Slashdot Mirror
India To Intercept, Monitor, and Decrypt Citizens' Computers (venturebeat.com)
Several readers have shared a report: The Indian government has authorized 10 central agencies to intercept, monitor, and decrypt data on any computer, sending a shock wave through citizens and privacy watchdogs. Narendra Modi's government late Thursday broadened the scope of Section 69 of the nation's IT Act, 2000 to require a subscriber, service provider, or any person in charge of a computer to "extend all facilities and technical assistance to the agencies." Failure to comply with the agencies could result in seven years of imprisonment and an unspecified fine. In a clarification posted today, the Ministry of Home Affairs said each case of interception, monitoring, and decryption is to be approved by the competent authority, which is the Union Home Secretary.
Explaining the rationale behind the order, India's IT minister, Ravi Shankar Prasad, said that the measure was undertaken in the interests of national security. He added that some form of "tapping" has already been going on in the country for a number of years and that the new order would help bring structure to that process. "Always remember one thing," he said in a televised interview. "Even in the case of a particular individual, the interception order shall not be effective unless affirmed by the Home Secretary."
The Internet Freedom Foundation, a nonprofit organization that protects the online rights of citizens in India, cautioned that the order goes beyond telephone tapping. It includes looking at content streams and might even involve breaking encryption in some cases. "Imagine your search queries on Google over [a number of] years being demanded -- mixed with your WhatsApp metadata, who you talk to, when, and how much [and add] layers of data streams from emails + Facebook," it said. "To us this order is unconstitutional and in breach of the telephone tapping guidelines, the Privacy Judgement and the Aadhaar Judgement," it asserted.
Explaining the rationale behind the order, India's IT minister, Ravi Shankar Prasad, said that the measure was undertaken in the interests of national security. He added that some form of "tapping" has already been going on in the country for a number of years and that the new order would help bring structure to that process. "Always remember one thing," he said in a televised interview. "Even in the case of a particular individual, the interception order shall not be effective unless affirmed by the Home Secretary."
The Internet Freedom Foundation, a nonprofit organization that protects the online rights of citizens in India, cautioned that the order goes beyond telephone tapping. It includes looking at content streams and might even involve breaking encryption in some cases. "Imagine your search queries on Google over [a number of] years being demanded -- mixed with your WhatsApp metadata, who you talk to, when, and how much [and add] layers of data streams from emails + Facebook," it said. "To us this order is unconstitutional and in breach of the telephone tapping guidelines, the Privacy Judgement and the Aadhaar Judgement," it asserted.
This wouldn't happen in the US because we have guns! Right? Oh wait, the government and courts regularly use data on/transmitted from citizens computers in court cases. Carry on.
disbelief is an understatement considering the group disbanded in last year?
Oooo-kay.
Considering how many Microsoft tech support centers they have in India.
....anything to go by then no-one need worry.
Those guys couldn't find their own butts using both hands, let alone be capable of what's in the article.
It'll just be thousands on Indians all trying to cheat from each other to learn how to do it.
Nothing to see here.
sounds like we need a renaissance in stegography. Nope not encrypted, nope no data there,
Just what the hell do you think provides the ultimate and final protection for your freedom?
The very government and courts you just said violate those rights?
Just because allowing a population to be armed to protect itself doesn't mean governments won't abuse rights.
Your knee-jerk GUNZ IZZ SKEERY!!!! straw man is pathetic and intellectually about as deep as an August parking lot puddle in a shitty Florida strip mall parking lot.
This is standard practice now. Its amazing that people once thought it was wrong that Stasi collected information about the citizens social interactions.
IANAL, but is the burden of proof on the government to prove the existence of a:
"competent authority" /s
On the other hand, a "secure", cloud based backup/restore service that leaves no trace on a "rental" laptop except the latest blank OS, would seem to be a great investment opportunity.
... don't mind our overlords showing their true colours.
Go on, show the world you utterly hate and fear your own citizenry and will stoop to any depth at all to fuck over your own citizens. A biometric card to track everyone and snoop in everyone's data for no reason? Why yes, mister wallet inspector, do show us what you're made of.
what the what now?
basically, this is a case of "do you own a 'computer'?, if so then we open up and read anything in what we deem to be a 'computer' any time we like"
I'm going back to floppy disks. or I would. except anything unreadable or not formatted to 1.44meg could be construed as "encrypted", and therefore if I don't hand over the "decryption keys" to a corrupt floppy disk, it's tantamount to 7 years jail time.
good job guys. shall we all start carrying round a little tube of anal lube as part of being a trusted citizen?
maybe do something useful with it like finding those scam call centres?
Comment removed based on user account deletion
Yesterday, we learned that China will be publicly shaming j-walkers using facial recognition. NPR asked if this was the beginning of an era where no transgression against the law would go unnoticed and unpunished. Now we see a country with a huge citizenry demanding access to (effectively) all personal information without protection of privacy. This is one of today's announcements in an unending chain of events ratcheting up tyranny around the globe.
.. a forced way to think, with tools to root out all transgressions to the prescribed ways, as this policy in India does - I am fearful for the future of liberty, and even just democracy.
What made, and to the extent we still have it, Makes America Great, is and always has been a promise of true liberty and freedom, however well fulfilled, to be your own person, to think your own private thoughts, to fulfill your own dreams, to seek happiness. This dream brings people to our nation who are beaten on suspicion of thinking thoughts deemed improper. When America champions this idea around the world, it gives ALL people (who can hear it) hope that one day they will live in a place that allows them to express themselves personally as they really are.
Every time I read about technology enabling oppression, suppression, tyranny, and conformity
We should be looking at these actions as examples of what NOT to do.. and yet they are increasingly harbingers of what our leadership WILL do here in America. We watch what happens abroad with horror, and then watch while people embrace and defend these horrors at home. I am baffled.
Troll On! my people.
Well, Australia already had this terrible idea and turned it into law. Why not do it everywhere and citizens privacy be damned, globally.
Imagine your search queries on Google over [a number of] years being demanded -
And nobody was ever concerned about the rights violation here.
What about providing basic services (running water, electricity and sanitation) to the more than 600 million Indian citizens who lack them? Is it because they currently have no means to encrypt anything, and you people in the government want for them to remain that way?
They have a lot of muslims there and of course, like everywhere there are muslims, that means crime and terrorism. It might be necessary to do this to control them. Why they just don't send the bastards to Pakistan and let in the Christian, Sikh and Hindu Pakistanis I don't know.
. "Even in the case of a particular individual, the interception order shall not be effective unless affirmed by the Home Secretary."
That line could have been written by a 419 scammer. If it had the word "modality" in it I'd be 100% convinced.
One can only imagine the contents of these messages. Lovely gems such as what street are we shitting on this week? Or maybe which teenage girl we are going to gang rape to death today? Or maybe how many million American cell phones we're going to call for tech support scams.
Processing any sort of personally identifiable data in India will be avoided just for this reason.
Call center over voice over IP included.
You are full of dogshit, Mr Coward. I'm running NetBSD 8.0 right now posting this and loving it. Just because you are a systemd-lover looking to pan the superior competition because you can barely install Ubuntu doesn't mean you need to go hostile-retard on your betters. All of the BSD's are like brothers, fighting sometimes, but mostly cooperating in beautiful ways and producing excellent results. For example, the NetBSD rc-system is shared between it and FreeBSD and many wireless drivers that originate in OpenBSD find their way quickly to NetBSD and FreeBSD. In my extensive decades-long experience (something you don't have, obviously) BSD has been nothing short of kick ass and a joy to work with. That's why so many Unix variants started with BSD code. Their gift to the world can hardly be underestimated. The BSD socket interface is the iron-clad standard in huge swaths of IT because it rocks, was truly free, and it wasn't OSI-style committee bullshit. Haters like you have to post shit like this as AC's because you really know how fucked up and wrong you are in the first place.
So does that mean these call centers in India can't be trusted (as if they couldn't be before) to secure information for western companies?! GOOD!
Life is not for the lazy.
Good riddance to Tata and InfoSys.
I have no doubt that the defense industry, among others, will be given winks and nods and get tipped off when foreign competitors are bidding against them, or when interesting IP is scooped up.
---- The above post was generated by the Turing Institute. Maybe.
Don't feed the trolls, asshat.
Velociraptor = Distiraptor / Timeraptor
Fuck you, too. I'll say what I like.
It's just saying if an agency has a warrant then they can search your computer or intercept it's communications and you will need to provide a means for them to search it, punishable by law. It's about the same as in the US give or take. The change he is making is it's now requiring a warrant and codifying the penanty for non compliance. Previously this was all being done ad hoc. Now it's regulated and law.
Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
The thing that killed NetBSD was its obsession with boat anchors pulled out of dumpsters. While the other BSDs were busy implementing their vision of a modern operating system, NetBSD was more like a hobby for guys playing with obsolete gear one step away from the landfill. That was precious time and resources wasted all for naught. Time and resources squandered on woolgathering and dumpster diving was time lost forever. And as the few developers drifted away to other projects, what was left resembled someone's garage museum of abandoned computers.
With mandated e-currencies in the name of tax collection and total monitoring of electronic communications and transactions... that is pretty much the nuts and bolts of democracy all wrapped up in a totalitarian package. Hopefully there is enough democracy left in India to give the government a good swift kick to the curb, but it seems that totalitarians have gotten better at making the loss of Liberty sweet enough to swallow.
Taxes should never be so high as to require a government to make the nation itself a prison in order to collect.
Did you notice that all this is happening in countries that have many not so educated people? Did we went thru this in Europe few centuries ago when only high level members of christians churches were allowed to learn shit?
Guess no one has to worry, nothing but incompetent computer blunderers over there...
Qed
That's all they'll find.
I submitted USA's own mass surveillance program 'Hemisphere' and that story NEVER got published. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/...
1. Government declares encryption void for the purposes of investigation and policing.
2. Backdoors forced into encryption algorithms, with the keys entrusted to the government
3. Keys leak into public domain
4. Public trust of encryption collapses
5. Ecommerce collapses
6. Banking system collapses
"Explaining the rationale behind the order, India's IT minister, Ravi Shankar.."
There's the problem. He's more skilled with a sitar than with encryption.
Meanwhile, in Canada, the advice to people planning to visit the US is say nothing about pot use (legal here) for fear of being banned from ever entering the US. Free thought and legal actions .. ah yes the land of the Free.
Only way to be sure the needful is done. Atleast 25% of them are child rapists anyways. Theres no cure fore that but ending them.
You can bet your ass the " important " people in India have exceptions in place for this law.
Eg: Big Brother can spy on you, but are exempt from being spied upon.
Fact: NetBSD is D E A D. End of story.
D E A D.
So we should too!
Contempt for truth and knowledge https://www.huffingtonpost.in/...
Casteism
For authoritarian leaders and governments, an "unconstitutional order to tap citizen's communications" is pure gold.
Bug baby, bug!
In short order, high level oversight and approvals (in this case, by the Home Secretary) will be reduced. Eventually they will be eliminated in an "administrative move to reduce the burden of meaningless paperwork. It just makes sense!"
SystemD is a cancer.
The worst pice of trash software in Linux history and was forced down on our throats without even a discussion.
Now that debian planning on finally removed the old sysVinit I'm glad I moving full speed to BSD only servers.
Fuck systemd and pottering, this piece of shit would deserve to be shot.