Slashdot Mirror


Apple Announces New $299 iPad With Pencil Support For Schools (theverge.com)

At its education event in Chicago today, Apple introduced a refreshed 9.7-inch iPad with Apple Pencil support. "The updated iPad will be available in Apple stores today, in silver, space gray, and a new gold finish," reports The Verge. "The tablet will include Touch ID, an HD FaceTime camera, 10 hours of battery life, an 8-megapixel rear camera, LTE option, and Apple's A10 Fusion chip." From the report: Apple previously lowered the price of its 9.7-inch iPad last year, with a base model starting at $329, but today it's going a step further for students. Apple is offering the new iPad to schools priced at $299 and to consumers for $329. The optional Apple Pencil will be priced at $89 for schools and the regular $99 price for consumers. This is obviously not the $259 budget iPad pricing that was rumored, but it does make it a little more affordable to students and teachers. This new iPad will be a key addition to Apple's lineup as it seeks to fight back against Google's Chromebooks. Apple's iPads and Mac laptops reigned supreme in U.S. classrooms only five years ago, accounting for half of all mobile devices shipped to schools in 2013. Apple has now slipped behind both Google and Microsoft in U.S. schools, and Chromebooks are dominating classrooms with nearly 60 percent of shipments in the U.S. Apple had some other non-hardware, education-themed announcements at its event today. "Apple demonstrated Smart Annotation, which allows teachers to mark up reports in Pages directly, and the company promised new versions of its iWork apps like Pages, Numbers, and Keynote that support the Apple Pencil," reports The Verge. "Teachers will also be able to use Macs to create digital books for their classrooms, and Apple is building a books creator into the Pages app." The company also announced a new augmented reality app called Froggipedia that lets students virtually dissect frogs using an Apple Pencil. The free iCloud offering for students has also been bumped up from 5GB to 200GB.

141 comments

  1. Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    $89 for the Apple Pencil? If a student uses it, how easy is this thing to lose?

    1. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Chain them to the desks.

    2. Re: Pencil by b0s0z0ku · · Score: 1

      I lost pencils and pens all the time. Textbooks, not so much. Even if the book came back with a few more scratches, it was still usable by the next student.

    3. Re: Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You probably only lost them because they were cheap and you didnâ(TM)t care. If you had to buy special pencils that were $100 each I bet you would pay more attention. Or just pay.

    4. Re: Pencil by b0s0z0ku · · Score: 1

      No, I lost them because they were thin, my backpack often had holes, and they fell out. And they didn't make an audible "thump" when they fell out. Honestly, I wouldn't have been able to afford it, I'd have figured out how to "borrow" one from a rich/preppy student who bullied me :)

    5. Re: Pencil by pnutjam · · Score: 1

      No, a pencil is much easer to lose and more likely to stop working or be damaged.

    6. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm more interested in how many times you can sharpen it before it becomes just a nub and you have to buy a new one!

    7. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

      This is where Apple's problem lies. I was reading an article about the new ChromeOS tablet from Acer they announced yesterday, and while it may not be as nice a piece of hardware, they said something about the stylus being available to schools in bulk for reasonable cost.

      So long as the iPad requires a $90 stylus, they won't make any serious inroads in education.

    8. Re:Pencil by mspohr · · Score: 3, Informative

      Logitech has one for $49 for the iPad... also keyboard and case.
      https://www.macrumors.com/2018...

      --
      I don't read your sig. Why are you reading mine?
    9. Re:Pencil by PolygamousRanchKid+ · · Score: 1

      If a student uses it, how easy is this thing to lose?

      . . . or get stolen.

      Apple is going the printer cartridge and razor blade route on this one. They won't make any money on the pads, but will make a killing selling the replacement pencils . . . which seem to go M.I.A. regularly.

      --
      Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
    10. Re:Pencil by Paradise+Pete · · Score: 2

      So long as the iPad requires a $90 stylus

      It's not required at all. Fingers will work just fine. They've just added support for it.

    11. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The pencil is not required in any way, and will not normally be used by students. They've merely added support for it. You know how tablets work, right? The inability to think here is astounding sometimes.

    12. Re:Pencil by hcs_$reboot · · Score: 0

      $89 for the Apple Pencil

      How to find out if an Apple product is overpriced? Check if the last digit is a '9'.

      --
      Slashdot, fix the reply notifications... You won't get away with it...
    13. Re:Pencil by rtb61 · · Score: 1

      Fingers on a keyboard and mouse work fine, tapping on a screen is stupidly slow. Going to give children computers in school, then they had better be creating lots of content on those computers ie notebooks with keyboards and trackpads, else you will just grind out empty consumers of content. It might feed Apple's bottom line but they know better and are very corrupt for pushing content consuming tablets rather than content creating notebooks. Students using computers should produce more content not less.

      --
      Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
    14. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Normally not used? maybe in this case because of stylus expense, or presumably most apps not being made to use it. But, this is the second ~$300 tablet in a row with high specs, 2048x1536 and a likely low latency advanced pen. This might be a game changer for pen computing.
      For me, I'd love to write in cursive on it (because as a French guy, that's the only way we know how to handwrite). Or maybe I'd learn some form of stenography, being that an application can teach it me and another could translate it to finished text.
      And more generally, free form writing and drawing (like, when you learn graph theory or project managing in higher education, etc.)

      For the kids? Math and geometry are a thing too, even in elementary and middle school.

      Now maybe I don't want an ipad (foremost I don't want a Chromebook, although political/social reasons aside I would maybe jump on that Chromebook tablet) and the ideal tablet would have dual USB (one for charging and one for USB drive! or keyboard and mouse, and so on) and run.. some OS that runs programs. Otherwise, I think I've always wanted a pen tablet, it's mostly been rare or $1000 and more (surface pro, recently ipad pro), expensive and tiny (samsung note 2, etc.) or there were toys in the 90s (Newton, Windows 3.1 tablets) that were irrelevant. So, over 90% people never really used a pen tablet yet.

    15. Re:Pencil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      LOL "They won't make any money on the pads" apple overcharges for everything.

  2. Little late there, Apple by Locke2005 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    My daughter's school already switched from having a few iPads to issuing literally every student in the school their own Chromebook. Google's web-based office tools are okay, and probably the only option on something with only 32G of memory.

    --
    I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
    1. Re:Little late there, Apple by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 5, Insightful

      32GB of memory? Holy cow, that's four times the RAM in my gaming PC!

      Oh, you meant 32GB of storage.

      What happened to Slashdot? I thought this was a website for nerds.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    2. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2

      What happened to Slashdot? I thought this was a website for nerds.

      He was born in 2005. Have you seen the "what's a computer" commercial? He is the goblin child.

    3. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I know the difference between storage and memory, but what I don't understand is why we are using male sheep for devices. I am surprised PITA has not complained about shoving these rams into tablets and computers and laptops.

    4. Re:Little late there, Apple by Mr+D+from+63 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The tablet form factor is not as useful in education as the notebook form factor.

      My kids schools use Chromebooks and they are used all the time. Kids need to be able type up reports, do research, move files, etc. No tablet is good for that. Keyboard and mouse/mouspad are the right tools for that job.

      IPads make great PR though.

    5. Re:Little late there, Apple by ITapeFatCashews · · Score: 0

      The creimertards took over and turned Slashdot into a Uber locker room.

    6. Re:Little late there, Apple by sjbe · · Score: 2

      What happened to Slashdot? I thought this was a website for nerds.

      FAR too many of them have left. Slashdot doesn't have much geek cred left.

    7. Re: Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So garbage. You send your child to school that makes them work with criminal tools in order to teach them what? Privacy is something to complain about, but it isnâ(TM)t worth actually paying for? If your going to have technology in the classroom do not waste your neighbors money on disposable data miners. Show kids that quality is worth paying for, and not having respect for tools will cost them personally. Not having technology would be far better than teaching kids to use google documents and the rest of that trash.

    8. Re:Little late there, Apple by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 1

      People can have gaming PCs that are not expensive nor cutting edge. Not everyone plays the shiny crap games with no actual content.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    9. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's rich from a guy who discusses child brides and ladyboys with co-workers in the middle of a workplace datacenter.
      I guess it's not bad if you're talking about exploiting people without enough agency to even consider complaining about their situation?
      Please help me understand the nuance here.

    10. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Creimer left Slashdot for YouTube. I know that hurts, Ivan. Please give up your creimer fixation and stop harassing the Slashdot community.

    11. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And here they are, running ads with a dumb kid that has no f'ing clue what a "computer" is.

    12. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Creimer has advocated changing the marriage laws of the United States to that of the Philippines: no marriages under 18, pararental consent from 18 to 21 and parental notification between 21 and 25.

      Do you support creimer's position or are you a pedophile?

    13. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Some are still here, just can't be bothered to post.

    14. Re:Little late there, Apple by rogoshen1 · · Score: 1

      you know, just because a game is shiny, doesn't mean it's devoid of content.

      (Looking at you Witcher 3)

      But, why limit yourself? especially since RAM is so cheap these days, and a good video card remains relevant for about 4 years.

    15. Re:Little late there, Apple by DRJlaw · · Score: 1

      32GB of memory? Holy cow, that's four times the RAM in my gaming PC!

      Oh, you meant 32GB of storage.

      What happened to Slashdot? I thought this was a website for nerds.

      Yeah, nerds who remember that memory is not limited to dynamic random access memory, but includes storage technologies like bubble memory. I mean, it's cute that you've recognized the distinction between immediate use memory and secondary storage, but us oldsters remember that "memory" used to be really weird and the flash storage of today is far better than the memory of old.

      God help you if iOS is ever changed to support optane-like technologies. Your head may explode.

    16. Re:Little late there, Apple by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 2

      Quad-core i5, 8GB RAM, GTX650. It's adequate for the games I play.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    17. Re: Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      PETA.

    18. Re: Little late there, Apple by Brockmire · · Score: 1

      Wtf? RAM is expensive. I was buying 32GB DDR3 kits for $90-110 years ago when RAM industry fucked itself. The current price for DDR4 is high and will come down later this year. Not that low, but lower than now.

    19. Re:Little late there, Apple by geek · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I took all the geek cred

    20. Re:Little late there, Apple by Joce640k · · Score: 2

      My pita never complained about pieces of dead sheep being inserted.

      --
      No sig today...
    21. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, Apple really messed up on the education field. Our large school district (25000) students looked at ipads when we started our 1:1 phase. That was back 5 years ago. Apple never really had an enterprise management system to easily manage that many devices. They relied on 3rd party vendor software that were cumbersome. Now they are noticing how big the education market is and are starting to get into it, but too late. Google did it right with their own management tool for their chrome devices. Managing chromebooks in an enterprise environment is so easy that any sites replacing Windows PCs with chromebooks will probably cast off a bunch of IT workers.

    22. Re:Little late there, Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      apples target market. the technically ignorant.

    23. Re:Little late there, Apple by Locke2005 · · Score: 1

      I'm old enough to remember when the only memory was magnetic cores threaded on wires... which was non-volatile, by the way.

      --
      I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
    24. Re:Little late there, Apple by inking · · Score: 1

      I very much disagree. When I was in high school, my backpack was stuffed with 300+ page thick paper books literally every single day. Maths, chemistry, biology. Those books have done irreparable damage to my back that I am making up for by staying healthy now, but will probably suffer from nonetheless once I get older.

      Working through a book on a laptop sucks. There are no two ways about it. An iPad coupled with something like LiquidText for reading and annotating and Notability for notes is godsend. This far outweighs the fact that the keyboard is a separate device and that moving files is a little different than it is on desktops.

      I think the biggest disadvantage is that you do get accustomed to this tablet way of doing things, which means that students wouldn’t be all that great with desktops once they do need them.

  3. Less than 10% discount??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Less than 10% discount??? For other brands that wouldn't even register as a mention, never mind a headline!
    And a $89 stylus... Nice...

    1. Re:Less than 10% discount??? by supremebob · · Score: 2

      Apple has always offered a 10% education discount on most of their hardware. I'm not sure why they are trying to hype this up like it's something new.

    2. Re:Less than 10% discount??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They should be selling these things at cost. Maybe at that price point they could stop their shrinking sales to education. I doubt it would make a difference because it would require cloud based apps and sharing, which Apple has not shown any interest.

  4. iCloud Storage by SeaFox · · Score: 3

    The free iCloud offering for students has also been bumped up from 5GB to 200GB.

    How about you get with the times and give that to everyone, Apple?

    1. Re:iCloud Storage by torkus · · Score: 4, Interesting

      lol seriously

      5GB is small enough to active discourage people from using it to back up their media vs other services that don't even lock you in but give you far more (or unlimited) free storage.

      Besides that, a $90 stylus that (unless apple forgot to announce it) has no way to attach to the ipad is overpriced and far too easily lost. How well do they really think that will go over? Once again, they ensure no one will use it.

      That's not even taking into account the fact that it's almost 1/3 of the cost for the iPad itself!! They're (badly) trying to pad the margin with another crappy accessory. Instead, a chromebook with an actual keyboard...yep.

      --
      You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
    2. Re:iCloud Storage by pnutjam · · Score: 1

      My kids school uses Ipads, so this is interesting to me. Although their icloud account was 25GB, which fills up from one backup. I was looking at using this to back them up when they turn them in this year. We rent them from the school.

      My biggest complaint is that we have to lie about our kids ages. You can't create a child account without an existing apple product to manage from, there is no ability to manage from a website.
      The school 'could' create child accounts, but they won't participate in the program for some reason. I spent a good two months trying to figure out why and complaining about the necessity to create a 13+ year old account for my six year old.

    3. Re:iCloud Storage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Besides that, a $90 stylus

      Jesus fucking christ, it's not a stylus. It's not required nor is it typically used. It's a specialized for of input available for those tasks that can benefit from it, such as art work.

    4. Re: iCloud Storage by Brockmire · · Score: 1

      You didn't catch any of the recent articles on how Apple is bad at backend and scaling stuff?

    5. Re:iCloud Storage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Apple sold over 200 million iPhones last year alone. You think it's reasonable to demand that they bring 40 exabytes of additional storage online every year and give it away for free in perpetuity? This isn't your home PC storage we're talking about where you can just order a Seagate off Amazon. You physically cannot buy that amount of storage even if you wanted to without working with hard drive manufacturers to put a plan in place for them to produce that amount of storage over a long period of time.

    6. Re:iCloud Storage by RazorSharp · · Score: 2

      The free iCloud offering for students has also been bumped up from 5GB to 200GB.

      How about you get with the times and give that to everyone, Apple?

      The upgrade is fairly cheap.

      --
      "From the depths of my skeptical and rationalist soul, I ask the Lord to protect me from California touchie-feeliedom."
    7. Re:iCloud Storage by Waccoon · · Score: 1

      Once again, they ensure no one will use it.

      Unless the school requires it.

      Even 20 years ago when I was in college, it was mandatory that we buy Apple computers for the school offices. The school would not allow us to buy anything else. I hated being responsible for ordering new computers for the campus newspaper office, since everyone hated them, but school policy is still policy.

  5. Very Easy to Lose by Roger+W+Moore · · Score: 2

    If it is like the current models then it has no means of attachment to the iPad when not in use.

  6. Strict education by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Good if you want a tablet that gets in the way of being used the way the student wants. Rather than have Apple approve every PDF I want to read on my tablet I just use my Android phone to read them off the memory card. Too simple for school.

    1. Re: Strict education by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What are you talking about? Apple doesnâ(TM)t care what PDFs you read

    2. Re: Strict education by Brockmire · · Score: 1

      I think that's a dig at the lack of external storage and the hassle of getting content onto an iPad that is a basic fucking download for anyone else.

  7. What a waste. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hopefully school districts spend their money on more teachers instead of toys.

  8. To quote someone famous by Lucas123 · · Score: 4, Funny

    "If you see a stylus, they blew it.” - Steve Jobs, 2010

    1. Re:To quote someone famous by supernova87a · · Score: 3, Informative

      Yeah, I think he meant if the primary UI requires a stylus then it sucks. This, supposedly, is turning an iPad into a *more* useful drawing, editing tool.

    2. Re:To quote someone famous by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not a stylus, it's a pen, you inconsiderate clod.

    3. Re:To quote someone famous by RazorSharp · · Score: 1

      "If you see a stylus, they blew it.” - Steve Jobs, 2010

      Jobs also didn't have any problem contradicting himself. If I remember correctly, he disparaged the whole idea of a tablet in the years leading up to the iPad's release. For years he was hypercritical of two-button mice, even though Mac OS supported right-click functions and eventually Apple released their own version of a two-button mouse. x86 was supposedly the antiquated, no-good cheap option until it wasn't.

      I think the opinions of Steve Jobs were always relative to the exact time he expressed them. His opinion one day had no bearing on his opinion the next day. Touch screen technology has changed quite a bit since he made that statement, making the utility of a stylus today much different than it was in 2010.

      Also, Jobs's opinions depended on what products Apple had on the market that day.

      --
      "From the depths of my skeptical and rationalist soul, I ask the Lord to protect me from California touchie-feeliedom."
    4. Re:To quote someone famous by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Context matters and that statement was in reference to a mobile phone.

  9. get em when they are young by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    before they are able to realize that the walls of the garden are to keep them in.

    One would think that the last place that we should allow corporate influence is in education, but i guess what is the alternative when we allow our politicians to constantly cut the budgets on one of the few investments that always pays off in the future.

  10. #2 Pencil support by jfdavis668 · · Score: 2

    Comes with a built in sharpener.

    1. Re:#2 Pencil support by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not from apple; there will be a sharpener dongle for 89$

  11. Vendor lock-in by fred6666 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Schools should not invest in an eco system with a single vendor for both hardware and software while there are more open alternatives. This is especially true for public schools, which shouldn't be allowed to enter such a high level of vendor lock-in.

  12. What more Apple stuff will need to be purchased? by Streetlight · · Score: 1

    Does this mean every teacher will need a school purchased $2,000 to $3,000 iMac computer with specialized software to interface to these new iPads? Will the schools also need additional school system purchased Apple specific centralized server hardware and software for all these iPads to do their job? There could be additional overhead I haven't thought of.

    --
    In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell
  13. ClassKit API by atomicalgebra · · Score: 2

    Apple also announced ClassKit api in order to integrate educational software into schools.

  14. Re:What more Apple stuff will need to be purchased by b0s0z0ku · · Score: 1

    No, how about a $500 Mac Mini? :)

  15. Apples still used in schools? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As of late, Chromebook seems to be the computer of choice for schools. They're mil-spec and cheap.

    1. Re:Apples still used in schools? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What is cheap is off lease business machines that can be had in the 150-200 range.

    2. Re: Apples still used in schools? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The military lets google spy on them?

  16. And while the pen technology is interesting... by magusxxx · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...there still being no update to their 2014 Mac Mini is not. *grumble*

    --
    Care killed the cat, but satisfaction brought it back.
    1. Re:And while the pen technology is interesting... by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 2

      Surely you meant there's still no update to the 2012 Mac mini, because 2014 was a downgrade.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    2. Re:And while the pen technology is interesting... by magusxxx · · Score: 1

      Agreed. BTW...typing this on my 2012 Mac Mini. :D

      --
      Care killed the cat, but satisfaction brought it back.
    3. Re:And while the pen technology is interesting... by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 1

      Your 2012 is still way faster than my 2010.

      At least I was able to upgrade it to 16GB RAM a few years later, unlike the new models.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    4. Re:And while the pen technology is interesting... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Or the 2015 iPad mini

      Captcha: senior

    5. Re:And while the pen technology is interesting... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Or the Mac Pro. It is telling when it takes a company years to come out with an updated workstation while the competition can do it in 6 months.

  17. Re:Little late there, Apple water by mickrussom by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I always flush before using the toilet.

    The routine is generally:
    1) Flush before use.
    2) Wipe any splashes off before papering.
    3) Use paper or seat cover if public.
    4) Use paper to create a shield to keep the wang from touching the bowl in front if public.
    5) Sit and defecate. Generally for each piece of feces I flush, I also flush out urine. Pretty much anything hits the water flush.
    6) While waiting I tend to flush while idle to keep the pipes clean.
    7) Wipe with 10-15 flushable wipes. Flush every 4-5 wipes. Keep flushable-wiping until all stains are gone from all angles (front back, back front, leg up, etc).
    8) Flush at least one extra time as flushable wipes can sometimes clump up.

    I also sometimes rig the toilet to continuously flush to clean it.

    I also like to urinate into running water, so I tend to pee into sinks that have running water. This way I ensure the best flow characteristics.

    I promise to waste water as much as I can because I have unmetered water. I promise. This is to force our stupid scum government who lets half of Mexico show up here on our dime to build new infrastructure rather than have me live Amish style because they are stupid morons who cant plan ahead. I leave the toilet rigged on, shower , a tub and 2 sinks on all the time to protest our stupid government.

    Mick mickrussom Russom

  18. Why Apple Pencil sucks by sjbe · · Score: 4, Informative

    Besides that, a $90 stylus that (unless apple forgot to announce it) has no way to attach to the ipad is overpriced and far too easily lost. How well do they really think that will go over? Once again, they ensure no one will use it.

    Yeah I have several problems it the Apple Pencil.
    1) Round so it easily rolls off tables if you set it down. They made it pretty instead of functional.
    2) The iPad isn't designed with a place to store it when not in use rendering it clumsy to transport
    3) Unless you are a fairly specific kind of artist (I'm not) the app support SUCKS. I'm an engineer and I can conceive of lots of uses for something like this but Apple isn't making it easy.
    4) Far too expensive for something that is easy to loose and can't be stored easily
    5) Did I mention the apps SUCK. Even for note taking which should be the most obvious thing in the world.

    I also have beef with the iPads for similar reasons
    1) Why are the icons stored in the same spacing as on an iPhone with WAY too much space in between
    2) The apps are either redundant to my iPhone or SUCK for anything more useful like taking notes or doing engineering.
    3) The cases are annoying and by and large suck. I really don't like the most common cases and Apple clearly thinks of cases and keyboards as an afterthought at best.

    I'd love to get something like an iPad but they simply haven't bothered to work on anything that is a viable use case for me. They just supersized my iPhone and didn't really bother to take advantage of the larger form factor in any serious way.

    1. Re:Why Apple Pencil sucks by jdavidb · · Score: 1

      For a little more than the price of two Apple pencil styluses, I can get two Amazon Fire tablets, which would be so much more useful for me and my family.

  19. Easier said than done by sjbe · · Score: 1

    Schools should not invest in an eco system with a single vendor for both hardware and software while there are more open alternatives.

    You mean like Microsoft + Intel? In principle I agree with you but good luck getting a practical setup without a substantial amount of vendor lock in.

    1. Re:Easier said than done by fred6666 · · Score: 1

      I agree it's hard, but it doesn't mean they should pick the absolute worst. Apple is the top in vendor lock-in.
      Either Windows PCs or chromebooks are a lot less locked-in since you can always purchase hardware from another manufacturer while keeping the same OS. Any school manager deciding to buy Apple products should be fired.
      Ideally, schools should also favor the purchasing of applications which are cross platform. So an iOS only application should be banned.

      If you want to vendor lock-in yourself or your family go for it. You'll have only yourself to blame if you are unable to switch away from Apple in a few years if you don't like their new products or the price increases. But schools should not force that vendor lock-in to students, and not use tax payer's money to dig a vendor lock-in hole.

    2. Re:Easier said than done by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How many Google Chromebook apps work on non-Google hardware? The biggest issue against ChromeBooks (out side of the fact that is spyware by design) is the fact that you are teaching using mediocre tools that aren't use in real life.

    3. Re:Easier said than done by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sorry, that was software/OS not hardware

    4. Re: Easier said than done by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not just schools using web based tools. A lot of businesses have been switching to Chromebooks, because they're absolutely sufficient for what 90% of users need, but they're much easier to administer. IT costs and frustration go down a lot.

    5. Re:Easier said than done by fred6666 · · Score: 1

      Most chromebook apps work on Google Chrome web browser on any platform (not just Google OS), and some even work in other browsers.

    6. Re:Easier said than done by RazorSharp · · Score: 1

      Schools should not invest in an eco system with a single vendor for both hardware and software while there are more open alternatives.

      You mean like Microsoft + Intel? In principle I agree with you but good luck getting a practical setup without a substantial amount of vendor lock in.

      It's possible, but it would require federal $$$ to make it happen.

      --
      "From the depths of my skeptical and rationalist soul, I ask the Lord to protect me from California touchie-feeliedom."
    7. Re:Easier said than done by inking · · Score: 1

      That’s funny, I switched from Android to WP to iOS just. Before that I switched from Windows to Linux and back just fine too. Must be some really terrible lock-in you have there if it’s causing you that much trouble.

    8. Re:Easier said than done by fred6666 · · Score: 1

      switching for a single user is much easier than for an organization. Also you may not have locked-in yourself too badly if you didn't purchase apps and tons of accessories. However you are now on iOS so let me know when you successfully switch back to something else.
      Hint: don't use any of the Apple services (mail/calendar/music/photos)

    9. Re:Easier said than done by inking · · Score: 1

      AFAIK, most schools don’t really on the Apple’s backend. It’s not very good.

  20. Re:Little late there, Apple water by mickrussom by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    lol, nice way to get water revenge there

  21. Yea no by eclectro · · Score: 1

    Whatever happened to regular pencils and paper and having a computer lab for students? As a taxpayer do I really need outfit the marxists in training with every electronic gadget there is??

    Guess what, you can do math without an ipad using just a pencil, paper, and maybe a $15 calculator. For wordprocessing, that's what a computer lab is for.

    --
    Take the cheese to sickbay, the doctor should see it as soon as possible - B'Elanna Torres, "Learning Curve"
    1. Re: Yea no by Brockmire · · Score: 2

      I was very depressed when my 13 year old nephew didn't know what handwriting looked like. "What language is that?" "Fuck man, that IS English".

    2. Re:Yea no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Right, but we're preparing students for a future where they use these skills in a modern setting, not the 1970s.

    3. Re: Yea no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cursive is useless in the 21st century. I am 50 and it has been over 20 years since I have handwritten anything. I can barely sign my name and it changes every time I do sign something. The thing I used to sign regularly was a check but I rarely use them; a box can easily last me a decade.

    4. Re: Yea no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I guess you must mean cursive. We got taught cursive in school only to be told to print everything once in college.

  22. This is a refresh, not a price cut. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The consumer price for the iPad is still $329 and $99 for the pencil. The school discount is incredibly minor.

    For $350, you can buy an Acer laptop with i3-7100U, 1 terabyte of storage, and 1080P, 15.6" screen.

    Chromebooks are fine too, but they seem best if managed by a company/school. It's not something I'd necessarily recommend for consumers.

  23. When a stylus is useful by sjbe · · Score: 2

    "If you see a stylus, they blew it.” - Steve Jobs, 2010

    Yeah he said it. But the reality is that a stylus is fine PROVIDED it isn't used like a mouse. A stylus should be used for drawing only. And drawing letters for note taking falls into that category. Just drawing because that is all it is good for. If you couldn't do it with a real pencil then you shouldn't be able to do it with a stylus as a general proposition. The problem with them tends to be that application developers easily forget this and get tempted into using a stylus like a mouse (or worse a keyboard) and that NEVER works well.

    A stylus can be hugely useful on a computer. I'd LOVE something that could be useful for taking notes and annotating documents digitally. But so far that corner of the market has been ignored and Apple is chasing a tiny group of artists and designers instead of the huge market for students and professionals.

  24. No by Comboman · · Score: 1

    No, kids loose pencils because they are very small in two of their three dimensions, meaning they can slip through a tiny hole in a pocket or backpack or even pencil-case (the thing specifically designed to store them). To make matters worse, they are also round (a design flaw Apple could have fixed but didn't) so that when they are inevitably dropped, they will roll away and roll under things or into cracks between things or down more holes.

    --
    Support Right To Repair Legislation.
    1. Re: No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ah yes, Apple deliberately made it cylindrical so people would lose them more often. Right.

    2. Re: No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Of course apple did, they could not even copy a #2 pencil properly

  25. Neither by Comboman · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Neither, they're going to spend the money buying assault rifles and weapons training for teachers. Because there's no way that could go wrong.

    --
    Support Right To Repair Legislation.
  26. Re:Goodbye android and chromeos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Enjoy your new bug ridden system.

  27. As opposed to... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A license for what windows, plus client licenses, plus server licences, plus client access licenses, plus directory services licenses and more!

  28. Now if they would fix their parental restrictictio by e3m4n · · Score: 2, Informative

    Unfortunately Apple is still way behind the ball on the granular parental restrictions that Android offers if they want to compete. The exact same parental nanny application, FamilyTime.io, on an Android, not only lets me set schedules for when my child can use their applications, but it will let me specify exactly WHICH apps they are allowed to use and which ones they are not during those schedules. On IOS my options include : Safari, Camera, Siri Dictation, iTunes Store, in-app purchases, and ---> ALL OTHER APPS. This means that if my child needs access to lets say the 'Remind' app, during school hours, I also have to give the child access to text messaging, skype, games, and another other stupid shit they happen to have just because the teachers heavily use 'Infinite Campus', and 'Remind' for academia. Whereas the _exact_same_ utility on Android lets me literally say yes/no to every installed app on the device. Many comunication with the developer indicate the fault lies DIRECTLY with APPLE.

  29. Much as anyone... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Who buys Microsoft should be fired. Way too much lock in.

  30. My 99 cent pad by rsilvergun · · Score: 1

    has had full pencil support for decades. Maybe longer. Anyone know when they pencil was invented?

    --
    Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
  31. a $300 dollar boondoggle, fantastic. by rogoshen1 · · Score: 1

    in the days of budget cuts and atrocious test scores; i'm really really glad apple is still able to get people to think their technology in the classroom is anything beyond a mixture of corporate welfare and advertising.

    The line of thought seems to be "STEM STEM STEM! if we get the kids using technology they'll be the next generation of tech gods!"

    But really, these are just tablets. And certainly don't represent much of an improvement over books, pencil, and paper. When it comes to you know, learning.

    Which is what they should be focusing on. Drop the common core bullshit, stop teaching to standardized tests, and let kids fail from time to time.

    The kids aren't creating a damn thing -- just being trained to consume content.

  32. What a strange world... by TimMD909 · · Score: 2

    The world has changed. Apple is now trying to do what Microsoft did 20 years ago. Unfortunately for Apple, you can't get the next generation hooked on your goods if they're not good enough and not the right price. Add in issues getting affordable software into their damned walled garden, and I'm completely confused as to why Apple would even go down this road.

    Maybe all the C* levels doing Himalayan amounts of cocaine while their engineers routinely micro-dose on acid is the explanation...

    From what I'm seeing, the price is still 2x-3x too high for giving to kids. Kids break shit all the time. Unless the iPads are completely indestructible, $300 will quickly turn into $900 after the inevitable third time the kid drops it from a height of only 0.5 meters. A better price point is $100-$150 in which the Chromebooks dominate.

    And as others have said here, tablets aren't that useful for anything more than casual use (like reading an ebook, watching YouTube while taking a shit, and shit-posting on your favorite social media). If you want your kid to actually be doing research, writing up papers, and doing homework, tablets are not the device to use.

    1. Re:What a strange world... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The world has changed. Apple is now trying to do what Microsoft did 20 years ago.

      What was the Macintosh Classic (1990) then?

      We had those at my primary school.

  33. LOL by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    This is supposed to be apples Chromebook-killer?
    What a half ass attempt.

  34. More trouble for Android by guacamole · · Score: 1

    So Apple almost owns the entire space for tablets costing 300USD or more. Amazon sells very very cheap tablets for 50-150USD. Within these tight brackets there exists very little room for Android tablets to exist and strive. If you look at what Samsung offers for the 200-300, it's only the ancient Tab A products.

    1. Re:More trouble for Android by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fire tablets are a customized version of Android (I believe they can run the same apps), so they technically should count.

      But it doesn't matter. Above $300 is laptop territory. Anyone with a brain will buy that instead of a tablet. Microsoft does provide updates for quite a while, unlike Android, and there's a large ecosystem of software that even iOS doesn't have.

      There are 2-in-1 Windows laptops that can double as a tablet if someone is really desperate for one.

  35. Apple has shown it's never too late... by SuperKendall · · Score: 0

    My daughter's school already switched from having a few iPads to issuing literally every student in the school their own Chromebook.

    Those must be amazing Chromebooks if they last for all eternity, for every student coming in!

    What's that? Eventually the school could shift to something else again, the way they did to Chromebooks? HMM.

    I'm sure the Chromebooks are fine, but they wouldn't be as useful to students as an iPad with a Pencil, and I'm pretty sure not as durable.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
    1. Re:Apple has shown it's never too late... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      "I'm sure the Chromebooks are fine, but they wouldn't be as useful to students as an iPad with a Pencil, and I'm pretty sure not as durable."

      Right on the first, wrong on the second, and on the third, the chromebooks are much cheaper than the cheapest tablet and trivially replaceable. When you forget your chromebook, someone can hand you another and -- boom -- you're back in business.

      Chromebooks are way easier to adminster en mass, and so cost less for labor.

      iPads are a phenomenally bad choice for schools compared to chromebooks.

    2. Re: Apple has shown it's never too late... by Brockmire · · Score: 1

      Durable? When did this happen? I hear of Apple shit breaking for looking at it the wrong way all the time.

    3. Re: Apple has shown it's never too late... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've tossed my Macbook Air in my backpack for three years, no case, and have had zero problems.

    4. Re:Apple has shown it's never too late... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Chromebooks are probably easier to repair as well. Most I've seen are just like laptops in that you can remove screws to open the case. Basic repairs could be down in-house or by virtually any repair store. Every tablet I've seen is a chore to open.

      Add the fact that clamshell laptops are inherently better protected (since there's screens aren't exposed to potential hazards), and you have a recipe for devices that will outlast a tablet no problem.

  36. GOOD! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Mediocre tools? GOOD! Why in God's name would you spend time teaching kids to use complex word processors? You're supposed to be teaching them to WRITE, not use whistles and bells which will change on every release.

  37. Yea ... but by waspleg · · Score: 2

    Google has been caught repeatedly spying on kids. and no one gives a fuck because they're cheap. Privacy was never even an issue which came up. I work in K-12. Cheap > * It's fucking sad to see kids with such limited locked in walled garden devices and not real computers, especially the federal free lunch crowd we serve (i.e. poor as fuck). They're extremely limited (even more so because Enterprise enrolled) and they don't even know it.

    We're paying ~$235 per HP G4 Chromebook, having said that there are schools in my district whose principals like their Kool-Aid Apple flavored and they will spend anything to look cool.

    At least in Education, technology is a fashion. Right now Google is in style.

    1. Re:Yea ... but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's fucking sad to see kids with such limited locked in walled garden devices and not real computers

      Why? Seriously, why? I'm a teacher, and the #1 step to everything is "load up the web browser." Nobody is using proprietary software, so really the OS or hardware being used is a complete non-issue as long as it doesn't get in the way.

      The last year, I kept a $100 Kangaroo Windows PC and an old computer running Ubuntu in the corner of my English classroom, and the class had access to Chromebook carts. The computer being used was a complete non-issue to the class, even to high school students who couldn't tell you what Linux even was.

      That said, this iPad is a non-starter for schools because it doesn't come with a keyboard, when obviously the whole idea is that students enter lots of information. I would love it if Apple released like a 2014 Macbook Air at school-level prices, but that will never happen.

    2. Re:Yea ... but by waspleg · · Score: 2

      At least for me, the primary reason I work in IT is because my elementary school was an IBM guinea pig and I was given a PS/2 which was in my bedroom at home.

      When I was supposed to be asleep I was figuring out how to load games from a command line. I was one of maybe 2 kids in the entire grade who could actually get "online" (Prodigy) because I figured it out myself. I was 9.

      Thirty years later all they're given are web browsers as operating systems which spy on everything you do or tablet toys (iPads). Even our virtual machine labs were better than this, at least they had an OS someone could look at it if so inclined and could run custom software some of which for creative purposes such as autocad/adobe suite/blender, etc.

      But no one cares, these are cheaper, they're locked the fuck down - you can do nothing at all that isn't explicitly allowed. Why? Mostly because their REAL primary uses are as babysitters and testing consoles not learning.

      What we have don't even support Android applications so it's limited to the Chrome OS "Store" which has about much useful shit in it as your average Windows phone.

    3. Re:Yea ... but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The issue is the support costs of making these linux desktops or windows desktops and or mac desktops. People want the students to have real computers and to have a good experience, but the amount of tech support and costs associated with that that keeps it from being affordable. If there was no support involved with Win 10, or OSX then they would be more pervasive in schools.

    4. Re:Yea ... but by waspleg · · Score: 2

      I literally am that support. It's not as expensive as all the outsourcing and bonuses to the top. Our district has annual budget in the hundreds of millions of dollars and waste plenty on spurious bullshit like new furniture for managers.

      We've outsourced our help desk which has a quarter of the skill at 3 times the price. The same for FMLA "management", vehicle repairs, transportation, and other departments which are constantly under the gun in this privatize everything race to the bottom loot everything for corporate cronies "I got mines" and fuck the public good culture. Betsy DeVos love us (no joke). I hope your district is better.

    5. Re:Yea ... but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So what? You're living in the tech world of 1997. Students can do basically whatever they want inside a web browser, and all the student tech runs from inside a web browser, so why is OS usage sacred?

      It's not babysitting, students load up Google Docs to write reports or they research shit online or they use educational software or they do standardized tests. It's real-life skills that are done fine within a web browser.

  38. kids break things by xeoron · · Score: 1

    Chromebooks are easy to repair, while ipads are not!

  39. inroads in education where is loans and the schoo by Joe_Dragon · · Score: 1

    inroads in education where is loans and the school can force you to buy them just like with text books.

  40. does apple have an rackmount server or vm rights by Joe_Dragon · · Score: 1

    does apple have an rack mount server or vm rights on non apple hardware for local MGT servers? or even local storage servers?

  41. Re:What more Apple stuff will need to be purchased by Joe_Dragon · · Score: 1

    with 2014 hardware at 2014 pricing.

  42. well cps should get them free and the union will g by Joe_Dragon · · Score: 1

    well cps should get them free and the union will get up pensions to pay for any thing.

  43. Finally by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    It's been how long since the Apple Pencil was introduced and they are just now getting around to adding support for it into their first party office suite? Not when the Apple Pencil was first released, not with iOS 11 which added drawing support across a lot of apps... they wait until NOW to do it. It's like they were trying to drive people to get Office 365 subscriptions so they can get Word/Excel/PowerPoint for iOS.

  44. Not wrong on the second by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    It's absurd to claim the Chromebooks are more useful. when you can just run Chrome to do anything on an iPad you could on the Chromoebook - but then you ALSO have tens of thousands of educational apps that are iPad only, and you ALSO have a pressure sensitive stylus for the screen which the Chromebook has nothing like.

    If you want to raise a classroom of people who do nothing but browse the web, I'm sure the Chromebook is fine. If you actually want educated children that are well-rounded, the iPad is superior.

    the chromebooks are much cheaper than the cheapest tablet

    New iPads are $400 with the Logitech rugged keyboard case and pencil. Looks like that gets you about 2.2 decent Chromebooks - replace more than two and you would have been better off with the iPad. The iPad will also last longer component wise as the cheaper Chromebooks will have soldering eventually fail, screens dying, etc.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
    1. Re:Not wrong on the second by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The biggest factor in using technology in a school is the TCO. That includes the labor/support costs associated with the tech. The LA billion dollar rollout was aborted because there were no tools to help the teacher/school system use them. Their lack (back then ) of multiple users was a huge increase in costs. All of the apps in the world won't help if you can't keep kids from going for porn over the school network, and playing games etc. ON a chromebook that is all eliminated. Maybe the software Apple built for several years after the LA failed rollout will help now, but buying a 100 pencil, and a bluetooth keyboard to boot with no mouse is a support nightmare. uncharged keyboards, lost pencils. 300 dollars in spare parts for each iPad.

    2. Re:Not wrong on the second by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps you missed this news? a Chromebook tablet with a stylus (that gets stored into the device)

      https://hardware.slashdot.org/story/18/03/26/189234/google-unveils-acers-chromebook-tab-10-ahead-of-apples-education-focused-event-tomorrow

  45. It's the software, not the cost by sjbe · · Score: 1

    For a little more than the price of two Apple pencil styluses, I can get two Amazon Fire tablets, which would be so much more useful for me and my family.

    If that is your use case then no argument. I'm not so concerned with the price but rather the fact that you just can't frakin' do anything genuinely useful with an Apple Pencil. I'm an engineer, an accountant, and I coach a sports team. Every one of those jobs has a LOT of paperwork that I could easily see doing on an iPad with an Apple Pencil but Apple in their infinite wisdom cannot be bothered to write the software to allow me to do it. They are worried about the three people doing graphics design rather than the millions who take notes and annotate and share documents. If Apple really was chasing the next big thing, it's right there. They just have to write the software to make it happen.

    If Apple would write that software it would be VASTLY more valuable than any number of Amazon Fire tablets. I would happily hand them a pile of money to solve the problem of good digital note taking and document sharing. Sadly Microsoft actually seems to be closer with their Surface products though they haven't really nailed it either because they are thinking about it as an operating system expansion rather than from a document process standpoint.

  46. Re:Little late there, Apple water by mickrussom by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not only this is silly complicated, you don't even get it.

    1) Wash your hands BEFORE you take a piss.
    2) Take a piss.

    That's all.
    If you're gonna shit, shit. Then we don't want a discussion about ass wiping (but muslims take note : toilet paper works because it's used with the right hand)