Ask Slashdot: Is There A Screen-Less, Keyboard-Less, Battery-Powered Computer?
Long-time Slashdot reader Wycliffe writes:
So I have a travel keyboard that I love. I can carry my OS on a USB flash drive. There are several options for portable battery powered monitors. The only thing I'm missing to have a completely modular laptop is the CPU/MB/RAM... I can get a laptop but it seems silly to carry around a laptop with a keyboard when I never use the keyboard. I don't need a long battery life, if I need more than an hour then I can find somewhere to plug it in...
I've thought about buying a small box like a Zotac and trying to replace the hard drive with a battery -- but does anything like this already exist...? Also, are there any systems like this with decent specs? Most stuff I see like the Intel Compute Stick are horribly underpowered compared to a decent laptop.
The original submission drew some interesting discussion. Another option is "a good x86/x64 tablet that I can install Linux on" -- especially with a decent processor -- or "laptop-like systems that got rid of the screen entirely... I just need the travel CPU part without the added weight of a second keyboard and monitor." So leave your best suggestions in the comments. Is there a good, lightweight computer that's battery-powered without a screen or a keyboard?
I've thought about buying a small box like a Zotac and trying to replace the hard drive with a battery -- but does anything like this already exist...? Also, are there any systems like this with decent specs? Most stuff I see like the Intel Compute Stick are horribly underpowered compared to a decent laptop.
The original submission drew some interesting discussion. Another option is "a good x86/x64 tablet that I can install Linux on" -- especially with a decent processor -- or "laptop-like systems that got rid of the screen entirely... I just need the travel CPU part without the added weight of a second keyboard and monitor." So leave your best suggestions in the comments. Is there a good, lightweight computer that's battery-powered without a screen or a keyboard?
raspberry pi and all its clones/derivatives. Add a USB battery extender pack. Done.
Liberty - Security - Laziness - Pick any two.
Intel Compute Stick + USB Power Bank
Jesus just buy a laptop dude.
It seems that your best solution is to install your OS into a surface/tablet with out a keyboard cover.
Why do you want to do this and what are you trying to accomplish?
One can buy laptops (i.e. Xps developer edition), chromebooks, tablets (iOS, windows and android), and smart phones that can offer you functionality in a portable form factor.
How do these existing options fall down when your needs come into play?
That's the first step to finding a solution rather than some hack job that "works but not really".
There's a nice section on barebones computers there
The screens and trackpads are so bad that not using them isn't a big loss.
OK, my earlier post I failed to notice the battery-powered requirement ... so ... Do you have an android phone (I'm guessing iOS would work too)? Why not use that? What are you trying to get done, anyhow?
Kangaroo PC http://www.kangaroo.cc/ makes a few products that might be relevant.
!st gen is on amazon for $50 and its USB powered so it will work with a phone extender battery pack. Sounds like everything you asked for.
Kangaroo Mobile Mini PC
Intel x5 z8500, internal battery
I have the smaller memory model and it gets hot but seems to be OK, the Plus model with more memory apparently has some heat issues according to the reviews.
I have Fedora 25 on it and I read somewhere it doesn't use the GPU for graphics, but it works fine for me in low demand uses.
The lack of GPU use might also be why I don't have the heat issues.
I can't get the sound out of the HDMI feed, but I think that will work eventually when the kernel gets enhanced.
I have plenty of common sense, I just choose to ignore it. -- Calvin
Updated ipads are around the corner and for very little money the kindle fire 8hd seem nice enough, certainly for many people though not if you want to develop etc on the move. They can work with bluetooth keyboards and pack decent power in a minimal space. When traveling I don t want the cable hassle of a sepeate screen and cpu, not to mention they have separate power supplies for longer use.
That sounds like something Casey Neistat wanted in the Samsung Dex: the ability to use it as a regular cellphone and then plug it into a docking station or PC to continue working on the cellphone.
https://youtu.be/uOFDmbUlrT4?t=101
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/03/samsung-dex-is-a-galaxy-s8-dock-that-makes-your-phone-into-a-desktop/
I'm looking for a similar device as the submitter. In my case I'll have a separate screen but I'd like something x86 that runs on batteries with automotive power. So when the vehicle starts the computer just keeps on going. It will essentially run most of the time, sleeping when I don't need it, or powering it off, perhaps with a signal. I need it to be x86 for now because of some software I need to run, so the Pi is out. VGA or HDMI out for the external touch screen. And I need at least two USB ports, or even better, a couple of real RS232 headers I can tap into (for GPS data and talking to an Arduino).
Even if I didn't need x86, the Pi doesn't quite cut it because there's no power management built into the thing. So far as I know it won't suspend or hibernate, or allow me to wake it on a timer like I can with x86 with a BIOS or EFI setting.
You should go with the 1802 membership card....
RCA 1802 w/ 16x16-bit registers, 16-bit address bus and 8-bit data bus
8 LED's and 8 toggle switches for bootstrapping and debugging
Bit-banged serial I/O
Low power consumption
Can even run BASIC
Might even survive the EMP of a nuclear blast if you choose the right components.
Rad-hardened CPU's available fairly cheap.
First microprocessor in space!
Just buy a Intel Nuc and a powerbank for it. It's even more modular than you wanted I guess, buy hey... Modular FTW!
The Raspberry PI would seem to meet your criteria. Battery powering one is as simple as a two cell Li-Ion battery and voltage regulator to bring the 7.4 volts down to 5.
You can wipe windows 10 and put linux on it. Have Mint on mine.
http://init.sh/?p=354
"Freedom in the USA is not the ability to do what you want. It is the ability to stop others from doing what THEY want"
Unfortunately, if you want a full fledged computer, you probably won't find anything smaller than a Zotac. That's the limitation of micro ATX boards basically. And then, unless you are very well versed in the dark arts of DIY electronics, it's gonna be very hard to make a battery work with a setup like that... Zotac and other microATX desktop PCs were not designed to work with batteries, but with a good power supply and AC.
Unless there's some ready made solution, afaik, the power motherboards, components and whatnot needs are very finnicky. Not only they need all sorts of voltages, the overall power draw is too much for batteries to handle.
If you don't mind having a lower powered desktop, I suggest looking for InFocus' Kangaroo PC. Packs an Intel Atom X5-Z8500 which is among the best you can get for the size, has an internal battery, and is the size of a smartphone only thicker. I have one. It's cheap too, around 100 something bucks.
http://www.kangaroo.cc/kangaro...
Problem is, it's still closer to Compute Stick than a laptop. And it's not getting better since Intel abandoned Atom.
Other options along the same line of Zotac is Intel NUC and... I think ASUS has some small boxes too. But they are all wall powered.
Last option might be just getting a laptop and taking the screen off I guess. :P I understand why some people want that, but apparently upscaling doesn't make much sense... you also need to understand that even though components on laptops might fit into a smaller form factor, the biggest part of a laptop ends up being the custom made batteries.
As for a tablet which you can install Linux on, I have a Dell Venue 11 Pro that originally came with Windows 8, installed Ubuntu on it, worked fine.
I'm also trying to force a Gole 1 ( http://www.gearbest.com/tv-box... ) to work with Linux but it has been a bit hard. I can force it to run Ubuntu, but neither wi-fi nor ethernet are working - you have to use an USB adaptor. Also, it seems the company used a smartphone touchscreen which doesn't flip orientation along with the screen. But likewise, the Gole 1 has an Atom CPU that is worse than the one inside the Kangaroo PC (Z83500). But it comes with a screen and a bunch of ports, Windows 10 and Android installed, at around double the price.
I'm not sure how compatibility goes, but there were some smaller tablets that ran Windows which I'm not sure if they'd work or not. Ubuntu also had their own smartphone and tablet, and I think they made a fork that worked with some of the Nexus devices... but I think the whole thing has been abandoned:
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Touch
Anyways, if you find out new stuff post here! I'm also interested.
Stuff like the Lenovo ideacenter are more mainstream/cheaper than Zotac. They also have an external power supply, meaning you can replace that with a 12v battery.
http://www.pcmag.com/feature/310878/lenovo-ideacentre-q190/4
But your biggest problem is the Intel requirement. You could stick a Debian ARM or Ubuntu ARM port onto a stock ARM TV box, they're a lot faster, a lot cheaper, a lot smaller and use a lot less power. I use them for all my new projects.
Move on, we have Smartphones like the S8 that can run full Office apps on a large screen now, its ridiculous to try to recreate that in homebrew.
It is a great little computer and does just what you asked. I have run windows 10 and Ubuntu Mate on it with little to no problem. Works great with a bluetooth keyboard and a hotel TV ?
Instead, you should have suggested that the dimwit purchase a tablet for around EUR 50.
is on this webpage. It's cheap.
Is There A Screen-Less, Keyboard-Less, Battery-Powered Computer?
Comment 1: Yes
Comment 2: No
Comment 3: Maybe
The comments should have been closed after this. Three comments. Not 46!! Well mine makes 47.
You'll probably need a portable generator to power it. But it's light, portable and powerful.
http://www.tomsguide.com/us/be...
Kangaroo, has battery power, can expand memory w/ microSD card up to 256GB. Runs windows 10 perfectly.
You can also buy extra docks, so you can leave the dock hooked up to monitor/mouse/peripherals, and just move the main computer box around.
http://www.kangaroo.cc/kangarooplus/
Sounds like the hipster assholes that go into restaurants with cameras from the 1890s and spend 30 minutes setting up to get a picture of $12 toast. Then they bitch about how the lighting sucks and they need suggestions on how to get the best shot to post in Instragram for their moms to see.
I got mine from the UDOO Kickstarter project. It was delayed but I have it now and it works great. Twice the size of a Raspberry PI. But with Intel x86 CPU (N3710 2.56 GHZ), 8 GB RAM, 128 GB M.2 SSD, Gigabit Ethernet, Wifi, Bluetooth and built in Arduino 101. Should be easy enough at add a battery (uses a 12V 3A power supply)
Kangaroo PC
2 GB RAM
32 Gig storage
Slot for MicroSD card
Room for a 2.5" HD/SSD (9.5MM)
4 hour battery
RJ-45, WiFi, Bluetooth Networking
VGA, HDMI video out
Fingerprint reader
Windows 10 OS included
Same physical size as a typical 2.5" USB HD
Ken
I haven't tried this myself, but from the specs it looks to be reasonable inexpensive, reasonably small and light, and reasonably powerful:
- Intel NUC (about 1 pound)
- fit-Uptime UPS for mini-PCs (about 0.5 pound and should power the NUC for maybe 1-3 hours on battery, depending on exact model of NUC etc)
Or a Lenovo Ideacentre stick. That way you have a "real" PC (as in x86 compatible).
Yes, there's no internal battery. Buy a USB battery bank, plug the stick into that. Add duct tape. Done.
Since battery life doesn't matter to you and seems form factor doesn't either.
I'm thinking your best bet would be to buy a NUC or similar (low watt i3/i5), rip it out of the case and tape it to the back of a GeChic portable monitor. Problem is findings a battery that's supplies 12v.
Alternately, find a second hand motherboard from a USB type-c powered laptop. There are plenty of power banks that can handle that.
Melania wouldn't know, she doesn't even sleep in the same house as me.
You can use a Intel Compute Stick for this, just add an external battery. https://www.newegg.com/Intel-Desktop-Computers/BrandSubCat/ID-1157-10
I use an anker battery model that is designed to re-charge USB devices, works great.
Comment removed based on user account deletion
You might look at a variation on a variation on the chromebook. I'm posting from a chromebook booting Mint from sd card and running entirely in memory. I also have a Asus C201 driving hdmi into my TV with wireless keyboard/mouse from my easy chair. Both are reasonably light and have respectable battery life.
I've been toying with the idea of grabbing a "chromebit" or "chromebox" to do similar things, but haven't really got a good "use case" to justify the purchase. These items lack the keyboard and screen, so all you'd need to sort out a battery power supply. Probably wouldn't do Windows, though.
Seriously, fuck this question.
Just get a laptop, and if you feel like using a travel keyboard along with it (for some reason), bring that along and plug that in to the USB slot. Just the idea of bringing a portable computer in a bag full of parts is weird. Not like hacker-weird, just like you needlessly fetishize your equipment.
There are no i5/i7 compute sticks that run off battery power.
Slashdot: providing anti-social weirdos a soapbox, since 1997.
Pencil and paper.
Maybe it's time to retire ask /.
Lately it seems that ask /. Is a section for retarded, non tech savvy people who also haven't figured out how to use a search engine.
I feel your pain here, sort of...
Having said that, speaking as someone who is, IMHO, tech savvy (about to dedicate a machine to run a PDP-10 emulator running FSM's own OS, TOPS-20...hey, no-one said the tech had to be current, did they?), there are some times when Googling something leaves you saying WTF? as the top 100 results on what you thought was an abstruse technical query end up being 7 lines of text which just more-or-less reiterate your query, albeit reworded, without answering it, surrounded by several MB of useless fucking graphics and javascript...so much noise, so little signal.
I quite understand why some people end up asking what appears, to some of you august geniuses here, to be an inane question, because they naturally assume that if they've had this idea, then someone else here must have gone down that road before and will share what they'd come up with as an answer. /. audience would be a bit more mature, and actually treat these things as serious queries, but, hey, no...seems that we're suffering an iteration of the 'Eternal September' here, instead of AOL, we've apparently attracted the attentions of people who're apparently /b/tards (failed)..or windows users..or, heaven forbid, windows admins...
You'd think the
Why the fuck is this idiots requirements so obscure? No screen and no keyboard?
Dude. Just buy a fucking tablet or laptop already.
Obscure? maybe for someone with limited experience..
OTOMH, I can conceive of a battery powered headless box doing remote/unattended data collection/equipment control/etc, with interactive access to said box for control/updates/data retrieval on site being via WLAN using whatever tablets/laptops/smartphones/whatever..
As you mention laptop there, and as someone else has also mentioned using a borked laptop for this, yes, looks like a good idea in theory, but if it fucks up, you've then got to find another borked laptop to hack, whereas things like the Raspberry Pi are readily and cheaply available and are 'drop in' replacements (not an endorsement for the Pi, BTW, just using it as an example).
[Captcha: drunken........That reminds me, I've a bottle of Ouzo chilling in the fridge.]
kk
I get good mileage from a NUC. Highly portable performant CPU module. Doesn't have battery option, but for me I'd only use it with power available. Myself, I use a laptop and ethernet cable to vnc into the NUC, however I can sometimes borrow monitors/keyboards, so I usually throw in an HDMI cable into my kitbag. You already have travel monitor/keyboard worked out so this might be an option for you, so long as you don't mind being tethered to power.
NewEgg has a Kangaroo PC. No screen or keyboard. Built in battery and mini dock with USB 2.0, USB 3.0, HDMI and power cord.
Did you look at the reviews? lots of mentions of battery issues...and this beast is fine so long as you want to run Win10, which, by inference '..I can carry my OS on a USB flash drive..', the original questioner doesn't.
If the original questioner hasn't abandoned ship, I'd suggest he Google 'fanless PCs' and take his pick, there's a lot of fun devices out there to choose from, depending on your application and how deep your pockets are....
There are batteries on sale on Amazon for brick computers, so I guess they exist.
https://learn.adafruit.com/7-hdmi-portable-monitor/overview
Check out Chinese gadgets, they have Intel machines with batteries the size of a cellphone, made to be portable. It's exactly what you want, I don't know brands though, there have also been a few on kickstarter or indieigogo.
Pipo might be brand and one that's like Geek____
It sounds as though you want to be talked out of buying a laptop.
I care about you too much to lie to you: the convenience of having a finished computer ready to use at a moment's notice will outweigh any other inconvenience that you perceive in the form factor.
You're a typical shit nerd. We Real People model our hardware/software solutions to accomodate the needs/wants of our life. You geeks shape your empty lives around cold technology. You have no goals, no taste for life. You only love unfeeling machines. And in the end you will hate everything because the best days of your existence are gone forever, wasted after hollow pursuits, in the endless wait for "something" to happen that would push you to the top. And guess what, that "something" never happened. It never will. Too late now. The pitiful remains of your improperly-called "life" waste away in solitude and misery. You never made it and you never will. Your days will end miserably, and your bloated corpse will be found one day after days of abandonment only because of the neighbours' complains about the smell. Your family will be spared the embarassing details of your passing, which will eventually leak. How terrible, how humiliating for the family who ended up shunning you like the rest of the world, to know that you died of a heart attack while masturbating at videos of underage japanese girls being tentacle-raped.
this would also allow your modular laptop to use the cell carriers data networks (if you bought a plan) and not just be limited to finding free wi-fi while on the go.
I need a wheelchair van for my son. Help me get the word out. https://www.gofundme.com/wheelchair-van-for-jj
Consider an NUC.
I bought my son a Skull Canyon NUC which is a full i7 6820HQ which I equipped with 32GB RAM and 1TB SSD. Not a cheap solution but great performance in something the size of a DVD case. There are similar and cheaper solutions with anything from a Celeron upwards.
Donte Alistair Anderson Roberts - hi son!
Karma: Chameleon
Amazon has fanless pcs running baytrail CPUs at 1.something GHz. They support msata and ddr3 ram. Good speeds, only $150 barebones. Runs on 12W so you could power from a battery pack for an hour. It's heavy for it's size tho, but comes with a plethora of connections
Minnowboard
Religion is what happens when nature strikes and groupthink goes wrong.
Backpack computers designed to provide a VR experience. They are battery powered and without screen or keyboard. But it is a high end PC for gaming. Probably not what you are looking for.
Stop worrying about the risks of nuclear power and start worrying about the risks of not using nuclear power.
"Battery powered monitor".
It also happens to contain the computer and it'll work with your travel keyboard.
And several of them are powerful enough to be your main machine.
One potential gotcha to think about- I'm not sure how many USB monitors require USB3. DisplayLink makes most of the chipsets, and their origins are in USB2 but I'm not sure how well their newest USB3 products do when attached to USB2.
There's the "is there enough data" question (but their DL2xxx chipsets did 1080P on USB2),
And there's the "is there enough power" question, since USB3 offers 80% more juice (0.9A vs 0.5A).
Also I've never heard of anyone try to compile DisplayLink's proprietary drivers on ARM, so more cross-your-fingers.
I suspect it *will* work but some potential gotchas to think about. Maybe you have a different idea for a portable monitor than me, dunno, but these USB powered things are what I think about.
It's not so much obscure as niche. I can point you to websites full of industrial PC that meet OPs specs and are hardened to IP 68 applications.. they are also $2k+ and use Pentium processors from the 2000's. But they're "industry standard" for industrial/civil engineering to do what you mentioned for remote access and harsh conditions.
Ever hear of google... geesh.
You can usually disassemble the LCD screen chassis. All you then need to do is remove the keyboard circuit board and you have a mobile computer that doesn't have a keyboard or screen.
A Chromebit or Chromebox as described here: http://www.androidcentral.com/... coupled with a portable Bluetooth or USB dongle-connected keyboard and mouse should work. We've been playing with these for signage but trying them out at home or at hotel rooms. They plug into HDMI TVs or monitors, and you can even install Ubuntu on them for a full stand-alone experience. (See https://www.reddit.com/r/chrom... for example.) Yes, you can find Windows alternatives, but what's the point?
I've seen a couple of mentions for the Intel NUC, but the Intel Compute Stick fits the bill better. Both Atom and Core mobile CPU options. Has a wall plug, but would work with a battery pack.
http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/compute-stick/intel-compute-stick.html
Even available with Linux preloaded.
https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIABRA4NG8682&ignorebbr=1&nm_mc=KNC-GoogleMKP-PC&cm_mmc=KNC-GoogleMKP-PC-_-pla-_-Desktop+PC-_-9SIABRA4NG8682&gclid=CMOBy6OLlNQCFd23wAodTqkBwA&gclsrc=aw.ds
Disclaimer: I work for Intel. But these are pretty cool.
It's basically a computer you wear on your back. It was designed for use with a VR headset as the screen, and as a result it's pretty powerful. So if you need x86, powerful GPU and battery, that's one way to go about it.
All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain... time... to... die...
Yes!!!!!!!
It's called a BRAIN.
How much CPU/Ram/GPU power do you want, top of the tree in battery powered computing would be VR backpack systems.
http://vr.msi.com/Backpacks/vrone
Also XMG and Zotac have one.
So far the most portable all-in-one computer I've seen that exists is the GPD Win. It's a pocket computer the size of a 3DS running Windows 10. It's got analog sticks on it and programmable buttons for gamers. Might also work with what you're looking for. It has a screen and a keyboard along the lines of an old smartphone's keyboard, but you don't have to use them as it has both an HDMI-out and bluetooth, so take that as you will.