · Score: 1

    This story is rubbish. Send from my iPhone, 2:06am .

    1. Re:no way by b783719 · · Score: 1

      Stop using your iPhone and go to sleep. Send from my iPhone, 3:24am .